|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 21:27:59 GMT
who? If your asking me, i can see a prod and pcb partnering. They did have a tl from pcb quite early that I didnt really follow and i felt was poor reasoned. From what I’ve seen of PCB recently they are actually kinda shaky on prods slot, so what gives this impression? Wheres the shaky read coming from, also gave that impression from the last bit of the sentence. i did quote that line from prod it one of my older posts which is prod reading pcb as town quite early on the game. |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 15, 2024 21:28:06 GMT
Ok were on the PC now first things first i wanna put together this list For what its worth this collection are not worthwhile D1 chops unless someone can find seriously compelling reasoning currently to chop them (imo) [Me, Fame, Fenrir] Were not chopping this D1
Me Slots that I TR / Feel very strongly about not being chopped currentlyFame The way Fame is currently playing is in a way that I think currently trends more towards T Fame rather than S Fame Im being actively lazy and not grabbing a bunch of his posts b/c I just got home and i wanna lay down for a few but if someone wants me to grab posts that point me towards T Fame lmk and I can prob grab a few out of his iso Creamy Feel like Creamy started off relatively meh and blah at SOD, but as the games progressed I feel like theyve gotten a lot better since then Turt ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132443/threadI talked about this slot earlier and the above post --> heres where i talk about it ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132460/threadNightEmerald His earlier posting felt decent to me, and I feel like it tracks form other instances ive seen of NE, so its left a decent impression thus far on me Slots that I dont want chopped but I feel less strongly about from those aboveFenrir Id like to see more of Fenrir but his earlier posting felt ~decent~ Lechen Im partly defaulting to what Fames said about this game and Black dnommy feeling ~relatively similar, I dont have a full read on the slot yet but currently dont think its a worthwhile chop atm I dont particularly care to keep the slots, but i think they lack content to be justifiable chops at the time of making thisdbd Saltycactus Crespo/Toni I havent read them enough, want to reread them, or would like pressure placed onto them or wouldnt mind seeing them chopped currently or some mixAligningstars PenguinD PCB Vade  Slots
Myanmario Realistically this is b/c I want Myan to come into thread and explain those reads b/c those scumreads feel whack I think the other things Id currently like to touch on is 2 reads that I think make sense atm 1) PenguinD and Myan are likely not partnered. This mainly comes off of the both of them voting me earlier, and (yes its a weird reasoning to unpartner them) but idt both mafia partners would both place votes on me together 2) Lechen and dbd are probably not partnered. Fame elaborated on this earlier, and I think the reasoning he had made sense / held water Im gonna come back but i feel kinda tired rn, and just got home so i wanna relax for a few if thats alright Some things we should do before DL: I dont want the vote to stagnate on Myan, i think we should look at / explore other slots (looking at you people that are on Myan as well rn) We should probably It doesnt have to be today, but its something for each of you to think about. Depending on which abilities are given tomorrow: Who should they be used on / given to and why? |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jul 15, 2024 21:33:56 GMT
anyone here
today is feeling like an off day where i dont thinbk im as focused on really reading the catchup as I should be, can yall give me a couple questions so I can try to focus on answering those?
|
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:34:35 GMT
ne/twt both leantown based off entrances pd slightly townier off prod conjecture, still not confident in reading prod either way rn tbh still waiting on myan/aligning to obvtown for me - do not vote d1 - pokecartbeast creamykitty nightemerald fame fenrir - would rather not be voted d1 - turtwigswiththrohs aligningstars vaderaven prodigu crespo penguind - fine to axe - saltiestcactus23 lechen myanmario tiers are ordered, i refuse to elaborate anything here kinda feels like your axe list is like scraping the barrel a bit saltiestcactus has 1 post, lechen has like less than 5 probably & myan has less than 5 too probably i mean i could move the "fine to axe" pool to include vade through pd but i feel like those slots have all done enough to not warrant being axed d1 prod had some ~sheepable comments on pd meta and i honestly found pd's reasoning to vote prod fine, toni has terrible activity but i found myself agreeing with earlier points + toni had similarly shaky activity in white dn so i don't get the pmeta read on them, prod i'm still not super confident on reading town but they're contributing enough readswise to warrant having a pass for d1, vade also has trended upwards in general as the slot has developed reads isn’t really defending prod when I think a scumpartner would put up some fight here, and points out “sheepable comments” on prods part Has prod in the middle of his axepool rather than at the top with me etc And says that he feels he could read prod either way but doesn’t really elaborate on that point AligningStars |
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 21:34:39 GMT
Ok were on the PC now first things first i wanna put together this list For what its worth this collection are not worthwhile D1 chops unless someone can find seriously compelling reasoning currently to chop them (imo) [Me, Fame, Fenrir] Were not chopping this D1
Me Slots that I TR / Feel very strongly about not being chopped currentlyFame The way Fame is currently playing is in a way that I think currently trends more towards T Fame rather than S Fame Im being actively lazy and not grabbing a bunch of his posts b/c I just got home and i wanna lay down for a few but if someone wants me to grab posts that point me towards T Fame lmk and I can prob grab a few out of his iso Creamy Feel like Creamy started off relatively meh and blah at SOD, but as the games progressed I feel like theyve gotten a lot better since then Turt ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132443/threadI talked about this slot earlier and the above post --> heres where i talk about it ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132460/threadNightEmerald His earlier posting felt decent to me, and I feel like it tracks form other instances ive seen of NE, so its left a decent impression thus far on me Slots that I dont want chopped but I feel less strongly about from those aboveFenrir Id like to see more of Fenrir but his earlier posting felt ~decent~ Lechen Im partly defaulting to what Fames said about this game and Black dnommy feeling ~relatively similar, I dont have a full read on the slot yet but currently dont think its a worthwhile chop atm I dont particularly care to keep the slots, but i think they lack content to be justifiable chops at the time of making thisdbd Saltycactus Crespo/Toni I havent read them enough, want to reread them, or would like pressure placed onto them or wouldnt mind seeing them chopped currently or some mixAligningstars PenguinD PCB Vade Slots
Myanmario Realistically this is b/c I want Myan to come into thread and explain those reads b/c those scumreads feel whack I think the other things Id currently like to touch on is 2 reads that I think make sense atm 1) PenguinD and Myan are likely not partnered. This mainly comes off of the both of them voting me earlier, and (yes its a weird reasoning to unpartner them) but idt both mafia partners would both place votes on me together 2) Lechen and dbd are probably not partnered. Fame elaborated on this earlier, and I think the reasoning he had made sense / held water Im gonna come back but i feel kinda tired rn, and just got home so i wanna relax for a few if thats alright Some things we should do before DL: I dont want the vote to stagnate on Myan, i think we should look at / explore other slots (looking at you people that are on Myan as well rn) We should probably It doesnt have to be today, but its something for each of you to think about. Depending on which abilities are given tomorrow: Who should they be used on / given to and why? Tbh here I honestly dont see where turt reads are coming from. All his reads seem so shaky and so un natural and he says i will explain in further depth and just never does it. your response to it was it doesnt force to make a partnership but none of turts reads have been straight or even direct. Thinking about it from a T perspective I would say turt is really not giving natural reads. I have made a wallpost about turt before and addressing about his readlist which doesnt make sense to me here and they never responded to it and just responded to vade instead because he could argue about his pmeta rather than his reads. |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:36:46 GMT
anyone here today is feeling like an off day where i dont thinbk im as focused on really reading the catchup as I should be, can yall give me a couple questions so I can try to focus on answering those? answering the questions prod gave out would be a good start, and I think it would be good for you to try and ask around about slots you haven’t really read into or are unsure about |
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 21:36:57 GMT
ne/twt both leantown based off entrances pd slightly townier off prod conjecture, still not confident in reading prod either way rn tbh still waiting on myan/aligning to obvtown for me - do not vote d1 - pokecartbeast creamykitty nightemerald fame fenrir - would rather not be voted d1 - turtwigswiththrohs aligningstars vaderaven prodigu crespo penguind - fine to axe - saltiestcactus23 lechen myanmario tiers are ordered, i refuse to elaborate anything here i mean i could move the "fine to axe" pool to include vade through pd but i feel like those slots have all done enough to not warrant being axed d1 prod had some ~sheepable comments on pd meta and i honestly found pd's reasoning to vote prod fine, toni has terrible activity but i found myself agreeing with earlier points + toni had similarly shaky activity in white dn so i don't get the pmeta read on them, prod i'm still not super confident on reading town but they're contributing enough readswise to warrant having a pass for d1, vade also has trended upwards in general as the slot has developed reads isn’t really defending prod when I think a scumpartner would put up some fight here, and points out “sheepable comments” on prods part Has prod in the middle of his axepool rather than at the top with me etc And says that he feels he could read prod either way but doesn’t really elaborate on that point AligningStars Yeah okay i see this coming from pcb btu no scum would be obviously defending a partner. But the sheepable comment is a good point but they didnt really evaluate it too much but they havent made a full read on them yet and honestly I could see this coming from both scum and town. No scum would actually hard defend their partner d1. |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:39:24 GMT
Ok were on the PC now first things first i wanna put together this list For what its worth this collection are not worthwhile D1 chops unless someone can find seriously compelling reasoning currently to chop them (imo) [Me, Fame, Fenrir] Were not chopping this D1
Me Slots that I TR / Feel very strongly about not being chopped currentlyFame The way Fame is currently playing is in a way that I think currently trends more towards T Fame rather than S Fame Im being actively lazy and not grabbing a bunch of his posts b/c I just got home and i wanna lay down for a few but if someone wants me to grab posts that point me towards T Fame lmk and I can prob grab a few out of his iso Creamy Feel like Creamy started off relatively meh and blah at SOD, but as the games progressed I feel like theyve gotten a lot better since then Turt ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132443/threadI talked about this slot earlier and the above post --> heres where i talk about it ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132460/threadNightEmerald His earlier posting felt decent to me, and I feel like it tracks form other instances ive seen of NE, so its left a decent impression thus far on me Slots that I dont want chopped but I feel less strongly about from those aboveFenrir Id like to see more of Fenrir but his earlier posting felt ~decent~ Lechen Im partly defaulting to what Fames said about this game and Black dnommy feeling ~relatively similar, I dont have a full read on the slot yet but currently dont think its a worthwhile chop atm I dont particularly care to keep the slots, but i think they lack content to be justifiable chops at the time of making thisdbd Saltycactus Crespo/Toni I havent read them enough, want to reread them, or would like pressure placed onto them or wouldnt mind seeing them chopped currently or some mixAligningstars PenguinD PCB Vade Slots
Myanmario Realistically this is b/c I want Myan to come into thread and explain those reads b/c those scumreads feel whack I think the other things Id currently like to touch on is 2 reads that I think make sense atm 1) PenguinD and Myan are likely not partnered. This mainly comes off of the both of them voting me earlier, and (yes its a weird reasoning to unpartner them) but idt both mafia partners would both place votes on me together 2) Lechen and dbd are probably not partnered. Fame elaborated on this earlier, and I think the reasoning he had made sense / held water Im gonna come back but i feel kinda tired rn, and just got home so i wanna relax for a few if thats alright Some things we should do before DL: I dont want the vote to stagnate on Myan, i think we should look at / explore other slots (looking at you people that are on Myan as well rn) We should probably It doesnt have to be today, but its something for each of you to think about. Depending on which abilities are given tomorrow: Who should they be used on / given to and why? With abilities, it largely depends on what ability scum gives us but if we get vig gift it might actually be good to idle it unless we gather up some strong srs by deadline or tomorrow, and if we get inspect I think it would best be used on some slots that we just want cleared up to smoothen progression, which is very up to your guys’s personal opinions |
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 15, 2024 21:40:15 GMT
im gonna go ahead and throw a townread on myan idc if they get voted or not thoguh
|
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:40:57 GMT
isn’t really defending prod when I think a scumpartner would put up some fight here, and points out “sheepable comments” on prods part Has prod in the middle of his axepool rather than at the top with me etc And says that he feels he could read prod either way but doesn’t really elaborate on that point AligningStars Yeah okay i see this coming from pcb btu no scum would be obviously defending a partner. But the sheepable comment is a good point but they didnt really evaluate it too much but they havent made a full read on them yet and honestly I could see this coming from both scum and town. No scum would actually hard defend their partner d1. Yeah agreed this is basically the point that I’m trying to tell you, I think you misinterpreted though, to me distancing is more of a subtle defense which is what you’re saying is happening, buddying is hard defending or tring your partner |
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 15, 2024 21:41:25 GMT
im gonna go ahead and throw a townread on myan idc if they get voted or not thoguh (based off of pmeta) |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:41:35 GMT
im gonna go ahead and throw a townread on myan idc if they get voted or not thoguh I what huh could you explain this?? |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jul 15, 2024 21:41:36 GMT
anyone here today is feeling like an off day where i dont thinbk im as focused on really reading the catchup as I should be, can yall give me a couple questions so I can try to focus on answering those? answering the questions prod gave out would be a good start, and I think it would be good for you to try and ask around about slots you haven’t really read into or are unsure about could you link them? as for rn i still don't feel strongly over anything fenrir's posted, (page 4 stuff unless theres been anything else) so I would like other people's perspectives on that at least. |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:42:01 GMT
im gonna go ahead and throw a townread on myan idc if they get voted or not thoguh (based off of pmeta) fine I’ll give you benefit of the doubt here but I am still on myan lmao |
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 21:43:43 GMT
Ok were on the PC now first things first i wanna put together this list For what its worth this collection are not worthwhile D1 chops unless someone can find seriously compelling reasoning currently to chop them (imo) [Me, Fame, Fenrir] Were not chopping this D1
Me Slots that I TR / Feel very strongly about not being chopped currentlyFame The way Fame is currently playing is in a way that I think currently trends more towards T Fame rather than S Fame Im being actively lazy and not grabbing a bunch of his posts b/c I just got home and i wanna lay down for a few but if someone wants me to grab posts that point me towards T Fame lmk and I can prob grab a few out of his iso Creamy Feel like Creamy started off relatively meh and blah at SOD, but as the games progressed I feel like theyve gotten a lot better since then Turt ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132443/threadI talked about this slot earlier and the above post --> heres where i talk about it ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132460/threadNightEmerald His earlier posting felt decent to me, and I feel like it tracks form other instances ive seen of NE, so its left a decent impression thus far on me Slots that I dont want chopped but I feel less strongly about from those aboveFenrir Id like to see more of Fenrir but his earlier posting felt ~decent~ Lechen Im partly defaulting to what Fames said about this game and Black dnommy feeling ~relatively similar, I dont have a full read on the slot yet but currently dont think its a worthwhile chop atm I dont particularly care to keep the slots, but i think they lack content to be justifiable chops at the time of making thisdbd Saltycactus Crespo/Toni I havent read them enough, want to reread them, or would like pressure placed onto them or wouldnt mind seeing them chopped currently or some mixAligningstars PenguinD PCB Vade Slots
Myanmario Realistically this is b/c I want Myan to come into thread and explain those reads b/c those scumreads feel whack I think the other things Id currently like to touch on is 2 reads that I think make sense atm 1) PenguinD and Myan are likely not partnered. This mainly comes off of the both of them voting me earlier, and (yes its a weird reasoning to unpartner them) but idt both mafia partners would both place votes on me together 2) Lechen and dbd are probably not partnered. Fame elaborated on this earlier, and I think the reasoning he had made sense / held water Im gonna come back but i feel kinda tired rn, and just got home so i wanna relax for a few if thats alright Some things we should do before DL: I dont want the vote to stagnate on Myan, i think we should look at / explore other slots (looking at you people that are on Myan as well rn) We should probably It doesnt have to be today, but its something for each of you to think about. Depending on which abilities are given tomorrow: Who should they be used on / given to and why? Track: if the town selects the player that is performing the nightkill, they are revealed as the killer that night phase. Watch: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, the player performing the kill is revealed as mafia. Imprison: if the town selects the kill target OR the player performing the kill, there is no kill that night phase. Kill: the town gets an extra elimination that day phase. This elimination is optional. Vigilante Gift: the selected player will receive an optional vigilante shot, to be used that night. If this player is being nightkilled, they will die without using their shot. Oracle: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, they may reveal another player's alignment upon their death. This reveal will occur at daystart. Doctor: if the selected player was chosen for the nightkill, they will survive. The mafia may elect to self target their nightkill on the night they choose this ability. Right now I think scum wouldnt pick either the doctor/imprison or the track/watch or oracle. Those can show who scum could/couldnt be and I dont feel like that would do that. I feel like they either choose Kill Or Vigilante as it has the highest chance of not finding scum and revealing how scum could be. If that was the case I would give the vig gift to ck and kill would be depending on how the game progresses. |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:44:57 GMT
answering the questions prod gave out would be a good start, and I think it would be good for you to try and ask around about slots you haven’t really read into or are unsure about could you link them? as for rn i still don't feel strongly over anything fenrir's posted, (page 4 stuff unless theres been anything else) so I would like other people's perspectives on that at least. oh wait it’s just one question mb but yeah I think it’s good to answer it, it’s in the prod wallpost u just replied to at the very bottom I cant link because I am on phone. I basically just said I tl Fenrir for the tow reads and dive into that prod comment that was made on my early line about rvsing slots you have experience with, but also that I get a bad feeing about how he votes Toni and says “I have thoughts on this but you can wait to hear them just sheep me lol” like it could be a real push but it feels so forced when you put it like this |
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 21:46:19 GMT
Also did prod fully ignore me
|
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:46:41 GMT
Ok were on the PC now first things first i wanna put together this list For what its worth this collection are not worthwhile D1 chops unless someone can find seriously compelling reasoning currently to chop them (imo) [Me, Fame, Fenrir] Were not chopping this D1
Me Slots that I TR / Feel very strongly about not being chopped currentlyFame The way Fame is currently playing is in a way that I think currently trends more towards T Fame rather than S Fame Im being actively lazy and not grabbing a bunch of his posts b/c I just got home and i wanna lay down for a few but if someone wants me to grab posts that point me towards T Fame lmk and I can prob grab a few out of his iso Creamy Feel like Creamy started off relatively meh and blah at SOD, but as the games progressed I feel like theyve gotten a lot better since then Turt ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132443/threadI talked about this slot earlier and the above post --> heres where i talk about it ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132460/threadNightEmerald His earlier posting felt decent to me, and I feel like it tracks form other instances ive seen of NE, so its left a decent impression thus far on me Slots that I dont want chopped but I feel less strongly about from those aboveFenrir Id like to see more of Fenrir but his earlier posting felt ~decent~ Lechen Im partly defaulting to what Fames said about this game and Black dnommy feeling ~relatively similar, I dont have a full read on the slot yet but currently dont think its a worthwhile chop atm I dont particularly care to keep the slots, but i think they lack content to be justifiable chops at the time of making thisdbd Saltycactus Crespo/Toni I havent read them enough, want to reread them, or would like pressure placed onto them or wouldnt mind seeing them chopped currently or some mixAligningstars PenguinD PCB Vade Slots
Myanmario Realistically this is b/c I want Myan to come into thread and explain those reads b/c those scumreads feel whack I think the other things Id currently like to touch on is 2 reads that I think make sense atm 1) PenguinD and Myan are likely not partnered. This mainly comes off of the both of them voting me earlier, and (yes its a weird reasoning to unpartner them) but idt both mafia partners would both place votes on me together 2) Lechen and dbd are probably not partnered. Fame elaborated on this earlier, and I think the reasoning he had made sense / held water Im gonna come back but i feel kinda tired rn, and just got home so i wanna relax for a few if thats alright Some things we should do before DL: I dont want the vote to stagnate on Myan, i think we should look at / explore other slots (looking at you people that are on Myan as well rn) We should probably It doesnt have to be today, but its something for each of you to think about. Depending on which abilities are given tomorrow: Who should they be used on / given to and why? Track: if the town selects the player that is performing the nightkill, they are revealed as the killer that night phase. Watch: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, the player performing the kill is revealed as mafia. Imprison: if the town selects the kill target OR the player performing the kill, there is no kill that night phase. Kill: the town gets an extra elimination that day phase. This elimination is optional. Vigilante Gift: the selected player will receive an optional vigilante shot, to be used that night. If this player is being nightkilled, they will die without using their shot. Oracle: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, they may reveal another player's alignment upon their death. This reveal will occur at daystart. Doctor: if the selected player was chosen for the nightkill, they will survive. The mafia may elect to self target their nightkill on the night they choose this ability. Right now I think scum wouldnt pick either the doctor/imprison or the track/watch or oracle. Those can show who scum could/couldnt be and I dont feel like that would do that. I feel like they either choose Kill Or Vigilante as it has the highest chance of not finding scum and revealing how scum could be. If that was the case I would give the vig gift to ck and kill would be depending on how the game progresses. Honestly if you give vig gift to me I will idle it unless someone jumps out as scummy to me but if you don’t like that and want me to shoot please give input on who you want dead |
|
|
|
Post by vaderaven on Jul 15, 2024 21:47:59 GMT
m3 w5ill eon'5c know why c3reakmy kittya is toni1 i t
|
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:48:27 GMT
Can someone translate this? |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jul 15, 2024 21:48:30 GMT
could you link them? as for rn i still don't feel strongly over anything fenrir's posted, (page 4 stuff unless theres been anything else) so I would like other people's perspectives on that at least. oh wait it’s just one question mb but yeah I think it’s good to answer it, it’s in the prod wallpost u just replied to at the very bottom I cant link because I am on phone. I basically just said I tl Fenrir for the tow reads and dive into that prod comment that was made on my early line about rvsing slots you have experience with, but also that I get a bad feeing about how he votes Toni and says “I have thoughts on this but you can wait to hear them just sheep me lol” like it could be a real push but it feels so forced when you put it like this oh, the question about using abilities? I do plan on getting to that later, but I meant moreso questions like "whats your read on A" "are B and C partnered?" etc because I think forcing myself to think about those questions helps me read with an actual motive instead of just kinda skimming. |
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 21:48:41 GMT
Track: if the town selects the player that is performing the nightkill, they are revealed as the killer that night phase. Watch: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, the player performing the kill is revealed as mafia. Imprison: if the town selects the kill target OR the player performing the kill, there is no kill that night phase. Kill: the town gets an extra elimination that day phase. This elimination is optional. Vigilante Gift: the selected player will receive an optional vigilante shot, to be used that night. If this player is being nightkilled, they will die without using their shot. Oracle: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, they may reveal another player's alignment upon their death. This reveal will occur at daystart. Doctor: if the selected player was chosen for the nightkill, they will survive. The mafia may elect to self target their nightkill on the night they choose this ability. Right now I think scum wouldnt pick either the doctor/imprison or the track/watch or oracle. Those can show who scum could/couldnt be and I dont feel like that would do that. I feel like they either choose Kill Or Vigilante as it has the highest chance of not finding scum and revealing how scum could be. If that was the case I would give the vig gift to ck and kill would be depending on how the game progresses. Honestly if you give vig gift to me I will idle it unless someone jumps out as scummy to me but if you don’t like that and want me to shoot please give input on who you want dead i dont really have a sr outside turt here, but idling a vig is a bad choice. Even if it was random if you shoot a slot who hasnt made much posts so that you could make a read on them its better if u shoot them so we get info. |
|
|
|
Post by AligningStars on Jul 15, 2024 21:49:06 GMT
m3 w5ill eon'5c know why c3reakmy kittya is toni1 i t me will know why creamy kitty is tony it |
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 15, 2024 21:49:36 GMT
Ok were on the PC now first things first i wanna put together this list For what its worth this collection are not worthwhile D1 chops unless someone can find seriously compelling reasoning currently to chop them (imo) [Me, Fame, Fenrir] Were not chopping this D1
Me Slots that I TR / Feel very strongly about not being chopped currentlyFame The way Fame is currently playing is in a way that I think currently trends more towards T Fame rather than S Fame Im being actively lazy and not grabbing a bunch of his posts b/c I just got home and i wanna lay down for a few but if someone wants me to grab posts that point me towards T Fame lmk and I can prob grab a few out of his iso Creamy Feel like Creamy started off relatively meh and blah at SOD, but as the games progressed I feel like theyve gotten a lot better since then Turt ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132443/threadI talked about this slot earlier and the above post --> heres where i talk about it ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/132460/threadNightEmerald His earlier posting felt decent to me, and I feel like it tracks form other instances ive seen of NE, so its left a decent impression thus far on me Slots that I dont want chopped but I feel less strongly about from those aboveFenrir Id like to see more of Fenrir but his earlier posting felt ~decent~ Lechen Im partly defaulting to what Fames said about this game and Black dnommy feeling ~relatively similar, I dont have a full read on the slot yet but currently dont think its a worthwhile chop atm I dont particularly care to keep the slots, but i think they lack content to be justifiable chops at the time of making thisdbd Saltycactus Crespo/Toni I havent read them enough, want to reread them, or would like pressure placed onto them or wouldnt mind seeing them chopped currently or some mixAligningstars PenguinD PCB Vade Slots
Myanmario Realistically this is b/c I want Myan to come into thread and explain those reads b/c those scumreads feel whack I think the other things Id currently like to touch on is 2 reads that I think make sense atm 1) PenguinD and Myan are likely not partnered. This mainly comes off of the both of them voting me earlier, and (yes its a weird reasoning to unpartner them) but idt both mafia partners would both place votes on me together 2) Lechen and dbd are probably not partnered. Fame elaborated on this earlier, and I think the reasoning he had made sense / held water Im gonna come back but i feel kinda tired rn, and just got home so i wanna relax for a few if thats alright Some things we should do before DL: I dont want the vote to stagnate on Myan, i think we should look at / explore other slots (looking at you people that are on Myan as well rn) We should probably It doesnt have to be today, but its something for each of you to think about. Depending on which abilities are given tomorrow: Who should they be used on / given to and why? Track: if the town selects the player that is performing the nightkill, they are revealed as the killer that night phase. Watch: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, the player performing the kill is revealed as mafia. Imprison: if the town selects the kill target OR the player performing the kill, there is no kill that night phase. Kill: the town gets an extra elimination that day phase. This elimination is optional. Vigilante Gift: the selected player will receive an optional vigilante shot, to be used that night. If this player is being nightkilled, they will die without using their shot. Oracle: if the town selects the player that was chosen for the nightkill, they may reveal another player's alignment upon their death. This reveal will occur at daystart. Doctor: if the selected player was chosen for the nightkill, they will survive. The mafia may elect to self target their nightkill on the night they choose this ability. Right now I think scum wouldnt pick either the doctor/imprison or the track/watch or oracle. Those can show who scum could/couldnt be and I dont feel like that would do that. I feel like they either choose Kill Or Vigilante as it has the highest chance of not finding scum and revealing how scum could be. If that was the case I would give the vig gift to ck and kill would be depending on how the game progresses. lowkey if i was scum i would choose oracle d1 because there is the least chance theyll hit the kill |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 15, 2024 21:50:44 GMT
Honestly if you give vig gift to me I will idle it unless someone jumps out as scummy to me but if you don’t like that and want me to shoot please give input on who you want dead i dont really have a sr outside turt here, but idling a vig is a bad choice. Even if it was random if you shoot a slot who hasnt made much posts so that you could make a read on them its better if u shoot them so we get info. I don’t wanna just random lolshot but I will see how game progresses and what info we could get, just saying I will not shoot in my townpool ever lol |
|
