|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 5:41:23 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 5:42:18 GMT
anyway more Flush Takestm:
zara can absolutely fake anything he has said thus far
aligning's non derpclear posts are fine otherwise
the nexus style situation i pointed out earlier with penguin and friends isnt completely bs, i think there's some substance there
i know nothing about pqwerty and am inclined to chalk up what i've seen to a style that i haven't fully assessed, leaning town
gonna do some other things for an undisclosed amount of time, hf
i am back can you explain me the roles? idk what they mean Which roles, I think there’s a sample of all rolepms under spoiler in the first post by Edj if that’s what you mean |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:43:50 GMT
Well what do you wanna walk about iavh? |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:44:23 GMT
i am back can you explain me the roles? idk what they mean Which roles, I think there’s a sample of all rolepms under spoiler in the first post by Edj if that’s what you mean no their abiliies hater, codemner, brilliant princess? never heard of them before |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:45:34 GMT
ftf is most likely a villager for having that #fear of me lol
|
|
|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 5:46:32 GMT
Which roles, I think there’s a sample of all rolepms under spoiler in the first post by Edj if that’s what you mean no their abiliies hater, codemner, brilliant princess? never heard of them before Hater = target needs 1 less vote to be hammered the next day beloved princess = the next day phase is skipped after this role dies condemner = this role wins by voting out a predetermined player, tho in this format condemners can swap targets on even nights and become jester if their target is nked |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:47:40 GMT
no their abiliies hater, codemner, brilliant princess? never heard of them before Hater = target needs 1 less vote to be hammered the next day beloved princess = the next day phase is skipped after this role dies condemner = this role wins by voting out a predetermined player, tho in this format condemners can swap targets on even nights and become jester if their target is nked does condemner end the game? |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:47:57 GMT
Well thats something to keep in mind then
|
|
|
|
Post by pqwerty on Apr 17, 2024 5:48:11 GMT
Hi PTSD great questions! #1 I'm not really sure... like I feel like the case was good on a surface level since it had reasoning-ish and wasn't just a random vote, but I also don't like how Lin started going "Pqwerty hasn't done anything towny all game". Maybe Lin is my executioner and the bait worked after all? I just don't see why someone would be pushing me like this 1 hour into the game unless they were 100% convinced I'm scum for saying I failed to do a fancy play. #2 I don't know yet. Maybe look out for Prodigu for saying they can godread Penguind when u struggle to do it. It might be possible that they can godread this game cuz they know the setup. Also a lot of their posting so far (and I get it, we're only an hour into the game) but it's mostly just saying they can godread penguin and helping people use the vote system. It's solving-adjacent in the sense that it isn't solving but it's stuff that helps in solving. Just keep an eye on it to make sure they're actually solving later on. #2.5 I'm bad at reading entrances and making entrances so I pretty much ignore them. So you’re saying you can see where my case is coming from, maybe let’s address that. What is your take on the STP vote, and why were you so hesitant to place a second vote? Also what is your take on prod/peng, do you think prod is setting up for a solve or generating content without the intent to actually solve the game? Sure so the stp vote was a random vote from Prodigu. I was hesitant to vote stp because I was about to enter thread and it looks really bad if I vote stp immediately after Prodigu as my entrance, to the point where the plan to even remotely fish out a condemner would just look scummy especially if I started getting heat on me and just said "yeah I was trying to fish out a condemner claim". So I just cut my losses and said yeah my plan failed immediately and would probably just end up with me getting mischopped. Right now I'm saying Prodigu could possibly be doing the second option since so far they've just generated content without solving. But again we're an hour or so in the game so it's not a heavy read. I'm putting it in my readlist but I'm actually more suspicious of FTF for having a POE already and saying that if you (Lin) are not wolf then it's one of Prodigu/Peng/PTSD |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:49:24 GMT
vote @pqwerty
|
|
|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 5:49:48 GMT
I feel like there hasn’t been enough activity for me to have a solid scum pool but ftf/ptsd lean town for me, I like Zara so far in terms of tone and posting asw but I’ll trust FtFs caution here. Prod and peng probably resolve over time and I’ll reevaluate my sl on pq after they respond to prods. completely null on the rest pls speak
|
|
|
|
Post by pqwerty on Apr 17, 2024 5:50:12 GMT
Step 1. Create discussion. Step 2. Read ISOs Step 3. Make reads. Step 4. Profit. I'm currently writing up step 3 from the little we have so far hihi gonna start on this post! as i like to say, yet I haven't said in a bit, lamist!!! vote pqwerty [/vote][/quote]
...uh, they asked me what my approach was to solving the game. This is my approach. Answering a question about how I'm gonna play the game is LAMIST? |
|
|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 5:50:19 GMT
Hater = target needs 1 less vote to be hammered the next day beloved princess = the next day phase is skipped after this role dies condemner = this role wins by voting out a predetermined player, tho in this format condemners can swap targets on even nights and become jester if their target is nked does condemner end the game? nope, game just continues as usual. I think condemner only condemns town tho |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:52:13 GMT
So you’re saying you can see where my case is coming from, maybe let’s address that. What is your take on the STP vote, and why were you so hesitant to place a second vote? Also what is your take on prod/peng, do you think prod is setting up for a solve or generating content without the intent to actually solve the game? Sure so the stp vote was a random vote from Prodigu. I was hesitant to vote stp because I was about to enter thread and it looks really bad if I vote stp immediately after Prodigu as my entrance, to the point where the plan to even remotely fish out a condemner would just look scummy especially if I started getting heat on me and just said "yeah I was trying to fish out a condemner claim". So I just cut my losses and said yeah my plan failed immediately and would probably just end up with me getting mischopped. Right now I'm saying Prodigu could possibly be doing the second option since so far they've just generated content without solving. But again we're an hour or so in the game so it's not a heavy read. I'm putting it in my readlist but I'm actually more suspicious of FTF for having a POE already and saying that if you (Lin) are not wolf then it's one of Prodigu/Peng/PTSD its quite simply an abhorrent post |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:53:48 GMT
I feel like there hasn’t been enough activity for me to have a solid scum pool but ftf/ptsd lean town for me, I like Zara so far in terms of tone and posting asw but I’ll trust FtFs caution here. Prod and peng probably resolve over time and I’ll reevaluate my sl on pq after they respond to prods. completely null on the rest pls speak ftf is only cautious because i always snow him as wolf, he will get over his fear soon enough |
|
|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 5:55:08 GMT
So you’re saying you can see where my case is coming from, maybe let’s address that. What is your take on the STP vote, and why were you so hesitant to place a second vote? Also what is your take on prod/peng, do you think prod is setting up for a solve or generating content without the intent to actually solve the game? Sure so the stp vote was a random vote from Prodigu. I was hesitant to vote stp because I was about to enter thread and it looks really bad if I vote stp immediately after Prodigu as my entrance, to the point where the plan to even remotely fish out a condemner would just look scummy especially if I started getting heat on me and just said "yeah I was trying to fish out a condemner claim". So I just cut my losses and said yeah my plan failed immediately and would probably just end up with me getting mischopped. Right now I'm saying Prodigu could possibly be doing the second option since so far they've just generated content without solving. But again we're an hour or so in the game so it's not a heavy read. I'm putting it in my readlist but I'm actually more suspicious of FTF for having a POE already and saying that if you (Lin) are not wolf then it's one of Prodigu/Peng/PTSD I like this response tbh I can see it coming from a town pov, I was wary of how tonally you seemed to avoid wanting to be the second vote and it felt like a bit of a fumble. I get the reasoning behind FtF tho I think the early read list is rly low effort and I’d see it as NAI vote @Prodiguwsg prod |
|
|
|
Post by pqwerty on Apr 17, 2024 5:56:36 GMT
Ah so Condemner is like a cop since they always get town targets. But that makes them want to side with mafia cuz unless maf kills condemner's target and we waste a day voting off a condemner (which would lead to condemner winning) then they won't want to work with town.
|
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 5:56:43 GMT
lin his response is bad lmao
|
|
|
|
Post by pqwerty on Apr 17, 2024 5:58:40 GMT
Yeah Lin. Zara saying my post is bad completely invalidates your opinions on it and also makes it a bad post at the same time.
|
|
|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 5:59:34 GMT
lin his response is bad lmao I can low-key see the reasoning for it from the pov he’s relatively new to the game, also I feel like scum wouldn’t blatantly read ftf as a sl for a low effort d1 scumpool |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 6:00:34 GMT
No, I don't like your push on ftf there at all pqwerty. Likewise fishing out the codemners? aren't codemners essentially 3p? So you are 3p hunting, that's wolf agenda to appear towny
|
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 6:02:42 GMT
lin his response is bad lmao I can low-key see the reasoning for it from the pov he’s relatively new to the game, also I feel like scum wouldn’t blatantly read ftf as a sl for a low effort d1 scumpool No, I think scumreading ftf there is NAI at best and kinda wolfy fmpov I have ftf as kinda towny for engaging the way he did and the reads he gave out. Likewise once again he's 3p hunting thats a red flag |
|
|
|
Post by pqwerty on Apr 17, 2024 6:04:04 GMT
lin his response is bad lmao I can low-key see the reasoning for it from the pov he’s relatively new to the game, also I feel like scum wouldn’t blatantly read ftf as a sl for a low effort d1 scumpool Not that this makes me good at the game but I've been playing mafia on and off (mostly off) for like 10 years now. I'm not new but I am still just liveposting rn so imagine these posts as more conversational and spontaneous than well-thought-out essays. |
|
|
|
Post by lindauna on Apr 17, 2024 6:04:45 GMT
No, I don't like your push on ftf there at all pqwerty. Likewise fishing out the codemners? aren't codemners essentially 3p? So you are 3p hunting, that's wolf agenda to appear towny Yea the focus on condemners and the angle they took in their first post about STP felt very out there to me, I dislike the FtF push, but I could see new town getting sidetracked here asw |
|
|
|
Post by zarathustra on Apr 17, 2024 6:05:25 GMT
No, I don't like your push on ftf there at all pqwerty. Likewise fishing out the codemners? aren't codemners essentially 3p? So you are 3p hunting, that's wolf agenda to appear towny Yea the focus on condemners and the angle they took in their first post about STP felt very out there to me, I dislike the FtF push, but I could see new town getting sidetracked here asw He just said he isn't new btw. I would rethink your read |
|
