Fire and Ice: Barcelona (Scum Tie)

[BoredGames]

Time for player ratings!

Good tier
Neo: Best town player at the end of the day, had decent reads and pushed for activity, shame he didn't get doc reads right enough of the time
Schia: 2nd of the town core, main advocate for activity which was great, reads were lacklustre 
Fort: The final town core member, made a good play at start of day 1, pushed for activity and questioned sus things others were saying, shame you fell off as game progressed 
Vigvig: THIS IS BORDELINE, the early game was horrible, but the late game was superb and well executed, although snaq doesn't agree with me I liked the idle play on the final night

Average tier
C7: I liked the constant notes of what scum have killed and how people have been interacting with themselves, but you did yourself no favours as the game progressed and ultimately not enough to warrant good tier
Zeep: Won, but little effort after subbing in to warrant anything but meh, lucky town was dragged down by mislynches 
Edjean: Did nothing, deserves meh
Sadnar: Took them too long to be useful, they became useful then were killed, shame
Zol: Was killed too soon because there was promise here, although initial reads were off

Bad tier

Cuddleszz: Could've easily saved yourself but instead made things a lot worse, crumbled under pressure 
Yash: Made yourself obvious with omgus, did nothing to remotely hint at you being town
SFL: When your dodging making reads and actively do nothing to help produce content whilst complaining about the lack of content, yeah u deserve the trash tier. If you want content it's an OC game go make it
Edzard: Yes, you broke the game at the end, BUT YOUR EARLY GAME WAS SO BAD NOTHING WAS SAVING YOU. I'm sorry actively wanting to lynch a tr wtf is this meta, you then contribute nothing of worth, instead moaning about people not getting your name right, then proceed to try and win town the game and COMPLETELY MESS IT UP CUZ U DIDN'T KNOW WHAT YOU WANTED TO ACCOMPLISH FROM IT. Nope you get trash tier

Overall, I have decided that NO ONE WILL RECIEVE MVP


Hope you enjoyed your trip to Barcelona!

[ZestOfLife]

Jul 16, 2019 23:07:18 GMT BoredGames said:

tenzhii  
C7  
cuddleszz  
Edjeanerations  
edwardzealchemist  
Fort Colorcastle  
®➕➕  
sadisticnarwhal  
Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪  
VigilanteVigoroth  
cyan  
yashgreninja  
ZestOfLife  

Welcome to Post game analysis, here I will comment on my thoughts before the game, during each day and overall performance of each player / faction!!!

Ok so let's start off with pre-game thoughts:

Scum teams seem, hmm, questionable, not quite sure what to make of them. Like Yash + Vigvig will either be a strong team or crumble by day 3, ice mafia seems capable enough but the sort of players to get killed off before day 2. Town seem strongest, but some noobs that could hold them back in the early days.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 1: 
Ok so let's get past RVS to the good stuff, with Fort claiming doc, strong move but also a very obvious town play
Neo sets himself up as a townlock for actually questioning fort's move, only one who considers fort being possible scum
Yash makes himself obvious by an omgus
Zol has bad reads- 1 player not meant to be in the game, the other 2 VTs
LMAO EDWARD CALLED TIE D1 YEET
Then C7 and Neo shift to Yash and boom Fire Maf is gone
LMAO GG u push cuddleszz for a kill they choose the same person vigvig chose... neo the doctor (yep doc could've went n1 u lot were lucky i didn't force idle scum and got a kill from them)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 2: 
Neo's first reads are actually spot on, nailed remaining fire maf and 1 ice maf, called the other ice maf not fire maf (pretty sure he tr'ed him at this point tho so)
Schia townlocks themselves by wanting activity, well done schia 
SFL makes the most stupidest comment this game-"someone undie this board" DO IT YOURSELF
Edzard decides to read schia as annoying, great play i support this
SFL avoids giving reads, gives reasoning instead which without the reads is what the point
Now we get to edzard making a fool out of himself, shifting on and off like he's doing the hokey cokey and claiming he will happily "lynch a tr," amazed town didn't dump him there and then
Cudd does himself no favours here, claiming edzard is buddying schia when it's clearly edzard being blinded by desperation, then it's curtains for ice mafia
Edjean kill is strange, zol kill makes sense 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 3:
Zeep joins the fun, says nothing, yay
Edzard is right to tr sfl, just is horrible at explaining why
Fort branding people actively pushing for activity as toxic... in that case more people should be toxic
Edzard is back at it again with the self incriminating 
schiavetto

Mafia Room Staff









Dollars never show up on CP time



Posts: 330



Jul 6, 2019 at 12:23pm Lucas ◢ ◤ and BoredGames like this

Quote







Post by schiavetto on Jul 6, 2019 at 12:23pm

I genuinely think some of you just don't get how frustrating it is to try and play a game when half the playerlist is exerting no effort.



Things happen. I get that. But there's a difference between having things going on that limit the amount of attention you can give to a game (believe me, I know, talk to me during the school year) and putting in the bare minimum while leaving others to solve the game for you.



The whole "Idk it's just different on forums" argument is out, too, since I see some of you doing this on server, too. If you want to play, play. If you don't, then don't--but in the meantime, you're here, and if you're old enough to browse these forums and proficient in English then it really shouldn't take some of you all that long to read a few pages and make an observation.



The whole "But no one's saying anything, so there's nothing to respond to!" argument doesn't work either--if there's no content? Make content.



The game's in POE stage but imagine how quickly we could be done with this if people would do... like, literally anything at all.

We need more people like this

SADNAR ACTUALLY CONTRIBUTED YES FINALLY HE'S MAKING HIMSELF TOWNY 
bad reads but still towny
Edzard claiming no one brought up kills when neo referenced them at start of day
Vigvig with the clean last minute plurshift 
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 4: 
So Fort kill makes sense, the Sadnar kill makes no sense, zeep trying to scumhunt with kill is a bad move at this stage
Schia and Edzard make the correct lynch before edzard self incriminates, forcing shia to re-evaluate 
VIGVIG CLAPS BACK SO HARD YES G THIS IS FLAMES GO SAVE URSELF 
Schia decides to lock me and them into a timeloop by lynching edzard as I post vote count -_-
Ahh edzard's defeatist post, so many flaws it would fail a health and safety inspection: u framed urself my dude scum didn't frame u at least not by night kills, if I were in this game I would've called for ur head day 2
BUT HE GAMEBROKE THE SCUM HOW THE FUCK DID HE MANAGE THAT
ok like how c7 moves down is edzard's tr list due to calling him scum lmao
c7 messed up by questioning the doc claim lol, even tho vig should've been called out harder for capitalising on this way too quickly
Also gj neo letting edzard claim doc and scum not believing him and finally killing you
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day 5:
Most of this was OC, so this is fun
anyway during night 4 EDZARD MAKES THE BIGGEST GAMBIT I HAVE EVER SEEN, YET FAILS TO ACTUALLY DO WHAT HE WAS AIMING TO DO, FFS ED U HAD THIS
He fakeclaimed scum to both scum and should've coordinated them to either each other or the same person, ed does neither
This causes scum to seek eachother out and work together
Night 5 Schia decides to do the same strat, it fails
Scum tie gg

Those werent reads those were reaction testing but ok

[ZestOfLife]

I think I never had a sr in that game

[tenzhii]

Jul 16, 2019 23:20:21 GMT BoredGames said:

Time for player ratings!

Good tier
Neo: Best town player at the end of the day, had decent reads and pushed for activity, shame he didn't get doc reads right enough of the time
Schia: 2nd of the town core, main advocate for activity which was great, reads were lacklustre 
Fort: The final town core member, made a good play at start of day 1, pushed for activity and questioned sus things others were saying, shame you fell off as game progressed 
Vigvig: THIS IS BORDELINE, the early game was horrible, but the late game was superb and well executed, although snaq doesn't agree with me I liked the idle play on the final night

Average tier
C7: I liked the constant notes of what scum have killed and how people have been interacting with themselves, but you did yourself no favours as the game progressed and ultimately not enough to warrant good tier
Zeep: Won, but little effort after subbing in to warrant anything but meh, lucky town was dragged down by mislynches 
Edjean: Did nothing, deserves meh
Sadnar: Took them too long to be useful, they became useful then were killed, shame
Zol: Was killed too soon because there was promise here, although initial reads were off

Bad tier

Cuddleszz: Could've easily saved yourself but instead made things a lot worse, crumbled under pressure 
Yash: Made yourself obvious with omgus, did nothing to remotely hint at you being town
SFL: When your dodging making reads and actively do nothing to help produce content whilst complaining about the lack of content, yeah u deserve the trash tier. If you want content it's an OC game go make it
Edzard: Yes, you broke the game at the end, BUT YOUR EARLY GAME WAS SO BAD NOTHING WAS SAVING YOU. I'm sorry actively wanting to lynch a tr wtf is this meta, you then contribute nothing of worth, instead moaning about people not getting your name right, then proceed to try and win town the game and COMPLETELY MESS IT UP CUZ U DIDN'T KNOW WHAT YOU WANTED TO ACCOMPLISH FROM IT. Nope you get trash tier

Overall, I have decided that NO ONE WILL RECIEVE MVP


Hope you enjoyed your trip to Barcelona!

LMAOOOOOOOOOOOO THE ED BULLYING yea ill take average. ngl ed was the sole reason we tied instead of having it be a scum shot because in order of trs mine were ed > vig > schia which seems really stupid right now but considering he was the docs buddy buddy he seemed like the best shot. tho ill grant you thats less to eds incompetence and more because i got lucky with neo shot but still i just wanted to spill what was happening last day

also yall were gawking at sadnar kill but lmAO did it pay off anyway gg theres nothing left to be said other than ed should own up to his weird play endgame and schia made a valiant effort but vig just contacted me first with more reason to believe him