|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Aug 16, 2024 2:18:26 GMT
Ngl L activity doesnt mean they should go d1 u say this like we dont have 2 no posters I legit never think no posters are the right vote d1 |
|
|
|
Post by saberslasher11 on Aug 16, 2024 2:18:29 GMT
Fort Colorcastle Izaya vaderaven turtwigswiththrohs saberslasher11 PenguinD Hallow + 2 no posters am i just scummy for not posting and having any thoughts |
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Aug 16, 2024 2:19:45 GMT
Okay. I'm not not following then. a. You don't have a read on pcb. b. You don't have a read on anyone who voted pcb (except pq). c. You don't like that pq said the wagon was likely town. d. You're village reading pq. This feels like being contrarian just to be contrarian rather than trying narrow the POE. Okay but like why said anything at all? pq didn't hardclear anyone. Just that he thinks it could be town-motivated. So to specifically shoot that down from someone you trust, I would assume you'd then have a specific reason for why you think at least one involved is scum rather than a vague "can't rule anyone out." Could you also highlight why the thought of an all village wagon is uncomfortable to you? I kind of like both of these posts, the second one feels fairly agressive in a way to push someone and it feels townie to me at least i feel like the way Animal Midwife is approaching Aligningstars probably doesnt come from mafia partners, the first one feels like its kinda trying to make sense of what was said it popped out to me but i think the more telling post is the 2nd one. @ne fwiw this post is kind of mid "animal is townie because solving and they're probably not partnered with the person theyre pushing" like this qualifies as an original thought but also it's not super in depth analysis or anything the slot feels somewhat afraid to put itself out there if that makes sense, this could be town hedginess but i get the vibes of "i want to look like im solving" if that makes sense? |
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Aug 16, 2024 2:20:15 GMT
u say this like we dont have 2 no posters I legit never think no posters are the right vote d1 i'd rather not let the no posters take over the entire game pookie |
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Aug 16, 2024 2:21:15 GMT
Fort Colorcastle Izaya vaderaven turtwigswiththrohs saberslasher11 PenguinD Hallow + 2 no posters All of those slots except for fort are just lurkers, this feels lazy af yes but they are scummier than you besides hallow is the only slot i really have reason to sr (and ive admitted this before) |
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Aug 16, 2024 2:22:27 GMT
I kind of like both of these posts, the second one feels fairly agressive in a way to push someone and it feels townie to me at least i feel like the way Animal Midwife is approaching Aligningstars probably doesnt come from mafia partners, the first one feels like its kinda trying to make sense of what was said it popped out to me but i think the more telling post is the 2nd one. @ne fwiw this post is kind of mid "animal is townie because solving and they're probably not partnered with the person theyre pushing" like this qualifies as an original thought but also it's not super in depth analysis or anything the slot feels somewhat afraid to put itself out there if that makes sense, this could be town hedginess but i get the vibes of "i want to look like im solving" if that makes sense? fair enough, give me a moment to find hallows greatest hits tm that really explain why I tr them. also fwiw you can just say my name you dont have to vaguepost about a person who doesnt like cks posts i want my name on that |
|
|
|
Post by Fort Colorcastle on Aug 16, 2024 2:22:29 GMT
I’ll try to catch up on things now, might not make it for EOD. Starting here. Fort: ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135458/threadI like this post it does feel genuinely solvy and I can actually agree with the point being made here. Main reason I sld fort was because of the vade shift though, and that still stands out to me and has never actually been addressed. what hasnt been addressed about it? I think these things are clear about it: 1) the post that caused the shift 2) the given reason why the shift happened 3) the given reason i want the slot gone obviously the given reasons aren't necessarily true if you think I'm lying with an agenda in mind, but you'd have to find the agenda yourself because I can't think of it |
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Aug 16, 2024 2:22:43 GMT
i feel like saberslasher is kind of choosing to be a lurker anyways lmao
like ive seen bro a few times and i dont think hes said something of solve value yet
|
|
|
|
Post by saberslasher11 on Aug 16, 2024 2:25:39 GMT
well heres a extremely low quality read list that are mainly based off vibes and not anything in particular(don't ask me to elaborate on them
1) PokeCartBeast-town
2) MyanMario-town, good vibes
3) Turtwigswiththrohs-idk
4) vaderaven--town prolly
5) saberslasher11-I am town
6) pqwerty-tpwn
7) AligningStars-scum
8) slowthepoke-scum
9) creamykitty-null
10) hallow-idk
11) PenguinD-idk
12) NightEmerald-scum, he wallpost
13) Animal Midwife-scum
14) Izaya-idk
15) kliff-town
16) litteleven-idk
17) cuddleszz-idk
18) Fort Colorcastle-town
|
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Aug 16, 2024 2:27:10 GMT
My current thoughts Town: Stp Pq Ani Izaya? Scum: Ck Aligning? Fort Idrk on rest, don’t expect me to back these up! id like to see t!izaya/s!fort elaboration, they didnt ping me either way when i skimmed (fort's recent content (reaction to ck read mainly) is pretty good though) |
|
|
|
Post by cuddleszz on Aug 16, 2024 2:29:12 GMT
I townread PQUERTY NE HALLOW aligningstars animal midwife.
NULL PENGUIND izbaf(sorry if misspelled)
Scumread fortcoloring(I find the reads weak and with a lack of sincerity with his responses to questions asked about the read)
Scumread vade(I’ve been gone longer then you for most of this game and yet every post you make always has the im too busy to make effort reading I understand school as a excuse but I can only tolerate it for so far and it’s been 36 hours since Start there should be more productive content from you I’ve seen it before as scum and town you.
Scumlean myanmario but I’ll focus this more so on d2
Scumlean kliff but will focus on this day 2 as well.
I’m tourist I’ll be visiting one of vade/fort tonight if one flips I’ll target the other if neither flip by vote tonight I’ll target fort first since another mentioned visit g vade
|
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Aug 16, 2024 2:29:52 GMT
well heres a extremely low quality read list that are mainly based off vibes and not anything in particular(don't ask me to elaborate on them 1) PokeCartBeast-town 2) MyanMario-town, good vibes 3) Turtwigswiththrohs-idk 4) vaderaven--town prolly 5) saberslasher11-I am town 6) pqwerty-tpwn 7) AligningStars-scum 8) slowthepoke-scum 9) creamykitty-null 10) hallow-idk 11) PenguinD-idk 12) NightEmerald-scum, he wallpost 13) Animal Midwife-scum 14) Izaya-idk 15) kliff-town 16) litteleven-idk 17) cuddleszz-idk 18) Fort Colorcastle-town can u give me like two reads with reasoning or your most confident trs/srs rn |
|
|
|
Post by cuddleszz on Aug 16, 2024 2:30:04 GMT
Vote @vaderaven
|
|
|
|
Post by PokeCartBeast on Aug 16, 2024 2:30:36 GMT
I townread PQUERTY NE HALLOW aligningstars animal midwife. noticing a severe lack of "PokeCartBeast" here |
|
|
|
Post by cuddleszz on Aug 16, 2024 2:31:05 GMT
Stp you’re just a special case that requires multiple days for me to read before going yeah vote him out too much uncertainty. Xd
|
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Aug 16, 2024 2:32:28 GMT
I townread PQUERTY NE HALLOW aligningstars animal midwife. NULL PENGUIND izbaf(sorry if misspelled) Scumread fortcoloring(I find the reads weak and with a lack of sincerity with his responses to questions asked about the read) Scumread vade(I’ve been gone longer then you for most of this game and yet every post you make always has the im too busy to make effort reading I understand school as a excuse but I can only tolerate it for so far and it’s been 36 hours since Start there should be more productive content from you I’ve seen it before as scum and town you. Scumlean myanmario but I’ll focus this more so on d2 Scumlean kliff but will focus on this day 2 as well. I’m tourist I’ll be visiting one of vade/fort tonight if one flips I’ll target the other if neither flip by vote tonight I’ll target fort first since another mentioned visit g vade cuddz what about me  |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Aug 16, 2024 2:32:39 GMT
Stp you’re just a special case that requires multiple days for me to read before going yeah vote him out too much uncertainty. Xd fuck bro did it before |
|
|
|
Post by cuddleszz on Aug 16, 2024 2:33:15 GMT
PCB your null to me I’ll have to check more on you d2 but this is where I’m standing until deadline because I’m on mobile just finished reading all of the game and sadly cannot sweat post n stuff on mobile I’m about to leave soon so I’ll check back in 11:30, if I’ don’t forget… weeded town out
|
|
|
|
Post by Animal Midwife on Aug 16, 2024 2:33:47 GMT
well heres a extremely low quality read list that are mainly based off vibes and not anything in particular(don't ask me to elaborate on them 1) PokeCartBeast-town 2) MyanMario-town, good vibes 3) Turtwigswiththrohs-idk 4) vaderaven--town prolly 5) saberslasher11-I am town 6) pqwerty-tpwn 7) AligningStars-scum 8) slowthepoke-scum 9) creamykitty-null 10) hallow-idk 11) PenguinD-idk 12) NightEmerald-scum, he wallpost 13) Animal Midwife-scum 14) Izaya-idk 15) kliff-town 16) litteleven-idk 17) cuddleszz-idk 18) Fort Colorcastle-town welcome to my POE |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Aug 16, 2024 2:33:51 GMT
I townread PQUERTY NE HALLOW aligningstars animal midwife. NULL PENGUIND izbaf(sorry if misspelled) Scumread fortcoloring(I find the reads weak and with a lack of sincerity with his responses to questions asked about the read) Scumread vade(I’ve been gone longer then you for most of this game and yet every post you make always has the im too busy to make effort reading I understand school as a excuse but I can only tolerate it for so far and it’s been 36 hours since Start there should be more productive content from you I’ve seen it before as scum and town you. Scumlean myanmario but I’ll focus this more so on d2 Scumlean kliff but will focus on this day 2 as well. I’m tourist I’ll be visiting one of vade/fort tonight if one flips I’ll target the other if neither flip by vote tonight I’ll target fort first since another mentioned visit g vade vade doesnt have a scumgame cuddz. |
|
|
|
Post by slowthepoke on Aug 16, 2024 2:34:24 GMT
bro im mad why do u have that doduo
|
|
|
|
Post by cuddleszz on Aug 16, 2024 2:34:24 GMT
I’ll play better d2 if alive otherwise I don’t got much more to say here be back in an hour, afk slots not worth focusing now.
|
|
|
|
Post by NightEmerald on Aug 16, 2024 2:34:37 GMT
ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135200/threadreally the main post i can point to wrt hallow feeling unagendad, it feels like genuine attempt to understand rather than prodding to prod ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135226/threadaddressed in wallpost 2, they were the first person to point out the seeming discrepancy, nobody else really did so before them to my knowledge, also feels like trying to get clarification where scumis more likely to just go "weird and bad reason vote this mf" ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135234/threadextension of above, you can argue that this one is more performative, but personally I still think it fits HOWEVER I didnt feel like checking if that one was a duplicate thought, im treating it as if only hallow and alstars were talking, so you may be right on this if I checked ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135410/threadthe post on liking animal midwife leads to this pretty naturally I think, but you probably would argue that talking about animal midwife as a potential vote here is weird and I dont think I have a way of explaining that so really my big takeaway is that hallow seems really willing to hear people out in one-on-one conversations, while I see where you're coming from with their reads on older posts not feeling townie, I personally dont think hallow is a person id vote in the near future
|
|
|
|
Post by MyanMario on Aug 16, 2024 2:34:43 GMT
Reminder that this is Not Their Name |
|
|
|
Post by cuddleszz on Aug 16, 2024 2:34:46 GMT
Hey man you got that dudtrio the goat 🐐
|
|
