Classic Mafia (GG Mafia)

[Fenrir]

Dec 6, 2018 3:07:28 GMT Cantius said:

Dec 6, 2018 3:05:34 GMT Fenrir said:

I don't follow this. IF I got plurality and claimed I'd claim Doctor.  FtF likely wouldn't counterclaim during Day 3 and would just move on to elsewhere. 

Fenrir is scum: We lynch him. Game over.
FTF is scum: Fenrir claims doc. We move on, and FTF kills Fenrir. Now we lynch FTF because TBZ is obv town.

Scum!FtF has no way of knowing I'm doctor when he makes that vote during Day 3. This potential sequence of events has no way of being in his head at the time he did that; you're approaching it as if he knew I was the Doctor when he voted me then.

[ForgotToFlush]

Dec 6, 2018 3:10:14 GMT Fenrir said:

Dec 6, 2018 3:07:28 GMT Cantius said:

Fenrir is scum: We lynch him. Game over.
FTF is scum: Fenrir claims doc. We move on, and FTF kills Fenrir. Now we lynch FTF because TBZ is obv town.

Scum!FtF has no way of knowing I'm doctor when he makes that vote during Day 3. This potential sequence of events has no way of being in his head at the time he did that; you're approaching it as if he knew I was the Doctor when he voted me then.

let the record show that FTF has insane PR reads
see: Hydra Game 4
but yeah Cantius you really do like over thinking things don't ya

[Cantius]

Dec 6, 2018 3:26:03 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

Dec 6, 2018 3:10:14 GMT Fenrir said:

Scum!FtF has no way of knowing I'm doctor when he makes that vote during Day 3. This potential sequence of events has no way of being in his head at the time he did that; you're approaching it as if he knew I was the Doctor when he voted me then.

let the record show that FTF has insane PR reads
see: Hydra Game 4
but yeah Cantius you really do like over thinking things don't ya

smh this is an argument against yourself

[Cantius]

But why would FTF lynch the Doctor as either alignment if he knew it...

[Cantius]

VOTE Fenrir
tbh I don't really care about this anymore

[ForgotToFlush]

Dec 6, 2018 3:47:17 GMT Cantius said:

Dec 6, 2018 3:26:03 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

let the record show that FTF has insane PR reads
see: Hydra Game 4
but yeah Cantius you really do like over thinking things don't ya

smh this is an argument against yourself

the game is a learning experience after all

[ForgotToFlush]

SPOILER: Click to show

[chapterseven]

HAMMER

The town lynched Fenrir , the Town Doctor, meaning that this game's winners are ForgotToFlush the Mafia Goon & Alexander489 the Mafia Pretty Man.



For the attacthed gif I just imagine Alex as Maya giving moral support in the back.


Alright hit me with feedback. What did you thinking of my hosting?, would you join another forum game hoster by me / in general etc. You can also talk about how you thought the game went as always. And ofc there's gonna be that one person who says they knew the scun team Day 1 and is gonna pop up and say that.

[chapterseven]

I'll do a full opnion of everything later but overall I thought this game was really good, only thing I could have asked for was more newbie players lmao because I think like 6/8 have played a forum game here before. But this was really good and I plan on hosting another Newbie game, if I did what type of game would you guys like it to be? 

[ForgotToFlush]

great game, well hosted
idm subbing into a newbie game in the future

[ForgotToFlush]

oh also I really appreciated the timely sub-ins

[Kaif]

ftf was scum after all, smh cantius

[spiderz]

I called them as scum d2

[Alexander489]

aye <3

[Alexander489]

was pretty fun for my first forum game just kept forgetting about it lol and got bodied

[chapterseven]

Dec 6, 2018 11:34:55 GMT spiderz said:

I called them as scum d2

Ok this actually did happen and I have logs of it so not calling bs on this one. Spiderz lowkey goat even though he didnt play.

[Kaif]

PogChamp Spiderz