|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 11:10:35 GMT
Want more opinions on this slot before I do start going into it. What do you think about the turt slot? no reads on turt ngl, that post could be made by either alignment I feel like turts follow up on my questions about myself and peng feel like very genuine reads that scum likely wouldn’t really put out there, if u have experience with turts forum meta fee free to comment on that but it makes me want to side him as a tl right now
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 11:12:31 GMT
Do you have anything to say in regards to peng or my interactions with them? I feel like that’s a good place to start for you rn honestly that interaction with Peng over prod makes you come across scummier imo bc first of all you've never rly played a game with town prod so you would t know much about his play style on forums so in a way I feel like it's more you just making shit up that you don't know just for towncred kinda but you could've read up on like dnommy but not sure about that This feels like a wholeheartedly townie post and is something that I almost certainly think scum would just glide by without any pressuring. While the post itself isn’t really accurate the motives behind it give me a town feeling I can’t shake rn
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 11:18:33 GMT
Aligning is finally alive, but what I’m seeing he doesn’t really have any content that stands out and makes me want to put him either side so I’m keeping it as null, interested to see what the slot does later on though once they get more content out
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 11:23:02 GMT
Do u have any reads, i would like some reads that u do have I never rly make reads early on unless something is really off because I feel like early game most stuff is NAI and people make reads jut for the sake of making reads early. I think there’s enough content to make reads rn. Like just gloss over the thread and reply to stuff that sticks out and you will form some reads pretty naturally
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 11:28:58 GMT
TOWN: creamy, turt, vade, OM NULL: everyone else SCUM: prodigu, fame, nightemerald ##vote prodigu how did you get to any of this btw fame pretty much said exactly what I’m thinking about this right now
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 15, 2024 12:29:11 GMT
just feels more genuine, kinda goes back into what i was saying where they say 'i dont see scum doing this' for ck, but they do have an explanation for prod, "feels like it wasn't deep enough to warrant this response" gives me actual insight into what they're thinking so you think it's a townie note for fenrir then? i think you're right on that comment being kind of ai or something close to it but not for this reason the interesting part for me is just looking at how well acquainted players interact with one another in thread because it's often very different to how two less acquainted players will interact so on that note, Prodigu, do you think that post is something fen would reasonably suspect you for based on your time playing games w/ him? in the past we've played games and you usually have ideas about his slot based on how he's treating you so just wondering if that applies here at all Hiiiii i just got to work so im playing catch up for a bit If were talking about Fenrir talking about me w/ that comment to CK (which im psure we are) Imo. I think its a weird thing to get hung up about at least when i was posting it, i didnt think much of it tbh Given like the amount of content in thread at the time I could get the angle of “id like to comment on something” Id like to see more of Fenrir (and its not a comment that gives me hard mafia vibes imo) id be more concerned if Fen towned me immediately and moved on
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 12:34:55 GMT
What are your reads as of right now, I'm curious, mainly asking Fame creamykitty, but input from other players would be nice. I'm just tryna see your headspace right now.
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 12:35:25 GMT
so you think it's a townie note for fenrir then? i think you're right on that comment being kind of ai or something close to it but not for this reason the interesting part for me is just looking at how well acquainted players interact with one another in thread because it's often very different to how two less acquainted players will interact so on that note, Prodigu, do you think that post is something fen would reasonably suspect you for based on your time playing games w/ him? in the past we've played games and you usually have ideas about his slot based on how he's treating you so just wondering if that applies here at all Hiiiii i just got to work so im playing catch up for a bit If were talking about Fenrir talking about me w/ that comment to CK (which im psure we are) Imo. I think its a weird thing to get hung up about at least when i was posting it, i didnt think much of it tbh Given like the amount of content in thread at the time I could get the angle of “id like to comment on something” Id like to see more of Fenrir (and its not a comment that gives me hard mafia vibes imo) id be more concerned if Fen towned me immediately and moved on Yeah, I don’t think fen really cared about the comment as much as people make it seem though, like he mentioned it and really kinda moved on with it, every townie has weird looking posts on occasion it’s natural
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 15, 2024 12:35:57 GMT
TOWN: creamy, turt, vade, OM NULL: everyone else SCUM: prodigu, fame, nightemerald ##vote prodigu how did you get to any of this btw @ck ik you also commented later abt this but i wanna make sure Fame sees this 1) Myanmario explain. 2) Fame what do you think of this readlist? When i read it it felt rly weird / something didnt seem right with it like….. part of me wants to think some degree of disingenuous (maybe im jumping to conclusions w/ this) but the Srs feel weird (I have to look at the rest of Myans posts) but it felt like —> jumped into thread —> dropped a readlist w/ not many other thoughts —> left thread w/o explaining readlist
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 12:38:45 GMT
What are your reads as of right now, I'm curious, mainly asking Fame creamykitty, but input from other players would be nice. I'm just tryna see your headspace right now. Honestly I feel kinda stuck in terms of srs right now because a lot of this pl hasn’t really made themselves present and peng is sitting back now that I’ve eased the pressure which isn’t something I like but I’m not hellbent on it being scummy. I’ve put turt in my tls and while I haven’t really read too much on PCB he’s giving starting to give off better vibes imo. Me and fame have somewhat mindmelded in this thread which I like, and I still wanna stick with my gut and keep prod towned for now. Honestly I just want myan/aligning to make some content lol.
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 15, 2024 12:41:14 GMT
Btw i wanna put Fame to TL / Town
Putting this disclaimer here: i wanna take some time to look over Fame iso when i have the opportunity to do so (i definitely havent read over every single Fame post yet so i am just kinda of talking about what i have skimmed)
At least on skim / the posts i have seen from Fame they feel relatively like —> trying to inquire / prompt explanations / dig a bit deeper / be intuitive which is usually what i put to T!Fame
I also like wanna put here *i do not think either Fame or Fenrir should be the vote at the end of the day unless theres some form of glaring issue with either of them*
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 12:41:31 GMT
how did you get to any of this btw @ck ik you also commented later abt this but i wanna make sure Fame sees this 1) Myanmario explain. 2) Fame what do you think of this readlist? When i read it it felt rly weird / something didnt seem right with it like….. part of me wants to think some degree of disingenuous (maybe im jumping to conclusions w/ this) but the Srs feel weird (I have to look at the rest of Myans posts) but it felt like —> jumped into thread —> dropped a readlist w/ not many other thoughts —> left thread w/o explaining readlist Agreed in terms of the readslist being offputting here, I think t!myan would make more of an effort to at least elaborate on them a little bit
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 12:47:27 GMT
Here’s pretty much every read I have rn, quote me for any questions about it but I think I’ve given my thought process well enough through my live post interactions
Town: Prod, Fame, Turt TL: PCB, Fen, NE Null: Vade and all of the inactives SL: Myan, Peng Hard scum: None
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 12:51:10 GMT
vote @turtwigswiththrohs
Just gonna plop down a vote on this
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 12:52:54 GMT
My SL on myan/peng is quite light because they came into the thread so late and might have activity issues, but I can’t really overlook them unless they do something townie, which I think isn’t asking too much for either of them.
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 12:55:25 GMT
vote @turtwigswiththrohs Just gonna plop down a vote on this I know my hard towning of turt feels rushed, but Turts play after I prodded them just screams town imho but I would love to hear why you are thinking the exact opposite of me rn
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 12:57:15 GMT
I assume you know turt way better than I do so enlighten me on his meta
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 15, 2024 13:08:56 GMT
Actually
vote@myanmario
I feel like this is more productive than keeping my rvs vote on lechen
While i do agree @ck that both myan and pd have some weirdness to them atm (imo) im not sure if both would be mafia like fwiw its more likely imo only 1 of them is mafia here than both of them tbh if there is a mafia in the 2 of them
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 15, 2024 13:09:40 GMT
Actually vote@myanmario I feel like this is more productive than keeping my rvs vote on lechen While i do agree @ck that both myan and pd have some weirdness to them atm (imo) im not sure if both would be mafia like fwiw its more likely imo only 1 of them is mafia here than both of them tbh if there is a mafia in the 2 of them vote @myanmario Vote didnt go through so im correcting it here
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 15, 2024 13:18:37 GMT
ok have wokey up now sorry about anything I've left I see I have a vote on me now so sorry for any confusion while i sleepy :/
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 15, 2024 13:22:00 GMT
I'm on mobile so no quoting multiple posts really but vade earlier townread me and now I'm like a big scumread and am voted so a little bit confused and ftr the only real reasons I see for vade voting me that she said is because I wasn't responding to questions dw I will. All the other reasons I saw from vade were kinda bs ngl most of them make me seem townier imo idk I can never tell with vade lol
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 15, 2024 13:23:37 GMT
I do agree with fame here that turt's entrance is pretty townie and they're poking/prodding where they need to be. I'm not too sure about pmeta personally, but with turt, they are usually more reserved in posting, and the past games they've been town, but its not really something I'm willing to use against them atp because they do seem genuine and townie. like what happened to this it was kinda very sudden
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 13:27:10 GMT
I'm on mobile so no quoting multiple posts really but vade earlier townread me and now I'm like a big scumread and am voted so a little bit confused and ftr the only real reasons I see for vade voting me that she said is because I wasn't responding to questions dw I will. All the other reasons I saw from vade were kinda bs ngl most of them make me seem townier imo idk I can never tell with vade lol let me ask you this, which part do you think is bs and why do you think so? I never townread you at all ftr, and now spinning it this way is just :/ I have a feeling you didn't even read my post so go back and read it please <3
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 15, 2024 13:30:16 GMT
ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132259/threadIn my opinion, this post was what made turt somewhat tl'd by a huge majority of players and while its not AI, I would argue that this seems like turt reading just for the sake of reading, and even though their assessment of me was fair, as I was inactive, but it feels a bit of trying to poke a slot to do somethin for towncred rather than genuinely interesting in my playing of the game. Especially after they have not looked into my interactions or other posts that would normally come out of poking someone. Their unpartnering comment was also weird, and out of scope imo ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132279/threadps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132247/threadThen there's these posts which strike out to me as odd and out of place, as they have been prodded and poked about these statements multiple times and it just feels like turt is ignoring them atp. They also seem to be relying on a lot of pmeta, which is fine, but would love to see this slot start reading with the info we have at hand. This slot is a very slight sl for me right now, but then again, could be easily NAI. Might also be interesting to mention turt's pmeta usually of not being confident in putting reads out as confortably as town, as I have seen from turt as my hydra partner. and then she made this post like an hour later with nothing in between kinda suddenly scumreading me and in some ways it feels like she has only really read like two posts of mine like I would like a little more from this slot before they go out and vote me typically I think they would know better than this not sure tho lol. Also with the point of my activity being higher, some games like hydra as well I had a higher activity and the reads I gave weren't exactly "reads" they were more of just small analysises from skimming through the beginning of the thread. As well with the pmeta point that is completely untrue imo my posts have not been relying on pmeta at all (depends what you count as pmeta) and not all of them were thought out completely but tbh I feel like yours have been kinda the same way os at least think about how you are playing as well because I could scumread you for the same reasons (and probably more) whatever tho I guess it's only 1 vote
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 13:30:49 GMT
Actually vote@myanmario I feel like this is more productive than keeping my rvs vote on lechen While i do agree @ck that both myan and pd have some weirdness to them atm (imo) im not sure if both would be mafia like fwiw its more likely imo only 1 of them is mafia here than both of them tbh if there is a mafia in the 2 of them ehhh idk, there is literally nothing from them that could help me either partner or unpartner them so I don’t wanna delve into that territory, I think they are just both weird slots individually
|
|