Food Mafia [Game Over!]

[incognito]

None of us can stop a kill with our roles so either mafia decided not to kill or they were just inactive.

[incognito]

So if I were to go by playstyle I would lynch citrus, but if I were to go by logic I would lynch igpay.
Reasons:
1-Inactive player, could have forgot to send in the kill.
2-His role is the most probable one to be a mafia role investigating as town. I don't see a mafia bomb in this game or a mafia (coronis' role)
Therefore,
lynch igpay
Tbh it's mostly becayse i want this to end

[Deleted]

May 30, 2015 14:00:45 GMT incognito said:

So if I were to go by playstyle I would lynch citrus, but if I were to go by logic I would lynch igpay.
Reasons:
1-Inactive player, could have forgot to send in the kill.
2-His role is the most probable one to be a mafia role investigating as town. I don't see a mafia bomb in this game or a mafia (coronis' role)
Therefore,
lynch igpay
Tbh it's mostly becayse i want this to end

...That was a lure! (It was actually done in an attempt to distract the kill to either you or Coronis, so the other could 'get Igpay lynched tomorrow easily' but eh.)
Lynch ODM
When Rabac made the case of 'inactive mafia not sending in a kill' you passively mocked it. But now... Now that you saw that I was willing to lynch Igpay tomorrow, what do you do? Exactly what a Mafiosi would.
You even validated it by saying "if I were to go by logic"... But your two reasons were pretty far from logic in of themselves. Either your pride encouraged you to foolishly piggyback on my false claims of a logical argument against Igpay, or you are scum who genuinely fell for that.
The only real question to be raised is: Would ODM, as scum, decide that NKing to lynch Igpay on a MyLo was a better option than killing Coronis then lynching Igpay on a LyLo? Of course he would. My vote was too unstable for ODM to trust me to place in on Igpay on a LyLo, even though I was considering Igpay as a target. But get it in MyLo, and suddenly we have a cause for pause that would make me hesitate and avoid lynching ODM.

Any complaints? If so, POST YOUR FREAKING ROLE PM. AT THIS POINT YOU CANNOT COMPLAIN IF THERE IS STILL THE PROSPECT OF A HIDDEN GODFATHER IF YOU DO NOTHING ABOUT IT.

[Igpay»atinlay]

I'm sorry I haven't been active. I'll post my opinions for now.

Citrus has a good point that odm hasn't posted his PM yet and for this I am suspicious. I also think that there's a good chance coro is mafia because of how little he's helped town. From what I've seen, all he's done is talk very holier-than-thou to everyone. odm has a good point about citrus that he has been very spammy and very eager to clear himself.

Overall verdict: you're all scum

man I suck at this. Basically, I think everyone should post his/her roles here. I'm fairly certain citrus did, but odm and coro haven't so please do that.

[incognito]

May 30, 2015 16:59:03 GMT Citrus Freak said:

May 30, 2015 14:00:45 GMT incognito said:

So if I were to go by playstyle I would lynch citrus, but if I were to go by logic I would lynch igpay.
Reasons:
1-Inactive player, could have forgot to send in the kill.
2-His role is the most probable one to be a mafia role investigating as town. I don't see a mafia bomb in this game or a mafia (coronis' role)
Therefore,
lynch igpay
Tbh it's mostly becayse i want this to end

...That was a lure! (It was actually done in an attempt to distract the kill to either you or Coronis, so the other could 'get Igpay lynched tomorrow easily' but eh.)
Lynch ODM
When Rabac made the case of 'inactive mafia not sending in a kill' you passively mocked it. But now... Now that you saw that I was willing to lynch Igpay tomorrow, what do you do? Exactly what a Mafiosi would.
You even validated it by saying "if I were to go by logic"... But your two reasons were pretty far from logic in of themselves. Either your pride encouraged you to foolishly piggyback on my false claims of a logical argument against Igpay, or you are scum who genuinely fell for that.
The only real question to be raised is: Would ODM, as scum, decide that NKing to lynch Igpay on a MyLo was a better option than killing Coronis then lynching Igpay on a LyLo? Of course he would. My vote was too unstable for ODM to trust me to place in on Igpay on a LyLo, even though I was considering Igpay as a target. But get it in MyLo, and suddenly we have a cause for pause that would make me hesitate and avoid lynching ODM.

Any complaints? If so, POST YOUR FREAKING ROLE PM. AT THIS POINT YOU CANNOT COMPLAIN IF THERE IS STILL THE PROSPECT OF A HIDDEN GODFATHER IF YOU DO NOTHING ABOUT IT.

I did not read all of that because you bore me. And actually i didn't even see the post you sent last night. I still don't have to defend myself as i explained the reason for my lynch.

[Coronis]

May 30, 2015 17:31:54 GMT Igpay»atinlay said:

I'm sorry I haven't been active. I'll post my opinions for now.

Citrus has a good point that odm hasn't posted his PM yet and for this I am suspicious. I also think that there's a good chance coro is mafia because of how little he's helped town. From what I've seen, all he's done is talk very holier-than-thou to everyone. odm has a good point about citrus that he has been very spammy and very eager to clear himself.

Overall verdict: you're all scum

man I suck at this. Basically, I think everyone should post his/her roles here. I'm fairly certain citrus did, but odm and coro haven't so please do that.

holier-than-thou Godfather

[incognito]

May 31, 2015 3:04:41 GMT Coronis said:

May 30, 2015 17:31:54 GMT Igpay»atinlay said:

I'm sorry I haven't been active. I'll post my opinions for now.

Citrus has a good point that odm hasn't posted his PM yet and for this I am suspicious. I also think that there's a good chance coro is mafia because of how little he's helped town. From what I've seen, all he's done is talk very holier-than-thou to everyone. odm has a good point about citrus that he has been very spammy and very eager to clear himself.

Overall verdict: you're all scum

man I suck at this. Basically, I think everyone should post his/her roles here. I'm fairly certain citrus did, but odm and coro haven't so please do that.

holier-than-thou Godfather

Coro can you please vote?

[incognito]

Igpay too, this game has gone on long enough

[incognito]

Dear ODM,
You are the Mango!

Mangoes are great! Everyone loves em, they look great, taste delicious, and did you know they were the national fruit of India?

Because every other fruit loves you, you can always ask them about what they're doing. Each night you can inspect someone. You'll find out their identity by doing so.

You are sided with the Fruit, and win when all non-Fruit members are eliminated.

This is my role pm if it makes you vote. It doesn't have a picture because I'm on my phone and can't figure out how to properly quote it.

[incognito]

Oh and I can also send all 3 of your roles if you want me to prove myself

[Coronis]

Decisions decisions.

[Igpay»atinlay]

May 31, 2015 3:04:41 GMT Coronis said:

May 30, 2015 17:31:54 GMT Igpay»atinlay said:

I'm sorry I haven't been active. I'll post my opinions for now.

Citrus has a good point that odm hasn't posted his PM yet and for this I am suspicious. I also think that there's a good chance coro is mafia because of how little he's helped town. From what I've seen, all he's done is talk very holier-than-thou to everyone. odm has a good point about citrus that he has been very spammy and very eager to clear himself.

Overall verdict: you're all scum

man I suck at this. Basically, I think everyone should post his/her roles here. I'm fairly certain citrus did, but odm and coro haven't so please do that.

holier-than-thou Godfather

?

[Coronis]

Well yeah this is getting boring. I think ODM's logic is pretty sound, regarding igpay and citrus' roles, so yeah. Eh if ODM is mafia cop aj sux for not giving us one. Plus I can't be sure I won't be killed tonight anyway. Oh well. lynch igpay gg everyone. oh plus i never bought that whole irl claim shit. get mad at me if its citrus tho, but if it was i assume he'd be voting with odm, to try and get igpay lynched so he could kill someone else then win tomorrow, but w/e

[ajhockeystar]

rip Igpay! He was the...

SPOILER: Click to show

Dear Igpay_atinlay,
You are the Strawberry!


Do you think that your role is berry good? Because I do. That joke was berry funny y/y

As a strawberry, you have lots of seeds. Twice during the game at night, you can choose to equip your seeds. If anyone tries to use a night action on you that night, you will throw your countless seeds at them until they leave.

You are sided with the Fruit, and win when all non-Fruit members are eliminated.

Night 9 Commence! Deadline is 2 days from now, or when I receive all actions.

[Coronis]

Classic.

[ajhockeystar]

I shall end the night, as I have received the game ending action.

Coronis was killed! He was...

SPOILER: Click to show

Dear Coronis,
You are the Watermelon!


Humans are mostly made out of water, and so are watermelons. So when we eat watermelons, is that cannibalism?

Since you're so big, your vote is worth 2. On every odd day (other than day 1), you'll grow even more, and your vote will be worth 1 more than it was before. This maxes out when your vote is worth 4.

You are sided with the Fruit, and win when all non-Fruit members are eliminated.

Citrus, being the last remaining town member, is endgamed! He was the...

SPOILER: Click to show

Dear Iosse,
You are the Cherry!


For some reason, cherries are always picked to be that food that contains the bomb in spy movies.

In this game, you happen to have a bomb with you, and if anyone tries to nightkill you, you'll blow up and they'll die in the process.

You are sided with the Fruit, and win when all non-Fruit members are eliminated.

This means that ODM, along with his deceased partners, TheVexinator and Fort, are the winners! Here is ODM's role:

SPOILER: Click to show

Dear ODM,
You are the Carrot!


Carrots are great! Rabbits love 'em, they look great as noses on snowmen, and they help your vision!

Since your vision is so great, each night you can inspect someone. You'll find out their identity by doing so.

You are also able to perform the factional nightkill.

You are sided with the Vegetables and win when you control half the town and nothing can stop you from doing so.

I may or may not make a postgame/provide thoughts later. Either way, feel free to discuss now, whether you're alive or dead!

[Coronis]

I blame aj for putting a maf inspector but no town one so meh. Maybe my fault since Mango was less likely to be in the game than Strawberry and Cherry but w/e. ODM also did well by not killing me til today gaining my trust. Since he knew I was mayor, I assumed if he was mafia I'd have been dead already. But oh well.

[rssp1]

This game was cancer, both sides played terribly after TWD's death. ODM played a decent endgame though, but he ought to have been lynched far before that. Shoutout to citrus for being logically sound throughout the whole game while getting shit on by everyone but Rabac, and shoutout to both Citrus and Rabac for having the exact reason as to why ODM was scum and then unlynching him.
I can't even give you guys credit for the lynch on Pobaeto, that was a complete and utter fluke.

I would say gg, but it's really not. As i said at least 9000 times to anyone who would listen to me, town definitely deserved the loss.

Note that when I say the game is cancer, it is in no way aj's fault. Almost completely the fault of the players. At least from now on, people are going to be wary of cops until certain things happen (not going to say what so I can help myself in future games :^))

[rssp1]

My only fuckup in the game (which i'll admit was a rather large one) was trusting ODM unconditionally and giving him all the roles. TWD's only fuckup was stating that his wincon had changed. Fort's only fuckup was claiming a confirmed role to the confirmed role's partner (which is terrible luck).

[ajhockeystar]

It's funny, a situation similar to this happened in a forum mafia game I was in. There was a Mafia Sensor- its purpose was to find a Traitor that was in the game. Us Townies didn't think that through, and followed the Sensor's results... At least until it got to MYLO, when a Suicide Bomber killed the Sensor. Quite the risky play, but it payed off. We managed to lynch one more mafia member before mislynching and losing

Anyways, moral of the story is that nobody is ever confirmed in Closed Setups. Ever. Someone can be 99% Townie, but never confirmed Town.

Now, I like my games to be close. They're more interesting, and overall more is coming out of the work I put into the roles. When you guys lynched 4 anti-town without any mislynches, I thought it was over. But damn, I can't believe ODM made that comeback. Due to their early success and seemingly good skills at finding scum, I kind of wanted town to win once they had made a couple mislynches and the game was a bit closer. I guess that just didn't happen though, they really messed up. Almost all town players after their death said, "ODM is scum, isn't he?" Yeah.

Did you guys not question yourselves, thinking "Why hasn't ODM died yet?" Did you think Coronis or Igpay was a doctor and that they've been protecting ODM the whole time? Why did ODM take so long to claim? There was literally nothing stopping him from posting his role PM immediately after he said he was cop. That's what should have been asked right when he said his first inspection. Basically, don't blindly follow the cop in a Closed Setup. Ever.

I can see the other side of the coin though- Coro didn't want to reveal his role at all, adding suspicion to him, Igpay was inactive... I mean, hindsight is 20/20

And as for the reasoning I didn't include a town cop. I don't like including them usually, the games usually happen to be follow the cop when I do so. (See: this game) Most of the time I make the cop/other info roles have limited uses/only be sidecops/other similar restrictions.

Here's the list of night actions:

SPOILER: Click to show

Night 1:
MyWay- Make Coro target himself
rssp- send message to TWD + public message
Vig- Convert TWD, steal Citrus's action, kill snack
ODM- Inspect Vig, kill snack
Vex- force TWD to vote MyWay
Igpay- idle
Drookez- idle

Night 2:
Igpay- Equip seeds
MyWay- make Sanj target herself
TWD- No kill
ODM- kill rssp, inspect Drookez
Vex- make Coro vote TWD
Sanj- drop apple on Drookez
rssp- send message to MyWay

Night 3:
ODM- inspect Igpay, kill Drookez
MyWay- action recharge
Igpay- idle

Night 4:
ODM- kill Igpay, inspect Rabbac

Night 5:
MyWay- make Sanj target herself
Igpay- equip seeds

After Night 5, it was just ODM's kills and inspects, which I didn't note down anymore.

I messed up and allowed MyWay and Vex to use their actions the first two nights... So I made them have to recharge for two nights before being able to use them again.

Anyways, I had fun hosting this game Stay tuned for the next round of the anon tourney coming soon after my exams end!

[TheWhoDoctor]

I'm just annoyed they didn't see it. mafia went after igpay, and he used the role he offered up to everyone, and yet you still lynched him.

[rssp1]

A combination of town inactivity/town boredom/town ineptitude lead to a town loss.

[Coronis]

Jun 2, 2015 0:34:04 GMT rssp1 said:

A combination of town inactivity/town boredom/town ineptitude lead to a town loss.

Plus you giving all the roles. Although yes I should've seen it if I was paying more attention.

[rssp1]

tbh while my giving the roles was a major fuckup, ODM made enough mistakes that good town would have lynched him.

[incognito]

Aj the only reason I inspected vigvig night 1 was becayse you gave mafia and 3rd party the same fakeclaims. When he said he was tomato i immediately knew he was third party, and tried to win the town's trust with that.
Also cut me some slack i won the game with no friggin partners.