|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Jun 17, 2024 17:30:19 GMT
I kinda think we're looking at a NE Myan Rea scum team tbh. This random TR'ing of myan by rea makes me really want to SR them, along with NE's chainsaw of defense of rea by changing the focus to me and stp's slot exclusively, and yet they still have not provided any reads whatsoever on other slots I think I can see where you're coming from, but tbh NE/Myan strike me as unpartnered off pg4-5--there's a point where NE reacts to Myan's joke abt chopping me in a way that's probably never partnered [x], [x](for it to be W/W it'd basically be one partner immediately No-and'ing the other on pg4, and then on the next page pushing back on another player defending them--it would be setting up a partner to have a bad time for no reason, barring a hellbus situation which, again, feels pretty inconsistent with the play we've seen from the slots thus far & doesn't really hold up to a cui bono). The Myan/rea stuff is definitely noticeable though & while there's room for error sure, it feels wolfier than not. |
|
|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Jun 17, 2024 17:32:12 GMT
Housework for a bit, back later this afternoon.
|
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 17:32:24 GMT
Like I think there's easily room for one of them to just be town, but it's hard to not see this as Myan being an uncomfy wolf, rea towning them on very little (with STP catching flack for pointing this out), Myan getting met with pressure on attempted reentry and flailing, with Fame playing half-handed around the slot (poised to either defend or bus depending on how the temperature), and then the sudden urgency around Lechen coming up with Myan/rea being plur'd. can confirm im uncomfy! overall i think this is always going to be a stretch- i haven't yet to see an interaction (?) between realti and fame, correct if wrong. idk how to comment on my own slot here but if i try to look on from a 3rd-person POV to me it seems like just passive-aggression / pushing thoughts |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 17:37:50 GMT
Hi guys i have reappeared, gonna read the ppl I havent read and try to comprehend shit.
|
|
|
|
Post by micromorphic on Jun 17, 2024 17:39:16 GMT
I'm finally caught up, I'm gonna take a break & eat, collect my thoughts, and start pushing. Sorry for taking a bit.
|
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 17:42:29 GMT
This is taking way longer than I thought it would, here's what I got going into Page 8: Page 5 - I actually went to page 24 of Hydra to see what Myan was talking about and I cannot understand why Myan townlocks vade after vade posts off hydra acc. What the fuck is realiti cooking. SlowThePoke makes more obvious but good reasoning for pointing out realiti’s bad myan read. Unpartnered from Myan is a bit of a stretch from that post alone, but from the elaboration from realiti, I’m willing to hear that POV out. Although all of realiti’s townleans have been jumping the gun, they note how it’s all shallow, which is disappointing but a fair response to being under pressure. Realiti slot is looking more town than scum but I want to see solid reads. Page 6 - realiti is absolutely winning 1v2 pressure, which is diabolical because those reads have really poor reasoning. Realiti’s post mentioning that STP’s pressure is scummy and vade’s pressure is towny is also exactly what I was thinking. Instead of observing realiti from a town POV, SlowThePoke feels like they are just being nitpicky with everything realiti is saying and not learning anything while vaderaven seems like they’re trying to observe realiti’s POV here from the questions, though I don't know what vade is taking in. Page 7 - After all of that, STP taking away “NAI leaning scum” from realiti’s slot is extremely disappointing. However, I don’t like realiti noting that they think myan has a greater than 25% chance to be town so we shouldn’t vote them. This reasoning is extremely wack and I really want to town this slot but I can’t take posts like this seriously. Schia’s posts after are all cool I guess, nothing really dazzling there but all cool messages. I don’t like how vaderaven mentions how realiti “doesn’t have a real reason for their reads”, like their reasons are real but I feel like it’s just not what you want to see. NightEmerald’s first post of substance feels like a whole bunch of nothing and all I learned is that everyone could be any faction. Realiti vs SlowThePoke & Vaderaven - realiti comes up looking the best from these exchanges IMO, because it just seemed like realiti was talking to walls from the final result of STP & Vade having shallow reads from their questioning. Overall, I'd like more from SlowThePoke besides from nitpicky prodding, I'd like if NightEmerald was actually taking in information instead of just posting lame messages, I'd like if vaderaven would read realiti's POV, I'd like if realiti could get solid reads. This 1v2 was extremely disappointing to read from all three sides. SlowThePoke and vaderaven seemed to be questioning with tunnel vision glasses instead of observing realiti's POV and realiti had some poor reasoning and didn't really care. I'm going into Page 8 now. My initial reads are from 5 pages of Day 1 filler, they are not as strong as anything gleaned from flips & interactions in the future. While the reasoning is not the strongest. it's still something that I believe to be true and would slightly tip someone towards town or scum. Everybody seems to be putting a lot of weight in these, but I give out these "gut" reads to preliminary sort people and to get discussion going, it's like brainstorming for a future thesis, these aren't hills that I will die on. Seems like it's worked because everybody is talking about them now so yay! My reads have changed & strengthened/weakened throughout the game as more information comes to light. This actually makes a lot more sense then what I was thinking lmaooo, I thought u were making like fullfleged reads bc of u using tl there, I’m pretty sure u said that in some of ur early posts as well and i probaly didnt see it. |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 17:55:06 GMT
My initial reads are from 5 pages of Day 1 filler, they are not as strong as anything gleaned from flips & interactions in the future. While the reasoning is not the strongest. it's still something that I believe to be true and would slightly tip someone towards town or scum. Everybody seems to be putting a lot of weight in these, but I give out these "gut" reads to preliminary sort people and to get discussion going, it's like brainstorming for a future thesis, these aren't hills that I will die on. Seems like it's worked because everybody is talking about them now so yay! My reads have changed & strengthened/weakened throughout the game as more information comes to light. This actually makes a lot more sense then what I was thinking lmaooo, I thought u were making like fullfleged reads bc of u using tl there, I’m pretty sure u said that in some of ur early posts as well and i probaly didnt see it. Btw, this doesnt mean I like what u did, I dont, but I can at least understand it |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:05:06 GMT
I like winsy and Snivy, agree with their points + natural tone = townlean for me. Fame slight TL, towny mindset from some posts but also good enough to fake it as mafia. Myanmario back to null and possibly slight sl, will continue to observe. On 2nd thought I feel better about NE bc faking anger at wade as mafia seems excessive so early on so it's probably a natural reaction. DDLC + PTSD pretty null Towniest people are still vade and schia Fuck i just lost my entire post. But anyways I really like this line, I think it helps with one of the main problems I had with the slot(them jumping the gun on reads) bc they actually gave reasonings for their reads and I like that. I also agree with these reads cuz when I did read, I thought winsy had townie vibes and agreed with the posts that toiletbro made, (barring me but I think I can get where there coming from) I havent really read fame yet bc reading fame is a whole can of worms that I know is gonna be hell, so cant really comment on that one. Another thing I like is that u show what u said earlier when u said, my reads cant change with the myan read, I dont really like that u didnt give a reasoning like the others, but its not that huge of a deal. It also doesnt really feel like distancing (in a scenario where myan and rea are both scum) because later on they go back and tl them after liking some of their posts. I havent finished reading realitis iso, but overall I do think that this post > my issues with them earlier, esp with realities explanation for the early reads and shit. There still null rn, bc I dont wanna change my read just off one post without reading the otherw, but I do feel better abt the slot and I do think theyre more likely town. But quick question, can you explain the difference between a natural and unnatural tone to u?bc u seem to use that as part of ur reasoning a lot and I don’t really understand what that means, besides the whole timid thing. Or u could also like explain what made winsys tone natural or smth so I can have a better understanding of what ur trying to say. I |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:06:39 GMT
ig just worth noting that myan felt it was necessary to try and unpair vade/stp for whatever reason atp Yeah I feel like Myan's Page 9 was not very strong as his comment felt random and out of place, i'd prob move him back to NAI for me as he's done good and bad so far imo ah nvm heres the explanation for the myan going back to null |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:09:56 GMT
K finished the small part of realitis iso I didnt read, and I dont see anything wrong with it, theyre prob unpartnered with iavh off the early interactions, that i saw with the previous slot, think ill stick it at a slight tl, and I want to see more stuff from realiti thats like their recent posts.
|
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:19:03 GMT
Im just gonna say, I really like micros posts a lot, like I like their take on the me and vade v realiti situation, and I agree with them that I was nitpicky with my pusu onto rea, I also get how they could see that its a tunnel(i dont see it as such, esp with vade, less so with me, bit I do get how they get to that conclusion), I dont really get what they disliked with ne or what changed for them tho, and they feel slightly non-commital with the “I think anyone can be any faction. Want actual alignment reads from them and not them just doing a ptsd(giving thoughts on posts but not sharing what they think of someones alignment), I do tl them tho and their probaly my 2nd strongest read besides schia
|
|
|
|
Post by winsytinsy on Jun 17, 2024 18:21:15 GMT
Goooooood morning yall Just got back from the cousins(Eid Mubarak to anyone celebrating btw), just skimmed thread, not too much of a deep dive, but thoughts so far. STP looks pretty towny, the pressuring they have done on slots, esp realti feels consistent with their townplay. Schia seems towny as well, but their general playstyle looks like town usually. Everyone is nai, not gonna put any sl/sr's on anyone without any good reason. Time to take a shower and the dive into the convo again to reply. Oh and ddlc is in this game so uh, Town lock on them Also it appears we arent just bolding for vote, doesn't look too hard to figure out, but I will more than likely ask questions about it that have probably been answered already. Thank you in advance for your patience Peace I love u bb <3 |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:24:14 GMT
Oh lord its the troll trio(winsy, iavh, ddlc)
|
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:26:41 GMT
Ima go eat should be back at 3
|
|
|
|
Post by winsytinsy on Jun 17, 2024 18:26:53 GMT
Ok so gonna be here until 4:30 cuz I gotta head off for work then, so I'll probably put my final vote out(If I can figure out this voting thing) onto one of myan/NE. I haven't liked a couple of myans posts where they just go x is town, x is scum, without saying much. NE had a worse start for me, but their slot is starting to turn around, they have made a couple of comments which, even if I don't agree with, I can see how they came to that conclusion
Now someone tell me how to vote pls
|
|
|
|
Post by winsytinsy on Jun 17, 2024 18:27:18 GMT
Oh lord its the troll trio(winsy, iavh, ddlc) u cant put all three of us and not throw ur own name up there too |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jun 17, 2024 18:29:37 GMT
I like tb's wallposts, they read as genuine to me, where they have a consistent reason to tr people, where me, vade, and realiti all have gotten trs because they think we're progressing thread (and that gives me a warm fuzzy feeling), especially how quick they were to answer the question about schia from vade (i could never my typing speed is far too slow.)
I don't understand what Fame's questioning of vade accomplishes, but I want to like Fame because I've been semi mindmelding with them before, so id like to hear from them as to what they were looking for from vade
i want more from ddlc, it feels like they wanted to just post to post and disappeared afterwards, not a fan.
fame/schia interaction is interesting, and while schia brings up good points, I feel like fame's responses in terms of thinking the questions show intent are at the very least genuine.
TR
schia
TL
realiti just generally seems to be solving the way they have in previous games ive played w them, their comment on starting discussion is something recent that i like
toiletbro for reasons posted earlier
fame for general mindmeldiness, could drop depending on how they answer my question about their questions to vade
MIXED
micro seems to be alright, but I want to interact once they're read up and make my reads off that as personal preference, I want to solve them by having them interact with others
ptsd just kinda seems fine? there's not really anything that theyve said that ive found interesting or particularly memorable
myan is someone I have absolutely no read on, to be honest I should read them more in depth but I 'm gonna postpostpone that because im getting hungry
lechen has posted
dact is a person in this game of mafia
clemens is as well but at least i know dact
iavh is null, the slot they subbed into would be in dippers but i hope iavh posts soon
vade still feels not great, but other people have made cases of them being a tunnel visioned town that make sense, I have a feeling that d2 I can make a solid read on them depending on who flips and how vade reacts to them. I'm sorry for getting too aggressive, I feel like I did exactly what I saw you doing.
stp has moved down by virtue of them not having done much to help the thread/town themselves, and i want them to come back to actually making progress.
winsy "making options" is weird, them claiming realiti's first post is ATE is weird, and them asking lechen to post reads when it seems as if they hadn't even read the full thread (mmentioning only my first 10 posts) feels weird, but I like their reaction to ptsd enough that i dont want to sl them
dippers
sylvie
ddlc
no srs or post-based sls, I don't believe that they're strong enough to be called as such, so I'd rather vote/nom from lower neutrals or the dippers
im sorry i type so slow, idt i missed anyone, and i did NOT write this from top to bottom so hmu if sometyhing needs more explanation/feels weird to yall
|
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jun 17, 2024 18:33:34 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jun 17, 2024 18:34:19 GMT
nvm actually was gonna post dumb shit
|
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jun 17, 2024 18:37:41 GMT
worth asking atp who you'll be nominating if you're voted out MyanMarioreads are cool but ultimately we're forced to vote between 3 candidates and choose from that pool so this is the only day we have of free reign over votes |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:39:35 GMT
Myan is entirely null here for me tbh, like, I dont feel like, any thoughts on what theyve said so far, theyre clearly trying, but I just dont feel much frok what theyve said biggest thing I see is the readlist from them so MyanMario if ur here can give explainations on them. Idm a myan vote bc I think myans unpartnered with vade and rea and if they flipped scum it’d help resolve the me v vade v rea that some ppl have. |
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Jun 17, 2024 18:41:56 GMT
worth asking atp who you'll be nominating if you're voted out MyanMario reads are cool but ultimately we're forced to vote between 3 candidates and choose from that pool so this is the only day we have of free reign over votes i wld really prefer not to be voted so ive been avoiding it but will give them atp probably nomming fame, stp, X, im still trying to think although im tempted to either throw in an afk slot or a tr |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Jun 17, 2024 18:43:53 GMT
unvote
|
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jun 17, 2024 18:45:02 GMT
worth asking atp who you'll be nominating if you're voted out MyanMario reads are cool but ultimately we're forced to vote between 3 candidates and choose from that pool so this is the only day we have of free reign over votes i wld really prefer not to be voted so ive been avoiding it but will give them atp probably nomming fame, stp, X, im still trying to think although im tempted to either throw in an afk slot or a tr is there a reason you're not nominating literally any of the other people you had listed as scumreads like winsy & ne were both listed as scumreads for you as of an hour ago |
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jun 17, 2024 18:46:18 GMT
current reads: town- vade micro realti stp mehh- schia ptsd leaning?- fame NE winsy lockscum- sylvie your nominations are looking like a single person you have as a scumlean, someone you already townread (stp), and another townread? |
|
