|
|
Post by VigilanteVigoroth on Jan 15, 2018 19:41:13 GMT
hmm
I think the safest play is to lynch Puppy Tactician
We cant be sure his interestest are protown, also he messed up his own claim
We can get the goo tomorrow, or mafia can kill them
Lynch puppy Tactician
|
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Jan 15, 2018 20:02:31 GMT
henlo boatman ees baque
Unlynch vigvig
Lynch Puppy
Puppy I have two question for you.
One. if you are actually the 2s solar god, why didn't you claim earlier? It's in your best interest to remain a wild card for this game, as you win with whatever faction.
Two. Really you'd fuck up your claim that badly?!?!?!?
I'm going to do a larger post later today so yeah
|
|
|
|
Post by Fenrir on Jan 15, 2018 20:07:39 GMT
I still don't have a ton of time right now, but stop that right now and vote someone else to test the Surv claim like myself and Rad mentioned >.>
|
|
|
|
Post by VigilanteVigoroth on Jan 15, 2018 20:46:17 GMT
why would keeping the surv around be useful
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Jan 15, 2018 20:55:18 GMT
<vigvig>why would keeping the surv around be useful
Mafia PGO
Tourists
Surv Conf Not PGO
Unlynch
~scorrch
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Jan 15, 2018 20:59:51 GMT
Surface Level Contribution
Doubled Down On VigVig; Weak Reasoning
Illogical Surv Lynch
Unlynch jumbowhales
Lynch OM Room
~scorrch
|
|
|
|
Post by Rocky Tactician on Jan 15, 2018 21:02:32 GMT
SI- OS Solar God. Only regularly played PS theme with Solar God. Solar god is generally OS anyways. Wasn't paying attention. Enough said. Lynch me if you want It's a bad idea, you'll lose. Lynch cultist instead. ~A Haiku You're forgetting that I can confirm myself. Lynch VigilanteVigorothEither you're just plain stupid, or you're not working in the interest of town, i.e. scum. Lynching survivor takes away one of the few lynches we already have, which is dumb especially when I can confirm myself. And if I weren't the survivor, why would nobody have CC'd by now? "We can't be sure his interests are protown" Why would I work with cult. That would just get me lynched off. Besides, what survivor goes into a game thinking "Oh, I'm going to work with mafia! That's the best way to win!" "We can get the goo tomorrow." This is completely illogical. We have no idea who the goo is, and they are the real threat, not the survivor. You're implying we know who the goo is. Will post again later, feel free to comment especially VigilanteVigoroth |
|
|
|
Post by qtball on Jan 15, 2018 21:40:51 GMT
unlynch Toni lynch Boatman
That's just gut after reading through some of the posts
|
|
|
|
Post by qtball on Jan 15, 2018 21:42:59 GMT
why would keeping the surv around be useful They're not beneficial per se, but why waste a lynch on them when we could be going after mafia / sk / goo thingy although I do town read this comment |
|
|
|
Post by BoredGames on Jan 15, 2018 21:53:24 GMT
icba to quote but "we can get goo tomorrow"
Vigvig, may i just remind you that it's semi reveal upon death, so it comes up as town / not town, therefore we theoretically would never know if cultist is gone (unless host will confirm this or if i'm being stupid and it isn't semi reveal and it actually reveals the role).
It may be nice to think we can hit cultist by day 2's lynch, but realistically we'll never actually know until the we reach night 5.
Please correct me if i'm wrong
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Jan 15, 2018 21:57:42 GMT
Unlynch VigilanteVigoroth
Wrong Unlynch Previous Post
Lynch Stays On bOATMAN
~scorrch
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Jan 15, 2018 22:28:56 GMT
<champ>I am skipping ScorrchingTheaph's post since I'm understanding little from what ScorrchingTheaph is actually saying
Rude
~~~
<fenrir>Scum would want to cc for just about every reason mentioned by Scorrching as well as the fact that town won't focus on them as a lynch target. Mafia PGO in particular benefits from being seen as a "safe Tourist target" for obvious reasons.
False
PGO CC = Every1 Else Safe Target
CC Can Be Disproved
Worthless Gambit
~~~
Puppy: [95] (Surv)
- Conf Scum
Boatman: [70]
- See Previous
VigVig: [65]
- Defensive
- Surv Lynch
Wob: [60]
- Lazy Reads
- Passive
Xnad [55]
- Very Fillery
- Gut Reads
Champ [55]
+ NAI Contributions
- Handpicks Who To Respond To
Bored: [50]
- Empty Wallpost
+ Partially Useful Input
whales: [50]
- Ate
+ Unique Perspective
RAD: [45]
+ Useful Contrib
Fenrir [40]
+ Pfft Tryhard
- Scumreads Where
Sparkli [40]
- Indecisive
+ Effort In Posts
Darnell [30]
+ Calm, Logical
Thunder~BALLZ [30]
+ Town Mindset
Toni: Submsu
DreamsX: Submsu
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Jan 15, 2018 22:29:29 GMT
Forgot To Sign Off
~scorrch
|
|
|
|
Post by peachu on Jan 15, 2018 22:50:16 GMT
tbh this lynch is kinda stupid, idk why we're lynching a 2S Solar God claim, especially since they can prove themselves and if Puppy wasn't Solar God, then the real Solar God probably would've ended day on puppy now (Toni, bored, tbz, vigvig, fenrir, om, rad, sparkli, champ have all been on at least once since Puppy claimed. This is 10/15 of the remaining PL ex. Puppy since its his claim, obviously. p edit: Scorr has been on/posted but idk why members list says he hasnt) So, minusing the 11 p edit: it is actually 12 people (inc. me + puppy) who have been on since Puppy claimed, here's the PL. ScorrchingTheaph, Boatman, Apple, VigilanteVigoroth, RADicate, Fenrir, Puppy Tactician, (jumbowhales), Champ∞1604, Bringer of Chaos, Zeke, Darnell, Broken Jukebox, DreamsX, Wob, Sparkli, Thunder~BALLZ. So that leaves; Bringer of Chaos, Zeke, Darnell, DreamsX and Wob. We can take away Xnad, Darnell and Wob as they have all voted at least once. This leaves DreamsX. So unless DreamsX would like to cc, Puppy is uncc'd. |
|
|
|
Post by Fenrir on Jan 15, 2018 23:48:23 GMT
Guess which film Fenrir just came back from watching. I can hardly focus rn because of "feels" but here we go. VigilanteVigoroth and OM~!, why is lynching Puppy the best option? If he is in fact Survivor he can confirm himself as such while we lynch another scumread in doing so. To Vigvig specifically the proposition that "we can get the goo tomorrow" is contradictory to the work you were doing at the start of the day analyzing how many deaths there will be before day 5 and your comment that we need to use every opportunity we have to lynch the cultist. Also, since you took note of the Survivor claim apparently after 6(?) pages, anything else in those 6(?) pages that stands out to you? To OM, I look forward to that larger post considering that you seem to have dropped all focus on Vigvig in favor of a Puppy lynch. BoredGames you're correct in that we won't know for sure when the cultist is dead (unless host error  ). ScorrchingTheaph, "worthless gambit" comment is true tbf. You mention your previous post regarding your read on OM; is it just the "illogical Surv lynch" or is there more? I ask because one could also say Vigvig made an "illogical Surv lynch" but you moved off him and onto OM. Also smh I'm not even tryharding yet. Re: scumreads, I didn't mention them outright (in part because I still had a ton of questions for people) although right now I'm looking at you, Whales, and more recently Vigvig and OM. peachu (Whales), thank you for the list. Due to both this and the "worthless gambit" mentioned by Scorrching, Puppy's most likely the optimal target if you're a tourist. If you're not a tourist, soft your target somehow in the event your target turns out to be the PGO (low chance, but if you live and Puppy does somehow die we at least have another person we know to be safe to target and if you do die we have something to look back at). I'm currently undecided, although I'm most likely lynching either Vigvig or OM by the end of the day. I'll leave my vote on Whales currently, as with a minor exception due to family dinner I should be on until the 1 AM my time deadline. |
|
|
|
Post by ForgotToFlush on Jan 16, 2018 0:13:09 GMT
~~~~
Lynch-Count {Day 1, #2}
Players:
Hammer Count (Plurality in effect): 9
Votes:
Darnell (1): Jumbowhales
ThunderBALLZ (1): Toni
Toni (1): DeathByWobbuffet
Jumbowhales (2): Fenrir, Darnell
Puppy Tactician (4)*: XnadrojX, Champ1604, VigilanteVigoroth, OM Room
OM Room (2): ScorrchingTheaph, ThunderBALLZ
The deadline is 1/16/18 at 2:00 am (AST) [Approx 5.75 hours]
If the day to were end, Puppy Tactician would be lynched.
~~~~
|
|
|
|
Post by Rocky Tactician on Jan 16, 2018 0:22:01 GMT
Unlynch VigilanteVigorothLynch OM RoomOM~! , yet another illogical surv lyncher. Get off of me, I get off of you. Trying to stay alive and gain the ability to confirm myself. Lynching me makes no sense. Just gives up another day. Would rather lynch VigVig but others seem to disagree. Do what you will, there are five hours left. Visiting ScorrchingTheaph tonight. No need to soft, confirmed tourist. No reason for mafia to waste a kill on me.
|
|
|
|
Post by RADicate on Jan 16, 2018 0:43:09 GMT
Unlynch VigilanteVigorothLynch OM RoomOM~! , yet another illogical surv lyncher. Get off of me, I get off of you. Trying to stay alive and gain the ability to confirm myself. Lynching me makes no sense. Just gives up another day. Would rather lynch VigVig but others seem to disagree. Do what you will, there are five hours left. Visiting ScorrchingTheaph tonight. No need to soft, confirmed tourist. No reason for mafia to waste a kill on me. Umm HELLO PUPPY HOW IS YOUR DAY READ YOUR FRIGGING ROLE PM. -1x 2-Shot Solar God Voteless Tourist (Survivor Win condition) V o t e l e s s I wanna believe that you are what you say you are because confirmable ccing is dumb but you are making it damned hard to. So here is the deal you will end day early today when lynch hopefully isnt on you and we shouldnt be lynching an uncc'd surv as its a waste of a lynch. Cool? Cool. And if day doesnt end early then you are actual scum! Now can we get off the confirmable role thanks. Will be home a bit later than expected to get the rest of my thoughts together but for now get off puppy. |
|
|
|
Post by peachu on Jan 16, 2018 0:48:44 GMT
unlynch Darnellalthough I still don't like his weird/terrible ate in defence to an RVS vote and hasn't done much else, I would like to lynch Boatman. Mainly because lynching Puppy is completely unreasonable and I got scumvibes in the post where OM lynched Puppy. a) "One. if you are actually the 2s solar god, why didn't you claim earlier? It's in your best interest to remain a wild card for this game, as you win with whatever faction." Firstly, if I remember correctly, no one explicitly prompted Solar God to claim besides Scorrch's crypted thing that you decrypted, but while rereading the thread, I failed to notice it. If you wanted Solar God to claim, then you should've prompted Solar God to claim. b) "Really you'd fuck up your claim that badly?!?!?!?" Might just be me, but I find this reaction kind of forced c) "I'm going to do a larger post later today so yeah"  d) Any reason you unlynched VigVig besides the Puppy claim coming up?
|
|
|
|
Post by ForgotToFlush on Jan 16, 2018 0:59:34 GMT
host error
not game breaking tho
votecount fixed
|
|
|
|
Post by Rocky Tactician on Jan 16, 2018 0:59:47 GMT
Wait, why am I voteless
that hurts
somebody get plur off me, this is dumb
if I die, it's not my fault
made an effort to claim
|
|
|
|
Post by ForgotToFlush on Jan 16, 2018 1:00:46 GMT
Apologies for the mistake
|
|
|
|
Post by Rocky Tactician on Jan 16, 2018 1:02:05 GMT
Unlynch VigilanteVigorothLynch OM RoomOM~! , yet another illogical surv lyncher. Get off of me, I get off of you. Trying to stay alive and gain the ability to confirm myself. Lynching me makes no sense. Just gives up another day. Would rather lynch VigVig but others seem to disagree. Do what you will, there are five hours left. Visiting ScorrchingTheaph tonight. No need to soft, confirmed tourist. No reason for mafia to waste a kill on me. Umm HELLO PUPPY HOW IS YOUR DAY READ YOUR FRIGGING ROLE PM. -1x 2-Shot Solar God Voteless Tourist (Survivor Win condition) V o t e l e s s I wanna believe that you are what you say you are because confirmable ccing is dumb but you are making it damned hard to. So here is the deal you will end day early today when lynch hopefully isnt on you and we shouldnt be lynching an uncc'd surv as its a waste of a lynch. Cool? Cool. And if day doesnt end early then you are actual scum! Now can we get off the confirmable role thanks. Will be home a bit later than expected to get the rest of my thoughts together but for now get off puppy. Hello there, RADicate! How's your day been? I hope you realized that you want to confirm me by ending day with plur off me, yet are making no real effort to get plur off me. It would be nice if you could at least try thanks. P l u r s h i f t Am currently home waiting to end the day but for now please get plur off me. |
|
|
|
Post by Fenrir on Jan 16, 2018 1:04:34 GMT
Note that Puppy's vote's been removed from the votecount. There's absolute confirmation for us he's the Survivor, if there was still any doubt.
UNVOTE: Jumbowhales
VOTE: Boatman
Either this or Vigvig would be a good lynch for today, and if this is the one that keeps us from wasting a lynch on the Survivor so be it.
|
|
|
|
Post by Rocky Tactician on Jan 16, 2018 1:07:33 GMT
VigilanteVigorothYour reasoning makes no sense. I can't be anti-town, I can't lynch. All I do is end the day. And tourist at night. Get off me now. I am confirmed.
|
|
).
