|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 23:10:34 GMT
Edjean do something scummy so I can use the vote gif I made Don't worry if I make it past a few days you're free to vote me, ain't no way people are letting me live that long if I'm town
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 23:07:31 GMT
Town Prodigu Clouds Ejdengations Cuddlez Dactly Fame Kliff saltiestcactus23 Scum null / weak: everyone else Prod as #1 and (I think) me as #3 is crazy!! I'd love to hear why you think this!! Even gut reads are fine, just lmk what's going on in that sweet ol noggin of yours
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 23:03:57 GMT
Wait I don’t know if this is replying to Fame or Cuddz lol but to clarify I meant I felt less confident in making reads due to me not having the meta knowledge of how people played in prior games. Right now I’m essentially just tone analyzing (which even then I haven’t talked to a lot of you before so I have no gage on how you normally communicate) because I don’t have past game experience with you all I could just reference to. I hope that makes sense but honestly very fair point from you I get where you were coming from. Sorry if the formatting is fucked on mobile I just want to make it known that I see this interaction and I see this message but I feel absolutely nothing when I read it. No knowledge gained. Just felt like that needed to be said
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 23:02:22 GMT
can you rehash this when you're sober lay off the drugs they're impairing your speech Strange This just in: Clouds hates drugs and alcohol and looks down on anybody who partakes in a bit of wacky tobaccy or jazz cabbage on the weekends get his ass
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 23:01:09 GMT
There's a towniness to Cuddz that I see in his posts even if I don't agree with the ideas like the urgency is more believable here than in some of the other posts people have made advocating for policy votes, particularly the way he's thinking more about the deadline + claims etc I think (?). Like right now is a more appropriate time to be doing that then at the start of the thread to me Don't worry about Cudd, he's definitely town for now. If he makes it to endgame then he's a threat but he usually gets nked so we won't have to vote him While I can't agree with everything he's saying (ex: camryn reads or camryn spelling) I still do think he's putting in effort in his own cuddly way
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:59:42 GMT
The balls to be so informed you found a goon and plant a vote and do nothing more is a level I strive to reach Fr can we all get good enough to be this sure about stuff
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:56:59 GMT
As a general mechanics question, do we hypo cop with results here (ie when Town Cop dies we’ll know who theyve checked and would have clears) or does the real cop only come forward if they get a redcheck? With both Mafia Cop and Mafia PL in rolelist im not completely sure on what we should do here mechanically speaking. Im guessing realistically we hypo here i think? Idm hypoing cop and PL, could definitely help with PL vs WW situation
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:55:34 GMT
gross I appreciate you tring me but I hate lurker votes
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:54:07 GMT
Hi, so I wanted to put a vote in before I go take my test and grind my paper today. It's likely to be subject to change but for now vote tommy2hands I want to first off state that this isn't because he scumread me, honestly it was the most he elaborated on any of his reads so I can't fault him. My issue and concern with tommy is that I find him to be an uncooperative slot in this game and that will become increasingly difficult to deal with. He refused to elaborate on a single one of his reads thus far and got angry when people asked him to do so. When he posts they are short, vague, and contradict themselves which I posted about a little bit earlier. I don't even know if he's scum but I don't have a solid scum read on anyone at the moment because all this meta being referred to I just don't have the same knowledge. But what I do know is that someone who is unwilling to elaborate when asked simple questions and gets aggro is not someone I think will be helpful to moving the game forward going on. Being unhelpful and unreadable as a result is just not something I'm interested in playing around. Yeah tl;dr he's annoying
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:53:06 GMT
U gotta just read the whole thread man edje Bro I always start from the beginning what r u talking about I give my thoughts as I discover information, if it's already been said then w/e but at least it was my own thoughts that I put out there
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:51:55 GMT
Hello everyone apologies for joining in late. So far, clouds’s reads pmuch match mine except iavh is strong townlean and kliff is light scumlean. Also I see clouds as a strong townlean in this scenario, will need to analyse more tho. Yeah bud you're gonna have to expand on these so I don't think you were just saying searching "read" in the thread and copying what people said about some of the biggest targets
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:50:20 GMT
Final note but Clouds has probably been the biggest enigma to me. He's been super active and aggressive with his views which he probably plays like that in general but something feels a tad bit off to me in regards to how he's conducted himself. He seems like VERY earnest which I can't decipher if it's him being town and trying to get the ball rolling or if it's just him cosplaying as town to avoid early suspicion. lol copy and paste of anyone who's ever played with clouds
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:48:27 GMT
Ok anyways my reads have changed a bit in the game as today progressed and I wanted to post a recap of things I think here. I no longer think IAVH is a good kill due to them being unreadable, as they definitely have given town but at the time I posted that they were legit only trolling so I thought they were gonna be hard to read and play with. I still think Fame is town and I feel pretty confident in that read, they were a driving force in a lot of discussion today and they seem to be playing with towns best interest in heart. Cuddlez I lowkey don't understand what the fuck you're saying in half your posts but you're def high and I'm also about to get high so tomorrow just bring some clarity on what you were saying. I honestly don't know how any of you have a read on Dactyl being town/scum and feel so fervently about that because he's been an overall neutral presence so far like I don't know how this polarizing debate is happening when I really think it could go either way with him, we don't have enough information from him at the moment. I'm leaning Crespo town just because his activity seems earnest and he's posting reads but tbh this is more of a gut read more than a read backed by any information so take that with what you will. A bit worried about TBZ and EDJ simply because they haven't said much at all yet but I'm hoping that changes tomorrow, definitely gives off vibes to me but maybe they just aren't super active in forum games who knows. Oh honey don't you worry about me, this is just my tactical playstyle so that I don't get killed the same night I join the game again I'm very much (partially) here and doing my best to respond to what I think is relevant. Ftr I don't think iavh was a good vote from the beginning. Not because I don't think they can be scum (I don't right now though) but just because we wouldn't get much out of voting them. An iavh scum flip would split town up too much and it would still be hard to tell who was pushing him for what reason. I think a bus at this point would have been unnecessary and anyone defending him wouldn't necessarily be scum either. Dw about Cudd I can understand him so we're all good Idk how to feel about Toni. I think he's fine but I'm not gonna put a label on him because I'm not really sure what I wanna do with several of the people in this game. Is TBZ usually an active poster? I feel like this is sorta just like him
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 22:42:53 GMT
salt/iavh votes still stand also i meant fame not game but the post still stands, townreads none, scumreads salt iavh fame carmy, salt has no presence and thats scumtelling of the slot, iavh or vintage my nickname for them, is going to be a very annoying slot to aligment tell without just breaking your brain apart without being cleared so this is also a policy vote for down the road regardless of aligment it just has to happen unless it gets cleared, fame is scumlean 50/50 playing into thier scummeta, and carmie is probbaly town and should be removed from this list but i just did not like this post talking about not being able to make reads because they never played with us before like wtf does that have to do with your ability to play the game and participate for it again im going to regard it as a stupid townie post but still, if your not addressed its because i dont care about you until further notice, and om you can come hit this zaza eventually Cuddposting makes me happy :)
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:50:25 GMT
get tos2 and camryn you too let's play THATS WHAT I FORGOT TO DO LAST NIGHT ty for the reminder
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:49:05 GMT
shoutouts gut reads
give me some content on the both of them :>
Look I'm gonna play my own game, okay? I'm gonna hunt scum my own way. I do not need direction, or you to tell me to give content, or anything like that. You do not need to push me to engage. I will engage even more than I have up to this point. This is wild that tommy just bites back immediately lol
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:46:59 GMT
kinda think om "towncoring" peng is vaguely townie on the grounds that peng has done nothing townie & it tends to look worse for scum to take a firm tr stance on slots that don't make sense to tr. also partly a same wavelength read 'cause i had similar thoughts about peng slot, but it was more like "surely peng would have more of an entrance if scum" know this shouldn't hold water in most cases, but there's something about the way he dropped in, left an rvs vote & locktowned iavh, then ditched that has me not wanting to vote him even though none of it raises green flags. i'll let this bake, we'll see what he's like when he's around more. i honestly don't think i've had s!peng experience in a forum game before, so if he's evasive in thread when he rands scum then this probably fits the bill and for the lack of experience alone, i don't feel set to commit to any sort of read here yet Wait... has PD really been town in every game in the last few months? That's wild.
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:45:15 GMT
I dunno I'm not liking Kliff's slot that much. I just feel like he's agreeing with the wrong things and ultimately not making much of an impact in this game despite having several posts. It would be easier if I could read his iso from the beginning but I'm not scrolling through 9 pages for the 4th time to find posts.
Either way it's not just the Dactyl read itself, it's also what came after. I feel like he was doing too much to solidify a read on someone who had like 5 posts, and that seems like it's coming more from someone who's informed rather than someone who's reading into people and attempting to solve. Maybe it's just me but I absolutely hate when people start off games by analyzing town/scum win chances. It's such fake contribution. I can understand trying to analyze the setup in a SemiOS or CS, but in a game where we already know everything it's just so fake to me.
In general he just seems too agreeable so far, like he's just trying to go along with the flow instead of saying anything groundbreaking. He doesn't need to say anything groundbreaking, but I'm used to his attempts at it at the very least and I'm not seeing that here.
For the record I'd like to say that if Kliff flips scum I don't think Clouds is partnered due to his 180 on Cliff
Vote Kliff
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:19:43 GMT
this is my first forum game that hasn’t ended in hosterror or me subbing, pls bear with me and let me know if im like using terms wrong or something You're lookin good so far my dude
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:17:12 GMT
i was gonna tag you and ask your thoughts after her post townreading you and om i wouldn't be that surprised if she jumped in her first game as scum & aced it immediately, but that felt like a pretty genuine post my 1 concern was that she felt like she had to make an excuse for not being here despite it being early, but we know she's been poisoned by ORGslol
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:13:19 GMT
tbh this town core? but add crespo too ^-^ town tbz Lowkey Toni might be town here he's kind of squeezing out alignments early on in the thread like they might not be super substantial reads but I can at least see some sort of thought being put into sorting people in the playerlist So Toni also makes posts like this and you skim over them and even tl Toni for it alright iavh is town vote edje Why do you think this? There's no way you can get away with flippantly placing votes like this as if it actually applies any sort of pressure But then PD says something like this and you instantly jump on him for it. You've probably switched your vote more than he has but you're pressuring PD for... what? Making reads and shifting votes? Honestly I'm not gonna say anything about the iavh defense because I agree with it. While I do believe Cudd could be right that SC or IAVH pressure can reval info this early on, I'm not really seeing anything from IAVH that's bad, or at least scummy. btw I don't sr Fame, I'm just saying he's being a hypocrite here
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 14:13:05 GMT
Girl I don't feel like trying to quote things because I don't know how the bleep forums work usually but I'll post some brief thoughts here from my point of view! Please bare with me and my reads since this is my first proper mafia so not everything is bond to make perfect sense to y'all but like hi I exist! - It seems like people want to vote iavh due to him trolling and not being very readable either way as a result, and I get that mindset because there is only so much you can go off of Day 1 so it makes sense to vote an anomaly here to get rid of a harder to read variable. - I could be naive, but OM and Fame tentatively read as town to me at the moment. I feel like OM is actively questioning other people's reads as well as providing reads of his own and all of them seem to be grounded in reason, so he doesn't give scum to me. Fame I feel like is challenging things and the logic behind them questioning other people seem to be sound. It seems like Fame is trying to play for what would benefit town the most here by questioning votes and mulling over if they are logical/fair. That's all I got for now it's hard for me properly analyze people's behaviors when I haven't played mafia with any of y'all before LOL While I do agree with these reads, at the same time I'm not a huge fan of some of Fame's posts, I'll find them and link them in a separate post. But yes I agree with OM town for now, while I haven't seen him push (which wasn't exactly necessary at the time) I like how he is actively just giving his thoughts on specific situations and trying to make his own reads. Can I say anything specific about him? Nope. But I've seen his posts so far and have made mental notes of stuff, same with Fame.
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 13:48:33 GMT
Ok so you think Fame is scum currently atm is what youre saying? Is there anyone you believe would be town at the current moment, or are there any other players you think could be scum from what theyve said so far that was a meme suggestion seriously wtf why is this the earliest post I can search from this thread
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 13:43:33 GMT
ok mate. that's funny. what a cracker. not iavh calling people crackers now...
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Nov 21, 2023 13:41:41 GMT
i have all the incentive to manufacture a push on iavh because frankly i haven't been around long enough to know if they've learned from our previous games and i am doubtful that they have slightly concerned about this vote that looks kinda opportunistic to yeet iavh, don't do that! b-baka! Ugh stop it
|
|