|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:02:45 GMT
as scum you will make posts similar to how you would as a town player dropping reads, but i think the biggest thing is just why these reads are dropping, i feel like as scum youre less committing to reads but a lot of this is based on what happened in that dn game which had been lower into activity hm yeah u actually have a point here, ik it is early in the game but Prod is noticeably uncommital, something that stands out to me is the Toni read that they seem to be hiding for some reason as well. I’m hesitant to sr them off this but it isn’t behavior I am really liking I won’t lie though the lack of commitment is kinda a byproduct of this thread state and I think it easily comes from a townie who just doesn’t really have enough info to be comfortable commuting yet |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 14, 2024 22:08:53 GMT
as scum you will make posts similar to how you would as a town player dropping reads, but i think the biggest thing is just why these reads are dropping, i feel like as scum youre less committing to reads but a lot of this is based on what happened in that dn game which had been lower into activity hm yeah u actually have a point here, ik it is early in the game but Prod is noticeably uncommital, something that stands out to me is the Toni read that they seem to be hiding for some reason as well. I’m hesitant to sr them off this but it isn’t behavior I am really liking the toni read hinges on him being here or not its not a real read of his content, its a read of how he plays when he rolls certain alignments (mafia) |
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 14, 2024 22:11:58 GMT
hm yeah u actually have a point here, ik it is early in the game but Prod is noticeably uncommital, something that stands out to me is the Toni read that they seem to be hiding for some reason as well. I’m hesitant to sr them off this but it isn’t behavior I am really liking the toni read hinges on him being here or not its not a real read of his content, its a read of how he plays when he rolls certain alignments (mafia) i know what you mean by this |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 14, 2024 22:13:03 GMT
idk i just want slots to take note of what prod is doing this game rather than drop early townreads on them and fail to reeval until its too late like that dn game i think this statement is fair i think what youre trying to get at is moreso that --> ppl should actually try to scrutinize / evaluate rather than drop a read and move on and letting me lazily slide by idk if you *actually* want me to be the vote and idt thats completely what youre aiming for, like i said i think the above is moreso what youre aiming at |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 14, 2024 22:16:45 GMT
the toni read hinges on him being here or not its not a real read of his content, its a read of how he plays when he rolls certain alignments (mafia) i know what you mean by this yea, i dont like *openly* stating it, its less so to like hide it and say "i have a secret alignment read on toni" more so to preserve the genuineness of it and to not ruin it to see if it continues or not |
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 14, 2024 22:17:06 GMT
i think ck is probably just obvtowning lol their posts feel super genuine actually and im pretty sure if i left this post until later in the game they'd just be spewed by how many people are interacting with them this game
|
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 14, 2024 22:20:40 GMT
like the issue w/ ck's super early posts is yeah they look designed to generate townreads on themselves & i think that's a real read that could come from pcb/anyone else calling it lamist-y
but i can't shake the feeling they're posting from a town pov bc of how 'objective' they're trying to be by looking at the game in third person/from the pov of others lol
|
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 14, 2024 22:20:46 GMT
i think ck is probably just obvtowning lol their posts feel super genuine actually and im pretty sure if i left this post until later in the game they'd just be spewed by how many people are interacting with them this game this is more of a random question for you, but i wanted to poke you, maybe fenrir about it, but what do you make of Alignings absenteeism? Hes usually not one for that, at least not the "ive made 2 posts" style |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:23:11 GMT
hm yeah u actually have a point here, ik it is early in the game but Prod is noticeably uncommital, something that stands out to me is the Toni read that they seem to be hiding for some reason as well. I’m hesitant to sr them off this but it isn’t behavior I am really liking the toni read hinges on him being here or not its not a real read of his content, its a read of how he plays when he rolls certain alignments (mafia) I see, I don’t really know Toni’s meta but what I think you’re getting at is him being inactive consistently is a big tell? |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jul 14, 2024 22:23:20 GMT
hi people, im here heres my thoughts on the things i actually paid attention to in the read pcb vote on fenrir feels nai ck talking about how pcb should vote people pcb's played with feels nai, idk how ck usually plays but anyone can give advice fmpov pcb response is a joke ck talking about activity feels sudden, but im struggling with how much, i dont feel like combing through past games to see if ck makes 'psa' posts there pcb calls ck a bit lamist, looked it up, and i am gonna stay far away from that stuff because the way i see it, saying someone's lamist is saying theyre trying harder to look town than usual, and i dont really have much of an idea of people's baseline level of towniness (on forum at least) skipping the rest of the convo because I feel like it would be a better idea to vote people you’ve played with, that pressure can actually be used to get an accurate read Eithers fine tbh Voting with no prior experience can also be good too Theres less of “i have to approach the slot this specific way” More of “Im going to approach the slot in my own way” i dont understand this in the context of pcb voting someone who they havent played with, what specific way are you talking about? it kinda just seems like a slightly less random rvs, and i dont understand how that's really approaching a slot in general skipping fame entrance and vade's 7 AM post asking for content because i just dont feel anything from it crespo kinda just says what pcb did in different words, and i dont like that personally ck bringing up the sc post into asking about ice cream is even more whiplash, and i think maybe they should chill tf out(maybe thats why they brought up ice cream hahahahah im not funny) crespo response to all that is fine If nobody feels like responding to my explanation then I’m not gonna continue this discussion. I’m not intent on committing too hard on this until I see more from SC though. i dont see where the explanation is, could you link and/or explain more? you kinda said 'these kinds of things could matter' which feels handwavey like the fame re-entrance, the phrase 'mostly because it implies the opposite is happening which is ?' is a good line im having a hard time explaining why its a good line so i decided to wordvomit things i like about it: new thought/read, unique feels genuine, not to shade other people but saying the above phrase is way more specific than calling it performative or lamist i cant think of anything else, theres probably more to say tho i like prodigus response (why they like pcb entrance), i dont personally see it for this game, but the line bout things grabbing your attention more is something i can empathize(i think thats the right word) with the ck posts: first one is meh, no particular strong feelings on it second post makes me empathize with ck. easiest way i can explain it is dnommy black with the whole d1 vade/me/realiti/stp stuff. replace aligning w me(that game), pcb w vade. I feel like in that game, I just focused on what vade did "wrong" and the stuff vade was accusing me for, and i think that same vibe is coming from ck here. third and fourth posts are kinda an extension of thoughts above, except more forgiving that me in the other game, though thats probably just them being better at playing the game calm okay holy fuck am i a super slow typist, gonna post this, and come back with a part two where i use less words, less brain, and hopefully less time |
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 14, 2024 22:24:02 GMT
i think ck is probably just obvtowning lol their posts feel super genuine actually and im pretty sure if i left this post until later in the game they'd just be spewed by how many people are interacting with them this game this is more of a random question for you, but i wanted to poke you, maybe fenrir about it, but what do you make of Alignings absenteeism? Hes usually not one for that, at least not the "ive made 2 posts" style i don't really have any thoughts on it bc i kind of just assumed it was typical slot behaviour i do kind of remember them being more active in past games but im not reading anyone from activity yet really |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:26:37 GMT
like the issue w/ ck's super early posts is yeah they look designed to generate townreads on themselves & i think that's a real read that could come from pcb/anyone else calling it lamist-y but i can't shake the feeling they're posting from a town pov bc of how 'objective' they're trying to be by looking at the game in third person/from the pov of others lol tbh I understand the LAMIST reads because it did look like I was trying to put on a big show, but my early posts came from me being overly excited for SOD (basically what fen said about it earlier) and a desire to get the game started somehow, now that things are happening I am trying to mellow out. |
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 14, 2024 22:28:29 GMT
that does not unpartner anything that's just a weird ass post hey I am here now what's up, I disagree that kinda thing doesn't seem forced to me so unpartnering them for now |
|
|
|
Post by Fame on Jul 14, 2024 22:32:56 GMT
that does not unpartner anything that's just a weird ass post hey I am here now what's up, I disagree that kinda thing doesn't seem forced to me so unpartnering them for now if you think they're unpartnered do you think they're more likely to both be town or be on opposite factions |
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 14, 2024 22:36:09 GMT
I don’t really know lechen and NE is usually a more reserved player from my experience playing with him, but I definitely think myan and turt being dead silent is odd ik forums is like def different from chat myan and turt forgetting theyre in a game or not doing much is typical imo the reason i mention lechen is b/c from my brief skim of Black Dnommy i saw ppl were decently able to make a consensus read of T for them so i was hoping to be able to do the same / similar early on here i cant bold anything on mobile so im gonna quote "myan and tuet forgetting theyre in a game or something or not doing much is typical" yea this is teue i forgot i was playobg mb guys |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:37:42 GMT
hi people, im here heres my thoughts on the things i actually paid attention to in the read pcb vote on fenrir feels nai ck talking about how pcb should vote people pcb's played with feels nai, idk how ck usually plays but anyone can give advice fmpov pcb response is a joke ck talking about activity feels sudden, but im struggling with how much, i dont feel like combing through past games to see if ck makes 'psa' posts there pcb calls ck a bit lamist, looked it up, and i am gonna stay far away from that stuff because the way i see it, saying someone's lamist is saying theyre trying harder to look town than usual, and i dont really have much of an idea of people's baseline level of towniness (on forum at least) skipping the rest of the convo because Eithers fine tbh Voting with no prior experience can also be good too Theres less of “i have to approach the slot this specific way” More of “Im going to approach the slot in my own way” i dont understand this in the context of pcb voting someone who they havent played with, what specific way are you talking about? it kinda just seems like a slightly less random rvs, and i dont understand how that's really approaching a slot in general skipping fame entrance and vade's 7 AM post asking for content because i just dont feel anything from it crespo kinda just says what pcb did in different words, and i dont like that personally ck bringing up the sc post into asking about ice cream is even more whiplash, and i think maybe they should chill tf out(maybe thats why they brought up ice cream hahahahah im not funny) crespo response to all that is fine If nobody feels like responding to my explanation then I’m not gonna continue this discussion. I’m not intent on committing too hard on this until I see more from SC though. i dont see where the explanation is, could you link and/or explain more? you kinda said 'these kinds of things could matter' which feels handwavey like the fame re-entrance, the phrase 'mostly because it implies the opposite is happening which is ?' is a good line im having a hard time explaining why its a good line so i decided to wordvomit things i like about it: new thought/read, unique feels genuine, not to shade other people but saying the above phrase is way more specific than calling it performative or lamist i cant think of anything else, theres probably more to say tho i like prodigus response (why they like pcb entrance), i dont personally see it for this game, but the line bout things grabbing your attention more is something i can empathize(i think thats the right word) with the ck posts: first one is meh, no particular strong feelings on it second post makes me empathize with ck. easiest way i can explain it is dnommy black with the whole d1 vade/me/realiti/stp stuff. replace aligning w me(that game), pcb w vade. I feel like in that game, I just focused on what vade did "wrong" and the stuff vade was accusing me for, and i think that same vibe is coming from ck here. third and fourth posts are kinda an extension of thoughts above, except more forgiving that me in the other game, though thats probably just them being better at playing the game calm okay holy fuck am i a super slow typist, gonna post this, and come back with a part two where i use less words, less brain, and hopefully less time I don’t know why you are pointing out my SC post then following with my filler post asking about ice cream lmao why does this give you whiplash? Sad nobody answered my ice cream question  and no it was not a metaphor for anything I’m not a poet. I’m on mobile so I can’t link or quote it in this post, but basically it was a little tell I used where scum pays attention to the usage of their own abilities and feels the need to bring them up, like how SC’s first and only post is them asking to not be nked n1 which gave me odd vibes, in hindsight someone brought up SC’s meta and how that could make it a townie post, which I agree with and I’ve pretty much dropped that read now. It’s not necessarily that I thought it was a big deal, but it’s one of those little things I like to point out early to generate discussion. Aside from that I don’t feel the need to point out much about this analysis, but I can appreciate it for what it is. |
|
|
|
Post by Turtwigswiththrohs on Jul 14, 2024 22:38:55 GMT
hey I am here now what's up, I disagree that kinda thing doesn't seem forced to me so unpartnering them for now if you think they're unpartnered do you think they're more likely to both be town or be on opposite factions I'm not sure I was understanding this right I meant unpartnering fen/prod based off of prods like first or second line along the lines of what aligned said |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:39:35 GMT
ik forums is like def different from chat myan and turt forgetting theyre in a game or not doing much is typical imo the reason i mention lechen is b/c from my brief skim of Black Dnommy i saw ppl were decently able to make a consensus read of T for them so i was hoping to be able to do the same / similar early on here i cant bold anything on mobile so im gonna quote "myan and tuet forgetting theyre in a game or something or not doing much is typical" yea this is teue i forgot i was playobg mb guys please turn on autocorrect you need it |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:40:59 GMT
that does not unpartner anything that's just a weird ass post hey I am here now what's up, I disagree that kinda thing doesn't seem forced to me so unpartnering them for now which unpartnering are you referring to? That post from vade was very vague in terms of what one of my multiple unpartnerings it is referring to |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 14, 2024 22:41:54 GMT
the toni read hinges on him being here or not its not a real read of his content, its a read of how he plays when he rolls certain alignments (mafia) I see, I don’t really know Toni’s meta but what I think you’re getting at is him being inactive consistently is a big tell? Toni notoriously rolls mafia at a rate of 90% mafia 10% town and i wish i was joking but im not, fame (maybe fenrir) can probably corroborate this to some degree but yea toni is heavily absent when he rolls mafia |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Jul 14, 2024 22:42:06 GMT
I don’t know why you are pointing out my SC post then following with my filler post asking about ice cream lmao why does this give you whiplash? Sad nobody answered my ice cream question :( and no it was not a metaphor for anything I’m not a poet i called it whip lash because you went from using a lot of big words to asking about ice cream thats really it |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:42:39 GMT
I see, I don’t really know Toni’s meta but what I think you’re getting at is him being inactive consistently is a big tell? Toni notoriously rolls mafia at a rate of 90% mafia 10% town and i wish i was joking but im not, fame (maybe fenrir) can probably corroborate this to some degree but yea toni is heavily absent when he rolls mafia I won’t knock it till I try it ig |
|
|
|
Post by Prodigu on Jul 14, 2024 22:43:20 GMT
this is more of a random question for you, but i wanted to poke you, maybe fenrir about it, but what do you make of Alignings absenteeism? Hes usually not one for that, at least not the "ive made 2 posts" style i don't really have any thoughts on it bc i kind of just assumed it was typical slot behaviour i do kind of remember them being more active in past games but im not reading anyone from activity yet really ok ty, its one of those, hmm hes only said 2 things this entire game so far, when i expect like.... more than that and idk if i should be reading into that or not |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:43:39 GMT
I don’t know why you are pointing out my SC post then following with my filler post asking about ice cream lmao why does this give you whiplash? Sad nobody answered my ice cream question and no it was not a metaphor for anything I’m not a poet i called it whip lash because you went from using a lot of big words to asking about ice cream thats really it oh yeah, I get tired of it eventually and like to throw in some random ass filler like that just to keep spirits up |
|
|
|
Post by creamykitty on Jul 14, 2024 22:45:28 GMT
i don't really have any thoughts on it bc i kind of just assumed it was typical slot behaviour i do kind of remember them being more active in past games but im not reading anyone from activity yet really ok ty, its one of those, hmm hes only said 2 things this entire game so far, when i expect like.... more than that and idk if i should be reading into that or not I think aligning is kinda hard to read tbh, id expect him to be more active but it really doesn’t set off a flag to me yet |
|
and no it was not a metaphor for anything I’m not a poet.