|
|
Post by kliff on Nov 21, 2023 0:41:56 GMT
Fair enough, But  if you read om's post carefully, he's not even saying dact is town on the grounds of him being willing to draw attention to himself -- there's a double negative in there and it looks like he's saying that he's town for not drawing attention to himself, so it made me question whether you'd even read the post or just wanted to signal boost something to appear helpful the reason i asked him to clarify was because i was wary of the idea of him saying dact was town for not drawing attention to himself which a) wouldn't have aligned with dact's play so far and b) is a bad reason to call anyone town Alright I see what you mean now, I did misinterpret the post earlier but I'll still stand by the read. |
|
|
|
Post by Crespo on Nov 21, 2023 1:15:15 GMT
i just skimread before going to sleep so I’ll post more explanatory posts tomorrow morning but for now I’m thinking:
- om’s read on dactyl looks weird, i’m not that familiar with s!om but gives off pocket vibes
- i scumread dactyl up until he started interacting prodigu
- if you read prodigu’s reads lists there’s not really anything new. Just giving his thoughts on stuff already established but has an odd fixation on peng and low posting slots. If prod flips s! I’d say look at high posters as a partner just based on that.
Vote staying on Prodigu for now gn
|
|
|
|
Post by tommy2hands on Nov 21, 2023 1:50:12 GMT
alright iavh is town vote edje
wolfy Pop-In I like Clouds and iamvery happy camryn i think could be scum. |
|
|
|
Post by tommy2hands on Nov 21, 2023 1:52:31 GMT
Girl I don't feel like trying to quote things because I don't know how the bleep forums work usually but I'll post some brief thoughts here from my point of view! Please bare with me and my reads since this is my first proper mafia so not everything is bond to make perfect sense to y'all but like hi I exist! - It seems like people want to vote iavh due to him trolling and not being very readable either way as a result, and I get that mindset because there is only so much you can go off of Day 1 so it makes sense to vote an anomaly here to get rid of a harder to read variable. - I could be naive, but OM and Fame tentatively read as town to me at the moment. I feel like OM is actively questioning other people's reads as well as providing reads of his own and all of them seem to be grounded in reason, so he doesn't give scum to me. Fame I feel like is challenging things and the logic behind them questioning other people seem to be sound. It seems like Fame is trying to play for what would benefit town the most here by questioning votes and mulling over if they are logical/fair. That's all I got for now it's hard for me properly analyze people's behaviors when I haven't played mafia with any of y'all before LOL Its been generally stated by others already but i will contribute here, generally the post speaks townie to me, appears to be a new players attempted entrance into the game by trying to give some general thoughts on their viewpoint so far. Putting them as a townlean for myself at the current time, would like to see how the slot develops from here Said generally a lot here. I sort of think you are scum cause a lot of your posts come off as fake. |
|
|
|
Post by tommy2hands on Nov 21, 2023 1:53:35 GMT
Dactyl7 prodigu pisxel seems town at a glance
OM scum
|
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Nov 21, 2023 2:01:55 GMT
i'm awake again and entirely unbothered to properly dissect through seven pages' worth of proper arguments so i'll just say that prodigu pinged me for reasons that other players have already stated, just not to the extent that they're fake
it's really more like they're trying to offend people as little as possible
i will ignore the fame/clouds angle of this game until later because it's a lot of stuff to go through but i do think that it's worth ruling out the slim possibility of them being aligned together. if one flips everyone should locktown the other
in lieu of a proper case i will just
vote pisx
thinking purely off of the dactyl read kind of being a little half-baked
|
|
camryn
Villager
it came to me in a delusion
Posts: 69 
|
Post by camryn on Nov 21, 2023 2:04:02 GMT
Its been generally stated by others already but i will contribute here, generally the post speaks townie to me, appears to be a new players attempted entrance into the game by trying to give some general thoughts on their viewpoint so far. Putting them as a townlean for myself at the current time, would like to see how the slot develops from here Said generally a lot here. I sort of think you are scum cause a lot of your posts come off as fake. Are you saying I'm scum because my posts came off fake or are you addressing prodigu here? I know you said you have a scum read on me regardless just unsure of who you are addressing in regards to the "fake posts" here. |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Nov 21, 2023 2:07:47 GMT
any specific reason here? seems like Pengs dropped 2 votes and went back to sleep to me he re-assessed happylappy and revoted that's good enough 4 me
|
|
|
|
Post by tommy2hands on Nov 21, 2023 2:09:32 GMT
Said generally a lot here. I sort of think you are scum cause a lot of your posts come off as fake. Are you saying I'm scum because my posts came off fake or are you addressing prodigu here? I know you said you have a scum read on me regardless just unsure of who you are addressing in regards to the "fake posts" here. Was about prodigu, sorry I'll try to be more precise with my language. Yes I am also scumreading you, it's on a lesser level than my other reads though. I am mainly looking at you since you arent doing much, but you had some excuse for it, but you're still around in the thread. |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Nov 21, 2023 2:10:51 GMT
tommy2hands do you mind expanding a bit on your reads (cam, dactyl, prod, pisx, myself) if you don't mind?
|
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Nov 21, 2023 2:11:29 GMT
Are you saying I'm scum because my posts came off fake or are you addressing prodigu here? I know you said you have a scum read on me regardless just unsure of who you are addressing in regards to the "fake posts" here. Was about prodigu, sorry I'll try to be more precise with my language. Yes I am also scumreading you, it's on a lesser level than my other reads though. I am mainly looking at you since you arent doing much, but you had some excuse for it, but you're still around in the thread. er wait what caused you to flip from that to tring prod |
|
|
|
Post by Dactyl7 on Nov 21, 2023 2:12:48 GMT
aside from your townread on fame (t!fame seems to be the consensus rn) and your townlean on cam, im noticing that your iso is basically just questions, so i will pose you a question who do you scumread right now, and why? fair thing to ask, something ive honestly, dont think ive fully questioned myself just yet so im gonna look at some ISOs and see what stands out at current time to me, I think out of any reads i have so far in terms of scumminess im currently inclined to put Kliff here. In reading this slot i have several conflicting thoughts, which generally stem from his TR on you despite you not having much content to make of at the time to say "I TR this person" The TR could be due to TMI of knowing that youre not part of his scumteam i generally find the slots progression on his TR on you to be "weird" similarly however, i find myself constantly questioning, why s!Kliff would say something such as that this early on in the game, at least from my POV I couldnt say I TR you off of the posts you made at that point id leave you in more of a Null category, and when questioned about it doubles down a bit which is interesting. Other SRs i would put here atp would be Peng, based only on his ISO being dropping 2 votes and thats it doesnt generally sit right with me, only other thing they said was "Iavh is town". Seems like theyre kind of reading the thread but not putting out more than a vote. you mentioned it in a post prior about Cyans ISO being entirely about a Iavh policy vote not being a good look and im inclined to agree here, they have given me the general vibe that they can put out decent work into the game so this is a slot id like to keep an eye on to see if they progress more than iavh Theres several slots id like to see content out of to make a more informed read on being EDJ, SC, Fingerlings, pisxel, tanpat, TBZ, tommy, cuddz (yea im listing the players that havent said much of anything yet) i feel like these reads are super constructed? if you know what i mean i dont really see a train of thought, it just sort of feels like they said "oh yeah this could be a scumtell ill say this" for now ill unvote iavh and vote prodiguscumlean for aforementioned reasons, would appreciate other thoughts on this |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Nov 21, 2023 2:12:54 GMT
i just skimread before going to sleep so I’ll post more explanatory posts tomorrow morning but for now I’m thinking: - om’s read on dactyl looks weird, i’m not that familiar with s!om but gives off pocket vibes - i scumread dactyl up until he started interacting prodigu - if you read prodigu’s reads lists there’s not really anything new. Just giving his thoughts on stuff already established but has an odd fixation on peng and low posting slots. If prod flips s! I’d say look at high posters as a partner just based on that. Vote staying on Prodigu for now gn Hmm, mentions odd fixation with Peng but doesnt say anything about OM towncoring Peng interesting figured this would be something worthwhile to comment on here if youre gonna talk about one why not the other. Me mentioning inactive slots is nothing new this is something i do every game, go look at Popcorn |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Nov 21, 2023 2:13:44 GMT
i just skimread before going to sleep so I’ll post more explanatory posts tomorrow morning but for now I’m thinking: - om’s read on dactyl looks weird, i’m not that familiar with s!om but gives off pocket vibes - i scumread dactyl up until he started interacting prodigu - if you read prodigu’s reads lists there’s not really anything new. Just giving his thoughts on stuff already established but has an odd fixation on peng and low posting slots. If prod flips s! I’d say look at high posters as a partner just based on that. Vote staying on Prodigu for now gn I'd argue this would have the opposite effect considering dactyl already stated intent to vote if I had >10 posts - if you're looking for pocketing wouldn't my interactions with fame be more likely?
dactyl is town sorry
|
|
|
|
Post by Dactyl7 on Nov 21, 2023 2:14:36 GMT
i just skimread before going to sleep so I’ll post more explanatory posts tomorrow morning but for now I’m thinking: - om’s read on dactyl looks weird, i’m not that familiar with s!om but gives off pocket vibes - i scumread dactyl up until he started interacting prodigu - if you read prodigu’s reads lists there’s not really anything new. Just giving his thoughts on stuff already established but has an odd fixation on peng and low posting slots. If prod flips s! I’d say look at high posters as a partner just based on that. Vote staying on Prodigu for now gn I'd argue this would have the opposite effect considering dactyl already stated intent to vote if I had >10 posts - if you're looking for pocketing wouldn't my interactions with fame be more likely?
dactyl is town sorry
would like to clarify that i basically just meant i was going to vote you if you were lurking |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Nov 21, 2023 2:15:38 GMT
I'd argue this would have the opposite effect considering dactyl already stated intent to vote if I had >10 posts - if you're looking for pocketing wouldn't my interactions with fame be more likely?
dactyl is town sorry
would like to clarify that i basically just meant i was going to vote you if you were lurking don't care it was townie buddy |
|
|
|
Post by Dactyl7 on Nov 21, 2023 2:16:52 GMT
going to head to bed now, i hope there is lots to sink my teeth into tmrw gn
|
|
|
|
Post by tommy2hands on Nov 21, 2023 2:32:06 GMT
tommy2hands do you mind expanding a bit on your reads (cam, dactyl, prod, pisx, myself) if you don't mind? just flash reads. Dactyl or cam is what I am thinking about mainly. |
|
|
|
Post by tommy2hands on Nov 21, 2023 2:35:12 GMT
Was about prodigu, sorry I'll try to be more precise with my language. Yes I am also scumreading you, it's on a lesser level than my other reads though. I am mainly looking at you since you arent doing much, but you had some excuse for it, but you're still around in the thread. er wait what caused you to flip from that to tring prod I am waiting to see what Prodigu says. |
|
camryn
Villager
it came to me in a delusion
Posts: 69
|
Post by camryn on Nov 21, 2023 2:38:14 GMT
tommy2hands do you mind expanding a bit on your reads (cam, dactyl, prod, pisx, myself) if you don't mind? just flash reads. Dactyl or cam is what I am thinking about mainly. I'm a bit confused at you putting out reads on 5 different players with minimal reasoning behind them and not elaborating any further when asked |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Nov 21, 2023 2:38:42 GMT
er wait what caused you to flip from that to tring prod I am waiting to see what Prodigu says. If you were waiting on a response from me i wouldve just said what OM said, dunno what you expect more than "You SR me in this post, and then in your next post you TR me thats whack" |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Nov 21, 2023 2:54:06 GMT
Eh actually idk, I still think Clouds' early posts are mega weird but him and Kliff are never S/S I don't think and I agree more with his read on Kliff i disagree that camryn's post indicates town alignment (i also dont think that it indicates scum alignment) its very possible that someone with experience with social games could come into a forum game for the first time and seem genuine in their reads despite being scumyeah, this is & has been on my mind for the record, which is why i wasn't as quick as say fame to throw it all to the wind and say camryn town what i think has me feeling decent about cam's slot though is the way she phrased her om & fame townreads -- as a first time scum player, it is not easy to make your reads come across in a way that displays some semblance of actually attempting to solve, and the reasoning she backed both reads with seemed kinda genuine to me |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Nov 21, 2023 3:01:59 GMT
I'm caught up, Dactyl is town specifically for the reason that I don't think scum would not be willing to draw attention in their first five posts i cba to fuck around with multiquoting so i'll just respond to you by quoting the post i was referencing misreading it isn't the part i have an issue with in kliff's case, in fact it has nothing to do with that. it's that i felt like kliff wasn't buying the read at all & was just attempting to come across as agreeable. this is more of a repeating pattern with his slot than it is just this 1 post, it reminds me of the sort of behavior kliff had in the 1 game i played where he was mafia and contrasts his town play a bit. he said he had his own interpretation on it, and sure, that's fine, but that sort of read piggybacking is usually more of a negative sign than a positive and it's compounded when it doesn't seem like the player seconding the read even follows along with what they're reading |
|
camryn
Villager
it came to me in a delusion
Posts: 69
|
Post by camryn on Nov 21, 2023 3:07:28 GMT
I'm caught up, Dactyl is town specifically for the reason that I don't think scum would not be willing to draw attention in their first five posts i cba to fuck around with multiquoting so i'll just respond to you by quoting the post i was referencing misreading it isn't the part i have an issue with in kliff's case, in fact it has nothing to do with that. it's that i felt like kliff wasn't buying the read at all & was just attempting to come across as agreeable. this is more of a repeating pattern with his slot than it is just this 1 post, it reminds me of the sort of behavior kliff had in the 1 game i played where he was mafia and contrasts his town play a bit. he said he had his own interpretation on it, and sure, that's fine, but that sort of read piggybacking is usually more of a negative sign than a positive and it's compounded when it doesn't seem like the player seconding the read even follows along with what they're reading Thank you for the clarification that makes a lot more sense to me now |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Nov 21, 2023 3:11:00 GMT
tommy2hands do you mind expanding a bit on your reads (cam, dactyl, prod, pisx, myself) if you don't mind? just flash reads. Dactyl or cam is what I am thinking about mainly. shoutouts gut reads
give me some content on the both of them :>
|
|
