|
|
Post by cyan on Jul 11, 2023 2:41:55 GMT
What about fame’s post makes you think they’re very paranoid? They’ve been in depth but I don’t see any of their reads as being outside the gamestate or burning hot—they’ve been more disciplined than agitated. Also paranoia can be great when they’ve been multiple town misvotes that cause you to reassess previously-read townslots, but none of this has happened yet and there hasn’t been any flips that could cause you to think this less than 48 hours in. I’m inferring that you think the paranoia is warranted when you mention how fame’s paranoia makes them town, which makes me think there’s a mismatch between how we see the game right now considering there’s been no information to think this way the general way they've been operating the game & clearly being very wary of how they're interacting with other people is very much so akin to how they act in games as town. see : them questioning my read on them as town/not scum for a seemingly strange, at least fmpov, reason - it's likely that they'll question intentions of other players townreading them v publicly and that's what i'm referring to for the sake of both me not dying d1 and because i think this angle is worth a fair amount of merit, i will now shift my vote onto the player of least importance Unvote FameVote ihbstin a perfect world my vote order is winsy/fame/aka/clem first and everyone else after but alas |
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Jul 11, 2023 2:46:29 GMT
oh yeah i might consider adding crespo to that pool. controversial take, maybe but low priority, if that's a concern for you. i just don't like the frequency:content ratio of their posts, with most of them being one-line observations. at the same time i think it's a good thing that they're stirring discussion in productive directions so i'm going to leave this far in the backburner iso them for the full picture, these posts are here just to illustrate my point: i really just have a hard time following this whole thing considering i think the starting point shouldn’t have been a starting point to begin with actually i guess it makes sense on neo’s part if he wants to reaction bait and make the thread go somewhere but the only iffy response is winsy admitting they’re posting less (albeit for oog reasons) okay i'm going to actually pull a 180 on everything i've done up to this point and say that i sl clem for their recent string of posts. it's frankly kinda weird that they're making blatant attempts at banter (with less substance than 9am fish 15p modexe town!cy trying to stay sane) while other slots are engaging in serious discussion. granted i don't think the discussion going on rn is productive, and i can see why someone would refuse to engage with it, but i'm not getting that sense i get the read on clem but also like my issue with it is just doesn't clem behave like this as either alignment? (hence my somewhat policy vote as soon as i realised this game wasn't gonna be different for them) upon first read of thread did not like akakakp’s posts, but they’re not actually bad i like the clouds questioning just the entrance was extremely iffy really dislike that reaction from pisx but it's so ballsy that i have to TR her. if they are scum they are just asking for me to vote/tunnel them and I was definitely thinking about it. can we get a votecount mymemoryisbad but also the first half of this message reads as conceding in the interactions with pisx to just end it and move on, to avoid thread pressure |
|
|
|
Post by iavh on Jul 11, 2023 2:51:42 GMT
I can't click the spoiler smh
|
|
|
|
Post by iavh on Jul 11, 2023 2:52:48 GMT
is this survivalism?
hmmmm
|
|
|
|
Post by frogo on Jul 11, 2023 2:55:42 GMT
ihbst red = clemens red btw
|
|
pisxel
Villager
♡♫ he on my hip like a tamagotchi ♫♡
Posts: 57
|
Post by pisxel on Jul 11, 2023 2:57:30 GMT
for future reference if i like a post consider it me agreeing with it in some way without wanting to bloat the thread with bad oneliners. thanks! oh yeah i might consider adding crespo to that pool. controversial take, maybe but low priority, if that's a concern for you. i just don't like the frequency:content ratio of their posts, with most of them being one-line observations. at the same time i think it's a good thing that they're stirring discussion in productive directions so i'm going to leave this far in the backburner since i have the opportunity right now w this post @ what i just said + my Like on this post here, i don't agree with the crespo read from cyan talon though i understand where they're coming from; i don't know crespo's pmeta that well, so maybe i'm wrong, but the consistency with which they're "oneliner"ing makes me think that that's just how they play the game. the oneliners in question aren't actually baseless/lacking in substance which is why i'm hesitant to agree with you here, and like you said they're actually moving conversations forward in a positive direction which is always helpful. |
|
pisxel
Villager
♡♫ he on my hip like a tamagotchi ♫♡
Posts: 57
|
Post by pisxel on Jul 11, 2023 3:06:07 GMT
ihbst red = clemens red btw can you elaborate on this i'm not seeing what you're seeing |
|
|
|
Post by fingerlings on Jul 11, 2023 3:07:47 GMT
ihbst red = clemens red btw can you elaborate on this i'm not seeing what you're seeing seconded |
|
|
|
Post by ®➕➕ on Jul 11, 2023 3:10:29 GMT
responding to the last neo post (since I can’t quote it and what I hope will be the last post on this)—what I’m saying is that you shouldn’t be basing your reads on mostly page 1 opening posts but every thread has to start somewhere and you don’t have any information very early on to discuss or analyze mafia reads. I was also part of the discussed content and thought it would be good to make a post about why I did what I did My problem was you commenting about it hours after the fact after numerous people already did and its not like you weren't here to comment on it because you in fact had posted ITT multiple times so its hard to me to take posts that essentially reiterate/spew the same point that was made countless times before which makes me feel a little wary on whether or not these ideas are really your own that aside said other slot involved in the "page 1 shenanigans" and still hasn't had a good showing so apparently my fos was not for naught considering my point being proven to be right unless your going to tell me he's somehow town ihbst is the other person (alongside clem) with a unique playstyle and if we’re using pmeta ibhst is usually very carefree and right now he’s being a lot more careful and posting relatively “safe” observations—feels like he’s compelled to be more restrictive in what he’s saying, which is a contrast with how he usually blurts what he thinks out loud. radar for now +1 this isn’t their town game from popcorn meta reading off of popcorn gameplay is nasty works |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 3:16:04 GMT
I'm now being asked to get up right I just did, and I'm not feeling well, someone get me a lemon tea (not cannibalism!) reads: fame and neo know of each other's roles (the one I am more confident on), I guess I'll wait to stop being the limbait (not likely) to see as being the limbait means that people look at your posts I just realised that the afk population... is massive. So many people not using votes. On the flipside, if they used their votes there will def be a chance I'll get smacked into oblivion d1, the second day of this game /shrug whoever pointed out I'm a punching bag, thank you.man i... why are you outing a read like that? and what alerted you about the punching bag thing? |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 3:18:48 GMT
upon first read of thread did not like akakakp’s posts, but they’re not actually bad i like the clouds questioning just the entrance was extremely iffy i think i slight townlean aka now but i don't feel like responding to their questions to me |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 3:20:34 GMT
ihbst red = clemens red btw maybe more than a slight townlean on aka, like think this sort of thought is less likely to be fabricated and more a real-time depiction of the firing of wolfhunting neurons |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 3:20:50 GMT
i'm gonna make myself sick if i keep typing like that
|
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 3:29:46 GMT
ihbst is weird, myan is underwhelming but not sure what to make of it yet, aka's improved, pisx is either a strong town or powerwolfing but i have no reason to vote her here and she's doing her part, ddlc/winsy probably aren't paired due to their entrance but both are somewhat individually scummy, cyan i'm extremely null on and don't have any resounding reason to tr them, clem i still think is a townlean despite the # of times i've questioned why a villager ever posts some of the things he has
vote Winsy Tinsy
|
|
|
|
Post by ®➕➕ on Jul 11, 2023 3:38:37 GMT
just a disclaimer I'm not remote for my wageslaving tomorrow so my activity outside of 7-8am est will be contingent on if proboards is blocked or not
|
|
pisxel
Villager
♡♫ he on my hip like a tamagotchi ♫♡
Posts: 57
|
Post by pisxel on Jul 11, 2023 4:11:53 GMT
the winsy vote is like a good vote but i would rather apply pressure on ihbst[see note below] and/or simply wld rather vote myanmario so i'm not interacting with it for now ^____________^
[] ihbst pressure is good bc their reactions can tell us a lot; their playstyle is very unique to them and if they start acting outside of it / against their norm once pressured it can tell us a lot about their alignment specifically wrt how mafia-adjacent they are
i'll probably hop on winsy wagon closer to eod if neither of the above get any traction, so don't be surprised if i unvote myan & vote winsy at some point. like if i see my vote is probably going nowhere i'll shift so my vote's like being used productively yk.
anyways logging off for the night unless i feel randomly inspired to .. checks notes .. play mafia (unlikely)
|
|
|
|
Post by iavh on Jul 11, 2023 5:16:57 GMT
I'm now being asked to get up right I just did, and I'm not feeling well, someone get me a lemon tea (not cannibalism!) reads: fame and neo know of each other's roles (the one I am more confident on), I guess I'll wait to stop being the limbait (not likely) to see as being the limbait means that people look at your posts I just realised that the afk population... is massive. So many people not using votes. On the flipside, if they used their votes there will def be a chance I'll get smacked into oblivion d1, the second day of this game /shrug whoever pointed out I'm a punching bag, thank you.man i... why are you outing a read like that? and what alerted you about the punching bag thing? I don't know what else to say, I'm being really confused rn also the punching bag thing was from you! |
|
|
|
Post by ®➕➕ on Jul 11, 2023 10:16:41 GMT
the general way they've been operating the game & clearly being very wary of how they're interacting with other people is very much so akin to how they act in games as town. see : them questioning my read on them as town/not scum for a seemingly strange, at least fmpov, reason - it's likely that they'll question intentions of other players townreading them v publicly and that's what i'm referring to and because i think this angle is worth a fair amount of merit, i will now shift my vote onto the player of least importance Unvote FameVote ihbstin a perfect world my vote order is winsy/fame/aka/clem first and everyone else after but alas i know its not the entire reason but finding it a little strange considering how well you've been playing for you think the other 15 players wouldve let you die to a 2 plur vote in a lolwagon being made up by clems and ddlc |
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Jul 11, 2023 11:37:50 GMT
for the sake of both me not dying d1 and because i think this angle is worth a fair amount of merit, i will now shift my vote onto the player of least importance Unvote FameVote ihbstin a perfect world my vote order is winsy/fame/aka/clem first and everyone else after but alas i know its not the entire reason but finding it a little strange considering how well you've been playing for you think the other 15 players wouldve let you die to a 2 plur vote in a lolwagon being made up by clems and ddlc i mean there's barely anyone here but yeah i can kinda see that |
|
|
|
Post by frogo on Jul 11, 2023 12:07:08 GMT
ihbst red = clemens red btw can you elaborate on this i'm not seeing what you're seeing lack of reaction to ihbst wagon + coming up with an excuse to keep RVS vote on cyan “is this survivalism hmm” |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 12:10:39 GMT
vote Fingerlings
nevermind gonna go back here, keep rereading winsy first page or so and it's fairly comfortable
|
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 12:11:37 GMT
can you elaborate on this i'm not seeing what you're seeing lack of reaction to ihbst wagon + coming up with an excuse to keep RVS vote on cyan “is this survivalism hmm” why'd you tag fingerlings in this? |
|
|
|
Post by frogo on Jul 11, 2023 12:15:00 GMT
fingerlings lack of reaction to ihbst wagon + coming up with an excuse to keep RVS vote on cyan “is this survivalism hmm” why'd you tag fingerlings in this? they also wanted clarification on the read |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 12:17:20 GMT
man i... why are you outing a read like that? and what alerted you about the punching bag thing? also the punching bag thing was from you! what i meant was if you think two players may be in the know about each other's role, why out that read unless it's beneficial to town in some way? all you're doing if you say something like that as a villager is giving scum a chance to catch something they might've missed. unless you mean that you think fame/neo can be s/s together? |
|
|
|
Post by Clouds on Jul 11, 2023 12:17:37 GMT
why'd you tag fingerlings in this? they also wanted clarification on the read alright ty guess i'm blind |
|
