Fire and Ice: The Public Domain Game Thread [GAME OVER]

[sayggtome]

Oh I'm so sorry i didn't realize it was that long. I will shorten my next post so it's easier to read I'm so sorry

[sayggtome]

**vote CCGeek** I'm on mobile I'll fix later.

[❗]

Apr 25, 2023 20:26:18 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

vvv
ForgotToFlush
vv
Schia, lindauna, scrooch
v
termsofservice, aka
w
Cyan, clems, ccg
ww
Myan
n
zesty/dactyl/sand

ftf died n1 by fire. What do we make of this, everyone?

vote no vote

[sayggtome]

That fire mafia killed them

[sayggtome]

Maybe fire mafia was ranked too lowkeky on the list, so they just were like let's kill him. Or they just somehow knew he was doc.

[sayggtome]

Please discard my read on theaph. I did not realized they died. Sorry.

[ihbst]

please get off

[cyan]

the game is just dead l m a o

ihbst's posts are the definition of bare minimum and their playstyle makes me think they're just really uninvested in scumhunting

and any player who wants to live but doesn't want to say anything outright inflammatory or potent is an instant policy.

[cyan]

i actually think it's quite nice that you're willing to contradict your sub slot with your reads but i do wish you could expand on all of your conclusions instead of shuttling them all out like this

May 1, 2023 21:34:09 GMT sayggtome said:

Okay. So I really hard read up to page 12, and started to get worried I don't know how long days are. I want to post some sort of contribution. I was taking too long to read, so I skimmed. I will reread hard later.

I thought Clemsen was easily seen as scum, as scum you can't really reinact towniness since you have TMI. It's a hard skill to learn and often cracks are shown by small mistakes, such as Clemson being on Myan for a horrible reason, pushing them, but not voting them until they were later called out. Scum naturally want to keep their options open, so I'm assuming that why they pushed but didn't vote them right away.

I want to cross reference Theaph, from what I seen they town read Clemson for no reason? I think they also town read akakap? Correct me if I'm wrong, I skimmed day two. I will reread!!!

I think the MyanMario push was odd to me personally, only because I personally could tell Myan was trolling in the beginning but recovered when they realized this was not how people were wanting to play. Change in tone basically. Also pmeta on MyanMario since I have been working closely will Myan for months, I could tell they were town. I'm assuming if I remember they died to ice mafia, so most likely ice thought they were fire mafia over the other people on the wagon. I'm trying to understand the thought process there.

I really don't understand how I been sided with ice mafia. I am town. But on Clemsen's stating they thought ccgeek/ailura was a t/s. But, never explained their reads on that. They did scum read CCgeek. Meaning ailura was town, but I'm assuming they only did that because Ailura was on them but got off and wanted to keep the vote off of them as long as possible because you know Ailura would def get them.

But I want to take notice of that read t/s read as well, I may be overreading things a bit too much, but I really think their push on CCGeek was fake? They only if I remember correctly hopped on the vote when someone else voted them. I feel like they voted their scum partner in a sense to give them some sort of shift off of them being ice mafia. Let's say either of them flipped ( both ice mafia in my eyes ) gives the other lee ( can't spell the word ) way. Most scum know they should vote their partner day one if they are being voted off. To atleast try to give some sort of clear for their partner. If the Clemsen was not voted off and CCGeek was, he would not be seen as ice mafia. Please do tell me if I'm overanyslising this spot!!!

I also want to bring notice to Dacty, they were second on Clemsen's vote. And if I remember they scum read him off of one line. I could be paranoid, but they didn't push and then didn't say anything after that. Maybe they thought the wagon would die down later, or the fact they could get early not ice mafia if they flipped.


Apparently akakakp flipped. I haven't read the days following into day two that much, so I will update on who I personally think is fire mafia when I read. I just wanted to post something.

I realized while reading ailura's reads, I didn't agree with a lot, so I'm sorry if I'm ruining their legacy. They scum read akakap though, while I town read them, but basically because of how they played day one. But I scum read Clemsen, they did not. I feel like I'm in a tight spot at the moment.

I want to continue into my reads on who I think is not ice mafia.

Cyan Talon is not ice mafia frankly because they got Clemsen right away, and continued to push them. They did not let them go, and saw scum. I also see them as town lean, due them activity contributing in the game and explaining their reads well. They get their point across every post I seen so far.

TE is also confirmed not ice mafia and I whole heartily think they are town. Due to their day one interactions with Clemsen. Yes, it was a poor vote on them base-wise, but you can tell TE voted out of pettiness rather than an actually read/push right off the bat, but they later recovered by explaining their read more. This may be a weak read, and is surrounded likely on a mirco read, I'm pretty confident. No way is their scum partner bussing day one so LOUDLY.

I will read day two and find my reads on who may be fire mafia, and post more town reads/town leans, but those are the only ones I feel confident at the moment.

but i want to highlight angles of discussion i think need to be cleared up in this game: TE not being ice goo is a valid read, and ice goo's reason for killing MyanMario and Schiavetto is pretty much a mystery (were they hunting n1 and fearkilling n2? were they suspecting schia of being scum?)

it's at least very clear from the lack of activity that neither kill in d3 was an explicit setup for a vote.

[cyan]

May 1, 2023 21:40:39 GMT ❗ said:

Apr 25, 2023 20:26:18 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

vvv
ForgotToFlush
vv
Schia, lindauna, scrooch
v
termsofservice, aka
w
Cyan, clems, ccg
ww
Myan
n
zesty/dactyl/sand

ftf died n1 by fire. What do we make of this, everyone?

vote no vote

i got a lot of shit for saying we shouldn't be paying attention to this. 

if you want to talk about something interesting we can talk about how both of the people giving me shit were killed n2

but i highly doubt flush was the focus for either kill because no one else was talking about his reads late d2/early d3

[cyan]

May 1, 2023 21:35:45 GMT sayggtome said:

**vote CCGeek** I'm on mobile I'll fix later.

you can use  

[cyan]

uh, format failure

[ b ] text [ / b ] is how you bold without spaces

[Fenrir]

Votecount 3.1

---

ihbst(2)-cyan , OM~!

❗(1)-termsofservice

Shaun-CCGeek(1)-ihbst

No Vote(1)-❗

Not Voting (2)-Shaun-CCGeek , sayggtome

Day 3 ends in ~23.5 hours. With 7 players alive, it takes 4 to hammer.

If the the day were to end now, ihbst would be eliminated.

[❗]

May 2, 2023 4:16:30 GMT cyan said:

May 1, 2023 21:40:39 GMT ❗ said:

ftf died n1 by fire. What do we make of this, everyone?

vote no vote

i got a lot of shit for saying we shouldn't be paying attention to this. 

if you want to talk about something interesting we can talk about how both of the people giving me shit were killed n2

but i highly doubt flush was the focus for either kill because no one else was talking about his reads late d2/early d3

yes that's right let's talk about it. Why did they die?

[ihbst]

why would I kill ftf my friend

[ihbst]

also don't you think scorrching is a weird kill when theaph wasn't on the fire wagon, we should also talk about this kill.

[ihbst]

bro scorrching was like my ssr and it was weird that the kill wasn't sylveon or cyan

[sayggtome]

Vote
CCGeek

[cyan]

May 2, 2023 12:43:08 GMT ihbst said:

also don't you think scorrching is a weird kill when theaph wasn't on the fire wagon, we should also talk about this kill.

scorr was the akakakp counterwagon. unless you think there's some deeper meaning behind the kill looking into it is kind of pointless

in fact, if you actually had thoughts, you would've given us some sort of guess as to what fire mafia wanted to achieve with the scorr kill. but no, you're just doing textbook IIoA + "Look at Me, I'm Helpful"

[cyan]

May 2, 2023 12:37:46 GMT ihbst said:

why would I kill ftf my friend

this was never implied in conversation at any point in the game btw

ihbst is literally speaking in a way that cannot be explained from a town perspective

May 2, 2023 12:52:10 GMT sayggtome said:

Vote
CCGeek

okay but you haven't exactly explained why and your read dump from earlier makes me think you scumread ccgeek because... clemens did?

[cyan]

which, need i remind you, ccgeek was clemens' counterwagon and there was all the reason to push the slot for "lack of activity"

with how frequently ccgeek gets wagoned and turboed this game i may have to just locktown them despite their absolute lack of input

[ihbst]

yeah, but I just feel like the Scorching kill wasn't the best kill there and the mafia mightve thought they were the other mafia

[ihbst]

unvote

[ihbst]

vote sayygg

[ihbst]

this slot hasn't been particularly townie this game+can fit in with both scum

tell me if there's something i missed