Vanilla NOC 3 [Game Thread]

[Fort Colorcastle]

I'm trying to imagine a world where erry actually hard bussed mighty and it's theoretically possible. Erry didn't start the vote on mighty until he was heavily under suspicion by me and others.

I would like to point out that I called out mighty's most nonsense post before anyone else.

anna needs to go before volo. please take that slot out before you get to that point.

[Fort Colorcastle]

Sept 6, 2022 3:21:43 GMT erry said:

Vote Fort

Sept 6, 2022 3:41:44 GMT ddlcfan69 said:

vote fort

both of you should provide reasoning for your personal case on me.

be detailed, please.

[Fort Colorcastle]

it matters regardless of my alignment because your reasoning will help people determine your motivations once i flip.

[snackers]

Vote Erry

[snackers]

town is throwing

[ddlcfan69]

My hangover finalllly wore off last night was like a dream lmao





But ye it’s time to case fort watch this drive

[ddlcfan69]

My main reason for susing fort is the reactions of mighty purely. Mighty shifted a lot, from bubida to mmib to anna to dewfew to the homie rudi which is still a bullshit wagon but it’s ok . I do think two scum coulda easily been on that but it’s also very possible fort intentionally was not on it. Then John lays a case for fort that Is why I originally sussed fort cuz his iso in the beginning was super floaty and just like idgaf about the game and I’m not funny but I’ll make jokes anyway. Then mighty votes John which was maybe defending but that was brief and then erry and mighty vote me for being afk which is fine to vote me for ig even tho there were two ppl who had never spoken in the game lmao. But ye mighty pushes me for be reason instead of fort I think to save him. I would love to hear your thoughts on this fort because mighty shifted to more then half the pl and he never voted you one time even tho he doesn’t even really defend you he just interacts with you as little as possible. That makes me think he was protecting you by just pushing town.

[ddlcfan69]

Writing that on a phone is a ducking pain but y’all better read that shit

[ddlcfan69]

Also the possibility of erry bussing is reaching to the moon lowkey it is very u likely erry is scum lol

[Fort Colorcastle]

Sept 6, 2022 21:09:49 GMT ddlcfan69 said:

Also the possibility of erry bussing is reaching to the moon lowkey it is very u likely erry is scum lol

As I mentioned before, it's less reaching when you consider the order of things happening. Erry started the vote on mighty at basically the perfect time to bus: everyone was super sus of him but no one was on him yet.

[Fort Colorcastle]

Sept 6, 2022 21:08:31 GMT ddlcfan69 said:

My main reason for susing fort is the reactions of mighty purely. Mighty shifted a lot, from bubida to mmib to anna to dewfew to the homie rudi which is still a bullshit wagon but it’s ok . I do think two scum coulda easily been on that but it’s also very possible fort intentionally was not on it. Then John lays a case for fort that Is why I originally sussed fort cuz his iso in the beginning was super floaty and just like idgaf about the game and I’m not funny but I’ll make jokes anyway. Then mighty votes John which was maybe defending but that was brief and then erry and mighty vote me for being afk which is fine to vote me for ig even tho there were two ppl who had never spoken in the game lmao. But ye mighty pushes me for be reason instead of fort I think to save him. I would love to hear your thoughts on this fort because mighty shifted to more then half the pl and he never voted you one time even tho he doesn’t even really defend you he just interacts with you as little as possible. That makes me think he was protecting you by just pushing town.

I'm trying my absolute best to understand this so I'm gonna just start by attempting to translate this to English:


Fort's ISO is suspicious because he doesn't care about the game and basically afk'd days 1 and 2
Fort is sus because of interactions with mightycannon

Mighty shifted a lot of votes (bubida mmib anna dewfew rudi) but never voted fort
Mighty voted John very briefly after John laid out a case for fort

He moves on to voting ddlc for inactivity in order to save fort

Mighty never defended fort but simply ignored fort

[Fort Colorcastle]

if you have any corrections or additions lmk, and then I'll address the formatted version of your post

pressing return really helps btw
i know for a fact you can press return on a phone.

[erry]

Sept 6, 2022 7:02:30 GMT Fort Colorcastle said:

I'm trying to imagine a world where erry actually hard bussed mighty and it's theoretically possible. Erry didn't start the vote on mighty until he was heavily under suspicion by me and others.

I would like to point out that I called out mighty's most nonsense post before anyone else.

anna needs to go before volo. please take that slot out before you get to that point.

I'm not gonna deny you theoretics, theoretically you could still be scum despite calling out Mighty's nonsense post as well. Even if it seems unlikely, its still very much so possible in theory.


I would like your thoughts on one thing though. You mention Anna needing to go and I can understand your reasoning why, they're a 100% afk slot that shows 0 signs of changing (especially given their tract record so far). Going to volo with that slot alive would be incredibly risky because then we'd need to gamble voting a slot we have absolutely no info on, which could still very well be town.

What I'd like to point out are Mighty's interactions around that slot, especially days 2 and 3 (Around the time when you were still doing the whole follow the cop bit). For the most part Mighty's votes were super wishy-washy, jumping from one person to the next, going onto whatever wagon was proposed. The only exception to this imo was when he proposed Anna as a vote, the only other person proposing them as at the time was you, but no one was really taking that all that seriously given the bit you were doing.

The odd part about it imo was it wasn't the same as his other votes where he just hopped on a wagon and basically said "Yup! I agree with this logic!" instead he actually proposed switching wagons to them a few times and seemed almost adamant on getting the slot voted. Now if we assume for 2 seconds that Anna is scum that means Mighty had been offering us to vote out his partner and was in fact almost hardset in doing so. This would leave us with two possible worlds as far as I'm concerned.

World 1: Anna wasn't scum, Mighty was just trying to them overboard because they seemed like an easy vote that wouldn't get much pushback. Pretty simple, nothing complex

World 2: Mighty was attempting to bus his scum partner. Ordinally I'd say bussing in this game makes no sense when scum can just stay AFK and coast the whole game, but specifically bussing that slot actually makes sense imo. Mighty could've looked at their partner Anna and knowing that they weren't going to help the scum team in anyway (based on previous games) elects to vote them out to help clear his own name, rather safely even. The vote could've easily gone off without a hitch too, after all he had Follow-the-Cop FortColors basically locking in a vote for him on that slot too, all he would need is one other vote and he could near guarantee lock it down and clear his name as a result.


Now, given these two proposed worlds and the context of Mighty's votes days 2 and 3 I'm curious what your thoughts are on Anna as a slot are, Fort. I do agree with you that they're a risk to take to volo, but I feel like the reasoning is a bit deeper than how its conveyed here, there's more to the slot than initially meets the eye imo and I'd really like your input on that.

[Fort Colorcastle]

Sept 7, 2022 2:31:50 GMT erry said:

Sept 6, 2022 7:02:30 GMT Fort Colorcastle said:

I'm trying to imagine a world where erry actually hard bussed mighty and it's theoretically possible. Erry didn't start the vote on mighty until he was heavily under suspicion by me and others.

I would like to point out that I called out mighty's most nonsense post before anyone else.

anna needs to go before volo. please take that slot out before you get to that point.

I'm not gonna deny you theoretics, theoretically you could still be scum despite calling out Mighty's nonsense post as well. Even if it seems unlikely, its still very much so possible in theory.


I would like your thoughts on one thing though. You mention Anna needing to go and I can understand your reasoning why, they're a 100% afk slot that shows 0 signs of changing (especially given their tract record so far). Going to volo with that slot alive would be incredibly risky because then we'd need to gamble voting a slot we have absolutely no info on, which could still very well be town.

What I'd like to point out are Mighty's interactions around that slot, especially days 2 and 3 (Around the time when you were still doing the whole follow the cop bit). For the most part Mighty's votes were super wishy-washy, jumping from one person to the next, going onto whatever wagon was proposed. The only exception to this imo was when he proposed Anna as a vote, the only other person proposing them as at the time was you, but no one was really taking that all that seriously given the bit you were doing.

The odd part about it imo was it wasn't the same as his other votes where he just hopped on a wagon and basically said "Yup! I agree with this logic!" instead he actually proposed switching wagons to them a few times and seemed almost adamant on getting the slot voted. Now if we assume for 2 seconds that Anna is scum that means Mighty had been offering us to vote out his partner and was in fact almost hardset in doing so. This would leave us with two possible worlds as far as I'm concerned.

World 1: Anna wasn't scum, Mighty was just trying to them overboard because they seemed like an easy vote that wouldn't get much pushback. Pretty simple, nothing complex

World 2: Mighty was attempting to bus his scum partner. Ordinally I'd say bussing in this game makes no sense when scum can just stay AFK and coast the whole game, but specifically bussing that slot actually makes sense imo. Mighty could've looked at their partner Anna and knowing that they weren't going to help the scum team in anyway (based on previous games) elects to vote them out to help clear his own name, rather safely even. The vote could've easily gone off without a hitch too, after all he had Follow-the-Cop FortColors basically locking in a vote for him on that slot too, all he would need is one other vote and he could near guarantee lock it down and clear his name as a result.


Now, given these two proposed worlds and the context of Mighty's votes days 2 and 3 I'm curious what your thoughts are on Anna as a slot are, Fort. I do agree with you that they're a risk to take to volo, but I feel like the reasoning is a bit deeper than how its conveyed here, there's more to the slot than initially meets the eye imo and I'd really like your input on that.

my thoughts are that I'd rather lose to you than to anna, so if it came down to volo with the three of us I'm always going to vote anna.

[Fort Colorcastle]

i'd also prefer to lose to ddlc or anyone that's made a post.

this is true of all of the lurkers

[Fort Colorcastle]

at that point I legitimately wouldn't care what the slots or interactions looked like. I would not like to lose to this slot, so it needs to go.

However, since we aren't at that point yet, I believe you make a great point. Ignoring the fact that mighty was jumping around on literally everything, which I don't see him joining my vote on anna as particularly exceptional, the easiest and most likely case is that anna is town.

Speaking of which, if you think it's unlikely that I called out mighty's nonsense before anyone else, I highly recommend you look for either my partner or, more likely, the actual scum pair.


Even if yall aren't particularly willing to entertain the idea of erry bussing, I recommend analyzing other things. What's snacker's case on Erry?


What's snacker's case on erry?

Sept 6, 2022 18:16:46 GMT snackers said:

[ Vote Erry

[/b][/b][/quote]
I'm gonna need a proper case from you for this please

[Fort Colorcastle]

FUCK i messed up the bbcode. first time in years, what an embarassment

[erry]

Remaining Players:

Erry - I know I'm town :]

Snackers - This would warrant its own separate post tbh, there's a lot here and honestly I think a solid case could be built for either scum or town (I'll try to make an in-depth post on this tomorrow after my classes) (Few notable points, they seemed to scumread Mighty a fair bit and stated that pretty clearly several times, but despite that never showed an ounce of pressure towards Mighty. They also seemed to believe strongly that John was town. The way they put certain things/how they read certain slots just felt a bit too on the nose imo, almost as if they were informed, yet despite that I'm still kinda currently leaning town on them tbh)

Anna - Previously Explained Why This Slot is Likely Town In My Post To Fort

TB - Another Inactive Slot! (They've at least posted some of their reads, but the amount of doubling back and lowposting makes it near impossible to read them imo. I had initially townread them, but after looking back over their iso I have no idea why I did. The posts feel like they could be scummy, especially with how panicky and they got and how they doubled back when they did, but at the same time that also just makes them feel like noob town which makes sense for TB) (There's probably something more that could be pulled out from this slots current posts, I'd like people to review them if they can)

MMIB - Townslipped (Not knowing Cyan was dead: ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/90076/thread)

ddlc - Also townslipped (Not knowing Cyan was dead: ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/90200/thread) (Also was pretty readily voted by Mighty when the vote was offered and did the same back to Mighty later on despite having other wagons set up in either case that could've helped them save face more)

Bubida - "I forgot about this game and don't want to read it" (Literally read their iso and you'll see what I mean lol)

Fort - The current wagon and by far the slot I have the most thoughts on:

(They started the game by trolling, but only began to actually play when they started to catch some flack. Their activity between the previous two days and the current one is shocking; it feels like they once again began actually trying but only now that pressure had been placed on them.

They bickered with Mighty a fair bit going into the day when Mighty was actually voted, voted Mighty initially, and even said they planned on voting Mighty later in the day as well, however, they opted to vote ddlc instead following my line of logic despite acknowledging that it wasn't the best strategy but never even trying to propose a better one. After ddlc began posting they hopped off of ddlc and back onto Anna, once again going against their scumread on Mighty.

I think one of the biggest things for me that makes them feel like scum is their posts like "I know my slot has to go, keep your votes on me" or "feel free to let me stop caring about the game ngl i'd be happy to" feel like the exact kind of posts I'd make to try to keep myself alive. The type of post that says, "Yeah guys, I don't care if you vote me because I'm town :]" it just feels sooooo fake af and really doesn't help their case given how they've been playing this game so far imo.

There's more I could say on this slot and I'd like to have some actual quoted messages with it, but that'll have to wait until tomorrow.)



Quick Note: I do recognize that ddlc and mmib townslipping could've just been faked, I'd like some peoples additional thoughts on those slots because of that.

[Fort Colorcastle]

dw id vote my slot too lol its really bad

I'm just trying to make sure yall do other scumhunting today too

[Fort Colorcastle]

fwiw my options upon being called out for trolling were:

- start playing and tank the sus for only playing when called out
- keep playing follow the cop and be perma nai

the second would probably cement me as uncaring town but

[mymemoryisbad]

Sept 7, 2022 16:25:58 GMT Fort Colorcastle said:

fwiw my options upon being called out for trolling were:

- start playing and tank the sus for only playing when called out
- keep playing follow the cop and be perma nai

the second would probably cement me as uncaring town but

this post took up an unreasonable amount of space

ill try to do stuff. 

simply put i dont like snackers i will give my reasons holup

[mymemoryisbad]

Sept 4, 2022 3:47:00 GMT mymemoryisbad said:

Sept 4, 2022 1:42:23 GMT snackers said:

vote erry

They bussed and is now going after scept sus

stop being bad at bolding

they really voting erry when i dont see the biggest reason for them to bus

they didnt really give a ton of reason for it either

[mymemoryisbad]

Sept 4, 2022 5:33:19 GMT snackers said:

Bro theyre spamming over a small line I put that was a test and u failed

You got on to seem town basically when you and mighty had some weird reactions mighty said they sred you at one point but didnt carry it through to make you guys seem like you werent related ig

also they posted this on mobile (bad) ((joke))

anyway the first part of this is hopefully a joke. if it is its unfunny. if it isnt then thats an insanely large lie

i dont think that the timing on errys vote was neccesarily (cant spell) making them seem like town cuz like fort said everybody sussed mighty(the majority at least).
i didnt really see the interactions they had so i cant comment on that part but ig i should read that

[mymemoryisbad]

Sept 2, 2022 0:51:13 GMT mightycannon said:

Sept 2, 2022 0:40:53 GMT erry said:

Its time. Activity has skyrocketed. There is no reason to keep Scum Mighty alive any longer. Vote Mighty.

I actually agree with the part about activity theres no reason to waste a vote on lurkers here
I feel like voting snackers or mmib here
vote snackers
I have to go rn so I can't explain this vote in depth really I won't be here for dl too

ig i found something he was pretty calm even tho he was on plur here

[micromorphic]

(2*) fort: erry, ddlcfan69
(1) snackers: mymemoryisbad
(1) erry: snackers
Not Voting: annaoceancat, typicalbastard, fort, bubidajeffery

Deadline is in 2 hours and 44 minutes. If the day were to end now, Fort Colorcastle would be voted. Please message me if there's an error in the votecount.