|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 5:19:02 GMT
mb, been quite busy for the past few days, but I'm here now
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 5:28:04 GMT
shoot me any questions atp I'm reading back will get back to you guys
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 15, 2024 5:38:23 GMT
turt entrance is pretty townie i like those posts
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 15, 2024 5:42:25 GMT
why do you think the comment on prod is AI over everything else? just feels more genuine, kinda goes back into what i was saying where they say 'i dont see scum doing this' for ck, but they do have an explanation for prod, "feels like it wasn't deep enough to warrant this response" gives me actual insight into what they're thinking so you think it's a townie note for fenrir then? i think you're right on that comment being kind of ai or something close to it but not for this reason the interesting part for me is just looking at how well acquainted players interact with one another in thread because it's often very different to how two less acquainted players will interact so on that note, Prodigu, do you think that post is something fen would reasonably suspect you for based on your time playing games w/ him? in the past we've played games and you usually have ideas about his slot based on how he's treating you so just wondering if that applies here at all
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 15, 2024 5:48:18 GMT
gm all, sorry wasn't free yesterday, will catch up on thread now where'd you get up to?
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 5:49:16 GMT
I do agree with fame here that turt's entrance is pretty townie and they're poking/prodding where they need to be. I'm not too sure about pmeta personally, but with turt, they are usually more reserved in posting, and the past games they've been town, but its not really something I'm willing to use against them atp because they do seem genuine and townie.
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 15, 2024 5:51:18 GMT
its moreso they arent playing outside of what they could be playing as if they were scum atm That’s true but you can’t necessarily say they are playing within their scum meta as well with this logic Your sl feels like “Well yeah they aren’t scummy, but what if they are scum I’m kinda scared” yeah this is basically exactly what i thought too seems like a longwinded explanation for it essentially being a vote made for pressure purposes
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 15, 2024 5:53:15 GMT
I do agree with fame here that turt's entrance is pretty townie and they're poking/prodding where they need to be. I'm not too sure about pmeta personally, but with turt, they are usually more reserved in posting, and the past games they've been town, but its not really something I'm willing to use against them atp because they do seem genuine and townie. do you think their posting here is less reserved here than in their usual town games? the meta is probably worth noting at least to some extent
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 15, 2024 5:57:56 GMT
i skimmed their iso on forums and it's kinda hard to tell, don't think there's anything standing out here compared to other games other than maybe the fact they don't wall post very often in other games like they did here
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 6:07:43 GMT
Im back
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 6:08:02 GMT
Alright ill read through see what and gives some thoughts
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 6:25:42 GMT
Okay first off, ill just state the slot I think just stands out to me and gives me big townie vibes is ck here. They have been active pretty much all the time and I think has great lines such as, ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132260/thread <- Although nothing much to see in this line they do seem like their legitimentally trying to solve the game all the way through and just give thoughts and opinion on other slots and has been great so far in doing it. ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132249/thread <- This line here is addressing what NE and I think had a fair response. They did have a thought process seeing it from a SC townie perspective dropped the read which they made to engage in converssation and gives off townie vibes. As well they have been constantly making more and more interactions and going through asking questions like why a vote was placed or why people aren't addressing other people (https://ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132211/thread) which I do really like.
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 6:28:07 GMT
hmm what is it to you that sticks out as particularly townie? what’s good about it to you? Quoting both of you, think like part of it is gut feeling to put some more words to it than that though, feel like most of the other entrances felt lack luster / unimpressive and this one kinda grabbed my attention more (emphasis on this grabbed my attention more), where i kind of walked away with a decent feeling about it. I like how it kinda feels like Pcb just jumps into thread, and it kinda feels ~more genuine than fake early posting imo Also I know this is quite early on but I feel like this has been PCB's usual entrance. Nothing too special and something that I feel PCB would do on either faction tbh.
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 6:33:26 GMT
if day were to end now and you were forced to place a vote who would you guys place a vote on mmm half tempted aligning tbh.
its moreso hes usually more present and he hasnt been idk if hes just busy outside of the game or what but id like to see him show up this is also coming from me b/c i havent put major work into sorting just yet, and ill prob do some analysis before i go to bed, and look at some isos too, and then put thoughts in thread in the morning (i wanna go play town of salem / watch youtube for a bit kek) feel like theres ~decent amt of content in thread now to be able to do some decent sorting if we can here tbh forgot this game existed mb guys
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 6:49:35 GMT
PCB comes to me a slight tl here. Giving thoughts on what they think about posts and giving pretty base level reads but have been putting pressure on vade slots which I do like. His vade read comes from vade pretty much fillering and not interacting much and I do think vade slot needs more pressure as nothing but their last line has been too meaningful here. Vade just comes to me as null slot.
|
|
Lechen
Villager
boar king
Posts: 56
|
Post by Lechen on Jul 15, 2024 6:57:17 GMT
gm all, sorry wasn't free yesterday, will catch up on thread now where'd you get up to? I lied, forgot I was playing this game after I had breakfast after saying that ill catch up to the thread lol. Will read up now, like right now.
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 7:01:42 GMT
Fame here is also shouting town to me. Great gameplay and pretty much has townie solving processes. Their lines like this ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132312/thread have pretty much stood up to me. They are pretty much trying to question a players motive and breaking it down. (Could someone also tell me what AI means, i thought u guys were talking about chat gpt this whole time). ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132240/thread <- Also a good address to their read on CK and has a townie solving process and makes sense as well. I follow through with their read here on Ck as well.
|
|
Lechen
Villager
boar king
Posts: 56
|
Post by Lechen on Jul 15, 2024 7:01:44 GMT
would like aligning/myan/ne to insert themselves into the thread so they can either obvtown or obvscum i honestly thought aligning would be here more tbh kinda surprised he hasnt been in thread all that much kinda disappointed i havent seen ne / aligning / lechen more this game so far, ik its a slow start and all but id like to have seen more think the only ppl that havent said anything are wut myan/ne/lechen/turt? maybe +1/2 more this was 6 am mine bro, was busy yesterday afternoon as well
|
|
Lechen
Villager
boar king
Posts: 56
|
Post by Lechen on Jul 15, 2024 7:03:56 GMT
gm all, sorry wasn't free yesterday, will catch up on thread now holy shit dimitri fire emblem I love fire emblem :heart:
|
|
Lechen
Villager
boar king
Posts: 56
|
Post by Lechen on Jul 15, 2024 7:07:04 GMT
Anyways, don't have any solid reads after catching up to thread, but I have played with dbd in smogon mafia before and he feels like he is in his scum meta? idk in the last smogon mafia game his activity was a bit shaky at the start and he flipped scum, and when he was town in the game before that one he was more active. It could also be because he looks at smogon more though cuz he does other stuff not just mafia there as well (same as me).
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 7:10:37 GMT
As for my started reads; I agree with most people on towning ck as for now they have been super active all of their posts great quality, probably won't be reconsidering this for a while On vade I feel like they haven't rly been quite as active or present with their thoughts as typical which might be a start of game type shit but as for reading back on their dnommy presence they were extremely active am hoping to see a little more from that slot as per usual (I know I just got here lol) Fen happy to see ya in here idt I've ever rly talked to you but have heard great things and am very excited to play with u, as for your posts they have been great and I feel like a lot of moments I have thought something while I was skimming and later on you would mention the same type of thing I'll try to find an example later if I remember mobile makes this hard kinda Prod is typical prod I'm getting t!prod vibes as for now, but I suck at being able to scumread prod I typically town players who have more presence and higher post quality so watch out for that later on Pcb is kinda null I should really go back and read everything more thoroughly so will go back and read up on you and hopefully look into it later on if I remember. I think those are all the most present slots for now ask me any questions if you need I'm open (please tag me in posts tho tyvm) Tvh i feel like these are pretty base level reads from turt here. Nothing too special here and not much elaboration and just left pcb at null while not really talking about any of their lines. They did elaborate on their read on prod but it just didnt make sense here. they liked the interactions they had with vade when it was literally clarifying on how the theme works? not really like turt here too much.
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 7:11:20 GMT
Anyways, don't have any solid reads after catching up to thread, but I have played with dbd in smogon mafia before and he feels like he is in his scum meta? idk in the last smogon mafia game his activity was a bit shaky at the start and he flipped scum, and when he was town in the game before that one he was more active. It could also be because he looks at smogon more though cuz he does other stuff not just mafia there as well (same as me). Want more opinions on this slot before I do start going into it. What do you think about the turt slot?
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 7:21:56 GMT
ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132259/threadIn my opinion, this post was what made turt somewhat tl'd by a huge majority of players and while its not AI, I would argue that this seems like turt reading just for the sake of reading, and even though their assessment of me was fair, as I was inactive, but it feels a bit of trying to poke a slot to do somethin for towncred rather than genuinely interesting in my playing of the game. Especially after they have not looked into my interactions or other posts that would normally come out of poking someone. Their unpartnering comment was also weird, and out of scope imo ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132279/threadps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132247/threadThen there's these posts which strike out to me as odd and out of place, as they have been prodded and poked about these statements multiple times and it just feels like turt is ignoring them atp. They also seem to be relying on a lot of pmeta, which is fine, but would love to see this slot start reading with the info we have at hand. This slot is a very slight sl for me right now, but then again, could be easily NAI. Might also be interesting to mention turt's pmeta usually of not being confident in putting reads out as confortably as town, as I have seen from turt as my hydra partner.
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 7:26:29 GMT
I'll look into other slots now, but I still don't understand why CK is widely tr'd here, imo there's nothing noteworthy and I would like yo know your guy's thoughts on the slot
|
|
Lechen
Villager
boar king
Posts: 56
|
Post by Lechen on Jul 15, 2024 7:29:10 GMT
Anyways, don't have any solid reads after catching up to thread, but I have played with dbd in smogon mafia before and he feels like he is in his scum meta? idk in the last smogon mafia game his activity was a bit shaky at the start and he flipped scum, and when he was town in the game before that one he was more active. It could also be because he looks at smogon more though cuz he does other stuff not just mafia there as well (same as me). Want more opinions on this slot before I do start going into it. What do you think about the turt slot? no reads on turt ngl, that post could be made by either alignment
|
|