|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 18, 2020 17:28:18 GMT
oh and sfl slot is cool i guess. Pro town, if you want to push the slot find a partner to flip, the activity is appreciated
|
|
|
|
Post by ddlcfan69 on Oct 18, 2020 18:29:16 GMT
Im with litt this format is not fun. Not sure if I should claim role or not so will wait but is there a way to see the roles of the game?
|
|
|
|
Post by passthesaltdude on Oct 18, 2020 18:59:19 GMT
Hey, I’m checking in again. Plur is on Derz if I know how to do math.
Cyan and Fen seems like good town for me at least, they’ve given reads and have asked questions.
I do like the way Gary has been pressuring Penguin and I do think that there’s a chance the penguin slot flips scum, I’ll end up lynching that slot in an hour or two if I get the chance.
We really need to keep an eye on OM since he just kind of dipped after a bit with no real substance to add.
I know that gut reads exist Litt but I’d love to see some substance on me, not required I just want to get into your headspace
Most slots once again have been too inactive to get anything from so it’s a little unfortunate.
|
|
|
|
Post by PenguinD on Oct 18, 2020 19:07:19 GMT
ddlc it’s a closed setup, if roles were known I think they are posted before game start.
|
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 18, 2020 19:08:59 GMT
Hey, I’m checking in again. Plur is on Derz if I know how to do math. Cyan and Fen seems like good town for me at least, they’ve given reads and have asked questions. I do like the way Gary has been pressuring Penguin and I do think that there’s a chance the penguin slot flips scum, I’ll end up lynching that slot in an hour or two if I get the chance. We really need to keep an eye on OM since he just kind of dipped after a bit with no real substance to add. I know that gut reads exist Litt but I’d love to see some substance on me, not required I just want to get into your headspace Most slots once again have been too inactive to get anything from so it’s a little unfortunate. a) you thinking that gary is actually pressuring penguin is either coming from a skimming phase, or from scum motivated to support another's push; but this makes you scum, not gary. Said pressure's not going anywhere, it's distributed in a deflecting way, I don't see how you'd think that Gary is actively pressuring Penguin D as a push and, where Penguin's reactions were scum motivated. b) Do you want to state your basis for the Penguin SR? All you've thrown about are general ideas, I'd love you explaining what you're thinking on the slot rn |
|
|
|
Post by chaostrodon on Oct 18, 2020 19:17:08 GMT
I would like for litteleven to explain his town reads |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 18, 2020 19:20:50 GMT
I would like for litteleven to explain his town reads and I would like for you to try hypoing why I read them first, or name whichever ones you think don't make sense with a line of reasoning why. It's 3 people, should be easy, right? |
|
|
|
Post by passthesaltdude on Oct 18, 2020 19:41:20 GMT
Hey, I’m checking in again. Plur is on Derz if I know how to do math. Cyan and Fen seems like good town for me at least, they’ve given reads and have asked questions. I do like the way Gary has been pressuring Penguin and I do think that there’s a chance the penguin slot flips scum, I’ll end up lynching that slot in an hour or two if I get the chance. We really need to keep an eye on OM since he just kind of dipped after a bit with no real substance to add. I know that gut reads exist Litt but I’d love to see some substance on me, not required I just want to get into your headspace Most slots once again have been too inactive to get anything from so it’s a little unfortunate. a) you thinking that gary is actually pressuring penguin is either coming from a skimming phase, or from scum motivated to support another's push; but this makes you scum, not gary. Said pressure's not going anywhere, it's distributed in a deflecting way, I don't see how you'd think that Gary is actively pressuring Penguin D as a push and, where Penguin's reactions were scum motivated. b) Do you want to state your basis for the Penguin SR? All you've thrown about are general ideas, I'd love you explaining what you're thinking on the slot rn First off, I love how I asked why you SR me and you told me why using that post, you stated a sr on me when I had 2 posts and you didn’t clarify why, and when you clarified why it was on my new third post. I should say this, I liked how Gary called out Penguins talk about the filler with OM. It seemed like pressure to me, then again I haven’t fully sat down and looked at everything yet. I also think it’s clear to note, that I never stated a sr on penguin or an intent to fully push them, but when I look at the current wagons a lot of them have 0 substance and I see no reason to be on them. I don’t like the penguin slot from how it’s called stuff out while still making lazy points without any backbone. The slot seems to say stuff that don’t really push town in a new direction. Just like you have said stuff and then given reasoning later, like you flipped a coin to find scum and then gave a reason ( I know you didn’t, since that’s against the rules, but you get the metaphor) I would love to know who a better lynch than penguin is, because all I’m looking for is a good lynch. |
|
|
|
Post by chaostrodon on Oct 18, 2020 19:48:30 GMT
Neither small nor OM have posted enough for me to attempt reading them. OM has parked on someone and small is on an afk player
I would agree with you on Penguin D's comment getting undue attention but that is still NAI , dont see where the town read came from . Tone , maybe?
|
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 18, 2020 20:19:27 GMT
Currently working will be baxk in 2-3 hours but
unlynch, lynch gts
Foh w that wack ass loq into peng there are better pushes
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 18, 2020 21:02:27 GMT
ok so preliminary reads: OM town | peng town | small town ddlc fan /chaos have undue attention for seemingly lackluster comments, sl ptsd here lynch ptsdderz is getting paid to perform like shit, gary is making 0 progress with questions, idfk what chaos is doing here. blurb is fair as a policy i refuse to read fen All small did was flavor claim and say I agree fen softed at the time of this post and that makes them a tr? okay |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 18, 2020 21:05:23 GMT
zz Am I not allowed to question someone without it being an activr push?
Absolutely nowhere did I call them scum, nor did I lynch them. In the words of Penguin, "I saw what they did as odd."
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 18, 2020 21:07:47 GMT
I would like for litteleven to explain his town reads and I would like for you to try hypoing why I read them first, or name whichever ones you think don't make sense with a line of reasoning why. It's 3 people, should be easy, right? Gets mad at me for distributing pressure in a "deflective" manner and then proceeds to completely deflect the question. This is the exact same scenario where Penguin just ignored my question and threw something else back at me |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 18, 2020 21:09:02 GMT
I've asked you about your reasoning for small with reasons why I don't think it should be
|
|
|
|
Post by PenguinD on Oct 18, 2020 22:04:21 GMT
and I would like for you to try hypoing why I read them first, or name whichever ones you think don't make sense with a line of reasoning why. It's 3 people, should be easy, right? Gets mad at me for distributing pressure in a "deflective" manner and then proceeds to completely deflect the question. This is the exact same scenario where Penguin just ignored my question and threw something else back at me Huh?? |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 18, 2020 22:21:25 GMT
Penguin I'm saying how at first you avoided my question and instead through one at me.
Litt did the same thing to chaos there
|
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 18, 2020 22:35:38 GMT
zz Am I not allowed to question someone without it being an activr push? Absolutely nowhere did I call them scum, nor did I lynch them. In the words of Penguin, "I saw what they did as odd." In this case yes, you are stalling your own progress by not scum hunting, and the entirety of your conversation with penguin has been cyclical so far. Make headway or you're not making way |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 18, 2020 23:52:06 GMT
ok so preliminary reads: OM town | peng town | small town ddlc fan /chaos have undue attention for seemingly lackluster comments, sl ptsd here lynch ptsdderz is getting paid to perform like shit, gary is making 0 progress with questions, idfk what chaos is doing here. blurb is fair as a policy i refuse to read fen Scumteam is litt and fenrir thank me later |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 18, 2020 23:54:29 GMT
a) you thinking that gary is actually pressuring penguin is either coming from a skimming phase, or from scum motivated to support another's push; but this makes you scum, not gary. Said pressure's not going anywhere, it's distributed in a deflecting way, I don't see how you'd think that Gary is actively pressuring Penguin D as a push and, where Penguin's reactions were scum motivated. b) Do you want to state your basis for the Penguin SR? All you've thrown about are general ideas, I'd love you explaining what you're thinking on the slot rn First off, I love how I asked why you SR me and you told me why using that post, you stated a sr on me when I had 2 posts and you didn’t clarify why, and when you clarified why it was on my new third post. I should say this, I liked how Gary called out Penguins talk about the filler with OM. It seemed like pressure to me, then again I haven’t fully sat down and looked at everything yet. I also think it’s clear to note, that I never stated a sr on penguin or an intent to fully push them, but when I look at the current wagons a lot of them have 0 substance and I see no reason to be on them. I don’t like the penguin slot from how it’s called stuff out while still making lazy points without any backbone. The slot seems to say stuff that don’t really push town in a new direction. Just like you have said stuff and then given reasoning later, like you flipped a coin to find scum and then gave a reason ( I know you didn’t, since that’s against the rules, but you get the metaphor) I would love to know who a better lynch than penguin is, because all I’m looking for is a good lynch. Im on mobile so my formatting will be horrendous. Why u just settling here fam wtf get up and attem fight those scum Would like you to like, unironically pressure those you consider odd. I know you thought chaos / ddlc got undue attention - how come? |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 18, 2020 23:55:32 GMT
^ Thats bad wording eye meant that eye cant vote today Bitch get back here and help Sl derz for this btw |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 18, 2020 23:56:43 GMT
Chaos has actually progressed fairly nicely here and I think im going to safely says he is town for the foreseeable future.
Those r all my thoughts 4 now
Ok now pretend those were all one post thanks
|
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Oct 19, 2020 0:40:28 GMT
Im with litt this format is not fun. Not sure if I should claim role or not so will wait but is there a way to see the roles of the game? Forum games are all about taking your time to form reads - you don't have to check in every hour or so. Also, this is U-Pick, everyone (presumably with one or two exceptions) got a role they wanted to play as. I would like for litteleven to explain his town reads Fair question, but are there any of those that you disagree with? Also, what reads do you have? Would be nice to get some transparecy out of you, so everyone's on equal footing. zz Am I not allowed to question someone without it being an activr push? Absolutely nowhere did I call them scum, nor did I lynch them. In the words of Penguin, "I saw what they did as odd." In this case yes, you are stalling your own progress by not scum hunting, and the entirety of your conversation with penguin has been cyclical so far. Make headway or you're not making way. Generally good advice from OM here - but if anything I'd point out that I townlean Gary from their stance and tone towards this line of questioning. That said, I can work with Penguin D being town as well, although I'd like for them to speak up more. No thoughts about the rest of the PL, but I would prefer a blurb lynch over the rest if shit hits the fan. |
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Oct 19, 2020 0:42:33 GMT
Chaos has actually progressed fairly nicely here and I think im going to safely says he is town for the foreseeable future. Those r all my thoughts 4 now Ok now pretend those were all one post thanks kind of struggling to see what makes you townlean chaostrodon ngl. not saying he's scum/town, but for what it's worth i can't discern anything about him from the few posts he has made |
|
|
|
Post by OM~! on Oct 19, 2020 1:22:36 GMT
Chaos has actually progressed fairly nicely here and I think im going to safely says he is town for the foreseeable future. Those r all my thoughts 4 now Ok now pretend those were all one post thanks kind of struggling to see what makes you townlean chaostrodon ngl. not saying he's scum/town, but for what it's worth i can't discern anything about him from the few posts he has made Mindset from those two seem pro-scumhunty and I like the day 1 attempt to get hooks into reads  |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 19, 2020 2:39:55 GMT
Sorry, I keep on forgetting about this game and I never feel like I have anything useful to add to the conversation. Penguin D does seem to just be trying to say useful stuff without looking deep into it, like many others have already pointed out. It’s mainly just ‘I don’t like -‘ without any explanation or reason to it, it seems a little lazy and forced. For the most part this has been kind of quiet and I don’t have anything new or different to add, so I’ll check back in in about 4 hours is the original post from which the read originated, you're trying to basically leech off an interaction, and this doesn't make sense especially when that interaction was net fruitless. a) you thinking that gary is actually pressuring penguin is either coming from a skimming phase, or from scum motivated to support another's push; but this makes you scum, not gary. Said pressure's not going anywhere, it's distributed in a deflecting way, I don't see how you'd think that Gary is actively pressuring Penguin D as a push and, where Penguin's reactions were scum motivated. b) Do you want to state your basis for the Penguin SR? All you've thrown about are general ideas, I'd love you explaining what you're thinking on the slot rn First off, I love how I asked why you SR me and you told me why using that post, you stated a sr on me when I had 2 posts and you didn’t clarify why, and when you clarified why it was on my new third post. I should say this, I liked how Gary called out Penguins talk about the filler with OM. It seemed like pressure to me, then again I haven’t fully sat down and looked at everything yet. I also think it’s clear to note, that I never stated a sr on penguin or an intent to fully push them, but when I look at the current wagons a lot of them have 0 substance and I see no reason to be on them. I don’t like the penguin slot from how it’s called stuff out while still making lazy points without any backbone. The slot seems to say stuff that don’t really push town in a new direction. Just like you have said stuff and then given reasoning later, like you flipped a coin to find scum and then gave a reason ( I know you didn’t, since that’s against the rules, but you get the metaphor) I would love to know who a better lynch than penguin is, because all I’m looking for is a good lynch. That's exactly the problem, it's not pressure you're looking at, it's a bunch of interactions that don't progress the gamestate. I updated my lean with your additional input but a) that's perfectly normal to do b) doesn't change what I have. also selflynch is a good one
ok so preliminary reads: OM town | peng town | small town ddlc fan /chaos have undue attention for seemingly lackluster comments, sl ptsd here lynch ptsdderz is getting paid to perform like shit, gary is making 0 progress with questions, idfk what chaos is doing here. blurb is fair as a policy i refuse to read fen All small did was flavor claim and say I agree fen softed at the time of this post and that makes them a tr? okay this sounds reasonably salty, idk why you're trying to discredit my TRs if you have no reason to push them. Are you just mad nobody sees your page long interaction with Penguin D as definitive town? I'll detail why I made those TRs if you really want transparency and I would like for you to try hypoing why I read them first, or name whichever ones you think don't make sense with a line of reasoning why. It's 3 people, should be easy, right? Gets mad at me for distributing pressure in a "deflective" manner and then proceeds to completely deflect the question. This is the exact same scenario where Penguin just ignored my question and threw something else back at me Except, this is a 100% constructive setting i.e arguing about reads. 1. It isn't the same situation by a long shot, and 2. Giving out free info without asking people to meet them half way is only going to leave the game underdeveloped. There's no pressure being had from the original question, I don't see why you'd think that way. Chaos has actually progressed fairly nicely here and I think im going to safely says he is town for the foreseeable future. Those r all my thoughts 4 now Ok now pretend those were all one post thanks kind of struggling to see what makes you townlean chaostrodon ngl. not saying he's scum/town, but for what it's worth i can't discern anything about him from the few posts he has made I think this is actually kind of bad cause chaos' posts feel definitive to read / make judgement on. Would prefer you attempted to give your takes on this. |
|
