|
|
Post by Alexander489 on Jun 20, 2023 1:21:07 GMT
i am already being reminded why i hate playing forum games lmao. keep in mind i am not used to the nature or style of forum mafia, so it might take some time to get used to. idk how to quote shit correctly but, style of play isnt really my thing. slower pace, reading up a lot, wallposting, etc. games usually end in me being voted out, but im gonna try to change that this game and be more effecient w my posts and reads. don’t really like 489’s comments about playing forum mafia considering I don’t think he’s at all inexperienced at forum mafia? and it feels like making cover for later misvotes—the tone certainly feels more apologetic (like we’re supposed to feel remorse) than anything else. I usually find that when players comment about their unfamiliarity with forum mafia or wanting to improve it’s in a more optimistic note (“excited about this game”) or they just don’t comment about it at all K |
|
|
|
Post by frogo on Jun 20, 2023 1:22:09 GMT
ah yes, because a discard read list = scumread. right. totally. You made a vote from said pool and moved two of those people in the pool to your next scum pool... |
|
|
|
Post by frogo on Jun 20, 2023 1:23:08 GMT
Like I understand the difference between one being about discards and the other being about actual reads but if that's the case then what read do you have on Lol Rito and TanPat?
|
|
|
|
Post by Alexander489 on Jun 20, 2023 1:23:16 GMT
ah yes, because a discard read list = scumread. right. totally. You made a vote from said pool and moved two of those people in the pool to your next scum pool... notice how said pool was sans winsy. tell me 1 line other than reading discards where winsy was a scumread of mine. |
|
|
|
Post by Alexander489 on Jun 20, 2023 1:23:51 GMT
Like I understand the difference between one being about discards and the other being about actual reads but if that's the case then what read do you have on Lol Rito and TanPat? nonposters?  at least winsy posted man. you are reading way too into this |
|
|
|
Post by frogo on Jun 20, 2023 1:25:17 GMT
I'm reading way into this because you decided not to give a straight forward answer.
|
|
|
|
Post by Alexander489 on Jun 20, 2023 1:26:21 GMT
I'm reading way into this because you decided not to give a straight forward answer. i have given you my answer lmao |
|
|
|
Post by frogo on Jun 20, 2023 1:31:23 GMT
Okey I don't think I have anything else to say regarding above and I reckon we are just gonna keep going in circles until people show up sooooo Here's totodile! |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 1:34:20 GMT
Good morning, I'm town. If you don't know me, I should introduce myself. My username is pokecartbeast, pcb/poke/pokecart/beast/worstmafiaplayerthisgame for short How I got my username: I forgot I have a total of 0 losses on this site. I am so good. This is also because I joined 1 games and the unfinished one is this game. Now for some of my playstyle introduction. I either play really aggressively or very passively, no in between. The playstyle changes really quickly. How people say I play: Any one of towny town, towny scum, scummy town, scummy scum. I am a CM. It stands for contradiction master. I hate walls of text because they are hard to read. I buckle under pressure. Shitposting is one of my specialities. I think this is all I have to say. Oh wait, no. Kindle is not my main choice of communication which is very good, I do not follow GMT+1 time zone. only scummy discards are lolrito's and winsy's imo, the former is definitely much scummier than the latter, mmib isn't on that list solely because of little liar (fuck little liar all my homies hate little liar) speaking of which, VOTE: lolrito
I sorta commented on PCB before but I wanna explain on this. Bantering/meming d1 is perfectly expected and acceptable, but I feel like the way he approached it circumvents its purpose and is more of a detriment to town. A lot of how town breaks the ice d1 is by interacting w others: establishing tone, making early connections, sort of getting a feel for the player base. I got the feeling that PCB wasn’t really trying to break the ice—not making any effort to encourage discussion or formulate early reads. Both of his posts have been bandwagony in the sense that sure, he’s reading posts, but he’s not actively interacting and instead regurgitating points that others have made (the d1 wall, the vote on lolrito), trying to sort of coast through d1 by making it seem like he’s there and providing something that doesn’t exist in reality |
|
|
|
Post by Alexander489 on Jun 20, 2023 2:02:57 GMT
Good morning, I'm town. If you don't know me, I should introduce myself. My username is pokecartbeast, pcb/poke/pokecart/beast/worstmafiaplayerthisgame for short How I got my username: I forgot I have a total of 0 losses on this site. I am so good. This is also because I joined 1 games and the unfinished one is this game. Now for some of my playstyle introduction. I either play really aggressively or very passively, no in between. The playstyle changes really quickly. How people say I play: Any one of towny town, towny scum, scummy town, scummy scum. I am a CM. It stands for contradiction master. I hate walls of text because they are hard to read. I buckle under pressure. Shitposting is one of my specialities. I think this is all I have to say. Oh wait, no. Kindle is not my main choice of communication which is very good, I do not follow GMT+1 time zone. only scummy discards are lolrito's and winsy's imo, the former is definitely much scummier than the latter, mmib isn't on that list solely because of little liar (fuck little liar all my homies hate little liar) speaking of which, VOTE: lolrito
I sorta commented on PCB before but I wanna explain on this. Bantering/meming d1 is perfectly expected and acceptable, but I feel like the way he approached it circumvents its purpose and is more of a detriment to town. A lot of how town breaks the ice d1 is by interacting w others: establishing tone, making early connections, sort of getting a feel for the player base. I got the feeling that PCB wasn’t really trying to break the ice—not making any effort to encourage discussion or formulate early reads. Both of his posts have been bandwagony in the sense that sure, he’s reading posts, but he’s not actively interacting and instead regurgitating points that others have made (the d1 wall, the vote on lolrito), trying to sort of coast through d1 by making it seem like he’s there and providing something that doesn’t exist in reality does it make a difference that the first post was a copy from what clem said? or does that make it worse in your eyes. i do agree what pcb said was echoed by multiple others w not only more effort but better reasoning asw. i do agree that lolrito is a good vote, and i could definitely see how this entrance to the game could be seen as just trying to blend in, in a way. i do rlly like what ive seen from fingerlings so far, definitely townradar rn, prob my only one so far. |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 2:43:37 GMT
does it make a difference that the first post was a copy from what clem said? or does that make it worse in your eyes. i do agree what pcb said was echoed by multiple others w not only more effort but better reasoning asw. i do agree that lolrito is a good vote, and i could definitely see how this entrance to the game could be seen as just trying to blend in, in a way. i do rlly like what ive seen from fingerlings so far, definitely townradar rn, prob my only one so far. Make a difference compared to what? But yeah I think his opening post being an exact copy the way it was is less “I’m bantering to break the ice and get to know some of yall” and more “I’m trying to find a way to enter the thread and this is an easy way of riding what somebody has already said to make myself seem innocent.” It being a copy compared to an original matters because Clem’s original opening post was a fine way of introducing himself and trying to provoke interactions, but PCB never really interacted w him or anyone with his post |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 2:45:02 GMT
But I just wanna note this is an early read and it’s difficult to make concrete reads when reading someone w just 2 messages
|
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:16:11 GMT
I’m more worried about the fact that the day is closing and we’ve not consolidated to any meaningful wagon—partially because of inactivity making it harder to read, but also the people that are here are making general passive reads e.g. “this guy discarded this so he’s more likely to be scum” and “this guy sounds good so he’s town” and not synthesizing what people have said to make any meaningful reads. It’s leading to an abundance of caution (which I think is pretty detrimental for town because we’re not going anywhere) instead of pressuring and pushing, even based on small reasons, to elicit reactions Also let it be known that I am not pushing clemens in any way rn we are just sharing opinions that are mostly irrelevant Stuff like this is what I mean. Like I don’t think anyone thought akakakp was pushing clemens at all and yet he’s being overly cautious and saying no no, im not actually pushing him. Akakakp also had 0 pressure or danger atp so it was an unprovoked message. Like who cares if you’re pushing clemens and why does it matter? It could be scum trying to not get up in flames and stay away from the spotlight, but it could also be town with imperfect information being cautious and making his intentions known he wasn’t sring clemens, so it’s imo mostly nai in the end. (ftr I think akakakp’s intentions have been towny so far). |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:18:49 GMT
Another example is clemens only discussing the mechanical aspects of the game and forming his reads based on that, then dipping
|
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:24:52 GMT
It could very well be an attempt for town to gamesolve but im worried about the fact that he’s only using them for the basis of his reads and ignoring the thread (which was my originally argument about discard discussion in the first place)
|
|
|
|
Post by mymemoryisbad on Jun 20, 2023 3:25:38 GMT
does it make a difference that the first post was a copy from what clem said? or does that make it worse in your eyes. i do agree what pcb said was echoed by multiple others w not only more effort but better reasoning asw. i do agree that lolrito is a good vote, and i could definitely see how this entrance to the game could be seen as just trying to blend in, in a way. i do rlly like what ive seen from fingerlings so far, definitely townradar rn, prob my only one so far. Make a difference compared to what? But yeah I think his opening post being an exact copy the way it was is less “I’m bantering to break the ice and get to know some of yall” and more “I’m trying to find a way to enter the thread and this is an easy way of riding what somebody has already said to make myself seem innocent.” It being a copy compared to an original matters because Clem’s original opening post was a fine way of introducing himself and trying to provoke interactions, but PCB never really interacted w him or anyone with his post haas pcb even said anything other than those 2 posts (one of which is a c/p) |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:26:16 GMT
But I ofc don’t want clemens gone
|
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:26:30 GMT
Make a difference compared to what? But yeah I think his opening post being an exact copy the way it was is less “I’m bantering to break the ice and get to know some of yall” and more “I’m trying to find a way to enter the thread and this is an easy way of riding what somebody has already said to make myself seem innocent.” It being a copy compared to an original matters because Clem’s original opening post was a fine way of introducing himself and trying to provoke interactions, but PCB never really interacted w him or anyone with his post haas pcb even said anything other than those 2 posts (one of which is a c/p) Nope |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:28:31 GMT
I think shaun’s sheeping is not something that scum would do bc its putting yourself out to get criticized/pushed, and I do agree that shaun is never in the same scum faction w clem
|
|
|
|
Post by mymemoryisbad on Jun 20, 2023 3:28:58 GMT
It could very well be an attempt for town to gamesolve but im worried about the fact that he’s only using them for the basis of his reads and ignoring the thread (which was my originally argument about discard discussion in the first place) idt clems is active rn/has been recently, he obviously was at gamestart but yes i agree- it is time to move on from reading off discards and start using the actual information out there there are some other people doing this i feel |
|
|
|
Post by mymemoryisbad on Jun 20, 2023 3:29:47 GMT
It could very well be an attempt for town to gamesolve but im worried about the fact that he’s only using them for the basis of his reads and ignoring the thread (which was my originally argument about discard discussion in the first place) idt clems is active rn/has been recently, he obviously was at gamestart but yes i agree- it is time to move on from reading off discards and start using the actual information out there there are some other people doing this i feel in reference to the last line, the still reading off discmeta is what i think others r doing |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:30:20 GMT
Alr Good Morning for real this time. Discard Meta isn't real, so I won't judge anyone based on it. In regards to my own role picking, I pick based on what is fun, which kinda factors into why I think discard meta isn't real. Anyway, Sac is a boring role, change my mind Seems like a genuine entrance into the thread, tl |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:37:39 GMT
Also would like to point out that like, half the people in here think my discard is scummy, and no one is voting me Just food for thought Again I think winsy’s defense to the discard discussion seems more to me like resistant town showing genuine emotion/reaction to an unfair process. I don’t think scum would be aggressive in defending themselves as it only puts the spotlight on themselves (he could have just ignored it and said nothing bc he had no votes on him and wasn’t being actively discussed) |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jun 20, 2023 3:41:09 GMT
Agree with what others have said about wallape, don’t have much to add, I think his reactions are genuine and more likely than not to come from a town mindset
|
|
|
|
Post by mymemoryisbad on Jun 20, 2023 3:43:55 GMT
dangerous amounts of inactivity so imma just do an update cuz theres really nothing going on
im not using this as a scale for towniness but im just pointing it all out
MyanMario- some short posts and left. one of them made 0 sense (clems + aka are either in same scum faction or tls) and hasnt been explained. voted and left
A kak akp- pretty active
I'm not iamveryhappy- was pretty active early on and has looked into a lot of mech based stuff, voted, but hasnt come back (probably sleeping or smthn). in total solidly active
oklolrito- completely inactive
Alexander489- pretty active, voted
ihbst- also did some short posts about mechs, voted, left
mymemoryisbad- pretty active, voted
slowthepoke- one post: voted and left
bluepillthink- completely inactive
fingerlings- pretty active, voted
PokeCartBeast- 2 posts, one being a c/p. voted and left
wallape- they said they were sleeping, but they were for a time active and still posted and made reads in the time they were active, voted
Shaun-CCGeek- sheeped clems early on, voted, left
winsytinsy- kinda came in early and posted a bit about disc meta and gave a short intro ig, attempted to vote clems (they didnt bold properly)
tanpat1712- completely inactive
edit: missed bolding a few names
|
|
at least winsy posted man. you are reading way too into this
