|
|
Post by yashgreninja on Jun 7, 2019 4:00:30 GMT
I didn't even realize that saying 'we' would be caught as a townslip, that's my bad. I'm not pretending to be a noob, I just regret not being more active day one since I now have to properly read back multiple pages of posts since I didn't know what was going on. Again, I said that message to (I think) wob after they asked what happened post-subbing in, and if you scroll down later, I point out that I forgot that it was D6, therefore explaining why I originally thought there was a doctor but in reality it doesn't exist. I know that this may seem like filler text, but I have nothing else I can say since, like you said Brady, nobody is talking for Day 2. I can see this being genuine, gonna maintain pressure as of now, also that “we” isn’t really that big of a slip, me picking at straws.. Which is all we have at this point. Although I like the defense you just made, still sticking on you FOR NOW Understood. By the way, thimblebony ain't talking much at all, I'd like to see him speak up or be given an activity check. |
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Jun 7, 2019 6:07:01 GMT
Sorry for this very mooby question but how do u bold uwu
|
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 12:31:22 GMT
Sorry for this very mooby question but how do u bold uwu type [ b] TEXT [/b] without the space in between the first bracket |
|
|
|
Post by sadisticnarwhal on Jun 7, 2019 12:37:24 GMT
Apologies for the lack of activity these past couple days. Tuesday/Wednesday I had a trip in the Adirondacks (no phone service) and yesterday I had knee surgery. Lynching ignitegod seems like the most pointless thing to me. Imo he was the most obvious VT from his first couple posts. If I had to do town reads it would go mylo=yash>ignite>toni>brady and not to say that brady is most likely to be scum I just ended the list with him because I don't think there is enough content to judge the others on.
Spiderz death is not very surprising and I guess you could say remaining mafia killed spiderz out of fear they were on to him. Probably shouldn't push that idea since it's common to kill town leader though. But that being said I don't think there is much of anything in this game to go off of currently besides brady's interactions
|
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:32:11 GMT
Apologies for the lack of activity these past couple days. Tuesday/Wednesday I had a trip in the Adirondacks (no phone service) and yesterday I had knee surgery. Lynching ignitegod seems like the most pointless thing to me. Imo he was the most obvious VT from his first couple posts. If I had to do town reads it would go mylo=yash>ignite>toni>brady and not to say that brady is most likely to be scum I just ended the list with him because I don't think there is enough content to judge the others on. Spiderz death is not very surprising and I guess you could say remaining mafia killed spiderz out of fear they were on to him. Probably shouldn't push that idea since it's common to kill town leader though. But that being said I don't think there is much of anything in this game to go off of currently besides brady's interactions First of all, Good to hear your surgery went fine and welcome back. Okay so, if you don't mind me asking why is YashGreninja so high on that town list? While I agree mylo is very townlike, I don't see YashGreninja being super townie? Although I do think toni xy is playing with a lot of active filler, I would totally scumread him if it wasn't how he also played his town games in forums. Kinda looked into it as town, yet now I can completely see him flipping mafia. Now for my new updated reads Ignited: it seems theres somewhat a uni-tr on ignited? That's also pretty odd to me but I guess it could be just me who sr's him. I'm not sure why everyone town reads him, I can see this and toni both flipping scum together Mylo13: Probably the most town right now, just like the mood he brings to the forum game so far.. Hard to put into words. YashGreninja: Starting to townread this more and more since the start of the new day, Unlynch Yash at first seemed pretty scummy.. But i remembered me doing the same thing in the newbie game a few weeks ago.. So yea SadisticNarwhal: Feeling as if you're pretty much on the same level as Yash but for a different reason. Not that he is new to forums, but he seems like his posts are very logical.. will post examples after this post as I have to quote them (The chromebook at school has 1 tab limit right now). Toni: Currently the most scummy to me after looking back on his posts.. Yes he played similar as scum in town in the previous forum games. But now that I think about it, that shouldn't excuse active filler and not contributing much at all.. I'd be okay lynching this with ignited.. I THINK Ignited could be bussing toni, we'll see how it plays out though. If toni does flip scum, I'm lynching between ignited and Sadistic.. I'll check after post if im missing anyone.. dumb chromebooks. I'd appreciate it (if there is a vig existing) to kill sadistic or ignited ONLY If this flips scum (use your better judgement on who). Probably wrong as my read on SFL was.. but meh Lynch Toni XY |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:37:04 GMT
I guess I'm good to NL? But Idk, I got taught when I was learning that NL-ing was usually a waste and just gave mafia an extra night lol. Anywho, Vote sadisticnarwhalSup? Sounds out of no where, where did the “Sup?” come from |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:37:45 GMT
Also something Toni XY did on the scum games but I’m pretty sure didn’t do on the town games |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:38:04 GMT
Anyways, now that I've sifted through every opening post, all I can see is people wishing to NL right now. I'll play my cards the same way I did in my first forum game; may I know why you think NL might be useful today? What I'm witnessing here is a repeat of what Brady did that game, which is endlessly and relentlessly pushing for NL to happen without giving solid reasons as to why it might work, making himself look a little panicky and scummy doing so. (no offense) Except this time, it's "NL without discussion, let's not help scum" FUCK no. This game is based on discussion, and if we don't discuss and hunt for scum in daytime, the only way for us to win will be by luck. Scum has at least one power role, and if we don't start finding them they're going to screw us over. On the flipside, we've got three real-life days to discuss and argue things, so let's make use of our time. And I'm not going to spend three weeks just crossing my fingers hoping all scum will die off eventually. TL;DR Discussion is essential for this game! A bit of advice: Change your avatar? Townlean sfl Self explainatory |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:38:56 GMT
Actually nevermind. I take that back. He's saying what I said but just fancier  Sounds like a way to disassosiate yourself with sfl early on while still townleaning him? |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:41:22 GMT
So you're saying that you tr everyone who's spoken? If so, what makes you think this? I don’t think that’s what he was implying, plus it was early on. Also noticing how you wanted to bring up the idea that everyone talking is town |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:44:09 GMT
Well, can we agree that Ignited does not deserve to live atm. Until he explains his deletion I am hard sr'ing this. No reason to delete any post for a joke. Although I do agree that ignitedgod deleting a post is suspicious and may need some explaining, the amount of aggression here is, I'd say, a little overboard. It's something to say that what he did makes him a likely scum, it's another to just straight-up want him dead. Nevertheless, post deletion is strongly against the rules, and he should explain what he did and why he did it. Lynch IgnitedGod Idk if someone pointed this out to me, but it’s posts like these which is now making me start to townlean ignited a little more.. New updated reads: Toni is scum and if so his partner is sadistic |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:48:26 GMT
One... what I deleted had nothing to do with the game itself. Two... Brady is over reacting. Three... I claimed that I am a town PR. Four... This is my first Forum game and I didn’t know it wasn’t allowed to delete posts Will address these one by one. 1) The post you deleted appears to have been the one instructing people to NL. 2) While I agree on this point, I feel that it isn't grounds enough for a lynch. 3) Being a town PR doesn't excuse you breaking the rules, and you deleting a post is suspicious behavior regardless of what you claimed. It can be seen as an attempt to hide information you initially gave away, which is, well, scummy. 4) Okay, I guess since this is your first game I can overlook that. I'd like to know, though, why you wanted to delete that post in the first place, and I believe Brady wants an answer to that as well. Seeing as how Brady is being jumpy and is just being bad over all LYNCH BRADY Being jumpy doesn't make him scummy, though? He's nervous - that can be indicative of confusion, which is a trait that newer players seem to have. I don't see how it makes him scum, though. And on a side note, lynches must be [ bolded] to count. Him pointing out to bold ignited’s lynch on me kinda makes me think ignited is town |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:49:38 GMT
This post was made before ignitegod deleted a post but I talk more about that under the next quote. I'd have to see what the post was to genuinely feel that the action of deleting it was suspicious. I don't thinking deleting is the scummiest thing and personally I don't find it all that suspicious because it's just day 1 so there's not much he could have said that's worth noting. Point 4 is what I agree with and we have to wait for his response. Can't fenrir tell us what the post was because deleting it was against the rules? I know on other forums mods can see deleted posts. [u{ I think you missed sfl’s first point? The post that was deleted was the post where he told us to NL today. That is game related [/u] ..[/quote] Also connects him to SFL |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:50:05 GMT
[u{ I think you missed sfl’s first point? The post that was deleted was the post where he told us to NL today. That is game related [/u] ..[/quote] Also connects him to SFL[/quote] Fail underline on “I think you missed sfl’s first point?” |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 14:53:18 GMT
Also sorry for the spam posts, but I am on my phone now and can open more than one tab so cool..
Basically new read is toni xy as scum, starting to see why you all townread ignited, and then most likely either sadistic is scum with toni, OR it’s a not active player
|
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:05:17 GMT
Heyo I'm here briefly!
|
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:11:46 GMT
Actually there is the argument of not killing mafia's only PR I suppose, but Role Cop is not a strong role for mafia, and no offense to Brady but I don't believe that would've swayed his choice in this situation haha. I mean theres a lot of assumptions in that, but I guess that’s how this game is played. Regardless those are good points except how is Role Cop not a sttong role for mafia? This is just possibly me but I wouldn't find a scum role cop that helpful, at best it would figure out a PR kill for Night 2 but I often find that they just get a VT or town claims earlier anyway. This could just be my experience however haha. Posts like this make me very much doubt Ignited is scum. Knowing SFL is mafia, I very much don't believe they'd post this about their partner, it's an obvious connection and a bit of whiplash that I think SFL would avoid. Also, he was full guns on Ignited just earlier too which could've easily led into an Ignited lynch had they been a pairing. Looking back I think this was him hoping Spiderz would get me lynched over Ignited, implying he was sure ignited wasn’t a PR? That would make sense, but I think Scum!SFL wouldn't have cared between you two if you're both town that much. You would've just been the easier option at the time given Spiderz was gunning for you lol. Looking at the set-up, these two roles existing means we have one more PR of Bodyguard or 1-shot Vigilante, and scum have no more PR's (Call me up on this if it's wrong). If we had a bodyguard, I'd be confused as to why they didn't save Spiderz, but depending on the situation we'll see haha. But 1-shot Vig seems more likely, and if so it could be a good power to have down the road. Also I think I already said all this lol Oops lol, forgive me there When he says we he means me and spiderz When he says doc he means potential bodyguard (or os vig) This feels like an unnecessary post Brady I didnt even know you lynched me Also I was trying to bait NK, so I would die instead of PRs I would Like to think that a maf NK means its someone who isnt AFK but idk for sure Spiderz was probably fear killed but i mean... Also I SR toni more then brady rn LYNCH TONI XYCare to elaborate..? Fair defense but it is completely based around ignorance However as I have read Toni’s previous games.. I’m getting a somewhat town vibe off of him. However this could have easily been him posting those links and changing his playstyle. As well as me not looking indepth enough.. However I can see this being a town view.. I am honoured that you think I'd put in that much effort into a forum game <3 Honestly though I don't really wanna lynch Brady that much because at least they are saying SOMETHING lol. There's like, 4 properly active people here lol. This isn't a good reason I feel. If someone is scummy, lynch them? Shouldn't matter if they're active or not. Just looking at this last quote but I guess that's kinda fair haha. But still, I *expected* Brady to consistently post so if they're mafia they could give more info? But regardless now, not sure sure on Brady anymore  |
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:12:44 GMT
I can see this being genuine, gonna maintain pressure as of now, also that “we” isn’t really that big of a slip, me picking at straws.. Which is all we have at this point. Although I like the defense you just made, still sticking on you FOR NOW Understood. By the way, thimblebony ain't talking much at all, I'd like to see him speak up or be given an activity check. This seems oddly specific? There's multiple talking very little, why did you call out thimblebony specifically? |
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:17:45 GMT
Apologies for the lack of activity these past couple days. Tuesday/Wednesday I had a trip in the Adirondacks (no phone service) and yesterday I had knee surgery. Lynching ignitegod seems like the most pointless thing to me. Imo he was the most obvious VT from his first couple posts. If I had to do town reads it would go mylo=yash>ignite>toni>brady and not to say that brady is most likely to be scum I just ended the list with him because I don't think there is enough content to judge the others on. Spiderz death is not very surprising and I guess you could say remaining mafia killed spiderz out of fear they were on to him. Probably shouldn't push that idea since it's common to kill town leader though. But that being said I don't think there is much of anything in this game to go off of currently besides brady's interactions Could you explain your Yash town read please? I somewhat agree with the last bit there too, but honestly I guess for mafia it would've been hard to NK anyone else? Part of my Day 2 starting suspicion on Brady was due to the Spiderz kill which seemed like a risky move that mafia may've done to cover for Spiderz's other scum read/s (Being Brady), but really most scum teams here could've made that exact kill. |
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:22:46 GMT
Apologies for the lack of activity these past couple days. Tuesday/Wednesday I had a trip in the Adirondacks (no phone service) and yesterday I had knee surgery. Lynching ignitegod seems like the most pointless thing to me. Imo he was the most obvious VT from his first couple posts. If I had to do town reads it would go mylo=yash>ignite>toni>brady and not to say that brady is most likely to be scum I just ended the list with him because I don't think there is enough content to judge the others on. Spiderz death is not very surprising and I guess you could say remaining mafia killed spiderz out of fear they were on to him. Probably shouldn't push that idea since it's common to kill town leader though. But that being said I don't think there is much of anything in this game to go off of currently besides brady's interactions First of all, Good to hear your surgery went fine and welcome back. Okay so, if you don't mind me asking why is YashGreninja so high on that town list? While I agree mylo is very townlike, I don't see YashGreninja being super townie? Although I do think toni xy is playing with a lot of active filler, I would totally scumread him if it wasn't how he also played his town games in forums. Kinda looked into it as town, yet now I can completely see him flipping mafia. Now for my new updated reads Ignited: it seems theres somewhat a uni-tr on ignited? That's also pretty odd to me but I guess it could be just me who sr's him. I'm not sure why everyone town reads him, I can see this and toni both flipping scum together Mylo13: Probably the most town right now, just like the mood he brings to the forum game so far.. Hard to put into words. YashGreninja: Starting to townread this more and more since the start of the new day, Unlynch Yash at first seemed pretty scummy.. But i remembered me doing the same thing in the newbie game a few weeks ago.. So yea SadisticNarwhal: Feeling as if you're pretty much on the same level as Yash but for a different reason. Not that he is new to forums, but he seems like his posts are very logical.. will post examples after this post as I have to quote them (The chromebook at school has 1 tab limit right now). Toni: Currently the most scummy to me after looking back on his posts.. Yes he played similar as scum in town in the previous forum games. But now that I think about it, that shouldn't excuse active filler and not contributing much at all.. I'd be okay lynching this with ignited.. I THINK Ignited could be bussing toni, we'll see how it plays out though. If toni does flip scum, I'm lynching between ignited and Sadistic.. I'll check after post if im missing anyone.. dumb chromebooks. I'd appreciate it (if there is a vig existing) to kill sadistic or ignited ONLY If this flips scum (use your better judgement on who). Probably wrong as my read on SFL was.. but meh Lynch Toni XY We had the same question about the yash townread haha! I'll make a post on that soonish, but first: Ignited is mostly getting TR by me due to the interactions between him and SFL. His play is pretty questionable but it could simply be his play style. Not sure the Toni/Ignited combo is that likely after Ignited going for Toni either, but it's still a possibility. Could you similarly explain why yash is getting townier for you? This post is overall pretty solid though, it bumps you up a bit on my townreads haha. |
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Jun 7, 2019 15:36:25 GMT
Brady u seem quite strong on it point. Ngl but i think it's important that we get srs. U guys have convinced me that u have some strong srs and I think it cool to have somewhat of an active town uwu
|
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:38:48 GMT
Wanted to do a bit of an audit so to speak on Yash so far, because he's given me somewhat of an off feeling since his very first post haha. This isn't an attack per se, but just wanted to get my thoughts down. I excused the off feeling on the first one because it could've been completely genuine and just possibly a tonal thing, but then he posted this 4 rl days (and one in mafia night) later: We killed mafia d1 but for some reason doc didn't heal Spiderz so now we lost our source of inspects. This post more confuses me than gets my suspicion up, but it still confuses me lol. I don't really understand Yash why you didn't post ANYTHING else before this? Like, a reaction to what happened or like reads or even your confusion as to what to do haha? I don't really think I can put it into words that much here either but I feel like this doesn't seem right. Lynch ignited, I don't buy it. This came right after Brady's vote for Ignited, which could be a case of unfortunate timing or even a newer town player following a read from someone else but I also found this off. Okay so I will somewhat agree with you all that Ignited’s interactions with sfl made him seem town.. I can understand this Unlynch Ignited What I would point out instead right now is that Yash tried hard to townslip following daystart.. Not much to go on, probably a temporary lynch.. Although I hate to see these experienced players put on a “noob” like persona. DoomedDitto (IgnitedGod) KNOWS HOW TO PLAY yet is acting like a noob. YashGreninja is doing the same. However at this point I find Yash less likely.. So for now abandoning the lynch on ignited. But please stop pretending to be a noob and actually contribute.. Lynch Yash I didn't even realize that saying 'we' would be caught as a townslip, that's my bad. I'm not pretending to be a noob, I just regret not being more active day one since I now have to properly read back multiple pages of posts since I didn't know what was going on. Again, I said that message to (I think) wob after they asked what happened post-subbing in, and if you scroll down later, I point out that I forgot that it was D6, therefore explaining why I originally thought there was a doctor but in reality it doesn't exist. I know that this may seem like filler text, but I have nothing else I can say since, like you said Brady, nobody is talking for Day 2. I don't believe Yash is pretending to be a noob here, and I understand slips of activeness can happen. But like, the last sentence in particular contains weird self-awareness reflecting on it 'seeming' like filler text and mentioning people not talking for Day 2 whilst also not adding that much to the conversation lol. Why did you believe there was a doctor anyway, and what did that relate to it being RL D6? Sorry here, I could just be misunderstanding you haha. I can see this being genuine, gonna maintain pressure as of now, also that “we” isn’t really that big of a slip, me picking at straws.. Which is all we have at this point. Although I like the defense you just made, still sticking on you FOR NOW Understood. By the way, thimblebony ain't talking much at all, I'd like to see him speak up or be given an activity check. Forgot to mention it earlier but I also like that Brady post there. But this most recent post from Yash was one I called out a second ago and it still irks me. Is there a reason why you're calling out thimble? Like, if I had to guess off the top of my head it'd be that you two were mafia together lol. Lynch Yash for now, would like more from them though haha! |
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:40:44 GMT
Brady u seem quite strong on it point. Ngl but i think it's important that we get srs. U guys have convinced me that u have some strong srs and I think it cool to have somewhat of an active town uwu Heyo there! Glad to see you up and about haha. Are you read up on most of what's happened? If so, do you have any reads/observations/recipe ideas*/thoughts about what's happened? Anything would help here 
*Ones featuring caramel would be greatly appreciated  |
|
|
|
Post by Brady1014 on Jun 7, 2019 15:40:46 GMT
First of all, Good to hear your surgery went fine and welcome back. Okay so, if you don't mind me asking why is YashGreninja so high on that town list? While I agree mylo is very townlike, I don't see YashGreninja being super townie? Although I do think toni xy is playing with a lot of active filler, I would totally scumread him if it wasn't how he also played his town games in forums. Kinda looked into it as town, yet now I can completely see him flipping mafia. Now for my new updated reads Ignited: it seems theres somewhat a uni-tr on ignited? That's also pretty odd to me but I guess it could be just me who sr's him. I'm not sure why everyone town reads him, I can see this and toni both flipping scum together Mylo13: Probably the most town right now, just like the mood he brings to the forum game so far.. Hard to put into words. YashGreninja: Starting to townread this more and more since the start of the new day, Unlynch Yash at first seemed pretty scummy.. But i remembered me doing the same thing in the newbie game a few weeks ago.. So yea SadisticNarwhal: Feeling as if you're pretty much on the same level as Yash but for a different reason. Not that he is new to forums, but he seems like his posts are very logical.. will post examples after this post as I have to quote them (The chromebook at school has 1 tab limit right now). Toni: Currently the most scummy to me after looking back on his posts.. Yes he played similar as scum in town in the previous forum games. But now that I think about it, that shouldn't excuse active filler and not contributing much at all.. I'd be okay lynching this with ignited.. I THINK Ignited could be bussing toni, we'll see how it plays out though. If toni does flip scum, I'm lynching between ignited and Sadistic.. I'll check after post if im missing anyone.. dumb chromebooks. I'd appreciate it (if there is a vig existing) to kill sadistic or ignited ONLY If this flips scum (use your better judgement on who). Probably wrong as my read on SFL was.. but meh Lynch Toni XY We had the same question about the yash townread haha! I'll make a post on that soonish, but first: Ignited is mostly getting TR by me due to the interactions between him and SFL. His play is pretty questionable but it could simply be his play style. Not sure the Toni/Ignited combo is that likely after Ignited going for Toni either, but it's still a possibility. Could you similarly explain why yash is getting townier for you? This post is overall pretty solid though, it bumps you up a bit on my townreads haha. Yash’s defense reminded me of my defense from ZestOfLife in the newbie game, where when I was being pushed hard by him as town (similar to spiderz in that regard), I reacted with a mindset of “I know you’re town, I don’t want to lynch you back but why are you pushing me off silly things” I went through a similar defense process if I recall, where I started changing my posts from single liners to actual defenses. If we pressured him a bit longer it would assume (from first hard) it would be hard to defend yourself from a “tunnel” per se.. I think him making that semi-formal defense even though I didn’t have much to go on shows town-like aspects imo. |
|
|
|
Post by Mylo13 on Jun 7, 2019 15:44:10 GMT
We had the same question about the yash townread haha! I'll make a post on that soonish, but first: Ignited is mostly getting TR by me due to the interactions between him and SFL. His play is pretty questionable but it could simply be his play style. Not sure the Toni/Ignited combo is that likely after Ignited going for Toni either, but it's still a possibility. Could you similarly explain why yash is getting townier for you? This post is overall pretty solid though, it bumps you up a bit on my townreads haha. Yash’s defense reminded me of my defense from ZestOfLife in the newbie game, where when I was being pushed hard by him as town (similar to spiderz in that regard), I reacted with a mindset of “I know you’re town, I don’t want to lynch you back but why are you pushing me off silly things” I went through a similar defense process if I recall, where I started changing my posts from single liners to actual defenses. If we pressured him a bit longer it would assume (from first hard) it would be hard to defend yourself from a “tunnel” per se.. I think him making that semi-formal defense even though I didn’t have much to go on shows town-like aspects imo. Okay, I can understand that! I also saw some of me in Yash's "My Bad"'s (Given I have a tendancy to apologise heaps haha) but that's not something I'd necessarily assign town points to. Do you have any ideas who I should read up next on? I was thinking along the lines of Toni or Sad. |
|
