|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 1, 2020 23:21:36 GMT
Vote Kitkat
you apologized for not speaking, put a tr on toni of all people, and then called your partner a tr. To answer your question, yes you have the same Role PM, but since I didn't necessarily like micro here in the first place you aren't helping, you alsp gave no mention to his reads and if you agreed with them, you basically just said I townread me.
Now, I like OM out of the gate, which helps me more with my slight suspicions I hold on edj. Not sure this is as important but OM, I know people have policied fenrir in the past as a fearkill because I've read through old games and am aware people think they are a god-like mafia player, which some would also say about yourself. As for me, I don't fearkill I pr hunt. But not this game, for I do neither as I'm town and ain't killing anyone.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 1, 2020 23:29:28 GMT
Not posting a lynch as of yet, I want to hear a response from the rest I mentioned as well. (although alex just forced it back on me and didn't even respond to me saying abdel did nothing.) not sure what you want me to say, i cant excuse what he did nor justify it. i dont know what goes on in his life, given that, he is town, as i am I. I hope you fix your reads on my slot. I can work with this. I like the acknowledgement that Abdel was 't great and ultimately can be considered neg-town, (although lurking should be considered more NAI) that he backs himself and Abdel genuinely, although I'd also like to note I never called you or Abdel scum. |
|
|
|
Post by skyfigueroa on Oct 1, 2020 23:43:34 GMT
sup sup i gotta class in 10 mins so ill make this quick and come back in like an hour since they aren't live anyway...
xnad v litt interactions r the most interesting to me just by skimming since you got xnad getting pressed and blunt over like every small thing someone did. I've only played one other game with xnad and that was the countdown game and his game looked pretty much the same in the sense that the tone's a bit angry and calling a lot of people out blah blah, which I would assume would be for pressure (and make him lean townie in my eyes for not playing too passive and trying to involve all the players instead of focusing on a few) but he literally flipped scum that game so i'm just holding that as NAI. I find litt the townier of the two from the interactions for actually calling out the insulting on every though process cuz I feel being frustrated about your reads being disregarded especially hurts as town when you don't know shit about anyone's roles and you're just trying to help. andddddddddd be right back that was just something i noticed while super super light skimming hf every1
|
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 1, 2020 23:49:39 GMT
My other thought on the Fenrir kill is that it's an attempted frame of Chap!slot or a PR snipe attempt, which is like incredibly lame either way how does it frame chap 8.4.3 fen been on that lynch chap vibe |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 0:18:07 GMT
sky policying xnad from a previous game isn't something I like. I get that they did hold off on it, and this might just be me but I hate when people use previous games as a reason to read someone.
|
|
|
|
Post by kitkatkk2 on Oct 2, 2020 1:09:50 GMT
Sorry I’m a little late to the party. I honestly don’t know what to think at the moment. Toni seems decently town. Btw, don’t partners get the the same role? Either way, micro is a tr. mind elab on why you feel this way? and i feel like you could provide more than that upon entrance. 8.4.3 It’s not a lot more than a hunch. His townread on Xnad is a part of it, because I do agree with him. CookieOMsters reads completely go against mine, but I do find him town. I’m going to hold off on the lynch and observe for just now. |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 1:16:41 GMT
kitkat you just said you townread someone because you agree with them and then said you townread someone you disagree with but want to lynch them. I'm reading it as a lame attempt to buddy toni, whom I didn't even see much of yesterday. Kitkat, I want you to form reads of off pushes specifically and interactions, not necessarily who they are on and who you do and don't agree with
|
|
|
|
Post by kitkatkk2 on Oct 2, 2020 1:37:54 GMT
I have a distinct reason for the Toni tr, but it’s one that I don’t feel needs to be shared. As for the Cookie read, I’m just trying to read, and it’s mostly based on his posts. Somebody mentioned micros reads, and as for the mist one, It’s null atm. I think the reasoning for that lynch was pretty nai. Eblurb hasn’t really talked, and I want to see what happens. The others, however, I mostly agree with. You’ll notice he SRed your partner, and with that, I do agree.
Vote Gary the savage
The post where you lynched me said that my tr on micro was TRing myself, and though I do know it is now, at the time, I wasn’t sure whether that was true. This is my first forum game. Also, looking at bgbs read on him day 1, there is that reasoning for my tr. bgb flipped a pr, and though he didn’t get any results, we can probably trust his reads.
|
|
|
|
Post by skyfigueroa on Oct 2, 2020 4:42:20 GMT
sky policying xnad from a previous game isn't something I like. I get that they did hold off on it, and this might just be me but I hate when people use previous games as a reason to read someone. ? If anything it was a reason to not read someone. I would've tred him if not for last game but I can't help but remember him playing similarly last time and flipping scum despite looking townie. He's not focusing on just a few people and made very good, valid points yesterday, I'm just holding off on the TR. I have a distinct reason for the Toni tr, but it’s one that I don’t feel needs to be shared. As for the Cookie read, I’m just trying to read, and it’s mostly based on his posts. Somebody mentioned micros reads, and as for the mist one, It’s null atm. I think the reasoning for that lynch was pretty nai. Eblurb hasn’t really talked, and I want to see what happens. The others, however, I mostly agree with. You’ll notice he SRed your partner, and with that, I do agree. Vote Gary the savage The post where you lynched me said that my tr on micro was TRing myself, and though I do know it is now, at the time, I wasn’t sure whether that was true. This is my first forum game. Also, looking at bgbs read on him day 1, there is that reasoning for my tr. bgb flipped a pr, and though he didn’t get any results, we can probably trust his reads. Well you can 100% trust his reads since you know he was town, how right do you think they are, though? Ok so uh reading the flow of d1 the bgb lynch wasn't that bad. It seemed like all the pressure was on bgb but someway somehow it was just a tie for plur with misty so....... The pushes on bgb were a lot more fleshed out and it kinda bothers me that the wagon that tied was voted by the way more inac players. lynch alex rn for abdel slot but alex looks like he's gonna be present so he can feel free to change my mind. |
|
|
|
Post by Crespo on Oct 2, 2020 6:30:27 GMT
Something irks me about Chap saying he wouldn’t mind getting off bgb but then proceeding to not unlynch
Might be a reach here but can anyone check interactions between Mist and chap pls (mobile)
|
|
|
|
Post by ToiletBro2 on Oct 2, 2020 8:10:20 GMT
I have a distinct reason for the Toni tr, but it’s one that I don’t feel needs to be shared. As for the Cookie read, I’m just trying to read, and it’s mostly based on his posts. Somebody mentioned micros reads, and as for the mist one, It’s null atm. I think the reasoning for that lynch was pretty nai. Eblurb hasn’t really talked, and I want to see what happens. The others, however, I mostly agree with. You’ll notice he SRed your partner, and with that, I do agree. Vote Gary the savage The post where you lynched me said that my tr on micro was TRing myself, and though I do know it is now, at the time, I wasn’t sure whether that was true. This is my first forum game. Also, looking at bgbs read on him day 1, there is that reasoning for my tr. bgb flipped a pr, and though he didn’t get any results, we can probably trust his reads. Mind sharing your reason for that? You cant just drop a bombshell like that and leave it, and if that's due to some pr result, that's a horrible soft that will ring alarm bells in both town and mafia minds |
|
|
|
Post by ToiletBro2 on Oct 2, 2020 8:18:19 GMT
Penguin D was somewhat scummy yday, but what speaks our to me is that pd and gts aren't on the same page. This game is unique on account of the partnership mechanic. Use it! Tb2 is neg town, but is tb2 + Litt neg town?!?!?! Especially if pd is new, they should be listening to and valuing gts's reads.
This reads to me as gts realising pd was somewhat scummy, and trying to cover themselves by providing an alternative, 'better' approach.
On another note, gts hasn't redeemed himself all that much, but that's another post which needs it's own reasoning which I'll do later.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 12:01:48 GMT
Tb2, I'm doing my job making the reads I feel will advance towards a town wincon, and although I said I didn't agree with my partner, I'll still back them
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 12:10:28 GMT
I have a distinct reason for the Toni tr, but it’s one that I don’t feel needs to be shared. As for the Cookie read, I’m just trying to read, and it’s mostly based on his posts. Somebody mentioned micros reads, and as for the mist one, It’s null atm. I think the reasoning for that lynch was pretty nai. Eblurb hasn’t really talked, and I want to see what happens. The others, however, I mostly agree with. You’ll notice he SRed your partner, and with that, I do agree. Vote Gary the savage The post where you lynched me said that my tr on micro was TRing myself, and though I do know it is now, at the time, I wasn’t sure whether that was true. This is my first forum game. Also, looking at bgbs read on him day 1, there is that reasoning for my tr. bgb flipped a pr, and though he didn’t get any results, we can probably trust his reads. uh you may not feel the reason to share the toni tr but the rest of us do. share it. The rest of this is basically you being a simp for micro and seeing yes I agree with everything. If you are going to agree with him, at least provide the reasons for all of his reads, since they aren't yours you're just copying them, I want you to do something. Give me reasons for trs and srs not I agree with micro. In terms of your remark on bgb, uh no. Just because someone is town, does not make their reads 100% accurate. They can be somewhat more reliable in terms of interactions, but that doesn't mean they are correct. For now, I am taking this lynch on me as omgus. You said micro somewhat read Penguin which means Gary must be scum. Kitkat, before you provide reasoning I want you, and this goes for everyone else too, to provide reasoning why I am scum and ignore Penguin completely. Because if Penguin is scum, which they aren't, I must be too and you'd have to find reasons why I am scum as well. So go and get em. |
|
|
|
Post by ToiletBro2 on Oct 2, 2020 12:10:40 GMT
I'm not too sure how I feel about the KitKat slot, because omg we saw a towny micro yday which is miraculous and tyvm micro, but I am still fussed about the 'distinct reason to tr' thing. That's not exactly scum reasoning but it's still really annoying. So eh tr on micro KitKat. Going to retract attack of Gary and place a null back on pd Gary because that is fair enough and the sr was more for reactions than anything else (yeah you can absolutely be on a different page than your partner). Now that I've redealt with those, I'll move on to making some more substantial reads (I.e. wait for litt to tell me who is scum  ) |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 12:11:40 GMT
Also, you can't say you townread someone after they died and use that they flipped pr as an excuse zz.
|
|
|
|
Post by kitkatkk2 on Oct 2, 2020 13:54:52 GMT
Also, you can't say you townread someone after they died and use that they flipped pr as an excuse zz. My logic was that bgb flipped town, and even though he could have got it wrong, I was using it to support my logic of WE ARE PARTNERS WITH THE SAME ROLE AND I DIDN'T KNOW THAT! Sorry for getting a little angry. Anyway. As for the Toni bit, a claim would fix ALL of this, but I don't want to do that just yet. We are decently powerful town rolesm and know who each other are. I will say that. |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 14:06:32 GMT
okay A. that doesn't even explain the bgb it whatsoever.
B. yes, you and micro have the same role Pm, you said you didn't know that the first time, and I didn't argue with you, I just answered your question when you first asked.
C. I'm literally the only one on you and I'm not asking for a claim. You could've given reason as to why you thought toni is town. But based off of what you've said there I'm lead to believe you could br nymphomaniac and just outed toni as a pr considering you said you know each other's roles.
Shame, really.
[/b]Unlynch kitkat[\b]
Not so much scum anymore, but really a detriment to town. We have bigger fish to fry.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 14:07:58 GMT
Bold fails 101
Unlynch Kitkat
|
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 2, 2020 15:06:25 GMT
Also, you can't say you townread someone after they died and use that they flipped pr as an excuse zz. My logic was that bgb flipped town, and even though he could have got it wrong, I was using it to support my logic of WE ARE PARTNERS WITH THE SAME ROLE AND I DIDN'T KNOW THAT! Sorry for getting a little angry. Anyway. As for the Toni bit, a claim would fix ALL of this, but I don't want to do that just yet. We are decently powerful town rolesm and know who each other are. I will say that. Kit, do you mind explaining why you think Gary's slot is just as scummy as his partner (penguin, I think)'s slot? I notice he prodded you to explain that read but you seemed to have ignored it. |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 2, 2020 15:19:10 GMT
Lynch Eblurb
bitch speak or i'm not getting off you
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 2, 2020 15:53:27 GMT
would also like toni to speak, since they haven't, in particular on kitkat
|
|
|
|
Post by Crespo on Oct 2, 2020 16:40:27 GMT
Oh my God I go to school and my name gets dragged by kitkat for the right reasons but why.
Was a bit ?? on the micro/kitkat slot but now I tr them and that's cause of the fact they tr me
Honestly I wanted to just cruise by today and let OM scumhunt but idk how to feel about him especially considering Edj's day 1
|
|
|
|
Post by Crespo on Oct 2, 2020 16:44:57 GMT
Penguin D was somewhat scummy yday, but what speaks our to me is that pd and gts aren't on the same page. This game is unique on account of the partnership mechanic. Use it! Tb2 is neg town, but is tb2 + Litt neg town?!?!?! Especially if pd is new, they should be listening to and valuing gts's reads. This reads to me as gts realising pd was somewhat scummy, and trying to cover themselves by providing an alternative, 'better' approach. On another note, gts hasn't redeemed himself all that much, but that's another post which needs it's own reasoning which I'll do later. I get the listening to and valuing each others reads but even as partners it's fair to have completely different reads as long as it's justified which is entirely the point of this gamemode lol Gts slot is bleh I agree but Jordan is telling me to push your slot so Imma read up on your posts by the end of the day |
|
blurb
Innocent Child
ball so hard
Posts: 92 
|
Post by blurb on Oct 2, 2020 17:08:26 GMT
the blurb reads (my post to show my thoughts on the game)
gonna be using a towniest -> scummiest format because i think it is the most appropriate. most of my reads come from how they present themselves + how they read bgb.
notes on my own slot - pretty much agree with everything they are saying to defend themselves, idk whyd you ask for content then lynch after thinking the content was "forced," like you were the one who forced it out of them; although, i may not read pd as hard as them.
i also don't believe looking into the fenrir kill is important, as they were obvious town from my pov, just by the way they were addressing wagons and the game
my reads aren't like very strong at all at this moment in the game and i think a bit later with deeper analysis i'll find something to focus on
t
abdel/alex - abdel honestly sounding like hes trollin, but i think alex's recovery was good and the alx seems like he wants to move the town in the right direction
chap/skyfig - i havent read much into this slot but they haven't done anything to make me scumread them
micro/kk2 - micro seemed townie from them asking the right questions and not just the scum ones that don't push town forward. kk2 has went in the other direction but they kinda just seem like town that doesnt want to die/doesnt know what they are doing atm
pd/gts - i see why people scumread pd but that would not be my priority lynch right now, as i dont't think there is much information to be had. pretty much null
litt/tb2 - not much reasoning but fos simply for the fact that i would've expected more from litt this game as town
edj/om - havent read on the om slot, but why edj reading into (and tring) the bgb lines like that. i wouldn't state a claim like that without very good reasoning anyway. it's like he knew he was town already and could cash in that "i told u" card.
xnad/toni - first off starting the game memeing and suddenly becoming serious with a read i do not vibe with. honestly unsure how that bgb wagon built up under the pretenses you set. i personally believed that predictions like that are nai, and have been in a few games i saw already. they are pointless, but they are just posts. also he said "I would say I don't like bgb, but meta knowledge tells me its not time to pass judgement on him yet," which was a pointless line imo since he was already on him. secondly, he was basically providing iioa when talking to lurkers. i wouldn't say toni has that good recovery anyway.
s
|
|
)