|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Jun 17, 2024 16:38:48 GMT
I don't think the read from aspen on rea's a bad shout tbh @ne
|
|
|
|
Post by micromorphic on Jun 17, 2024 16:40:01 GMT
This is taking way longer than I thought it would, here's what I got going into Page 8:
Page 5 - I actually went to page 24 of Hydra to see what Myan was talking about and I cannot understand why Myan townlocks vade after vade posts off hydra acc. What the fuck is realiti cooking. SlowThePoke makes more obvious but good reasoning for pointing out realiti’s bad myan read. Unpartnered from Myan is a bit of a stretch from that post alone, but from the elaboration from realiti, I’m willing to hear that POV out. Although all of realiti’s townleans have been jumping the gun, they note how it’s all shallow, which is disappointing but a fair response to being under pressure. Realiti slot is looking more town than scum but I want to see solid reads.
Page 6 - realiti is absolutely winning 1v2 pressure, which is diabolical because those reads have really poor reasoning. Realiti’s post mentioning that STP’s pressure is scummy and vade’s pressure is towny is also exactly what I was thinking. Instead of observing realiti from a town POV, SlowThePoke feels like they are just being nitpicky with everything realiti is saying and not learning anything while vaderaven seems like they’re trying to observe realiti’s POV here from the questions, though I don't know what vade is taking in.
Page 7 - After all of that, STP taking away “NAI leaning scum” from realiti’s slot is extremely disappointing. However, I don’t like realiti noting that they think myan has a greater than 25% chance to be town so we shouldn’t vote them. This reasoning is extremely wack and I really want to town this slot but I can’t take posts like this seriously. Schia’s posts after are all cool I guess, nothing really dazzling there but all cool messages. I don’t like how vaderaven mentions how realiti “doesn’t have a real reason for their reads”, like their reasons are real but I feel like it’s just not what you want to see. NightEmerald’s first post of substance feels like a whole bunch of nothing and all I learned is that everyone could be any faction.
Realiti vs SlowThePoke & Vaderaven - realiti comes up looking the best from these exchanges IMO, because it just seemed like realiti was talking to walls from the final result of STP & Vade having shallow reads from their questioning.
Overall, I'd like more from SlowThePoke besides from nitpicky prodding, I'd like if NightEmerald was actually taking in information instead of just posting lame messages, I'd like if vaderaven would read realiti's POV, I'd like if realiti could get solid reads. This 1v2 was extremely disappointing to read from all three sides. SlowThePoke and vaderaven seemed to be questioning with tunnel vision glasses instead of observing realiti's POV and realiti had some poor reasoning and didn't really care. I'm going into Page 8 now.
|
|
|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Jun 17, 2024 16:40:37 GMT
Like I don't know that I'm super sold on it, and I wish it were coming from someone with more content bc I can definitely seeing it be an opportunistic sort of thing, but I do think out of my current batch of TL's rea's got the least going for them and I can see someone landing on a WR there
|
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:40:39 GMT
vote @pqslays
Snaq edit: fixed vote
|
|
|
|
Post by aspen22 on Jun 17, 2024 16:41:00 GMT
Half his posts are some form of “I TR vade and schia”, I read that as kissing up to the people most likely to apply pressure. The repeated focus on lechen to me comes from nowhere and is a counterproductive discussion. I read that as reality trying to appear to be applying pressure in a not actually helpful way Ok I feel like you're just making up reasons because i've definitely expanded on both of these things and done more than that. Not a good look But it seems like you've read the thread, so What are your thoughts on the other players in the game. No other thoughts. Once you flip I will re-evaluate |
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:41:42 GMT
This is taking way longer than I thought it would, here's what I got going into Page 8: Page 5 - I actually went to page 24 of Hydra to see what Myan was talking about and I cannot understand why Myan townlocks vade after vade posts off hydra acc. What the fuck is realiti cooking. SlowThePoke makes more obvious but good reasoning for pointing out realiti’s bad myan read. Unpartnered from Myan is a bit of a stretch from that post alone, but from the elaboration from realiti, I’m willing to hear that POV out. Although all of realiti’s townleans have been jumping the gun, they note how it’s all shallow, which is disappointing but a fair response to being under pressure. Realiti slot is looking more town than scum but I want to see solid reads. Page 6 - realiti is absolutely winning 1v2 pressure, which is diabolical because those reads have really poor reasoning. Realiti’s post mentioning that STP’s pressure is scummy and vade’s pressure is towny is also exactly what I was thinking. Instead of observing realiti from a town POV, SlowThePoke feels like they are just being nitpicky with everything realiti is saying and not learning anything while vaderaven seems like they’re trying to observe realiti’s POV here from the questions, though I don't know what vade is taking in. Page 7 - After all of that, STP taking away “NAI leaning scum” from realiti’s slot is extremely disappointing. However, I don’t like realiti noting that they think myan has a greater than 25% chance to be town so we shouldn’t vote them. This reasoning is extremely wack and I really want to town this slot but I can’t take posts like this seriously. Schia’s posts after are all cool I guess, nothing really dazzling there but all cool messages. I don’t like how vaderaven mentions how realiti “doesn’t have a real reason for their reads”, like their reasons are real but I feel like it’s just not what you want to see. NightEmerald’s first post of substance feels like a whole bunch of nothing and all I learned is that everyone could be any faction. Realiti vs SlowThePoke & Vaderaven - realiti comes up looking the best from these exchanges IMO, because it just seemed like realiti was talking to walls from the final result of STP & Vade having shallow reads from their questioning. Overall, I'd like more from SlowThePoke besides from nitpicky prodding, I'd like if NightEmerald was actually taking in information instead of just posting lame messages, I'd like if vaderaven would read realiti's POV, I'd like if realiti could get solid reads. This 1v2 was extremely disappointing to read from all three sides. SlowThePoke and vaderaven seemed to be questioning with tunnel vision glasses instead of observing realiti's POV and realiti had some poor reasoning and didn't really care. I'm going into Page 8 now. thank god someone actually mentioned it micro town, moving on |
|
|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Jun 17, 2024 16:43:32 GMT
This is taking way longer than I thought it would, here's what I got going into Page 8: Page 5 - I actually went to page 24 of Hydra to see what Myan was talking about and I cannot understand why Myan townlocks vade after vade posts off hydra acc. What the fuck is realiti cooking. SlowThePoke makes more obvious but good reasoning for pointing out realiti’s bad myan read. Unpartnered from Myan is a bit of a stretch from that post alone, but from the elaboration from realiti, I’m willing to hear that POV out. Although all of realiti’s townleans have been jumping the gun, they note how it’s all shallow, which is disappointing but a fair response to being under pressure. Realiti slot is looking more town than scum but I want to see solid reads. Page 6 - realiti is absolutely winning 1v2 pressure, which is diabolical because those reads have really poor reasoning. Realiti’s post mentioning that STP’s pressure is scummy and vade’s pressure is towny is also exactly what I was thinking. Instead of observing realiti from a town POV, SlowThePoke feels like they are just being nitpicky with everything realiti is saying and not learning anything while vaderaven seems like they’re trying to observe realiti’s POV here from the questions, though I don't know what vade is taking in. Page 7 - After all of that, STP taking away “NAI leaning scum” from realiti’s slot is extremely disappointing. However, I don’t like realiti noting that they think myan has a greater than 25% chance to be town so we shouldn’t vote them. This reasoning is extremely wack and I really want to town this slot but I can’t take posts like this seriously. Schia’s posts after are all cool I guess, nothing really dazzling there but all cool messages. I don’t like how vaderaven mentions how realiti “doesn’t have a real reason for their reads”, like their reasons are real but I feel like it’s just not what you want to see. NightEmerald’s first post of substance feels like a whole bunch of nothing and all I learned is that everyone could be any faction. Realiti vs SlowThePoke & Vaderaven - realiti comes up looking the best from these exchanges IMO, because it just seemed like realiti was talking to walls from the final result of STP & Vade having shallow reads from their questioning. Overall, I'd like more from SlowThePoke besides from nitpicky prodding, I'd like if NightEmerald was actually taking in information instead of just posting lame messages, I'd like if vaderaven would read realiti's POV, I'd like if realiti could get solid reads. This 1v2 was extremely disappointing to read from all three sides. SlowThePoke and vaderaven seemed to be questioning with tunnel vision glasses instead of observing realiti's POV and realiti had some poor reasoning and didn't really care. I'm going into Page 8 now. thank god someone actually mentioned it micro town, moving on NE mentioned it too, relatively soon after you brought it up |
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:44:15 GMT
current reads:
town-
vade
micro
realti
stp
mehh-
schia
ptsd
leaning?-
fame
NE
winsy
lockscum-
sylvie
|
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:45:06 GMT
Yo I’m town Down to axe schia for fun, TB is freelim How many pings did it take for your wolfmates to get you in here & posting so soon? ;o wait i randomly jumped to this while looking for ne how did i miss it |
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jun 17, 2024 16:45:35 GMT
the motion towards answers should be evident in me questioning them in the first place! This is like... fundamentally untrue (in that the fact of questioning doesn't perforce mean someone's looking for answers). Like c'mon, you know this, even outside of mafia that's not the case.
Let's start here: what's your read on me? I made a post earlier about me being threadspewed; I still hold that to be the case (vade's imo another slot that's probably approaching this point), but I think it's cause for concern that your posts just straight up don't feel like you're trying actively to discern alignment--and while yeah, that doesn't exclude you from flipping villager, I think it's def a trait that skews wolfy and in the context of my other concerns I don't think it's an unfair position to take.
Would also go on to say that like, if you are villaging here, I don't think the adversarial stance is really that fruitful.
what do you mean by your slot being threadspewed? i see the case for vade don't think anything you've posted is particularly out of range so townreads that are essentially "schia saying wolves fake content is good townplay with no agenda" are a bit egregious imo, especially when TB2 is prefacing some of his posts with the fact you guys have previous experience in games together you're middling for me atm |
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:47:04 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:48:25 GMT
thank god someone actually mentioned it micro town, moving on NE mentioned it too, relatively soon after you brought it up where is this btw i cant find it |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jun 17, 2024 16:48:38 GMT
I don't think the read from aspen on rea's a bad shout tbh @ne idk i just wanted more, if that makes sense. They may have a read on realiti, but the wording used felt too vague for me to either agree or disagree with them. aspen please give me something here, your thought process is entirely opaque Half his posts are some form of “I TR vade and schia”, I read that as kissing up to the people most likely to apply pressure. The repeated focus on lechen to me comes from nowhere and is a counterproductive discussion. I read that as reality trying to appear to be applying pressure in a not actually helpful way I don't see how trs on people applying pressure is a scum-indicative thing, moreso the opposite, and while the focus on lechen is odd, it feels like tunnel vision since I've done the same thing when I tried to vote sylvie. typing up a bigger post on the side btw. |
|
|
|
Post by micromorphic on Jun 17, 2024 16:49:08 GMT
I'm switching up on NightEmerald they're cool starting Page 8
|
|
|
|
Post by realiti on Jun 17, 2024 16:49:23 GMT
This is taking way longer than I thought it would, here's what I got going into Page 8: Page 5 - I actually went to page 24 of Hydra to see what Myan was talking about and I cannot understand why Myan townlocks vade after vade posts off hydra acc. What the fuck is realiti cooking. SlowThePoke makes more obvious but good reasoning for pointing out realiti’s bad myan read. Unpartnered from Myan is a bit of a stretch from that post alone, but from the elaboration from realiti, I’m willing to hear that POV out. Although all of realiti’s townleans have been jumping the gun, they note how it’s all shallow, which is disappointing but a fair response to being under pressure. Realiti slot is looking more town than scum but I want to see solid reads. Page 6 - realiti is absolutely winning 1v2 pressure, which is diabolical because those reads have really poor reasoning. Realiti’s post mentioning that STP’s pressure is scummy and vade’s pressure is towny is also exactly what I was thinking. Instead of observing realiti from a town POV, SlowThePoke feels like they are just being nitpicky with everything realiti is saying and not learning anything while vaderaven seems like they’re trying to observe realiti’s POV here from the questions, though I don't know what vade is taking in. Page 7 - After all of that, STP taking away “NAI leaning scum” from realiti’s slot is extremely disappointing. However, I don’t like realiti noting that they think myan has a greater than 25% chance to be town so we shouldn’t vote them. This reasoning is extremely wack and I really want to town this slot but I can’t take posts like this seriously. Schia’s posts after are all cool I guess, nothing really dazzling there but all cool messages. I don’t like how vaderaven mentions how realiti “doesn’t have a real reason for their reads”, like their reasons are real but I feel like it’s just not what you want to see. NightEmerald’s first post of substance feels like a whole bunch of nothing and all I learned is that everyone could be any faction. Realiti vs SlowThePoke & Vaderaven - realiti comes up looking the best from these exchanges IMO, because it just seemed like realiti was talking to walls from the final result of STP & Vade having shallow reads from their questioning. Overall, I'd like more from SlowThePoke besides from nitpicky prodding, I'd like if NightEmerald was actually taking in information instead of just posting lame messages, I'd like if vaderaven would read realiti's POV, I'd like if realiti could get solid reads. This 1v2 was extremely disappointing to read from all three sides. SlowThePoke and vaderaven seemed to be questioning with tunnel vision glasses instead of observing realiti's POV and realiti had some poor reasoning and didn't really care. I'm going into Page 8 now. My initial reads are from 5 pages of Day 1 filler, they are not as strong as anything gleaned from flips & interactions in the future. While the reasoning is not the strongest. it's still something that I believe to be true and would slightly tip someone towards town or scum. Everybody seems to be putting a lot of weight in these, but I give out these "gut" reads to preliminary sort people and to get discussion going, it's like brainstorming for a future thesis, these aren't hills that I will die on. Seems like it's worked because everybody is talking about them now so yay! My reads have changed & strengthened/weakened throughout the game as more information comes to light. |
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:50:22 GMT
would love for someone to nom stp btw
|
|
|
|
Post by realiti on Jun 17, 2024 16:50:29 GMT
current reads: town- vade micro realti stp mehh- schia ptsd leaning?- fame NE winsy lockscum- sylvie Why is sylvie scum for you, and if it's a troll vote can you vote & case the next scummiest person |
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jun 17, 2024 16:50:33 GMT
not feeling very amused by myan's lousy test or whatever, not really believable to me that this is the only content you're capable of producing after evading doing anything for the whole phase you still haven't elaborated on why you asked me the question in particular MyanMario |
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:51:39 GMT
Actually I lied, winsytinsy I’m going to absolutely pummel you tomorrow please be active it would be helpful. PTSD you’re welcome to join in cuz atm I can’t read u but like, d1 so w/e Why don't you like winsy? going to say trust! for now but if they get online i'll elaborate, nvr said i dont like them tho |
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:53:36 GMT
not feeling very amused by myan's lousy test or whatever, not really believable to me that this is the only content you're capable of producing after evading doing anything for the whole phase you still haven't elaborated on why you asked me the question in particular MyanMario idrg how I could possibly be evading here, i made it clear when i was around and when I wasn't, there's a large difference between not producing anything important vs. dodging producing anything important regarding the QIP, i just wanted to see how you'd answer it, idt there was a hidden motive besides gauging you + wanting to know ur thoughts |
|
|
|
Post by aspen22 on Jun 17, 2024 16:53:52 GMT
Looks like we have enough online now…
Welcome to the SUMMER OF GATSBY! I hardclaim TOWN. GATSBY is GOD!
From now on, each forum game this summer will have at MINIMUM 1 GATSBY alt per game, including the ones currently running! I will game throw at the perfect time in each to create an air of MUSK and AROUSAL.
Furthermore, I am excited to announce my return to live play! 2 of my puppets are on their way to topping leaderboard… oh what a time to be alive!
GATSBYs GIRTH will PENETRATE the mafia room for all time. We must #freezorquax and #deletemafia! Coward bitch Snaquaza will run away, WHOREENhero will be disposed! Only GATSBY shall remain!
|
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 16:54:30 GMT
current reads: town- vade micro realti stp mehh- schia ptsd leaning?- fame NE winsy lockscum- sylvie Why is sylvie scum for you, and if it's a troll vote can you vote & case the next scummiest person i get that its prolly throwing me under the bus still but just dont worry abt it atm, im around for a majority of the day so im not exactly in a rush to move around my vote |
|
|
|
Post by micromorphic on Jun 17, 2024 16:54:47 GMT
Looks like we have enough online now… Welcome to the SUMMER OF GATSBY! I hardclaim TOWN. GATSBY is GOD! From now on, each forum game this summer will have at MINIMUM 1 GATSBY alt per game, including the ones currently running! I will game throw at the perfect time in each to create an air of MUSK and AROUSAL. Furthermore, I am excited to announce my return to live play! 2 of my puppets are on their way to topping leaderboard… oh what a time to be alive! GATSBYs GIRTH will PENETRATE the mafia room for all time. We must #freezorquax and #deletemafia! Coward bitch Snaquaza will run away, WHOREENhero will be disposed! Only GATSBY shall remain! oh jeez! |
|
|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Jun 17, 2024 16:54:53 GMT
This is like... fundamentally untrue (in that the fact of questioning doesn't perforce mean someone's looking for answers). Like c'mon, you know this, even outside of mafia that's not the case.
Let's start here: what's your read on me? I made a post earlier about me being threadspewed; I still hold that to be the case (vade's imo another slot that's probably approaching this point), but I think it's cause for concern that your posts just straight up don't feel like you're trying actively to discern alignment--and while yeah, that doesn't exclude you from flipping villager, I think it's def a trait that skews wolfy and in the context of my other concerns I don't think it's an unfair position to take.
Would also go on to say that like, if you are villaging here, I don't think the adversarial stance is really that fruitful.
don't think anything you've posted is particularly out of range so townreads that are essentially "schia saying wolves fake content is good townplay with no agenda" are a bit egregious imo, especially when TB2 is prefacing some of his posts with the fact you guys have previous experience in games together you're middling for me atm Combination of general treatment/pairable interactions. I'd agree with you re: "egregious" if TB were making a fuss out of the case--but it's an elaboration that was given readily after vade asked and was relatively understated. I don't think it's really all that out of line, by way of initial reads, doesn't read as pained, and while I can understand taking issue with someone invoking meta/past experience as a crutch in place of an actual read, I think it's pretty decently reasonable to bring it up the way TB does there (i.e., introducing it as one of the lenses being used to read my slot, and then lightly going into some of the other reasoning).
Do you take TB/Myan to be viable partners?
|
|
|
|
Post by realiti on Jun 17, 2024 16:55:29 GMT
Just realized there's no night phase. Some of us gonna be playing 10 straight days of mafia
|
|
