|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jun 18, 2024 17:01:42 GMT
Feel like more recent stuff from arti has me pushing them into TL here too
|
|
|
|
Post by Sheep★Go★Moo on Jun 18, 2024 17:08:49 GMT
I disagree
Also sue me for forgetting i signed up lmfao
|
|
|
|
Post by yashgreninja on Jun 18, 2024 17:11:48 GMT
vote @OMcall me out for going against the grain of the PL, idc, but I refuse to vote PCB or Aligning Can you explain this one? I feel like the constant TRing of OM by the PL is a mix of vibes + just shoehorning the read itself, and it seems way too easy to just assume that with little to nothing going for it. You could say this is hypocritical of myself and you'd be right but I'm not necessarily towning myself or convincing anyone I'm town either. Simply just off of vibes, I already don't like how d1 progressed, would've been better off voting me so I could nom more questionable slots than these three and actually force question mark slots to start playing the game for everyone else's benefit Also I feel like in the same light that OM is being TRed, PCB did a very similar thing and unless I'm misreading the progression with regards to both them + OM, I fail to see what the difference is aside from forcibly making PCB an easier vote Aligning also feels like a slot that people justify to be voted out, not because they've done anything inherently scummy, rather they just use the OM nom as an opportunity to reiterate their TR on him and then deflect attention to the other two as a result To be quite frank, I feel like all 3 of these slots could go either way, and I can't say with full confidence that one is more likely to be scum than town, so from my perspective, looking at what I think/know, I'm voting the person I think has provided the least likely to be town, and that is OM Feel free to disagree or call me out for any of this, idrc Only thing that makes me hesitant on OM in future rounds is that if they are scum but more and more ppl town him, he could become impossible to deal with, but there's also the complete opposite of the spectrum where cuddleszz came basically out of nowhere and accused me of being scum with OM which I found kinda weird? I'm not going to solve for partners this soon but I feel like cuddz and OM could either be TvT or TvS? If it's the latter, then I wouldn't know who to pick for town and scum, although in the event that the game progresses in that direction generally, I wouldn't be opposed to voting either out |
|
|
|
Post by Sheep★Go★Moo on Jun 18, 2024 17:13:14 GMT
I'm inclined to tl OM~! after going through their d1 iso, they are actively making an effort to ask questions and progress the game(albeit this comes after the random sl's on them for not...talking?) The standard for making a town effort is also pretty low atp... I am curious about your reads on yash and john atm(zzzz one post so far) I kinda assumed your interactions with gary were hella fabricated until i realized that...sheep is just actively lurking, the sole contribution being a vote on prodigu that could've been applicable on a lot more slots at that time which kinda makes me sl them I also have to ask how my prod read being applicable to other ppl makes it a scummy reason to read someone? he was the example i saw and disagreed with hence my vote. furthermore there were a good 4/5 other vanities which going by ur logic should mean that the read is elsewhere applicable lol |
|
|
|
Post by Sheep★Go★Moo on Jun 18, 2024 17:14:40 GMT
Can you explain this one? I feel like the constant TRing of OM by the PL is a mix of vibes + just shoehorning the read itself, and it seems way too easy to just assume that with little to nothing going for it. You could say this is hypocritical of myself and you'd be right but I'm not necessarily towning myself or convincing anyone I'm town either. Simply just off of vibes, I already don't like how d1 progressed, would've been better off voting me so I could nom more questionable slots than these three and actually force question mark slots to start playing the game for everyone else's benefit Also I feel like in the same light that OM is being TRed, PCB did a very similar thing and unless I'm misreading the progression with regards to both them + OM, I fail to see what the difference is aside from forcibly making PCB an easier vote Aligning also feels like a slot that people justify to be voted out, not because they've done anything inherently scummy, rather they just use the OM nom as an opportunity to reiterate their TR on him and then deflect attention to the other two as a result To be quite frank, I feel like all 3 of these slots could go either way, and I can't say with full confidence that one is more likely to be scum than town, so from my perspective, looking at what I think/know, I'm voting the person I think has provided the least likely to be town, and that is OM Feel free to disagree or call me out for any of this, idrc Only thing that makes me hesitant on OM in future rounds is that if they are scum but more and more ppl town him, he could become impossible to deal with, but there's also the complete opposite of the spectrum where cuddleszz came basically out of nowhere and accused me of being scum with OM which I found kinda weird? I'm not going to solve for partners this soon but I feel like cuddz and OM could either be TvT or TvS? If it's the latter, then I wouldn't know who to pick for town and scum, although in the event that the game progresses in that direction generally, I wouldn't be opposed to voting either out I think there’s scope to say here that in a world where OM is town that at minimum 1 tl on them is scum following other people |
|
|
|
Post by deadbydaylight on Jun 18, 2024 17:24:10 GMT
OM slot seems rather safe rn
vote @aligningstars for now
Snaq edit: fixed vote
|
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jun 18, 2024 17:51:25 GMT
Can you explain this one? I feel like the constant TRing of OM by the PL is a mix of vibes + just shoehorning the read itself, and it seems way too easy to just assume that with little to nothing going for it. You could say this is hypocritical of myself and you'd be right but I'm not necessarily towning myself or convincing anyone I'm town either. Simply just off of vibes, I already don't like how d1 progressed, would've been better off voting me so I could nom more questionable slots than these three and actually force question mark slots to start playing the game for everyone else's benefit Also I feel like in the same light that OM is being TRed, PCB did a very similar thing and unless I'm misreading the progression with regards to both them + OM, I fail to see what the difference is aside from forcibly making PCB an easier vote Aligning also feels like a slot that people justify to be voted out, not because they've done anything inherently scummy, rather they just use the OM nom as an opportunity to reiterate their TR on him and then deflect attention to the other two as a result To be quite frank, I feel like all 3 of these slots could go either way, and I can't say with full confidence that one is more likely to be scum than town, so from my perspective, looking at what I think/know, I'm voting the person I think has provided the least likely to be town, and that is OM Feel free to disagree or call me out for any of this, idrc Only thing that makes me hesitant on OM in future rounds is that if they are scum but more and more ppl town him, he could become impossible to deal with, but there's also the complete opposite of the spectrum where cuddleszz came basically out of nowhere and accused me of being scum with OM which I found kinda weird? I'm not going to solve for partners this soon but I feel like cuddz and OM could either be TvT or TvS? If it's the latter, then I wouldn't know who to pick for town and scum, although in the event that the game progresses in that direction generally, I wouldn't be opposed to voting either out I feel so called out by some of this So i like wanna understand this 1) You think the TRs on OM are being shoehorned in, so like does this mean ppl are trying to just strongarm OM into like Town / Towncore in your eyes? ^ if like thats what you mean (and i think it is) it looks like youre thinking ppl putting OM into town are just fabricating the read, which would ig mean that at least 1 or 2 maybe 3? Idk if id put 3. But in a Scum OM world then that some of those reads are trying to just make sure OM reaches an endgame scenario essentially? Who would you put as an OM partner here then 2) do you think new TR OM readers are just fabricating the read then to try to get an easy mis vote off onto Aligning / Pcb? 3) I dont like the last justification part of like where youre saying that if OM reaches future rounds he’ll be problematic to deal with. I dislike this because it feels like youre trying to justify a vote onto OM b/c “he could be scum and if he is lets get rid of him now b/c he could be a pain later if ppl town him” I feel like this is disregarding the “well what if OM is town here” I think like realistically in the T OM world the vote ends up being rly bad when OM can definitively do rly well in an end game scenario (i think the world is T OM tbh) Idk about this last part tbh |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jun 18, 2024 17:52:37 GMT
OM slot seems rather safe rn vote @AligningStars for now Wdym by safe? Like do u mean town? Or what exactly? Why aligning over pcb? |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Jun 18, 2024 18:08:55 GMT
Can you explain this one? I feel like the constant TRing of OM by the PL is a mix of vibes + just shoehorning the read itself, and it seems way too easy to just assume that with little to nothing going for it. You could say this is hypocritical of myself and you'd be right but I'm not necessarily towning myself or convincing anyone I'm town either. Simply just off of vibes, I already don't like how d1 progressed, would've been better off voting me so I could nom more questionable slots than these three and actually force question mark slots to start playing the game for everyone else's benefit Also I feel like in the same light that OM is being TRed, PCB did a very similar thing and unless I'm misreading the progression with regards to both them + OM, I fail to see what the difference is aside from forcibly making PCB an easier vote Aligning also feels like a slot that people justify to be voted out, not because they've done anything inherently scummy, rather they just use the OM nom as an opportunity to reiterate their TR on him and then deflect attention to the other two as a result To be quite frank, I feel like all 3 of these slots could go either way, and I can't say with full confidence that one is more likely to be scum than town, so from my perspective, looking at what I think/know, I'm voting the person I think has provided the least likely to be town, and that is OM Feel free to disagree or call me out for any of this, idrc Only thing that makes me hesitant on OM in future rounds is that if they are scum but more and more ppl town him, he could become impossible to deal with, but there's also the complete opposite of the spectrum where cuddleszz came basically out of nowhere and accused me of being scum with OM which I found kinda weird? I'm not going to solve for partners this soon but I feel like cuddz and OM could either be TvT or TvS? If it's the latter, then I wouldn't know who to pick for town and scum, although in the event that the game progresses in that direction generally, I wouldn't be opposed to voting either out I don't think this is a real read you have im not going to lie |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Jun 18, 2024 18:12:58 GMT
I feel like the constant TRing of OM by the PL is a mix of vibes + just shoehorning the read itself, and it seems way too easy to just assume that with little to nothing going for it. You could say this is hypocritical of myself and you'd be right but I'm not necessarily towning myself or convincing anyone I'm town either. Simply just off of vibes, I already don't like how d1 progressed, would've been better off voting me so I could nom more questionable slots than these three and actually force question mark slots to start playing the game for everyone else's benefit Also I feel like in the same light that OM is being TRed, PCB did a very similar thing and unless I'm misreading the progression with regards to both them + OM, I fail to see what the difference is aside from forcibly making PCB an easier vote Aligning also feels like a slot that people justify to be voted out, not because they've done anything inherently scummy, rather they just use the OM nom as an opportunity to reiterate their TR on him and then deflect attention to the other two as a result To be quite frank, I feel like all 3 of these slots could go either way, and I can't say with full confidence that one is more likely to be scum than town, so from my perspective, looking at what I think/know, I'm voting the person I think has provided the least likely to be town, and that is OM Feel free to disagree or call me out for any of this, idrc Only thing that makes me hesitant on OM in future rounds is that if they are scum but more and more ppl town him, he could become impossible to deal with, but there's also the complete opposite of the spectrum where cuddleszz came basically out of nowhere and accused me of being scum with OM which I found kinda weird? I'm not going to solve for partners this soon but I feel like cuddz and OM could either be TvT or TvS? If it's the latter, then I wouldn't know who to pick for town and scum, although in the event that the game progresses in that direction generally, I wouldn't be opposed to voting either out I don't think this is a real read you have im not going to lie Like it boils down to "Okay OM is getting kinda Mega TRed but he has the potential to be wolf and also cuddleszz slot is weird"
I am of the opinion PCB is the wolfiest out of the three of us because PCB's solving was an attempt to get control of threadstate rather than actual solving, there's a lack of flexibility that feels like he wasn't trying to actually solve the game but show he has reads and progressions without actually doing things to re-evaluate them.
I am also of the opinion that you bullshitted this entire post to make you wanting me out of the game make sense.
can someone put yash up as a nom.
|
|
|
|
Post by deadbydaylight on Jun 18, 2024 18:25:38 GMT
OM slot seems rather safe rn vote @AligningStars for now Wdym by safe? Like do u mean town? Or what exactly? Why aligning over pcb? Safe = pretty sure it's town for now, aligning and PCB are interchangeable and I have to reread a lot again |
|
|
|
Post by cuddleszz on Jun 18, 2024 18:32:47 GMT
OM can i have your updated townread list?
|
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Jun 18, 2024 18:51:35 GMT
Prod/Toni > Gary/Align > John > Artic > Penguind/Sheep > Cuddz > DeadbyDaylight/ice_knight > turtwig > yash/pcb
Feeling around here~
- I've liked Peng/Sheep's recent posts
- disliked yash's a whole lot
- think your posts fit ur general gameplay but hesitant on whether you're just a crazy person or not
- moving john down until he posts again he needs 1 townie post a day to keep up
- DbD / Ice / Turtwig I just need to see more from
If nommed I think I throw up 3 of ice turt yash pcb
|
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jun 18, 2024 19:05:19 GMT
Entrance wise and pretty much vibe wise I do like PCB's enterance giving vibes early on in the game. Really not too much outstand plays from anyone else here. I dont see to why as twt is being townbinned here as they didnt fully answer the question. @turtwigwiththrohs if its good to build a towncore who do like so far and why? Also I do see yash coming in as a bit of a town vibe here and giving analysis to tone but nothing much outside of that (hbay yash). Ice_knight pretty null, said something useless about not knowing whose mafia really early on which I would say is very slightly town Ill assume toni is crespo and they give townie vibes. Came off with a pretty straight on entrance and just energetic vibes. I havent played much with them so I cant say anything but tonally i like them. Om not doing his magic and just voted yash for the sake of freeing up his schedule is pretty weird considering we have already 2 votes on yash (their vote failed) so i dont like OM too much here. If anyones active rn feel free to question me or my thoughts Kinda like trying to take a look at aligning rn, and try to work through pcb / align kinda just looking a lot at iso it feels kinda flat to me rn, gonna try to just talk myself through some stuff ig to see if i can get somewhere, Feel like the Yash and OM reads here stick out to me a bit Like context wise the Yash one was like, idk if Yash even made more than just his availability post so idk about the town vibe from that The OM read is weird too, like fwiw i feel like im putting myself in Oms shoes to some extent here, or like i have had a similar experience to some extent where like you do 1 like thing ppl dont get and ppl are trying to put bad vibes on you from it or like you havent gotten far enough in x amt of time reading wise and i feel like this echoes that thought for me a bit Gonna try to see if i can find some positive points for aligning if i can, same for pcb tbh Would rly appreciate him popping in before dl so we can get something a little bit better, was hoping either of them would be here |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jun 18, 2024 19:09:41 GMT
My read on pcb is not bc they tried to solve early on in the game its because what they did try to do felt like wolf pretending to solve rather than naturally looking to evaluate slots He made an opinion off of 1 or 2 posts, stuck with it, and didn't try to pressure them really, instead just openly going "this is weird to me" without much going into the evaluation Imo, it doesn't read as town who's solving but rather wolf who's trying to take control of threadstate Understood, thank you clarifying. I do like this coming from OM, these do definitely make sense here and I get see where OM is coming from and I feel like this is townie solving. Kinda going back to here, Feel like this is a positive point i can speak on for align where hes talking to OM about his pcb / john reads Kinda gives like —> attempting to actually understand the read and like work out the details |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jun 18, 2024 19:14:15 GMT
Understood, thank you clarifying. I do like this coming from OM, these do definitely make sense here and I get see where OM is coming from and I feel like this is townie solving. Kinda going back to here, Feel like this is a positive point i can speak on for align where hes talking to OM about his pcb / john reads Kinda gives like —> attempting to actually understand the read and like work out the details Feel like where im at rn is like OM > > > Pcb ~=~ Align Gonna take a look at pcb see if i can find some points for him too Again, would rly like to see both of them show up here tbh. |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jun 18, 2024 19:22:25 GMT
Kinda going back to here, Feel like this is a positive point i can speak on for align where hes talking to OM about his pcb / john reads Kinda gives like —> attempting to actually understand the read and like work out the details Feel like where im at rn is like OM > > > Pcb ~=~ Align Gonna take a look at pcb see if i can find some points for him too Again, would rly like to see both of them show up here tbh. Scrap that for like a lil bit, phones dying at work atm so ill read pcb through when i get home hopefully they both show up by then |
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Jun 18, 2024 19:23:15 GMT
Good morning morioh-cho, most reads are the same as before
i liked arti's interaction with cuddz, felt genuine? the qualms i had with the slot d1 still stay but i'm less confident in scumreading them now
twt still lighttown but i townread most of the activeposters atp (prod/om/cuddz/aligning/toni/yash/gary in order of towniest to least townie) so i want to say that there are 1-3 scum within twt/pd/deadbydaylight/sgm/john/iceknight - scumlean on PD still persists even after popin, sgm/iceknight/deadbydaylight/john's limited contributions all still feel very null, would like to FOS deadbydaylight specifically for not really having a preference between me/aligning + sheeping the general consensus on OM and SGM for their recentposts feeling more inclined to defend themselves than form reads
gth scumteam arti/pd/deadbydaylight/sgm
will have to further reread aligning/om (which i dont rlly feel like doing rn lol) to see where i'd rather vote, all in all i tr both slots
|
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Jun 18, 2024 19:34:20 GMT
actually just rereading through today's pages I really like the approach OM is taken specifically their reads on me and yash, though i obviously disagree with the former and still townlean yash, don't feel manufactured and I can see the thought process behind them - take ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/129884/thread for example, i like this line as a livereact to yash's read + establishment of sr on yash + reiteration of the sr on me aligning's contributions today have been fine, i like the solves in a void but they also don't have the same "town solving through the game" feeling that their d1 popin did would like to livepost a bit more before i decide on a vote but I'm leaning a bit towards aligning atp |
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Jun 18, 2024 19:38:32 GMT
AligningStars what's your opinion on my slot and om? who would you rather vote here and who are you nomming if you flip? fwiw I'm nomming arti/pd/sgm here
|
|
|
|
Post by Snaq ◢ ◤ on Jun 18, 2024 20:04:29 GMT
Votecount 2.2: 2 hours to go until deadline. If deadline was right now, AligningStars would be voted out. Please let me know of any mistakes in the Votecount. (2) AligningStars: Prodigu, articunight(1) PokeCartBeast: OM~!(1) OM~!: yashgreninja(11) Not Voting: cuddleszz, Turtwigswiththrohs, Sheep★Go★Moo, Crespo, PenguinD, AligningStars, Ice_Knight, PokeCartBeast, deadbydaylight, John, Gary The SavageMake sure to submit your Death Noms in PMs even if you are not being voted right now before the day is over. Remember: they will be randomized if you do not (though I'll try to track you down first).
|
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jun 18, 2024 20:06:56 GMT
Im back, seems like i have 2 votes on me. Will be answering questions rn.
|
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jun 18, 2024 20:13:31 GMT
AligningStars what's your opinion on my slot and om? who would you rather vote here and who are you nomming if you flip? fwiw I'm nomming arti/pd/sgm here Juts like u i really like both your slots, i didnt like OM at first but when i did start interacting with him and they did give me like valid answers i started tr'ing them more. As for now my noms would probably go into arti/cuddz/turt. For me turt has like i siad done a whole lot of nothing for now and hasnt really done anything too townie and didnt actually answer questions asked to them directly. Arti is like not answering my questions and didnt really giev a clear understanding to me on why they even voted ck in the first place. Also came on to me today while sr'ing pcb the other day. cuddz reads dont really make sense to me and really just saying things that dont really help progress the game and just pots reads without why they think someone is town or scum. |
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jun 18, 2024 20:14:35 GMT
If theres any concerns i will vchange it, i kind of think i go here so womp womp
|
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jun 18, 2024 20:17:07 GMT
AligningStars what's your opinion on my slot and om? who would you rather vote here and who are you nomming if you flip? fwiw I'm nomming arti/pd/sgm here also where did ur sgm read come from, i saw no lines coming from you about that slot. |
|
