|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 2:36:50 GMT
lynch garythesavage
Eye Found Scum Like the Devil.
|
|
|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 2:37:46 GMT
edj litt is litt scum if anything, edj is town for the rest of the game.
|
|
|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 2:38:04 GMT
quojova is scum too
|
|
|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 2:38:24 GMT
3rd scum is scept
|
|
|
|
Post by PenguinD on Dec 2, 2020 2:42:12 GMT
lynch garythesavage Eye Found Scum Like the Devil. edj litt is litt scum if anything, edj is town for the rest of the game. Same. Why do you think this  |
|
|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 2:45:05 GMT
trust the process I'll think of something later
|
|
|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 2:49:57 GMT
why did this game start already lynch kaifbro why are you lynching your partner epic town post tl:dr no it's not optimal if it's option A (like I think it is? Can some1 conf for me) depends on if divorcer has priority over mafia kill I think, and idk if it does also 2 setup posts in 2 minutes? ez scum vote omalready explaining why hes voting om to cover up later woo Derz is town btw Lynch Penguingotta spread the love >forgot about this game It hasn't even been 3 hours lmao Any case on edj by PTSD saing "he lynched OM without reason" is stupid. Thats exactly what rvs is. Im lynching Penguin without reason rn, does that make me scum?? As for litts line about it I really couldn't tel if they were meming or not. Regardless, its not like you need an rvs lynch even without any reads to define you as town because rvs isn't what makes someone town. If edj wasn't lynching at the end of the day it'd be another story but for now, the pressure on him is just immature quojova pls learn how to multiquote lmao so you aren't taking up 6 spots with a sentence each This post reads like a minor verbal inaccuracy to me which is very nitpicky but there isn't too much else going on. "Quick thoughts: Edjean lynch on OM without any really explanation is a little weird, I understand we are in early game, but he has a lynch before that. So I’d love to see an explanation there. " ^in no world is that a "case". I'm not sure what you are trying to get out of shutting this down at this moment besides some """towncred""" for pointing to something and calling it stupid. PTSD was starting to explain it as a case until he caught himself as it turns out with the situation with the lynches which was explained above right afterwards. As for the towncred comment, the game is mafia. The whole point is for towncred, whether you're town or not. In this case I was not just pointing at something and calling it stupid, but I was saying what we should verge from, and rather form cases on reads and interactions with reactions, as well as other policies and strategies that can be used to find scum, rather than mindlessly going off of an rvs lynch This post reads like a minor verbal inaccuracy to me which is very nitpicky but there isn't too much else going on. "Quick thoughts: Edjean lynch on OM without any really explanation is a little weird, I understand we are in early game, but he has a lynch before that. So I’d love to see an explanation there. " ^in no world is that a "case". I'm not sure what you are trying to get out of shutting this down at this moment besides some """towncred""" for pointing to something and calling it stupid. For more clarification, edj did not have a lynch before OM. I don't know what you see every single one of garys posts are scumposts, every single one without fail. |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Dec 2, 2020 3:51:57 GMT
quojova pls learn how to multiquote lmao so you aren't taking up 6 spots with a sentence each he is so mad rn |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Dec 2, 2020 4:08:35 GMT
Any case on edj by PTSD saing "he lynched OM without reason" is stupid. Thats exactly what rvs is. Im lynching Penguin without reason rn, does that make me scum?? As for litts line about it I really couldn't tel if they were meming or not. Regardless, its not like you need an rvs lynch even without any reads to define you as town because rvs isn't what makes someone town. If edj wasn't lynching at the end of the day it'd be another story but for now, the pressure on him is just immature This reads as a wolf scraping for content. Picking a take that's agreeable with but doesn't progress the game. Post also comes off a difficult to reach premise at that point in reading, that edje is town and being pushed badly, and refuses to put in mindset how ptsd's acting at that point of time. This post reads like a minor verbal inaccuracy to me which is very nitpicky but there isn't too much else going on. "Quick thoughts: Edjean lynch on OM without any really explanation is a little weird, I understand we are in early game, but he has a lynch before that. So I’d love to see an explanation there. " ^in no world is that a "case". I'm not sure what you are trying to get out of shutting this down at this moment besides some """towncred""" for pointing to something and calling it stupid. PTSD was starting to explain it as a case until he caught himself as it turns out with the situation with the lynches which was explained above right afterwards. As for the towncred comment, the game is mafia. The whole point is for towncred, whether you're town or not. In this case I was not just pointing at something and calling it stupid, but I was saying what we should verge from, and rather form cases on reads and interactions with reactions, as well as other policies and strategies that can be used to find scum, rather than mindlessly going off of an rvs lynch this slot has no plans to scumhunt, and is just going to feed off town badposting to get a foot in the game |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Dec 2, 2020 4:11:31 GMT
PTSD was starting to explain it as a case until he caught himself as it turns out with the situation with the lynches which was explained above right afterwards. As for the towncred comment, the game is mafia. The whole point is for towncred, whether you're town or not. In this case I was not just pointing at something and calling it stupid, but I was saying what we should verge from, and rather form cases on reads and interactions with reactions, as well as other policies and strategies that can be used to find scum, rather than mindlessly going off of an rvs lynch fair enough, good response I guess what concerns me now is not that you are trying to earn cred (which I admit is a generally NAI move that is being done by everyone) but how you plan on generating reads after dismissing early-game squabbles good response in what sense? In that the logic behind it is correct, or that the post is consistent, or that it's coming from a town mindset? need a vibe check |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Dec 2, 2020 4:14:28 GMT
kaif makes sense even without expanding on points, Gary's iso hurts to read
still have ptsd from Gary flipping town in countdown but vote gary
much more confident in this because I noticed displaced reads on my first skim and had it validated on the last page meaning I'm not the only one to catch ii
|
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Dec 2, 2020 4:33:47 GMT
claiming to omgus is called the porcupine defense because you subtly discourage votes, but also are tasty as fuck to a person willing to push you wonder who's taking the free towncred off this post Sort of curious why this post was made. If you were interested in who would take the free towncred wouldn't you normally just let it sit? it's a shitpost, I wanted reactions from edje specifically as opposed to waiting for someone to 'town' themselves which is basically just going to be me wifomming their choice Do you read anything at all into Litt trying to get the ball rolling Not really, at least not for now. Getting discussion generated is usually ( not always ) a good thing, and it wasn’t really forced. That being said Litt and Edjeans are early slots that we should keep an eye based on their early interactions with each other. misguided, posting more is a necessity for both factions as for keeping an eye, here's an exercise while the day is free and the sky is fresh: Take out a notepad, write the names of every player. read every content post and make a pure gut decision on whether a post is town or scum, and make a required mark. Tally up and gain free insight on where you should go next, + try checking their interactions with other players. Incredibly basic but given you're scraping from the top of the thread with reads it's a good place to start I ignored that message because I didn't understand how you could get towncred from a post like that ...actually I still don't I think the idea is: -survivalist scum wouldn't want votes/attention -if someone voted you they would get a vote (and attention) -therefore voting you is townie behavior obviously faulty logic but the kind of micro-distinction that might lead to cred more like scum doesn't want to start on any potential bad foot in the game , they'd much rather just want to pretend to generate content rather than force themself to, unless they're good enough |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Dec 2, 2020 4:47:08 GMT
eye am all alone. help me.
|
|
|
|
Post by quojova on Dec 2, 2020 4:47:22 GMT
edj litt is litt scum if anything, edj is town for the rest of the game. why do you think edj is town |
|
|
|
Post by quojova on Dec 2, 2020 4:57:30 GMT
fair enough, good response I guess what concerns me now is not that you are trying to earn cred (which I admit is a generally NAI move that is being done by everyone) but how you plan on generating reads after dismissing early-game squabbles good response in what sense? In that the logic behind it is correct, or that the post is consistent, or that it's coming from a town mindset? need a vibe check I meant in a general overarching sense the game philosophy is sound, that all factions will want towncred and there are probably better places to look for scum than in an rvs vote. Where I think his post fails is to supply any alternative at all in this specific game for where reads should be generated. In hindsight not really a "good response" but as a rebuttal to that specific line of mine it seemed like it worked. Gary's game philosophy has nothing to do with his alignment this specific game though, so I don't consider Gary anywhere above null for the post despite how I think some parts of it are well-written. |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Dec 2, 2020 5:22:26 GMT
good response in what sense? In that the logic behind it is correct, or that the post is consistent, or that it's coming from a town mindset? need a vibe check I meant in a general overarching sense the game philosophy is sound, that all factions will want towncred and there are probably better places to look for scum than in an rvs vote. Where I think his post fails is to supply any alternative at all in this specific game for where reads should be generated. In hindsight not really a "good response" but as a rebuttal to that specific line of mine it seemed like it worked. Gary's game philosophy has nothing to do with his alignment this specific game though, so I don't consider Gary anywhere above null for the post despite how I think some parts of it are well-written. yeah fair felt like foot off the gas pedal, in that sense, because progressing from questioning to towning gary felt like a unexplained leap, that's fine
get the feeling your initial q was dodged / Gary chose to focus on a specific point to refute more easily, do you not get that sort of inkling as the post maker?
|
|
|
|
Post by quojova on Dec 2, 2020 5:45:39 GMT
I meant in a general overarching sense the game philosophy is sound, that all factions will want towncred and there are probably better places to look for scum than in an rvs vote. Where I think his post fails is to supply any alternative at all in this specific game for where reads should be generated. In hindsight not really a "good response" but as a rebuttal to that specific line of mine it seemed like it worked. Gary's game philosophy has nothing to do with his alignment this specific game though, so I don't consider Gary anywhere above null for the post despite how I think some parts of it are well-written. yeah fair felt like foot off the gas pedal, in that sense, because progressing from questioning to towning gary felt like a unexplained leap, that's fine
get the feeling your initial q was dodged / Gary chose to focus on a specific point to refute more easily, do you not get that sort of inkling as the post maker?
Sort of? To begin with my question was basically what he planned to do with his post, with my idea being that it was made pretty much "to feed off town badposting to get a foot in the game" which is vibe I got very strongly from it. I think he did answer it, in "I was saying what we should verge from, and rather form cases on reads and interactions with reactions, as well as other policies and strategies that can be used to find scum, rather than mindlessly going off of an rvs lynch " which in an idealistic town world is correct and a good plan that would make shutting down rvs pressure worthwhile if he actually had any of those things to back it up. So I would say he answered it, but in a way that didn't really satisfy the main concern of the question and is now creating an "I'm going to try to gather some cred without advancing the town agenda" feeling for me because he hasn't tried to execute the practical side of his gameplan. |
|
|
|
Post by quojova on Dec 2, 2020 5:48:47 GMT
lynch garythesavage Eye Found Scum Like the Devil. edj litt is litt scum if anything, edj is town for the rest of the game. Same. Why do you think this It appears you have opinions. Post pls I assume they aren't exactly the same as Kaif's with absolutely nothing else to add |
|
|
|
Post by PenguinD on Dec 2, 2020 6:00:17 GMT
Same. Why do you think this It appears you have opinions. Post pls I assume they aren't exactly the same as Kaif's with absolutely nothing else to add Early acumreads are weird. Especially a full team one |
|
|
|
Post by chapterseven on Dec 2, 2020 6:19:51 GMT
Votecount Day 1 Version 3 --------------------------------------- Hammer: 6 (Plur) blurb Edjeanerations Kaif Schrodinger OM~! (2)* {Edjeanerations, Quojova} spiderz quojova (1) {PassTheSaltDude} PenguinD passthesaltdude (1) {OM} litteleven (1) {Spiderz} Gary The Savage (2) {Litt, Kaif} Not Voting {4} (Eblurb, Sceptorus, Penguin D, GaryTheSavage) Players (& Current Votes) Eblurb Edjeanerations (OM) Kaif (GaryTheSavage) Sceptorus OM (PassTheSaltDude) Spiderz (Litt) Quojova (OM) Penguin D PassTheSaltDude (Quojova) Litteleven (GaryTheSavage) GaryTheSavage If deadline was right now, OM would be lynched. The current deadline is Thursday, December 3rd at 1:30PM EST --------------------------------------- Halfway through Day 1 |
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Dec 2, 2020 6:41:55 GMT
lynch garythesavage Eye Found Scum Like the Devil. edj litt is litt scum if anything, edj is town for the rest of the game. Same. Why do you think this Do you mind explaining why you agree with Kaif's reads? |
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Dec 2, 2020 6:44:24 GMT
kaif makes sense even without expanding on points, Gary's iso hurts to read still have ptsd from Gary flipping town in countdown but vote garymuch more confident in this because I noticed displaced reads on my first skim and had it validated on the last page meaning I'm not the only one to catch ii While you're correct in saying that Gary's iso is bad but I don't think I've seen Gary play in a forum game before so I'm gonna give him the benefit of the doubt and let him redeem himself before I consider shifting my vote. Gary, the stage is yours  |
|
|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 6:45:58 GMT
edj litt is litt scum if anything, edj is town for the rest of the game. why do you think edj is town pmeta from last game (ace attorney) |
|
|
|
Post by Kaif on Dec 2, 2020 6:50:15 GMT
going to add that litt is also town for the rest of the game, scum wouldn't sheep me so happily after that excuse of a case on gary
|
|
|
|
Post by quojova on Dec 2, 2020 7:00:07 GMT
It appears you have opinions. Post pls I assume they aren't exactly the same as Kaif's with absolutely nothing else to add Early acumreads are weird. Especially a full team one why do you think edj is town pmeta from last game (ace attorney) These are possibly the least satisfactory responses of my mafia lifespan. Could either of you say anything else (I'm not asking for a full readslist from penguin) going to add that litt is also town for the rest of the game, scum wouldn't sheep me so happily after that excuse of a case on gary atp I'm interested in where most people are for you because I can't decipher your posts |
|
