|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 19, 2020 3:08:41 GMT
Neither small nor OM have posted enough for me to attempt reading them. OM has parked on someone and small is on an afk player I would agree with you on Penguin D's comment getting undue attention but that is still NAI , dont see where the town read came from . Tone , maybe? Was hoping you'd have more comments about Penguin, but let's open it up. TRs were given to people who crossed over the town line at that point in time, small had a good post d1 without any vote influencing intention behind it despite having two early lynches, OM attempted to give reads early on and tried to provide direction for town without making any missteps. Penguin is arguably the most controversial TR of the three, their efforts aren't very helpful to town at all. That being said, you're right with Tone being a major factor here, their objective to provide information regardless of how bad it seems makes me read them as town here. Currently working will be baxk in 2-3 hours but unlynch, lynch gtsFoh w that wack ass loq into peng there are better pushes I like this, but isn't it strictly better to pressure a person supporting a bad push rather than attack the push itself? I think it's a valid outlook on the game but I don't think not playing into town wincon = scum; rather, the interactions sprung up by a bad push help find scum better. Do you want to supply more context than the fact Gary's not playing to a town wincon here, I just think there's a better lynch here. I've asked you about your reasoning for small with reasons why I don't think it should be The only reason I can see is them having 1 line, don't see anything else. Quoted this because I posted the reasoning for my TRs above, would like your thoughts on them. |
|
|
|
Post by Schrodinger on Oct 19, 2020 4:41:32 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Oct 19, 2020 5:35:05 GMT
kind of struggling to see what makes you townlean chaostrodon ngl. not saying he's scum/town, but for what it's worth i can't discern anything about him from the few posts he has made Mindset from those two seem pro-scumhunty and I like the day 1 attempt to get hooks into reads  I swear, reading this made me see  <img src=" ![]( "\"made") " alt="" style="max-width:100%;"> |
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Oct 19, 2020 5:35:52 GMT
today on botched meme attempt.
anyway, @litt I'd like to hear your take on chaostrodon because I still can't get anything from them. What, exactly, did you find?
|
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 19, 2020 8:35:37 GMT
today on botched meme attempt. anyway, @litt I'd like to hear your take on chaostrodon because I still can't get anything from them. What, exactly, did you find? they have 3 different takes on stuff throughout, i think there should be a read of some form on them, with that fact personally, i'm reserving judgement for their response to my tr list cause they did ask for it, but their reaction to the counter question was genuine / made sense to me, and they had a first good realpost. I don't see any reasons to sr them yet. my issue's that you're seeing them as a blank slot, rather than town/scum/nulling them yet |
|
|
|
Post by chaostrodon on Oct 19, 2020 14:01:14 GMT
>Fair question, but are there any of those that you disagree with?
Also, what reads do you have? Would be nice to get some transparecy out of you, so everyone's on equal footing.
The Gary-Penguin interactions are pointless and people who try to salvage something out of it are naturally suspicious , which would be PTSD and Fenrir .
I am guessing litt glossing over Fenrir but pressuring PTSD is the basis of OM's read
But I still respect litt's town read on Penguin , and I would agree with it irrespective of what litt's alignment turns out to be
The small read however I dont agree. All he has done is made some vague posts about his role and I dont see whats good about them. The lack of vote influencing intention seems to just be stemming from the lack of activity
Im beginning to think we arent going to get much info by sitting on small , ddlc or Spiderz. I find all 3 to be a bit anti-town but nothing inherently scummy
So Im gonna lynch Fenrir and see what happens
Lynch Fenrir
|
|
|
|
Post by smallworldz on Oct 19, 2020 15:15:50 GMT
Time for the first readwall~
1.Chaostrodon-the gary/penguin interaction is good to analyze to see if its t/s/,s/s,t/t and see if anyone is sheeping or siding with gts and or penguin.The entire context of the push was bad, however as the reasons were bad.I also dont get how fenrir is suspicious when what he asked penguin was a good question.if we go from that pov cyan would be more scummy as they asked penguin for a read rather than giving their own
2.Cyan Talon-iffy, why a blurb lynch over anyone else?why ask penguin about the state of the lynches when it was clearly 2 rvs's?sl
3.PassTheSaltDude-says theres a chance penguin flips scum, and might vote on them later (while currently lynching no one), and then next post says they dont sr penguin, you prob should scumhunt then. also says they are looking for a good lynch, are you asking to sheep someone?
4.OM-gave reads but didnt ask much questions nor pushed anyone (can be said with multiple people here actually),null
5.Spiderz-weird claim, prob has some interaction with ddlcfan69,null rn
6.Penguin D-contradicted himself, unless he meant to say dislike which is what i was reading it as lol,answers to the questions were fine tho
7.Gary the Savage-questions penguin while ignoring most other people,still townie even tho he gave bad reasons for a push cause of questioning and general scumhuntiness
8.Litt Eleven-townie,asking questions making reads, iso wise hasnt said anything contradictory etc
9.Fenrir
-looking back his lines may not be a pr soft, but could instead be him tryna look townie,hasnt said much tho he is fine so far; i agree with him asking about peng voting gary over OM
10.smallworldz
11.ddlcfan69-null;says he has a desire to kill spiderz which is something, especially given spiderz claim
12.blurb
-scumlean;not because he hasnt said anything, its cause no one else voted him for not saying anything ,especially since its still rvs and some people still dont have solid reads yet
(watch as this gets ripped to shreds)
vote cyan talon
|
|
|
|
Post by passthesaltdude on Oct 19, 2020 15:44:03 GMT
I should be clear, I think there’s a chance Penguin flips scum but it’s not a scumread. I don’t think Gary flips scum, but I don’t townread him either if that makes sense.
I haven’t been keeping up with gamestate nearly enough to make a certified push, to the request of OM I do think that what Litt has been doing is somewhat weird. Especially since Litt never fully told me why they SR before I said stuff. If you really scum leaned me from 2 posts, I want to see what you scumread me from those two specific posts. It almost seems like trying to push an easy slot by picking everything apart, rather than reading everything.
I’m sorry if my wording has been confusing, I don’t want to lynch Penguin anymore, I’ll make that clear. I think his comments on filler was weird, but looking back on it, it was nothing major, once again he could still flip scum from the weird comments, but I have no intention to pressure him on it,
I would like to see more from Chaos and DDLC but I also think they haven’t really done anything noteworthy and nothing really to warrant a lynch over, Id love to see more activity from those slots though. The filler is a bit weird, but that’s probably just the transition from chat mafia,
OM, how do you feel about Small+Litt? Small hasn’t really had much aside from that read post, and the Litt read just seems out of frame kind of. Just the idea that Litt has a said a lot so they have to be town, it seems out of tone compared to everything else small had said.
Small, expanding in your reads. What makes Litt townie opposed to the other active posters? Has anything they’ve said struck a townie chord with you? Why lynch Cyan when you had other scumreads (Like blurb) and you said cyan was iffy.
Lynch small , overall I want to pressure Litt/Small some.
update on chaos their new post is really conscience and answers some good questions, I’m pushing this slot to a town lean.
Small, how willing would you be to shift to Fenrir with me?
|
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 16:39:01 GMT
what the fuck is wrong with you all
|
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 16:40:17 GMT
ah for fucks sake I have to reselect all the posts
|
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 17:13:32 GMT
> lynch spiderz cuz why not I would find this line a bit sus in chat mafia , but I dunno how forum mafia reads work. Anyway Vote ddlcfan69Check bold Check bold So like, ddlc is playing this like chat mafia based on that line, but i'm p sure its coming from a lack of not understanding how shit works in fourm though, regardless this is townie from terri I for one am a massive fan of voting Spiderz cause "why not" 'Tis up to you what you find sus, but I personally don't think there's anything too out of the ordinary in that line. We're only a few posts in and there's not a ton of content, so we're still in that RVS-y stage where people making jokes like that isn't super major imo. I like this post, explains it from a diff angle I read it but also completely true D1 takeaways so far OM is a monkey Litt hates everyone and everything ddlc sheeps OM "cuz wynaut". I see this as the same as fenrir lynching small just like litt as for now. Chastrodon is confused. Small is basically just here. And fenrir is a tryhard. Nothing new. Lynch PTSDur takeaways are very garbage, like insanely garbage all of those are just untrue and stupid, use ur head and read whats actually going on thanks I claim unhealthy desire to kill spiderz but not scum Fuck off 3v9 cool cool i claim to be either hololive or saint seiya yubi yubi i hate this site and everyone, idc if everyone sees me as scum for putting out rage commentary but i cannot deal with this well i'm just gonna shake > lynch spiderz cuz why not I would find this line a bit sus in chat mafia , but I dunno how forum mafia reads work. Anyway Vote ddlcfan69Check bold Check bold dw, you've got the hang of it right enough - basis for reading remains the same regardless of medium and you'd be on the right track if this wasn't D1 and any line could be interpreted as banter. I'm thinking and I have 0 clue why you would say this or what it means. Don't claim if this is real or not, there is no reason to. see above: D1 banter is a thing, and i feel like this line was part of it. There's really nothing I can do to comment on gamestate or push a vote at the moment, so I might as well just lynch blurb to see what I get out of that. Will make several posts after CLrus and my own walrus would love for these posts to be in a wall, if you're just here to comment on banter like i did These 2 posts ping me as scum Cyan, he keeps doing this thing as scum, where none of his posts are actual analysis, like a mix of IIoA and just asking questions and going no where with it, id prefer actual reads or analysis on game so far instead of your thanks. I asked you a question because you contradicted yourself in your own statement, of which you never even answered the question lol. The only way you could see me being defensive in that way is if OM and I are scum partners. I'd like an answer to the previous question still instead of a redirection, and I'd also like to ask. Do you think OM and I are scum partners? Sidenote on your points on sheeing: It is day 1, a few hours in. They lynched the same person as someone else to put two lynches on them. This is rvs, likely for reactionary purposes. This is not sheeping. Never implied you and OM were partners, just thought it was odd. On the second part, you are correct. I was mistaken on the whole sheeping thing and have received some backlash on it, but it’s fine. This looks like a townie reaction to me, im gonna talk about gary peng stuff in a bit, Peng is giving townie reactions, I dont like that a majority of the game is dismissing this ok so preliminary reads: OM town | peng town | small town ddlc fan /chaos have undue attention for seemingly lackluster comments, sl ptsd here lynch ptsdderz is getting paid to perform like shit, gary is making 0 progress with questions, idfk what chaos is doing here. blurb is fair as a policy i refuse to read fen Bro what, LMAO, Gary defo generated some townie reactions from peng I have no clue what your on about, Chaos is also playing, I dont know what ur smoking but you are being insanely dismissive of other townie's contrubutions oh and sfl slot is cool i guess. Pro town, if you want to push the slot find a partner to flip, the activity is appreciated Litt is playing forcing reads to look townie, painfully obvious, esp with the OM and SFL tr's, and not an inherent scum read on me just saying I play like shit, to not scum reads players that would shut his bullshit down so quick but instead try this shitty pocket attempt Hey, I’m checking in again. Plur is on Derz if I know how to do math. Cyan and Fen seems like good town for me at least, they’ve given reads and have asked questions. I do like the way Gary has been pressuring Penguin and I do think that there’s a chance the penguin slot flips scum, I’ll end up lynching that slot in an hour or two if I get the chance. We really need to keep an eye on OM since he just kind of dipped after a bit with no real substance to add. I know that gut reads exist Litt but I’d love to see some substance on me, not required I just want to get into your headspace Most slots once again have been too inactive to get anything from so it’s a little unfortunate. Hey, I’m checking in again. Plur is on Derz if I know how to do math. Cyan and Fen seems like good town for me at least, they’ve given reads and have asked questions. I do like the way Gary has been pressuring Penguin and I do think that there’s a chance the penguin slot flips scum, I’ll end up lynching that slot in an hour or two if I get the chance. We really need to keep an eye on OM since he just kind of dipped after a bit with no real substance to add. I know that gut reads exist Litt but I’d love to see some substance on me, not required I just want to get into your headspace Most slots once again have been too inactive to get anything from so it’s a little unfortunate. a) you thinking that gary is actually pressuring penguin is either coming from a skimming phase, or from scum motivated to support another's push; but this makes you scum, not gary. Said pressure's not going anywhere, it's distributed in a deflecting way, I don't see how you'd think that Gary is actively pressuring Penguin D as a push and, where Penguin's reactions were scum motivated. b) Do you want to state your basis for the Penguin SR? All you've thrown about are general ideas, I'd love you explaining what you're thinking on the slot rn fuck this interaction holy, this is all so bad, can you all just pull up specific posts when you pull up reads, also more gary slander, hes been trying and it looks townie, and its actually generated shit, this may come from a perspective of reading the whole game already but this read is awful, and also this "scum motivated to support another's push" but then say it doesn't point to a gary + ptsd team is LOL. PTSD I have no qualms besides for me WANTING SPECIFIC POSTS, I read that shit and and it looked townie to me shrug, and also going back to cyan, you should know his scum meta by now. zz Am I not allowed to question someone without it being an activr push? Absolutely nowhere did I call them scum, nor did I lynch them. In the words of Penguin, "I saw what they did as odd." In this case yes, you are stalling your own progress by not scum hunting, and the entirety of your conversation with penguin has been cyclical so far. Make headway or you're not making way Much better take, although I do think he's generated good content from peng he should be scum hunting better and making better posts on gamestate instead of being tunnely Im with litt this format is not fun. Not sure if I should claim role or not so will wait but is there a way to see the roles of the game? Forum games are all about taking your time to form reads - you don't have to check in every hour or so. Also, this is U-Pick, everyone (presumably with one or two exceptions) got a role they wanted to play as. I would like for litteleven to explain his town reads Fair question, but are there any of those that you disagree with? Also, what reads do you have? Would be nice to get some transparecy out of you, so everyone's on equal footing. In this case yes, you are stalling your own progress by not scum hunting, and the entirety of your conversation with penguin has been cyclical so far. Make headway or you're not making way. Generally good advice from OM here - but if anything I'd point out that I townlean Gary from their stance and tone towards this line of questioning. That said, I can work with Penguin D being town as well, although I'd like for them to speak up more. No thoughts about the rest of the PL, but I would prefer a blurb lynch over the rest if shit hits the fan. Again with the give advice 2 be townie it pings me as scum, but cyan had some actual analysis here which is cool..? but it was passive as fuck, he said same thing wrt to gary and om thing though Chaos has actually progressed fairly nicely here and I think im going to safely says he is town for the foreseeable future. Those r all my thoughts 4 now Ok now pretend those were all one post thanks kind of struggling to see what makes you townlean chaostrodon ngl. not saying he's scum/town, but for what it's worth i can't discern anything about him from the few posts he has made *stares at cyan trying to stay neutral as hell and then go nowhere with this question* Time for the first readwall~ 1.Chaostrodon-the gary/penguin interaction is good to analyze to see if its t/s/,s/s,t/t and see if anyone is sheeping or siding with gts and or penguin.The entire context of the push was bad, however as the reasons were bad.I also dont get how fenrir is suspicious when what he asked penguin was a good question.if we go from that pov cyan would be more scummy as they asked penguin for a read rather than giving their own 2.Cyan Talon-iffy, why a blurb lynch over anyone else?why ask penguin about the state of the lynches when it was clearly 2 rvs's?sl 3.PassTheSaltDude-says theres a chance penguin flips scum, and might vote on them later (while currently lynching no one), and then next post says they dont sr penguin, you prob should scumhunt then. also says they are looking for a good lynch, are you asking to sheep someone? 4.OM-gave reads but didnt ask much questions nor pushed anyone (can be said with multiple people here actually),null 5.Spiderz-weird claim, prob has some interaction with ddlcfan69,null rn 6.Penguin D-contradicted himself, unless he meant to say dislike which is what i was reading it as lol,answers to the questions were fine tho 7.Gary the Savage-questions penguin while ignoring most other people,still townie even tho he gave bad reasons for a push cause of questioning and general scumhuntiness 8.Litt Eleven-townie,asking questions making reads, iso wise hasnt said anything contradictory etc 9.Fenrir -looking back his lines may not be a pr soft, but could instead be him tryna look townie,hasnt said much tho he is fine so far; i agree with him asking about peng voting gary over OM 10.smallworldz 11.ddlcfan69-null;says he has a desire to kill spiderz which is something, especially given spiderz claim 12.blurb -scumlean;not because he hasnt said anything, its cause no one else voted him for not saying anything ,especially since its still rvs and some people still dont have solid reads yet (watch as this gets ripped to shreds) vote cyan talonFor the most part this post looks townie, but i'm so confused as to what your trying to say about chaos, i also dont agree with a lot of these reads, blurb as that reasoning is bad and doesnt really make sense but i do see what hes trying to do, gary, litt, om. he makes another good point on cyan, he again is trying to stay neutral |
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 17:14:46 GMT
Gonna say I'm town leaning OM, and scum reading Litt and Cyan, their interactions with each other have been garbage too with litt making that shitty read on cyan
|
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 17:31:03 GMT
Neither small nor OM have posted enough for me to attempt reading them. OM has parked on someone and small is on an afk player I would agree with you on Penguin D's comment getting undue attention but that is still NAI , dont see where the town read came from . Tone , maybe? Was hoping you'd have more comments about Penguin, but let's open it up. TRs were given to people who crossed over the town line at that point in time, small had a good post d1 without any vote influencing intention behind it despite having two early lynches, OM attempted to give reads early on and tried to provide direction for town without making any missteps. Penguin is arguably the most controversial TR of the three, their efforts aren't very helpful to town at all. That being said, you're right with Tone being a major factor here, their objective to provide information regardless of how bad it seems makes me read them as town here. Currently working will be baxk in 2-3 hours but unlynch, lynch gtsFoh w that wack ass loq into peng there are better pushes I like this, but isn't it strictly better to pressure a person supporting a bad push rather than attack the push itself? I think it's a valid outlook on the game but I don't think not playing into town wincon = scum; rather, the interactions sprung up by a bad push help find scum better. Do you want to supply more context than the fact Gary's not playing to a town wincon here, I just think there's a better lynch here. I've asked you about your reasoning for small with reasons why I don't think it should be The only reason I can see is them having 1 line, don't see anything else. Quoted this because I posted the reasoning for my TRs above, would like your thoughts on them. This blurb is cherrypicking and inconsistent lol, more evidence that those reads were forced to all hell. The small and om townread are the shitties pocket attempts i've ever seen, those reasonings are so minuscule compared to what other members have done, and you pick those weird ass angles to look at it with is tottally cherry picking certain posts, what the fuck does "small had a good post d1 without any vote influencing intention behind it despite having two early lynches, OM attempted to give reads early on and tried to provide direction for town without making any missteps" mean. I can say this about any early posts in this game. Those TR's were forced as fuck in order to look townie >Fair question, but are there any of those that you disagree with? Also, what reads do you have? Would be nice to get some transparecy out of you, so everyone's on equal footing. The Gary-Penguin interactions are pointless and people who try to salvage something out of it are naturally suspicious , which would be PTSD and Fenrir . I am guessing litt glossing over Fenrir but pressuring PTSD is the basis of OM's read But I still respect litt's town read on Penguin , and I would agree with it irrespective of what litt's alignment turns out to be The small read however I dont agree. All he has done is made some vague posts about his role and I dont see whats good about them. The lack of vote influencing intention seems to just be stemming from the lack of activity Im beginning to think we arent going to get much info by sitting on small , ddlc or Spiderz. I find all 3 to be a bit anti-town but nothing inherently scummy So Im gonna lynch Fenrir and see what happens Lynch FenrirBe more assertive Imo, this is a player problem, I want to see you pressure Litt more, esp after all that, I also do agree with the penguin vs gary shit, but the other stuff doesnt make sense I should be clear, I think there’s a chance Penguin flips scum but it’s not a scumread. I don’t think Gary flips scum, but I don’t townread him either if that makes sense. I haven’t been keeping up with gamestate nearly enough to make a certified push, to the request of OM I do think that what Litt has been doing is somewhat weird. Especially since Litt never fully told me why they SR before I said stuff. If you really scum leaned me from 2 posts, I want to see what you scumread me from those two specific posts. It almost seems like trying to push an easy slot by picking everything apart, rather than reading everything. I’m sorry if my wording has been confusing, I don’t want to lynch Penguin anymore, I’ll make that clear. I think his comments on filler was weird, but looking back on it, it was nothing major, once again he could still flip scum from the weird comments, but I have no intention to pressure him on it, I would like to see more from Chaos and DDLC but I also think they haven’t really done anything noteworthy and nothing really to warrant a lynch over, Id love to see more activity from those slots though. The filler is a bit weird, but that’s probably just the transition from chat mafia, OM, how do you feel about Small+Litt? Small hasn’t really had much aside from that read post, and the Litt read just seems out of frame kind of. Just the idea that Litt has a said a lot so they have to be town, it seems out of tone compared to everything else small had said. Small, expanding in your reads. What makes Litt townie opposed to the other active posters? Has anything they’ve said struck a townie chord with you? Why lynch Cyan when you had other scumreads (Like blurb) and you said cyan was iffy. Lynch small , overall I want to pressure Litt/Small some. update on chaos their new post is really conscience and answers some good questions, I’m pushing this slot to a town lean. Small, how willing would you be to shift to Fenrir with me? This small shift to fen with me makes no sense to me and isn't very consistent with your old reads so im ?_?, but what annoys me more is why pressure small over Litt, esp when Litt has been a Alignment Indicative discussion machine all game. My issue so far with a majority of town is that everyone is town reading active assertive/aggresive players while the newbies/passive/worst players are getting pushed and scumread here, can we all re-evaluate our reads because the current read state is annoying the shit out of me. |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 19, 2020 17:32:13 GMT
Gonna say I'm town leaning OM, and scum reading Litt and Cyan, their interactions with each other have been garbage too with litt making that shitty read on cyan thank you spiderz i will weigh in on this when you lynch your sr |
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 17:32:30 GMT
Player Meta, and scum playing good are factors here lets not push those new to forum like PSMaf is prone to
|
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 17:33:01 GMT
Gonna say I'm town leaning OM, and scum reading Litt and Cyan, their interactions with each other have been garbage too with litt making that shitty read on cyan thank you spiderz i will weigh in on this when you lynch your sr ahahaha if you bothered to read my earlier posts i cant fucking lynch because of my role |
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 19, 2020 17:34:00 GMT
thank you spiderz i will weigh in on this when you lynch your sr ahahaha if you bothered to read my earlier posts i cant fucking lynch because of my role which i did, which is why i said you were paid to perform like shit |
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 17:36:48 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by litteleven on Oct 19, 2020 17:45:48 GMT
for one thing, this wallpost has convinced me to unlynch ptsd vote cyan talon since ptsd's wagon traction is awful and I'm not sure of the slot;s intentions anymore; and I v much think sfl staying at a blank slate on chaos is scummy since they're not reading but they were also a focal point of activity for the game; since that's no longer the case, I'm more comfortable with this lynch; piggybacking statements but i get the right vibes from spiderz's push here; did a good job at that atleast. I still highly contest the effectiveness of Gary's pushes at all, but I don't think the slot is directly scum since it has town intentions, to clear that up. + chaos tr feels kind of universal here, unless anyone wants to contest that. preliminary reads are still preliminary spiderz they're meant to stipulate activity; not all of it needs to hit its mark; in my defense, they're all forced in a sort since I didn't want to miss anyone out on my original asssessment. I firmly believe fenrir is intentionally playing to a Null read d1 so I don't want to read that slot, but my thoughts on everyone else exists right there. |
|
|
|
Post by spiderz on Oct 19, 2020 17:59:01 GMT
for one thing, this wallpost has convinced me to unlynch ptsd vote cyan talon since ptsd's wagon traction is awful and I'm not sure of the slot;s intentions anymore; and I v much think sfl staying at a blank slate on chaos is scummy since they're not reading but they were also a focal point of activity for the game; since that's no longer the case, I'm more comfortable with this lynch; piggybacking statements but i get the right vibes from spiderz's push here; did a good job at that atleast. I still highly contest the effectiveness of Gary's pushes at all, but I don't think the slot is directly scum since it has town intentions, to clear that up. + chaos tr feels kind of universal here, unless anyone wants to contest that. preliminary reads are still preliminary spiderz they're meant to stipulate activity; not all of it needs to hit its mark; in my defense, they're all forced in a sort since I didn't want to miss anyone out on my original asssessment. I firmly believe fenrir is intentionally playing to a Null read d1 so I don't want to read that slot, but my thoughts on everyone else exists right there. Ill put a hold to the forced reads bit for now, "I still highly contest the effectiveness of Gary's pushes at all, but I don't think the slot is directly scum since it has town intentions, to clear that up." you say this but then you also claim that you TR peng because his tone... does that not mean gary has succeeded in getting an alignment indicitve reaction? dont give me bs that it wasn't those posts that gave u the townie vibe bc pengs stuff was p NAI before all that went down. this reaction is hilarious though, because litt's tone has dramaticly shifted from being incredibly aggresive all game 2 very oh passive and accepting tone, id go as far to say it looked like he was nervous, I guess its cool that he finally pressures cyan but its also like is this distancing??? now back to reads, this isnt a valid defense, since clearly they are to stipulate activity, but scum does it to get feedback like "look this player is contributing so many reads all ready they are town!!!" and the reasonings ive already dissected were cherry picking and inconsistent to what you've scumread others as. Biggest takeaway is just the dramatic tone shift after being called out |
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 19, 2020 18:01:31 GMT
Okay, sorry about coming in late had a busy morning.
Litt what you said right there "I still highly contest the effectiveness of Gary's pushes at all, but I don't think the slot is directly scum because it has town intentions" is the same way I felt about Penguin, hence why I asked about your small tr, and ignored the others as I found it the most questionable. Small's wallpost I briefed through, amd although I really have only interacted with litt and Peng, that's NAI. I can see where you're coming from and you can claim "I'm not scumhunting" and I'll solemnly disagree. OM's chaos tr is there and also I see the reasoning, but I don't know i I called them a tr. I do like what they posted about mine and Penguin's interactions.
I'd like to see PTSD and fenrir give thoughts on everything, as well as ddlcfan but they're giving town vibes. I also like sfl's pushes and counters so far, so tr them too.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gary The Savage on Oct 19, 2020 18:04:59 GMT
Derz is a townlean. Although I don't agree with all his stuff, like caling my day one takeaways (when like 5 eople had spoke at the time of the post lol) trash  , I like ultimately the majority of his thoughts and progress on the game. Also litt if you don't think I'm directly scum why are you on me lmao |
|
|
|
Post by ddlcfan69 on Oct 19, 2020 18:05:41 GMT
Uh I would like to say that my contributions may be unhelpful and I may not read half of the things that are being said but...
At least im not Fenrir
|
|
|
|
Post by ddlcfan69 on Oct 19, 2020 18:09:26 GMT
Also derz lynch was just for shits and giggles I prob scum read cyan or litt but will wait before I make my lynch
|
|
|
|
Post by passthesaltdude on Oct 19, 2020 18:16:48 GMT
I just gave my thoughts, but to go over everything, I haven’t focused on cyan yet much, though I do agree that I haven’t seen much of real substance come from them.
I’d like to pressure small specifically because of their wall post, and I asked for a shift to Fenrir mainly to see their reaction on it, I wasn’t really planning on shifting to Fenrir yet, but considering it’s a 3 person team I’m trying to figure out who is and isn’t a viable team.
I am more than happy to shift to Litt as OM has pointed out some of their flaws and they aren’t giving me insanely town vibes. I just saw 95% of the playlist townreading Litt, and I wanted to pressure one of those people.
If we can give a shift to Litt I’ll gladly join it, but I also want to see a lot more from small.
This game has been very slow paced and I very much want to see more interactions and I’m still trying to get a hold on my own reads aswell, as there a lot of slots I don’t know how I feel about.
I’d love Litt to just give me a guess on the 3 person scumteam from their perspective!
|
|
, I like ultimately the majority of his thoughts and progress on the game.