Countdown 6: A Game of Halves (GAME OVER)

[slowthepoke]

wait bro didnt recive the dodrio W

[MyanMario]

Aug 16, 2024 2:25:39 GMT saberslasher11 said:

well heres a extremely low quality read list that are mainly based off vibes and not anything in particular(don't ask me to elaborate on them
1) PokeCartBeast-town
2) MyanMario-town, good vibes
3) Turtwigswiththrohs-idk
4) vaderaven--town prolly
5) saberslasher11-I am town
6) pqwerty-tpwn
7) AligningStars-scum
8) slowthepoke-scum
9) creamykitty-null
10) hallow-idk
11) PenguinD-idk
12) NightEmerald-scum, he wallpost
13) Animal Midwife-scum
14) Izaya-idk
15) kliff-town
16) litteleven-idk
17) cuddleszz-idk
18) Fort Colorcastle-town

Awesome sauce ty, tmrw i might ask u to go a bit in depth / analyze a bit more but I’ll prod you over time

[slowthepoke]

ima go sleep tbh

[saberslasher11]

vote @slowthepoke

[slowthepoke]

bruh

[creamykitty]

Aug 16, 2024 2:22:29 GMT Fort Colorcastle said:

Aug 16, 2024 2:03:01 GMT creamykitty said:

I’ll try to catch up on things now, might not make it for EOD. Starting here.

Fort:

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135458/thread
I like this post it does feel genuinely solvy and I can actually agree with the point being made here.

Main reason I sld fort was because of the vade shift though, and that still stands out to me and has never actually been addressed.

what hasnt been addressed about it?
I think these things are clear about it:
1) the post that caused the shift
2) the given reason why the shift happened
3) the given reason i want the slot gone

obviously the given reasons aren't necessarily true if you think I'm lying with an agenda in mind, but you'd have to find the agenda yourself because I can't think of it

From what you’ve said it is literally just a policy vote, which is a dumb excuse and like I said I think the agenda in mind here is to dunk on the slot and push the mischop over your RVs on STP

[NightEmerald]

Aug 16, 2024 2:25:39 GMT saberslasher11 said:

12) NightEmerald-scum, he wallpost

[slowthepoke]

Aug 16, 2024 2:39:42 GMT NightEmerald said:

Aug 16, 2024 2:25:39 GMT saberslasher11 said:

12) NightEmerald-scum, he wallpost

Nah ne thats a valid point, i dont wanna read allat

[NightEmerald]

Aug 16, 2024 2:40:31 GMT slowthepoke said:

Aug 16, 2024 2:39:42 GMT NightEmerald said:

Nah ne thats a valid point, i dont wanna read allat

i have nothing to say to that beyond "skill issue"

[creamykitty]

Aug 16, 2024 2:29:12 GMT cuddleszz said:

I townread PQUERTY NE HALLOW aligningstars animal midwife.
NULL PENGUIND izbaf(sorry if misspelled)
Scumread fortcoloring(I find the reads weak and with a lack of sincerity with his responses to questions asked about the read)
Scumread vade(I’ve been gone longer then you for most of this game and yet every post you make always has the im too busy to make effort reading I understand school as a excuse but I can only tolerate it for so far and it’s been 36 hours since Start there should be more productive content from you I’ve seen it before as scum and town you.
Scumlean myanmario but I’ll focus this more so on d2
Scumlean kliff but will focus on this day 2 as well.

I’m tourist I’ll be visiting one of vade/fort tonight if one flips I’ll target the other if neither flip by vote tonight I’ll target fort first since another mentioned visit g vade

cuddz where am I

[NightEmerald]

shit posting the clown pic again wouldve been funnier

[PokeCartBeast]

Aug 16, 2024 2:34:37 GMT NightEmerald said:

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135200/thread
really the main post i can point to wrt hallow feeling unagendad, it feels like genuine attempt to understand rather than prodding to prod
ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135226/thread
addressed in wallpost 2, they were the first person to point out the seeming discrepancy, nobody else really did so before them to my knowledge, also feels like trying to get clarification where scumis more likely to just go "weird and bad reason vote this mf"
ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135234/thread
extension of above, you can argue that this one is more performative, but personally I still think it fits
HOWEVER
I didnt feel like checking if that one was a duplicate thought, im treating it as if only hallow and alstars were talking, so you may be right on this if I checked

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135410/thread
the post on liking animal midwife leads to this pretty naturally I think, but you probably would argue that talking about animal midwife as a potential vote here is weird and I dont think I have a way of explaining that

so really my big takeaway is that hallow seems really willing to hear people out in one-on-one conversations, while I see where you're coming from with their reads on older posts not feeling townie, I personally dont think hallow is a person id vote in the near future

i think in general the slot just feels like its playing very safe solvewise, i do like some of the points here though (the ck interaction specifically does feel genuine)
it could be town hedginess, could be scum, probably have to let the slot post a bit more to get a better read here i think

[slowthepoke]

Aug 16, 2024 2:41:05 GMT NightEmerald said:

Aug 16, 2024 2:40:31 GMT slowthepoke said:

Nah ne thats a valid point, i dont wanna read allat

i have nothing to say to that beyond "skill issue"

Nah bc i actially read it unlike most people

[NightEmerald]

Aug 16, 2024 2:45:23 GMT slowthepoke said:

Aug 16, 2024 2:41:05 GMT NightEmerald said:

i have nothing to say to that beyond "skill issue"

Nah bc i actially read it unlike most people

Oh damn ty, as an apology I wont make you read another one like that again (i am too lazy to make something that big again)

[NightEmerald]

though if there's one takeaway i want people to actually give me their thoughts on its the one with the fkn picture in it because i dont get why "so basically your reads are similar to myans" gets responded to with "well myan has 1 post and a rvs"

[pqwerty]

what's with cuddz and the wooper coming out of nowhere to start posting?

[creamykitty]

Aug 15, 2024 22:27:41 GMT NightEmerald said:

ck d1 analysis

shade is used to refer to the casting of doubt on someone elses reads without any real reason. Reasons that i consider real are vote analysis, posts that demonstrate actions counter to the reasoning in the read, and the like.

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135064/thread
tl on pq overunfiltered posting

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135126/thread
reaction seems fine, feels nai

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135133/thread
slight progression to their pq read where their 'drawing attention to themselves' is also a reason for the tl

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135155/thread
mentioned earlier, feels like a post meant to cast shade on pq's read than an attempt to solve, i just dont think it's a good hypothetical beyond a 'what if' scenario

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135190/thread
expanding on the drawing attention to self point.

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135191/thread
slight disagreement with kliff over pq's solviness early (ig thats the best way to phrase it) tentative unpair

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135193/thread
prodding kliff on myan read

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135194/thread
more elaboration on drawing attention point

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135197/thread
shade of kliff's myan read, where ck argues myan entrance is nai instead of towny

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135201/thread
liking pq's posts as a new reason for the tl

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135208/thread
asking pq for reads wrt the pcb wagon, feels fine

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135211/thread
(probably in response to pq based on the usage of the word tone) shade on pq for midwife read based on reactions, reasoning boils down to paranoia ("lets not get too hasty"-esque reasoning over what i percieve as a lean)

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135214/thread
pcb read feels like it came out of nowhere, was addressed after earlier wallpost

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135216/thread
this one is really weird vibes.
gonna put this here

When pointed out that they and myan had similar posts, ck straight up discredits myan's posting. It probably is accurate, according to pq, myan hasn't really been on, but I personally dont think the reaction is townie, id expect town to be indifferent or try to explain how their reads formed, not focus on the other person mentioned

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135219/thread
more antimyan posting

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135301/thread
I actually agree with ck (because i think aligning is town) but it's phrased to shade animal midwife, while keeping actual reads on aligning vague

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135305/thread
not sure what this achieves, because its positioned as a defense of alstars, but the point ck is using feels distinct from the points pq and alstars are discussing, where ck's read about scum letting wagon happen usually has a conclusion of the wagon target being town, but pq and alstars are discussing the voters themselves.

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135314/thread
could see this from town, kinda shocked me back into trying to be impartial

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135316/thread
i feel like this is pq implying that either they or pq is an experienced scum player but i feel like im tripping to think that way someone reality check me on this

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135333/thread
warning: didnt look at linked posts, maybe something weird about them idk
more progression on pq tl

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135338/thread
ck defending turt's calling myan's post bait, shading kliff saying that myan makes those kinds of reads genuinely.

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135397/thread
reasoning for fort scum, feels good, second person they actually seem like theyre trying to solve

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135399/thread
hallow tl, noncommittal (keep eye on them)

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135402/thread
this feels like an overreaction to a tl(?)

"creamkitty has been contributing, helpful and progressive throughout this whole day 1 which is pretty ProTown. No reason to overthink things, I think they stood out a bit too much for me, which gave me the random thought that Creamkitty could be a confident, excited scum player.
Creamkitty is just fine for me."

and ck suddenly brings meta into this, maybe out of the assumption that kliff would form reads on them the same way kliff did myan

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135406/thread
did not see any mention of the word powerwolf, wtf?

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135408/thread
honestly not really casting shade, this feels like ck just defending myan not really saying "yeah but also maybe not" to izaya's read

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135417/thread
aligning sl, not sure if this a vibe read or not

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135420/thread
shade on hallow for unpartnering stp and pcb

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135434/thread
progression on aligning sl, feels wrong to me, especially since the context around it was that pq went "dude that was sarcasm" and aligning went "oh then nvm"

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135436/thread
ck agrees to kliff over fort in a noncommittal way (trending better, still unsure which side to lean)

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135443/thread
seems fine

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135450/thread
really noncommittal, feels unwilling to let go of a scum aligning world

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135465/thread
pcb progression based on earlier reasoning of scum letting wagon happen, w no resistance

ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/135470/thread
progression on pcb

and i think thats it

Referring to the image you linked, what I thought PQ was trying to say is that myan felt townie in a similar way to PCB and himself like I mentioned, which is why I had a responses that seemed like “throwing shade” because I don’t agree with towning the slot just for a half trolly reaction bait post because it really is NAI and it feels like towning myan for it is simply just blowing things out of proportion. 

[NightEmerald]

Aug 16, 2024 2:51:16 GMT creamykitty said:

Referring to the image you linked, what I thought PQ was trying to say is that myan felt townie in a similar way to PCB and himself like I mentioned, which is why I had a responses that seemed like “throwing shade” because I don’t agree with towning the slot just for a half trolly reaction bait post because it really is NAI and it feels like towning myan for it is simply just blowing things out of proportion. 

but nowhere was the word town even uttered by pq, nor really any indication that myan was being even tled fmpov, i dont get what it is youre cooking but i dont like it

[pqwerty]

saberslasher11 how much of this game have u read btw?

[NightEmerald]

also for the love of god you dont need to quote the whole wallpost please stop making my scroll wheel wear out

[creamykitty]

Whole aligning thing was me being odded out by the shift, gonna refer you to basically just go read that whole argument with STP and understand that was my opinion on aligning, my interpretation so I said something like that kinda out of frustration because me and STP felt like we were just going in circles, I haven’t been here for a decent bit so I’ve not really read into aligning so I’ll take a look at their posts and see where that lands me

[creamykitty]

Aug 16, 2024 2:54:07 GMT NightEmerald said:

Aug 16, 2024 2:51:16 GMT creamykitty said:

Referring to the image you linked, what I thought PQ was trying to say is that myan felt townie in a similar way to PCB and himself like I mentioned, which is why I had a responses that seemed like “throwing shade” because I don’t agree with towning the slot just for a half trolly reaction bait post because it really is NAI and it feels like towning myan for it is simply just blowing things out of proportion. 

but nowhere was the word town even uttered by pq, nor really any indication that myan was being even tled fmpov, i dont get what it is youre cooking but i dont like it

Was a reply to my post where I said pq/PCB had townie vibes, and PQ says myan felt the same way in 2 posts

[NightEmerald]

Aug 16, 2024 2:57:48 GMT creamykitty said:

Aug 16, 2024 2:54:07 GMT NightEmerald said:

but nowhere was the word town even uttered by pq, nor really any indication that myan was being even tled fmpov, i dont get what it is youre cooking but i dont like it

Was a reply to my post where I said pq/PCB had townie vibes, and PQ says myan felt the same way in 2 posts

i read it as 'myan felt good about pq and pcb in two posts' maybe i fucked up. still think you're scum off all the other stuff though

[pqwerty]

this is a lot of ppl to keep track of

it's like everyone has their own srs and no one has like a consensus on who they think the wolves are

i personally think ck ne stp as am and hallow are town

i think myan gets a pass for today for being silly. i think vade gets a pass for being busy

and everyone else i was too lazy to go into depth on ISOing.

i really think it's weird how many people are just appearing for EOD when we had all day to do stuff
and i don't know why saber thought ppl were sus of him / needed to randomly start spouting reads out.

i also think it's weird that twig disappeared cuz normally they'd be helping or trying to help or something.

i really doubt it's twig saber + 1 but like im very tired and for some reason im very townread

[pqwerty]

NightEmerald i kind of thought from the liveposting last night that ck felt townie. iirc i talked him out of a tunnel. or maybe it was someone else.

really regret not taking notes this game