|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Aug 20, 2019 11:03:17 GMT
Is this game worth a full read up? I skimmed a little, and from what I saw, surv didn't claim and is likely dead, leaving us with maf/sk/cult. Absolutely yes. |
|
|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Aug 20, 2019 11:07:19 GMT
Also Fort Colorcastle re: Fen, it's mostly bc most of my suspicions against his slot are relational - things like votes, interactions with other players, etc. Moreover, I don't see solo scum calling attention to their fishiness like that when they're head is on the chopping block. |
|
|
|
Post by Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪ on Aug 20, 2019 11:11:38 GMT
Reiterating that, especially given how little Drook gave us, it's important imo that we get your full thoughts on the game as it has developed.
Zorq lynch seems tasty, someone should give me a reason not to jump on
I won't be home tonight so hmu early if you need me
|
|
|
|
Post by qtball on Aug 20, 2019 16:37:19 GMT
Im being adamant about ani being town and i am probably wrong about it but people seem too quick to hop on it
|
|
|
|
Post by Fort Colorcastle on Aug 20, 2019 20:12:55 GMT
ok now that I actually read the paragraph I can respond to it confusion is not feigned. not sure why you insist on reading it as fake. asame for the references to mafia. you're overthinking it I'm literally talking to the mafia. bif you really think I haven't been engaging with actual content then I suggest you actually read my iso. I think you've just been noticing my questions because I'm the only one asking them. and because I have a lot of posts, so maybe you'll see a post with just a question cI notice that you came at me yesterday for activity? I responded but like.... ? are we in the same game? da. Explained literally in the post your responding to. It comes across that way because I don't see you consistently trying to make sense of the things you're confused about. b. I mean you can say I'm overthinking it, and maybe I am, but I don't see the utility of it. It's not like we're talking about persuading folks to claim, or arguing for a certain shot to happen overnight--today's goo lynch is, as you said, necessary for all living players' wincon. I guess I just don't see the point of you making such a visible fuss about that. c. I don't mean to suggest you're never engaging with meaningful post, I'm saying there's a pattern of you asking low-effort questions and moving on. Like, there's a difference between a generative question like this or this, compared to this (context made it extremely apparent that I was waiting on Neo's post, and you didn't so much as touch that) or this (i don't understand a world where you're only commentary on that post is a question that can be answered by googling). I'll fetch more if you need them, but my point is this: I'm not saying it's always the case, I'm saying it's enough of a trend that it's caught my attention. d. Spoke on this yesterday so I'm not sure why it's coming back up--you just happened to make a disappointing post at a time. Activity is actually one of the things I don't fault you for. e) You didn't really go into it here, but I read back to see if I could better understand your position on Ani. You've said your open to the possibility of him being goo, but that you're not willing to lynch him today because you can't know for sure. That falls a bit flat for me, but if there's more to it please share - like, if there's a chance of him being goo, by your own admission, and if all players need to prioritize a goo lynch today, by your own admission, why is ani off the table entirely?
that's a lot to respond to. before I start, I'm very disappointed I didn't wake up to more people's content
a) my attempts to try and make sense of the things im confused about are the questions I ask.
b) my thoughts yesterday was "if mafia doesn't want to kill umbrella, who has such a strong possibility of being goo, then they're pushing the onus onto the lynch for that slot and you know what fk that nope im not doing it" HOWEVER now im thinking its possible that umbrella is just mafia which is why mafia hasn't killed them.
c) i admit i haven't googled anything but i could just ask and get an answer. the game is moving pretty fast, so there's usually something new for me to look at by the time i get an answer.
d) oh i must've missed your statement
e) i meant that i don't have to lynch him today because i can't know for sure. i'm just not doing it because of what i said yesterday. its literally that simple don't overthink.
all in all i think you're just overestimating the amount of effort i'm putting into this game and overthinking my actions as a result.
also i just thought of something: goo could claim mafia today if they're in danger of being lynched lmao
|
|
|
|
Post by Fort Colorcastle on Aug 20, 2019 21:39:08 GMT
also for the final point drookez got subbed out for ?, who has been posting do you have any thoughts on the second part of that bullet? honestly i barely have any impressions on them. However, since he got subbed out, I think it was more likely due to genuine inactivity instead of carefully calculated lurking (see: umbrella's exactly 5 posts in a day and then didnt respond to your prodding at all) |
|
|
|
Post by Umbrella on Aug 20, 2019 21:51:58 GMT
Alright, unfortunate mislynch there but it would’ve been a miss either way. I’m leaning towards lynching vooper and see what’s happening with scorrching today. can you expand on that a bit also, do you have any thoughts on days 3/4 more generally? yes, I haven’t really been a fan of Vooper’s posts this game, honestly like half of them seem not related to the game and the other half feel like he’s trying to force himself to seem town. Last day the neo lynch wasn’t awful tbh but I think that their were probably better options although I don’t think anyone was shifting off the two wagons at the time. |
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Aug 20, 2019 22:37:17 GMT
Going at this with the hindsight of knowing flips but not whether or not they died from lynches/nk.
Page 1-3: edwardzealchemist looks like maf rather than sk to me; meaning Schia not maf. Zorquax is also a genius he predicted 32nd post. Fort admitting to taking Animale's bait doesn't seem geniune to me. I do not like how he pretends to not know who "ani" is and then proceeds to unlynch "Ani" and feign confusion. VigVig opening about edzard rubs me the wrong way b/c it is borderline filler and does not actually state anything about gamestate.
Page 4-6: Don't like Fort's take on Zorro, especially b/c he doesn't put a lynch behind it until a bunch of posts after his read. Thinking that VigVig might just be lazy. Edward's comment on sadnar makes me thinkg they are not scum team. ed/fen interaction looks like ed trying to appeal to fen and have fen not lynch him.
To be continued...
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Aug 20, 2019 22:38:28 GMT
Is this game worth a full read up? I skimmed a little, and from what I saw, surv didn't claim and is likely dead, leaving us with maf/sk/cult. most people atm think ed was sk I would ask "who is 'most people?'" but a majority does not prove anything. Want to provide some evidence behind this read? inb4 it is very clearly stated somewhere and I haven't read it because I'm not done reading up |
|
|
|
Post by ForgotToFlush on Aug 21, 2019 0:02:29 GMT
Sub Notice:
cyan has subbed in for VigilanteVigoroth
Additionally, here's a public reminder that Rule 10 is still in effect.
|
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Aug 21, 2019 0:04:20 GMT
Consider this my confirmation post, then. Tapatalk notifications FTW
I've got a lot to do later, so I won't make any catch-up posts in probably the next 12 hours or so. Rest assured, I'll try as much as I can.
|
|
|
|
Post by ForgotToFlush on Aug 21, 2019 0:11:06 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Aug 21, 2019 0:14:10 GMT
Page 7-9: Don't like VigVig's blatant sheep of tbz. Mindmeld most of what spiderz said. Wp soft from Mylo; don't agree with Schia's take though. Scum doesn't want to fake claim macho. Not surprised by lack of explanation behind Vig's reads. All he's saying is "mild TR" with nothing to back it up.
Page 10-12: And ofc Vigilante hops on Dull wagon. Mindmeld w/ Quacker about Vigoroth. Weak rebuttal to spiderz from Fort. Deflects to Alex for no apparent reason, and describes himself as "easy picking" when there are people actively tring him. Decent reads from Fen slot imo.
Page 12-14: Neo's case on vooper is interesting, as I was tonereading his as town. Disagree with his framing of thunder pocketing ani. BALLZ tends to strongly defend a townread D1, although I may be biased as I have animole as a townlean. I don't see narwhal commenting anything about spiderz, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think naruto-not-kun tripping. Edward's post about PGO is bull; mental gymnastics to fuel a lynch. Continues to dig his own grave etc etc (skimming his posts). VigVig soft defense bad, same with ten-77. Don't like voop's response to R++: "let me know if u wanna talk heart"
Read alchemist as SK, FFFF as maf, arachnid as surv/goo, sadistic maf. (subject to change)
Page 15-19: Imagine posting a dictionary screenshot and being wrong. Interesting that banana spritzee is still alive after his claim. Fort pulling percentages out of his bum. Thunder's annoyance at Fort parking seems geniune. No idea what a morphosyntactic is, but Fort got BTFO. :vigvig: lynching for low activity seems like cw attempt. Mindmeld w/ Fen (again). Zeal's read of Zeep as not SK again seems like TMI. "I am still certain scum r gonna bus me" What did he mean by this? Vigoroth complaining about "low effort scumhunting" seems quite hypocritical.
To be continued...
|
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Aug 21, 2019 0:16:41 GMT
that last post has ultimately discouraged me from putting effort in reading the early game, but it's nice to see effort made in this game
I'll try the last few pages, I guess?
|
|
|
|
Post by Fort Colorcastle on Aug 21, 2019 0:31:40 GMT
most people atm think ed was sk I would ask "who is 'most people?'" but a majority does not prove anything. Want to provide some evidence behind this read? inb4 it is very clearly stated somewhere and I haven't read it because I'm not done reading up i can't give evidence about who is most people, but the reason I am convinced he was sk is because we've been down to 1, 0, and 1 kills per night respectively since he died. |
|
|
|
Post by Fort Colorcastle on Aug 21, 2019 0:50:22 GMT
Page 7-9: Don't like VigVig's blatant sheep of tbz. Mindmeld most of what spiderz said. Wp soft from Mylo; don't agree with Schia's take though. Scum doesn't want to fake claim macho. Not surprised by lack of explanation behind Vig's reads. All he's saying is "mild TR" with nothing to back it up. Page 10-12: And ofc Vigilante hops on Dull wagon. Mindmeld w/ Quacker about Vigoroth. Weak rebuttal to spiderz from Fort. Deflects to Alex for no apparent reason, and describes himself as "easy picking" when there are people actively tring him. Decent reads from Fen slot imo. Page 12-14: Neo's case on vooper is interesting, as I was tonereading his as town. Disagree with his framing of thunder pocketing ani. BALLZ tends to strongly defend a townread D1, although I may be biased as I have animole as a townlean. I don't see narwhal commenting anything about spiderz, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think naruto-not-kun tripping. Edward's post about PGO is bull; mental gymnastics to fuel a lynch. Continues to dig his own grave etc etc (skimming his posts). VigVig soft defense bad, same with ten-77. Don't like voop's response to R++: "let me know if u wanna talk heart" Read alchemist as SK, FFFF as maf, arachnid as surv/goo, sadistic maf. (subject to change) Page 15-19: Imagine posting a dictionary screenshot and being wrong. Interesting that banana spritzee is still alive after his claim. Fort pulling percentages out of his bum. Thunder's annoyance at Fort parking seems geniune. No idea what a morphosyntactic is, but Fort got BTFO.  lynching for low activity seems like cw attempt. Mindmeld w/ Fen (again). Zeal's read of Zeep as not SK again seems like TMI. "I am still certain scum r gonna bus me" What did he mean by this? Vigoroth complaining about "low effort scumhunting" seems quite hypocritical. To be continued... this isn't even me being petulant i legit cannot tell what a third of the nicknames/abbreviations you're using refer to.
the fact that you keep using different names for the same person just makes it more confusing. After rereading this post 4 times, I understood a few more but still have no idea what Quacker, animole, naruto-not-kun, ten-77, FFFF, BTFO, and Zeal are.
-----
ok about the content itself
Who is the subject of this sentence? "Deflects to Alex for no apparent reason, and describes himself as "easy picking" when there are people actively tring him." If you meant me, I explained the reasoning in my response to fenrir in my first post of the next day. But I don't remember describing myself as easy picking?
so much of your first big paragraph was spent commenting negatively on vigvig, and yet your readslist doesn't mention him at all?
i see you responding to a shitpost in a summary/reaction post. nice! im glad that filler was important enough for your post I'm glad you realized those %s were pulled out of nowhere. Just like ed's gamesolve-based lynch. I'm also glad that was important enough for you to comment on, but not the neo/vooper interaction going on.
---
I'll be honest here...
I think we found vigvig's scumbuddy.
If day goes to tomorrow I'm going to lynch this slot just because it takes me way too much brainpower to read his post.
|
|
|
|
Post by Fort Colorcastle on Aug 21, 2019 0:50:44 GMT
*if game goes to next day phase
is what my last sentence there meant
|
|
|
|
Post by Fort Colorcastle on Aug 21, 2019 0:51:19 GMT
that last post has ultimately discouraged me from putting effort in reading the early game, but it's nice to see effort made in this game I'll try the last few pages, I guess? no, go read it for yourself. That was such a bad summary you need more than that. |
|
|
|
Post by qtball on Aug 21, 2019 3:26:44 GMT
can honestly see quax+fenrir at this point, their wagons together and relative passiveness this game lead me to believe theyre scum
|
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Aug 21, 2019 3:55:46 GMT
this isn't even me being petulant i legit cannot tell what a third of the nicknames/abbreviations you're using refer to.the fact that you keep using different names for the same person just makes it more confusing. After rereading this post 4 times, I understood a few more but still have no idea what Quacker, animole, naruto-not-kun, ten-77, FFFF, BTFO, and Zeal are. Zorquax, Animallover77, NeoNaruto, Zeep, Fort, blown the fuck out, edwardzealchemist Who is the subject of this sentence? "Deflects to Alex for no apparent reason, and describes himself as "easy picking" when there are people actively tring him." If you meant me, I explained the reasoning in my response to fenrir in my first post of the next day. But I don't remember describing myself as easy picking? If you read my previous sentence you can tell that I am referring to you. There's no need to rely on memory when your words are set in stone. ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/61611/threadso much of your first big paragraph was spent commenting negatively on vigvig, and yet your readslist doesn't mention him at all? What you call my readlist includes three dead players and you. It is a list of scumreads along with alignment reads. It is far from final for obvious reasons and I am unsure about VigVig because he's not the roundest spoon in the bowl when it comes to forum games. i see you responding to a shitpost in a summary/reaction post. nice! im glad that filler was important enough for your post I'm glad you realized those %s were pulled out of nowhere. Just like ed's gamesolve-based lynch. I'm also glad that was important enough for you to comment on, but not the neo/vooper interaction going on. You're "shading" me because I made an off-hand comment about how Schiavetto schooled your shitpost? So what was the point in making up those percentages? Don't deflect to the neo/vooper interaction that I actually did comment on. I'm not sure if you're trying to cherry-pick or if you didn't read my post. Neo's case on vooper is interesting, as I was tonereading his as town. [...] Don't like voop's response to R++: "let me know if u wanna talk heart" If day goes to tomorrow I'm going to lynch this slot just because it takes me way too much brainpower to read his post. t. brainlet |
|
|
|
Post by Umbrella on Aug 21, 2019 4:03:18 GMT
this isn't even me being petulant i legit cannot tell what a third of the nicknames/abbreviations you're using refer to.the fact that you keep using different names for the same person just makes it more confusing. After rereading this post 4 times, I understood a few more but still have no idea what Quacker, animole, naruto-not-kun, ten-77, FFFF, BTFO, and Zeal are. Zorquax, Animallover77, NeoNaruto, Zeep, Fort, blown the fuck out, edwardzealchemist Who is the subject of this sentence? "Deflects to Alex for no apparent reason, and describes himself as "easy picking" when there are people actively tring him." If you meant me, I explained the reasoning in my response to fenrir in my first post of the next day. But I don't remember describing myself as easy picking? If you read my previous sentence you can tell that I am referring to you. There's no need to rely on memory when your words are set in stone. ps-mafia.proboards.com/post/61611/threadso much of your first big paragraph was spent commenting negatively on vigvig, and yet your readslist doesn't mention him at all? What you call my readlist includes three dead players and you. It is a list of scumreads along with alignment reads. It is far from final for obvious reasons and I am unsure about VigVig because he's not the roundest spoon in the bowl when it comes to forum games. i see you responding to a shitpost in a summary/reaction post. nice! im glad that filler was important enough for your post I'm glad you realized those %s were pulled out of nowhere. Just like ed's gamesolve-based lynch. I'm also glad that was important enough for you to comment on, but not the neo/vooper interaction going on. You're "shading" me because I made an off-hand comment about how Schiavetto schooled your shitpost? So what was the point in making up those percentages? Don't deflect to the neo/vooper interaction that I actually did comment on. I'm not sure if you're trying to cherry-pick or if you didn't read my post. Neo's case on vooper is interesting, as I was tonereading his as town. [...] Don't like voop's response to R++: "let me know if u wanna talk heart" If day goes to tomorrow I'm going to lynch this slot just because it takes me way too much brainpower to read his post. t. brainlet Scorrching said period I- Okay maybe I’m forced to stan..❤️ |
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Aug 21, 2019 4:08:00 GMT
Scorrching said period I- Okay maybe I’m forced to stan..❤️ dont❤️me |
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Aug 21, 2019 4:27:14 GMT
Page 19-22: Fort's immediate frame of Neo as conf scum after BALLZ's inspect is extremely disingenuous. Subpar play from tbz imo, but he's uncced so it's whatever and maybe I'm blinded by hindsight. Mindmeld with Schia here. I think Ed was SK based on previously saying "I wont claim surviour BECAUSE i am not surviour." Wifom attempt because he's afraid of surv cc but wants the benefit of softing it. Spicy claim from VigVig. I'll get back to it later because night actions/flips. The following posts are in chronological order. I can't figure out whether or not Fort thinks tbz's track indicates scum!NeoNaruto or not. actually considering that we have confscum there's no need to wagon this early unlynch neowe can always lynch him later lol also please do use brain like actually schia is right; your result doesn't mean anything every single town tourist visited a townread/pr claim i want you to not lynch him today so you stop tunnelling and actually be productive with the day instead of lynching someone you already know is scum posts are refering to neo/tbz. reread context if youre confused To be continued... |
|
|
|
Post by ScorrchingTheaph on Aug 21, 2019 4:29:53 GMT
Lynch Fort
|
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Aug 21, 2019 8:18:35 GMT
I'll just play my standard cards here. Can you make a brief statement on why you read Fort as scum? Meanwhile, I think I could use a recap of who's claimed what roles and targets. |
|
