Ace Attorney Mafia: Good Game Town!

[passthesaltdude]

Nov 13, 2020 19:21:14 GMT Edjeanerations said:

I'll just come out and claim then. I'm a tracker and the reason I started tring Ayia d2 is because I tracked him and saw that he went nowhere. Unfort because of the Litt death I wasn't able to track anyone which is why I'm sorta at a standstill but it that's on me for relying on my role (though it saved me because I outed myself too early). Anyways yeah from here we can probably poe scum, plus it should be easier once we get all the claims on the board.

Assuming this is a 5v3 what makes you think Ayias partner couldn’t have sent the kill?

[Edjeanerations]

Nov 13, 2020 19:36:34 GMT passthesaltdude said:

Nov 13, 2020 19:21:14 GMT Edjeanerations said:

I'll just come out and claim then. I'm a tracker and the reason I started tring Ayia d2 is because I tracked him and saw that he went nowhere. Unfort because of the Litt death I wasn't able to track anyone which is why I'm sorta at a standstill but it that's on me for relying on my role (though it saved me because I outed myself too early). Anyways yeah from here we can probably poe scum, plus it should be easier once we get all the claims on the board.

Assuming this is a 5v3 what makes you think Ayias partner couldn’t have sent the kill?

Even if that was the case I highly doubt scum is just 3 mafia goons. Even if Ayia's supposed partner had sent a kill that probably would've implied that they were most likely a goon and that ayia and his other partner had nothing else to do. Also if this is 4v2v1 then that would make the likelihood of having just goons lower. The fact that there's all this shit going around about cops and teachers and whatnot makes me believe that scum has something to do with inspects, so why would Ayia idle?

[Kaif]

Nov 13, 2020 18:18:28 GMT passthesaltdude said:

Nov 13, 2020 17:44:04 GMT cl said:

Ptsd who do you want to vote today

I really think Edjean/Kaif is today’s absolute best option and I’m leaning Edjean

I want to look at the Penguin D slot pretty closely but they are fine for now.

If you think we should take the risk lynching a PR claim today then I have some thoughts there, but I think the best idea is to Lynch edjean/Kaif (maybe Penguin but Chap was a very townie slot)

why do you think this is the case btw because I absolutely do not agree

[Kaif]

at least 1 of the 4 prs are lying

[cl]

The lynch today should be ideally between SSR and PTSD as a role cop and OS role cop cannot be same aligned.

Everyone should give thoughts on one of the two and then we vote

[cl]

Everyone should give thoughts on both* and then vote out one of the two.


Kaif is getting scummy sadly but per my tradition I'd like to keep him alive till lylo

[ScorrchingTheaph]

claim
Lynch Kaif

[passthesaltdude]

Nov 14, 2020 14:53:54 GMT cl said:

The lynch today should be ideally between SSR and PTSD as a role cop and OS role cop cannot be same aligned.

Everyone should give thoughts on one of the two and then we vote

I should make it clear now, no role is guaranteed and no setup will make 100% sense, so I think trying to use the logic of ‘only 1 PR’ can exist, is very flawed. I want to know how you feel about the Restless spirit claim btw and Edjeans tracker claim.

[Kaif]

vt

[Kaif]

Lynch Passthesaltdude this or ssr '-'

[Kaif]

also dl is like 5 am for me so I def wont be up then, would be great if ppl talked more so that I had more things to comment on

[ScorrchingTheaph]

Unlynch Kaif
Lynch PenguinD
claim

[PenguinD]

Nov 14, 2020 17:56:49 GMT ScorrchingTheaph said:

Unlynch Kaif
Lynch PenguinD
claim

Didn't exactly see a reason to claim? I'm a vt.

[Edjeanerations]

Nov 14, 2020 17:50:06 GMT Kaif said:

Lynch Passthesaltdude this or ssr '-'

Wasn't PTSD confed as town somehow or am I just making stuff up? Also I'd rather lynch ssr over PTSD here just because PTSD has been townier this game if we compare the two.
Lynch SSR

[OM~!]

Episode 3: Turnabout Samurai - Day 3 - 10 minute recess.

Here is a summary of the trial so far.

passthesaltdude - 1* - (Kaif )
PenguinD - 1 - (ScorrchingTheaph )
superstarsrock - 1 (Edjeanerations )

There is 22 hours and 30 minutes left in the day. If deadline was now, passthesaltdude would be lynched.

[ScorrchingTheaph]

Kaif:            vt
ayia:            Mason*** (according to cl)
cl:              Mason
?:               OS Restless Spirit
passthesaltdude: OS Alignment Cop
Edjeanerations:  Tracker (on ayia)
superstarsrock:  Alignment Cop
PenguinD:        vt
i think it is better to lynch vt or restless claim, mechanically speaking

[cl]

Ptsd:

This Restless Spirit claim is tricky. On one hand it fits both flavor and setup bc of the Treestump and is strongly town AI and that alone is enough to disqualify scorr as a lynch today.


PTSD saving his action is okay and SSR inspecting another cop claim is also logical.

(which is why I desperately wanted ptsd out d1 but literally everyone shifted to sky)


An OS alignment cop doesn't really make sense in a 12 player game but we have a tracker and a mason pair so yeah idk.

I agree with the lynch VT thing but I'm unsure who to pick in it

[cl]

Which is why I'd still stick to the cop v cop claim

[cl]

Just so we know in cop v cop im voting ssr and not ptsd.

[cl]

Litt being town threw me off hard tbh

Dude had the towniest first half of d1 then spiraled into darkness.

Still upset with Litt being town

[Edjeanerations]

cl ScorrchingTheaph passthesaltdude if it came down to lunching the vts right now who would you lynch

[cl]

If I'm voting in the VT pool I'd pick one of the Chap / scept slots.

If I'm voting the cop pool I'm PROBABLY picking SSR

[ScorrchingTheaph]

I would probably lynch PenguinD so that in the rare scenario where he flips town, I would be able to blame him for being inactive instead of myself for being unable to read scum. Both are probably Mafia though; 6 vts seems like it doesn't add up.
I would honestly rather nl than go through with a cop lynch, but I would pick PTSD to live.

[cl]

Wait.
it's potentially 5v3
It is MYLO.

[cl]

Pmylo*
W/e

Scorr makes more sense now