Post by Fenrir on Jan 14, 2018 16:41:20 GMT
I can't stay on for too long this morning, but just wanted to comment on what's been said so far.
why are you caring about a single rvs lynch so much lmfao
plur isnt even on you lmfao
also your terrible ate wont get you anywhere
A single lynch is how it all begins but fair enough, I don't have plur. I'll move away from changing up my lynch for now until I see how people react later on until the day. Got my eyes on you though...So here on my current thoughts on this interaction. I can see why a town-aligned Darnell would be thrown off by my first post, if only because it isn't really the typical RVS. Said first post is of course intentionally atypical for reaction purposes, although Darnell's vote on me doesn't feel like it's opportunistic. Despite that, I'm currently unsure on Darnell's alignment because his other posts feel...I'm not sure how to phrase it, "over the top"? I'm referring to things like "I suggest you unlynch now to avoid some pain" and "Got my eyes on you" which on one hand feels like a common scare tactic but on the other hand almost doesn't feel serious and I have a hard time believing that Darnell was genuinely trying to intimidate Whales into moving off him.
As for Whales himself, I think his first post, the one with the "clearly trying to soft that he's gamethrowing" comment, was intended as an RVS post which Darnell took seriously. Despite this, I think it's Whales who had a worse reaction. Darnell essentially asked if Whales's vote was random or serious, and Whales immediately leapt to a "Why do you care?! Also AtE!" response, which to me is an overreaction.
ok a few thoughts
We HAVE to get rid of the cultist
theres no way any faction is gonna reach a majority before n5
Because of this, Beloved Princess is very neg utility. My suggestion is that whoever is the Beloved Princess claims, and we hope scum arent stupid, because we need as many possible deaths as possible before n5, maximising our chances of getting rid of the cultistI mean, Beloved Princess's always negative utility. Them claiming might be a valid strategy; my only reservation is that there's no incentive for scum to not kill them down the road if we successfully lynch the cultist early on. Perhaps the Princess should just claim if they're about to be lynched? Yes, there's a chance they'll end up being nightkilled, but as there are currently 16 players there's a relatively low chance the Princess will end up the lynch target and thus they may be able to stay hidden.
Count Down
Game Difficulty [12/26]
Joke RVS? Boring.
Word Choice, Take Note
Unknown Reveals, Softs Important
~scorrchGreen Herring [10]
Red Herring [3]
Black Herring [1]
Yellow Herring [1]
Blue Herring [1]
Threats: 1>3>1>1
~~~
Ra, Kinich Ahau, Helios, Surya
Snow White, Cinderella, Belle
Both Should Claim
~~~
Cult Common Threat
Princess Should Be Safe
~scorrchI'm in agreement with everything in both of these posts to one extent or another, but is there a reason for phrasing them so vaguely? If there is I don't want to be the one who "explains" it and ruins everything, but I think there's a chance people will overlook it or not realize what you're saying as it is.
INCOMING SOLVED GAME!
Boatman is obviously scum because his picture thing shows him as a minority in direct opposition to 3x as many players as him. Probably solo.
Radicate is clearly scum because Alpha Werewolf.
DBW is Lila, who shot only town, and shooting town hurts town and helps scum, therefore Lila is also scum. Ed is immune to this line of thought because I said so.
Champ is scum because we've got to turbo the new promos. Darnell for the same reason
DreamsX doesn't want to be bothered and is thus a loner, AKA Survivor.
All six scum nailed!
VOTE: Boatman
Henlo mr. mafia player aye am boatman
Aye am a HERO to the people and aye can poke u with a stick
but in all seriousness, Lynch VigilanteVigoroth
posts are him walking in circles trying to seem important to town by stating facts already done, but he otherwise hasn't helped much in terms of info / scumhunting (Yes, I under stand this is d1, but even then he's done next to nothing compared to the other posts)
Another person who's done shit with their posts is xnad, but I'm assuming he's about to post something that's gonna do shit and not just dip on a question
someone decrypt scorrching for me tyHe's saying the solar god and beloved princess should claim and that on a threat level SK > Mafia > Cultrod > Solar God, but cultrod and SK could be switched, not really sure.To respond to the second part of this first, I guess it doesn't matter if I "explain" now. I assumed for some reason that the cultist was "blue", possible just since I interpreted it to be the greatest threat. That's something I wouldn't mind ScorrchingTheaph clearing up, I guess (which color connects to which faction, and if something else is a greater threat than the cultist then why?).
Regarding Vigvig, the game hasn't even gone on for 24 hours and over half the players haven't posted. At the time Vigvig posted especially only five other players had posted in the game. One would be rather hard-pressed to go all-out with scumhunting at that point. Additionally, I don't really think he's "walking in circles" with those posts as the things he brings up (potential Beloved Princess claim and figuring out how many chances we have to kill cult) hadn't actually been brought up at that point.
Question to OM: What made you assume that Xnad but not Vigvig would go on to post something meaningful, and why not mention Sparkli, who at the time had even less than Vigvig?
Re: Sparkli: What do people think of them currently? On one hand I feel like they would feel pressured as scum to "conform" and place a random vote in their first post, but also there's no real reason for them to not place a random vote in said post-they mention being aware that the game is in RVS but then say that they themselves aren't voting because they don't have any scumreads at the time-which, again, there was very little to base said scumreads on anyway. This refers more specifically to their first post. Their second one I can realistically see them as being unwilling to vote due to a lack of strong, scumreads it just throws me off that they felt the need to justify not voting in their first post with "I don't have scumreads" despite mentioning that it was RVS.
Champ1604 and ScorrchingTheaph, what doesn't seem pleasing about Vigvig's reaction? To me it seems NAI, although now that we have a bit more I wouldn't mind hearing from VigilanteVigoroth himself.
plur isnt even on you lmfao
also your terrible ate wont get you anywhere
As for Whales himself, I think his first post, the one with the "clearly trying to soft that he's gamethrowing" comment, was intended as an RVS post which Darnell took seriously. Despite this, I think it's Whales who had a worse reaction. Darnell essentially asked if Whales's vote was random or serious, and Whales immediately leapt to a "Why do you care?! Also AtE!" response, which to me is an overreaction.
We HAVE to get rid of the cultist
theres no way any faction is gonna reach a majority before n5
Because of this, Beloved Princess is very neg utility. My suggestion is that whoever is the Beloved Princess claims, and we hope scum arent stupid, because we need as many possible deaths as possible before n5, maximising our chances of getting rid of the cultist
Game Difficulty [12/26]
Joke RVS? Boring.
Word Choice, Take Note
Unknown Reveals, Softs Important
~scorrch
Red Herring [3]
Black Herring [1]
Yellow Herring [1]
Blue Herring [1]
Threats: 1>3>1>1
~~~
Ra, Kinich Ahau, Helios, Surya
Snow White, Cinderella, Belle
Both Should Claim
~~~
Cult Common Threat
Princess Should Be Safe
~scorrch
Boatman is obviously scum because his picture thing shows him as a minority in direct opposition to 3x as many players as him. Probably solo.
Radicate is clearly scum because Alpha Werewolf.
DBW is Lila, who shot only town, and shooting town hurts town and helps scum, therefore Lila is also scum. Ed is immune to this line of thought because I said so.
Champ is scum because we've got to turbo the new promos. Darnell for the same reason
DreamsX doesn't want to be bothered and is thus a loner, AKA Survivor.
All six scum nailed!
VOTE: Boatman
Aye am a HERO to the people and aye can poke u with a stick
but in all seriousness, Lynch VigilanteVigoroth
posts are him walking in circles trying to seem important to town by stating facts already done, but he otherwise hasn't helped much in terms of info / scumhunting (Yes, I under stand this is d1, but even then he's done next to nothing compared to the other posts)
Another person who's done shit with their posts is xnad, but I'm assuming he's about to post something that's gonna do shit and not just dip on a question
Regarding Vigvig, the game hasn't even gone on for 24 hours and over half the players haven't posted. At the time Vigvig posted especially only five other players had posted in the game. One would be rather hard-pressed to go all-out with scumhunting at that point. Additionally, I don't really think he's "walking in circles" with those posts as the things he brings up (potential Beloved Princess claim and figuring out how many chances we have to kill cult) hadn't actually been brought up at that point.
Question to OM: What made you assume that Xnad but not Vigvig would go on to post something meaningful, and why not mention Sparkli, who at the time had even less than Vigvig?
Re: Sparkli: What do people think of them currently? On one hand I feel like they would feel pressured as scum to "conform" and place a random vote in their first post, but also there's no real reason for them to not place a random vote in said post-they mention being aware that the game is in RVS but then say that they themselves aren't voting because they don't have any scumreads at the time-which, again, there was very little to base said scumreads on anyway. This refers more specifically to their first post. Their second one I can realistically see them as being unwilling to vote due to a lack of strong, scumreads it just throws me off that they felt the need to justify not voting in their first post with "I don't have scumreads" despite mentioning that it was RVS.
Champ1604 and ScorrchingTheaph, what doesn't seem pleasing about Vigvig's reaction? To me it seems NAI, although now that we have a bit more I wouldn't mind hearing from VigilanteVigoroth himself.
