|
|
Post by AlexSnaq on May 6, 2024 16:16:39 GMT
im cool w pressure on the slot and am not a fan of the opening either (saying you'll sheep people is not helping us progress the game at all), but it feels very aligned with what aligningstars would do at least, im not sure about pcb's posts and would have to go back Recent posts have given some content tho, i dont know what to think yet but am curious what you think of these posts (links instead of quotes to save space) ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/119643/threadps-mafia.proboards.com/post/119628/threadps-mafia.proboards.com/post/119628/threadAt the very least you can't say they're scared of being judged, but I don't think scum!as would be scared either You posted the second link twice btw, assuming there was supposed to be a third link. As for the first post I honestly find it kind of ironic. The post from Astaroth that its quoting is one of their few posts that I actually felt had substance to it, so calling it nai is kind of funny to me. Honestly the post I find more nai is the one where they call it nai, it feels like an attempt to contribute but it really doesn't lead us anywhere. As for the second post I'd typically agree with their opening statement "tbh i find it hard to make reads early d1," but the follow up is what confuses me tbh. They say its hard to make reads d1 because its too much thinking, instead of attributing it to something like a lack of content. I feel like d1 should almost require less thinking since there's less content you have to backread or remember. What this post is saying to me is that d1 is difficult for them because they have to think, as in no one has given up a solid reads for them to just follow along with. The post also feels like an easy way to deflect them from actually having to contribute until a later point where, once again, there will likely be established reads or pressure that they could just use. I kinda disagree with your point that they're not scared to be judged because that's exactly how the second post reads to me. I forgot to follow-up here, sorry I agree with your take on the "NAI" astaroth post. I do think that saying they like maya is pretty okay at that point of the day though. It gives us some idea of where their headspace is at, would be curious how it progresses from this point on, especially next to a lot of posts I can't get much out of. Wrt not being judged, I mostly felt that way with the posts that were less serious. Though, I do not think that they are not giving much information because they're scared to be judged, rather than not having much to say rn I guess saying this I feel like I'm kinda agreeing w/ Alex's read on Spaghetti, though I do hope to see more content soon (especially from PCB tbh) I'd hoped you'd elaborate on the Grace read when I asked but I also can't really fault you for not having that much to say about em rn - Snaq |
|
Dactyl's Influenze
Dead Player
Kobelless and Tonicrespoinfluenze are going to mop the floor with all you G League bottom feederS
Posts: 2
|
Post by Dactyl's Influenze on May 6, 2024 16:17:55 GMT
hey d00ds are we ready t0 kill all t0wnies??
|
|
|
|
Post by commanderations on May 6, 2024 16:18:23 GMT
gm mafia fans
|
|
|
|
Post by AlexSnaq on May 6, 2024 16:20:34 GMT
Anyways I’ll make my solid entrance now because I have zero excuse not to. This is my first forum game, so it definitely caught me off guard with posts about solid vote options when (in my opinion) it’s super early in the mornin and nobody’s reasonably fuckin awake. All that stated, I took a bit of time to read, and I thinkkkk we’re going the wrong away about this. I see that there’s a lot of posts about “this person town because xxx” and YES make those reads… but I don’t think sharing those reads is a good idea. With multiple noms, I could see factions going for universally tred players, which obviously fucking sucks for us. I’m unsure how we can make those reads without completely screwing ourselves, but maybe we look at like.. groups of 3 or smth and then try to scumhunt from there? (Going to suggest we do it from sign up sheet, for fairness) Now, I’ve also only been awake 20 minutes and I’m probably not cooking with this? But I’m just sharing out here. ngl I'm not approaching this game differently as a player from whether it's multiball or not. It might be my lack of experience but I'd be curious what other people would suggest what to do wrt it being multiball. Specifically realabcavh (bc you mentioned we're forgetting it's KAT) Personally, I do believe that bundling the power of town in coordinating and discussing our reads is more worthwhile than not, even if it does give Mafia the power to kill uniTRs (which.. if they're good players, they could probably figure out who people TR anyway). If we do not, dying without having your reads be known also means that they might be in vain - Snaq |
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:20:51 GMT
Also since this game has so much scum in it, I think my strategy is mostly going to be finding unpaired town and then brute forcing my way through the POE.
|
|
|
|
Post by AlexSnaq on May 6, 2024 16:20:53 GMT
hey d00ds are we ready t0 kill all t0wnies?? profile pic please |
|
|
|
Post by PhoenixWrong on May 6, 2024 16:23:05 GMT
i got scared id have to remember 2 different slots |
|
|
|
Post by AlexSnaq on May 6, 2024 16:23:40 GMT
Some minor housekeeping details id like to touch on real quick Question to the general thread are we doing hypos on cop / seer? Also fwiw im gonna say 95% of the posts that come from this slot are going to be coming from Prod. Myan isnt as heavily active as I am but if you need something ID’d just lmk (Why) do you think we should? |
|
|
|
Post by PhoenixWrong on May 6, 2024 16:25:10 GMT
Good morning! (Well morning for me). I’ve been skimming the thread, and so far the only people I like are darkness and snaqalex, everyone else seems pretty null. I think the big thing I can say rn is that I agree w alexsnaq on everything about commanderations, they’re still null to me, but ig we will see how that evolves. Generally, I prefer not to make reads off entrances because I don’t like it when it’s done to me, often times I will post complete filler and some asshat goes OH MY GOD HE DIDNT SAY HI HE SAID SOMETHING ABOUT BEING TIRED GET HIS ASS. -ne why am i null |
|
|
|
Post by PhoenixWrong on May 6, 2024 16:25:47 GMT
why do you like those 2 slots and not pq and prodigu as well
|
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:26:16 GMT
Anyways I’ll make my solid entrance now because I have zero excuse not to. This is my first forum game, so it definitely caught me off guard with posts about solid vote options when (in my opinion) it’s super early in the mornin and nobody’s reasonably fuckin awake. All that stated, I took a bit of time to read, and I thinkkkk we’re going the wrong away about this. I see that there’s a lot of posts about “this person town because xxx” and YES make those reads… but I don’t think sharing those reads is a good idea. With multiple noms, I could see factions going for universally tred players, which obviously fucking sucks for us. I’m unsure how we can make those reads without completely screwing ourselves, but maybe we look at like.. groups of 3 or smth and then try to scumhunt from there? (Going to suggest we do it from sign up sheet, for fairness) Now, I’ve also only been awake 20 minutes and I’m probably not cooking with this? But I’m just sharing out here. ngl I'm not approaching this game differently as a player from whether it's multiball or not. It might be my lack of experience but I'd be curious what other people would suggest what to do wrt it being multiball. Specifically realabcavh (bc you mentioned we're forgetting it's KAT) Personally, I do believe that bundling the power of town in coordinating and discussing our reads is more worthwhile than not, even if it does give Mafia the power to kill uniTRs (which.. if they're good players, they could probably figure out who people TR anyway). If we do not, dying without having your reads be known also means that they might be in vain - Snaq I think Sylvie is just really paranoid with all the killing roles that we won't be able to keep up with all the killing and just be left with a very lukewarm town. If anything I think that's just a sign that we really need to play well to avoid that. -pq |
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:29:48 GMT
Some minor housekeeping details id like to touch on real quick Question to the general thread are we doing hypos on cop / seer? Also fwiw im gonna say 95% of the posts that come from this slot are going to be coming from Prod. Myan isnt as heavily active as I am but if you need something ID’d just lmk (Why) do you think we should? I think hypo is always a good idea when there's no protection on cop/seer (cuz I doubt scum will protect investigatives), but I just don't know how we implement it. Do we say like (I got a negative result on x) and then when real cop/seer flips we change "negative result/positive result" to "not mafia/mafia" etc? I'm down for it cuz then invests can safely get their invests out. -pq |
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:30:43 GMT
Anyways I’ll make my solid entrance now because I have zero excuse not to. This is my first forum game, so it definitely caught me off guard with posts about solid vote options when (in my opinion) it’s super early in the mornin and nobody’s reasonably fuckin awake. All that stated, I took a bit of time to read, and I thinkkkk we’re going the wrong away about this. I see that there’s a lot of posts about “this person town because xxx” and YES make those reads… but I don’t think sharing those reads is a good idea. With multiple noms, I could see factions going for universally tred players, which obviously fucking sucks for us. I’m unsure how we can make those reads without completely screwing ourselves, but maybe we look at like.. groups of 3 or smth and then try to scumhunt from there? (Going to suggest we do it from sign up sheet, for fairness) Now, I’ve also only been awake 20 minutes and I’m probably not cooking with this? But I’m just sharing out here. keep this to urself bc im noticing and iykyk WHAT DOES THIS MEANNNN |
|
|
|
Post by PhoenixWrong on May 6, 2024 16:31:28 GMT
pqslays (Pqwerty + SylvieSlays)
ProdiguMyan (Prodigu + MyanMario)
commanderations (commanderawesome + Edjeanerations)
AlexSnaq (Alexander489 + Snaquaza)
SpaghettySyndicate (AligningStars + PokeCartBeast)
cerry7 (erry + C7)
xxdarknessxx (Clouds + camryn)
realabcavh (iamveryhappy + abcaba)
astaroth (Spiderz + LittEleven)
Searing Grace (Schiavetto + OM)
Dactyl's Influenze (Dactyl7 + Influenze)
winnerpov (NightEmerald + lindauna)
remaining slots:
sabrinacarpenter (bananaspritzee + abdel)
turtwigswithravens (Turtwigswiththrohs + vaderaven)
Scumplay (Fame + PassTheSaltDude)
beginnersluck (Yoshman8 + annaoceancat)
top 7 names im currently uninterested in eliminating today, everyone is in order based on posts so far- koba
|
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:35:33 GMT
Have any of the bottom of your list really posted much yet Nick?
Cuz usually I don't think scum is afk but there's a distinct lack of chaos and distrust here that makes me wonder if no one is actively meddling with it. -pq
|
|
realabcavh
Treestump
abcaba and... uhhh who's that? oh it doesn't matter dw
Posts: 24
|
Post by realabcavh on May 6, 2024 16:36:14 GMT
Town: AlexSnaq Dove in and started solving. If they're scum they'd have to be deep wolf cuz the analysis seems deep and hard to fake especially since they've been delivering consistent quality. probably my highest tr rn. Townlean: Phoenixwrong I've seen this playstyle come from town where they just say town and scum on posts before finally making a readslist. I also agree with their reads so far so it's sort of a mindmeld. townlean for now. darkness They appear to be solving and reevaluating. I feel like s!darkness wouldn't have reconsidered my slot so quickly and would've just pushed me more cuz I'm pretty lhf. Townlean Null: Astaroth It's only like 14 posts but nothing really pings me about it. I need to see more from them to really have an opinion but I looked into this slot since people were sl-ing it already. Spaghetti This slot feels like it's just meme-ing rn so until they stop that it's null. commanderations Idk darkness says they're openly not caring and I sort of agree. They don't seem to be pushing any agenda rn so even if they're a scum they don't seem to pose any threat to anyone. There's also like hints of solving here. Kinda null I think still tho cuz it's not too hard to fake. Scum lean: Searing Grace Their slot just feels really fillery. It's a bunch of questions whose answers don't seem to really matter (asking people if they are scum, asking me if I'm going to play different, asking Camryn if they have any player meta, asking how the start of day should be played differently) and a bunch of comments that don't really matter (randomly voting phoenixwrong and needlessly saying that it was an rv, saying that they want the darkness gimmick to stop, read receipts). Idk it just seems like they're posting on things that don't matter and lead to off-topic tangents. Also idk why people don't seem to like me saying "I think Grace is sus for thinking darkness' gimmick is sus, and I'd sus them even more if they try to make a case on darkness for it cuz sussing a gimmick is a bad reason to sus someone". It just feels like a weird slot. I don't know how to feel about it exactly but a very low confidence sl for now. whyare you on this acc  |
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:37:45 GMT
whyare you on this acc I made an oops. -pq |
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:38:36 GMT
But also realabcavh do you have anything to say about my reads? Or is that all u had to say?
|
|
|
|
Post by SylvieSlays2 on May 6, 2024 16:39:05 GMT
Anyways I’ll make my solid entrance now because I have zero excuse not to. This is my first forum game, so it definitely caught me off guard with posts about solid vote options when (in my opinion) it’s super early in the mornin and nobody’s reasonably fuckin awake. All that stated, I took a bit of time to read, and I thinkkkk we’re going the wrong away about this. I see that there’s a lot of posts about “this person town because xxx” and YES make those reads… but I don’t think sharing those reads is a good idea. With multiple noms, I could see factions going for universally tred players, which obviously fucking sucks for us. I’m unsure how we can make those reads without completely screwing ourselves, but maybe we look at like.. groups of 3 or smth and then try to scumhunt from there? (Going to suggest we do it from sign up sheet, for fairness) Now, I’ve also only been awake 20 minutes and I’m probably not cooking with this? But I’m just sharing out here. ngl I'm not approaching this game differently as a player from whether it's multiball or not. It might be my lack of experience but I'd be curious what other people would suggest what to do wrt it being multiball. Specifically realabcavh (bc you mentioned we're forgetting it's KAT) Personally, I do believe that bundling the power of town in coordinating and discussing our reads is more worthwhile than not, even if it does give Mafia the power to kill uniTRs (which.. if they're good players, they could probably figure out who people TR anyway). If we do not, dying without having your reads be known also means that they might be in vain - Snaq You’re def right, and as PQ said earlier I’m really just paranoid about losing all of the good town early, especially with my lack of being able to make good reads consistently. I’m thinking now that we should focus more on scumreads today and we can focus more on finding town when it comes to like tmr - Sylvie |
|
|
|
Post by AlexSnaq on May 6, 2024 16:40:38 GMT
Have any of the bottom of your list really posted much yet Nick? Cuz usually I don't think scum is afk but there's a distinct lack of chaos and distrust here that makes me wonder if no one is actively meddling with it. -pq ftr with anna / vade being new to forum games (as far as i know) and yosh / turt being inexperienced, I would believe them naturally not having taken the initiative to join the game yet. (Esp Yosh/Anna slot, neither of whom is very active in Mafia.) I do expect to see content from the other two soon tho |
|
|
|
Post by AlexSnaq on May 6, 2024 16:41:56 GMT
pqslays feels very genuine rn
- Snaq (likewise w the above. I often forget to tag my posts)
|
|
|
|
Post by commanderations on May 6, 2024 16:47:33 GMT
ok i have read. Too lazy to quote a bunch of posts so will instead just respond to a lot at once:
i like alexsnaqs opening lines and am kind of mind melding with their opening reads- iavh opening felt kinda awkward to me and am also leaning town on phoenix after they stopped being cringe and I think aligning's behaviour is relatively townie. clouds def does not make it out of null for me tho i cannot ever dismiss the possibility of being pocketed :(.
re prod i would love to hypo inspects (in the form of just "inspected x player as town, not saying seer or cop) but i dont think ive seen a successful hypo on ps mafia for like 4 years. We should break the curse and be the first tho
some added reads outside of the snaqalex ones: im sticking with the shit i said about pq last night, i think they have continued to stay town tone. Same with prod ngl. At this point i may be misconstruing active players with tls but idk i hope not, am not doing that with clouds/schiom slots. I also didnt like tbz/abdels entrance but i think i hated how tbz played in the last forum game i played with em and they were town so wont put much meaning on that. Dont think i have a read on c7 slot, but I like what theyve said thus far for the sake of progressing the game at least, so dont want a vote there.
Would love if the other half of the game would start talking because as people have mentioned this tr shit is unhelpful with 3 kills a night, towncores arent gonna happen. Gotta start scum hunting, I have listed too many people I dont want to vote heres some people i do wanna vote:
vote @realabcavhand also dact and also winnerpov and also tbz
|
|
|
|
Post by PhoenixWrong on May 6, 2024 16:49:02 GMT
Have any of the bottom of your list really posted much yet Nick? Cuz usually I don't think scum is afk but there's a distinct lack of chaos and distrust here that makes me wonder if no one is actively meddling with it. -pq i separated the 0 posters from the rest |
|
astaroth
Bodyguard
spiderz + litteleven
Posts: 163
|
Post by astaroth on May 6, 2024 16:49:20 GMT
Also, cam and I both agree that ca is a townlean for us so far Main reasons at least from my end were that commie's posting seems like he's reacting to things naturally and also lacks hesitance to stick votes to the frequent posters for reasons as shallow as "the slot is annoying" which, while that's not inherently townie, felt like he does not give a f*ck about his image. Not saying this is something anyone should do at all, because it's not and he does not deserve to be getting a pass for it, but I townread his approach to it unfortunately and that I cannot control We have also agreed to censor profanity such as f*ck and sh*t, because unlike the many heathens in this world, we do not want to cause harm with foul language - Clouds echoing this read, commie's thread presence was honest yeah im leavin thread now Will form better reads on pc tmrw but based on vibes Rn I like prodimyan schiaom (minus the banner) and pqsylv phoenix wrong entry was good Commanderations is also somehat townie (minus the banner) Xxdarknessxx is a vibe sr but that might be the emoposting so idk Litt signed but idrc for their posts that much either way so they’re nai Anyways goodbye -as I want to like this, I think How do we feel, @searing Grace - Clouds feels less like trying to fit in more like actively sorting the game im a fan
Spot on I can see those being real reads for Aligning, but it would be good for him to expand on some of the townreads, particularly the prodmyan one I'm... unsure how you get to prodmyan as town given what we have seen so far related note think this interaction from clouds!pov is pretty solvy => good, question feels worded to draw out "worse" responses like serene grace response asw obv yeah probably would toss a unpair between camclouds/omschia off this - litt |
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on May 6, 2024 16:49:26 GMT
Let's get one thing straight, I'm in this strictly for the badge  tbh schia can u make me one of those with a turtwig - turt |
|
