|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 29, 2023 12:28:26 GMT
also you know what's funny is like edj was like "scum always puts a mafia in the second or third trial" and the second & third trial are my top two townreads right now... I wish there was a way to dislike messages
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 29, 2023 12:23:09 GMT
Hey guys, sorry I haven't been on the forum in a couple of days, the only time I was able to make during work was for fish, otherwise I've been pretty busy in/out of work. Either way I'm gonna be here from now on so I need to read up. I'm on page 18 and probably won't comment on everything I see but I will take note of it
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 27, 2023 19:34:09 GMT
Which like, they're gonna find out are wrong but I digress. But at least they're not just blatantly pushing me for it and basing every single person in the game's reads off of me because of it also i wasn't basing anyone's alignment off of it but wob's and to a lesser degree schia, but schia is scummy on their own ok I'll admit I was getting a bit defensive but I still think you were, pmuch everyone you made reads on except for schia and PD were somehow related to me
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 27, 2023 19:32:09 GMT
The second line of this is where i start to take issue with this. You asked "do you think wob is scum for mentioning it" You did not ask what he thought of wobs alignment you asked him if he thought he was scum or not. Edj did answer "why would i think wob is scum when he asked for explanation" (im paraphrasing this but itll show up in the quote anyway). So this feels like to me youre attempting to change what you originally asked without actually having done so. After rereading it, the first line i also have to take issue with as well. You again never asked who Edj thought was scum you asked: "why couldnt everyone have not seen it" If you were attempting to get at something else wouldnt it be easier to just straight up ask instead of attempting to imply the question that wouldnt get answered? yeah, but instead of answering whether or not he thought wob was scum, he immediately defaulted to towncasing wob's push on him as if my question was directly implying i thought he thought wob was scum. maybe he read it that way, it's possible, but it doesn't make sense to think the behavior is scummy and then pivot into towncasing that exact behavior and sure, i could've asked which players he thought were pushing him in bad faith, but it was pretty obvious when he said anyone not named penguind so i was more keen on the idea of seeing if he viewed the pushes differently or was throwing a blanket over them & calling them all scummy, which is something i view as a scum behavior i think this is... a decent way for you to be reading this and pretty elaborate, so thank you for responding Clouds: "do you think wob is scum for x?" Edj: "I don't think wob is scum for x" Clouds: :O WHY ARE YOU DEFENDING HIM OUT OF NOWHERE :O lol
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 27, 2023 13:12:13 GMT
thanks i still don't get it ): so they thought i was implying smth and i told them to think what they think! See the issue with this is that we have multiple people in this game who are just chocked up to being "X because they're X". I believe Myan or Clouds said something about that applying to wob, but this moreso applies to both Winsy and Clem. We're not gonna be able to read them if they don't give us anything of substance to read which is annoying because I can't see them as anything but null currently. I would like to hear some genuine reads from iavh, Wob, and winsytinsy
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 27, 2023 13:04:38 GMT
clouds why are your reads based off edje alignment when we cant flip them for twenty years they're not based on edj's alignment, just the wob townread & to a lesser degree spiderz wob also isn't that bad on his own, i just don't see any reason his posts can't come from scum i guess. but his takes are good regardless of his alignment also like what do you want me to do, pretend i don't scumread edj just cause we can't flip him?yeah lol Also I do agree with the wob stuff and I see him the same way I see abby which is why both are town in my eyes
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 27, 2023 13:00:58 GMT
i see so you're heavily implying i'm scum from this, but haven't taken a stance on me yet. why? Bro? I'm saying that other people, for example spiderz and wob, are noting their suspicions about me being first. Which like, they're gonna find out are wrong but I digress. But at least they're not just blatantly pushing me for it and basing every single person in the game's reads off of me because of it. I'm not saying I deserved to get insta-nved by some people even though they're based for that but the point still stands that I'm the towniest mf who ever lived, and I hate that I just have to keep going back and forth with you on it when I can't even make reads because yesterday only peng and occasionally abdel were actually speaking and trying to objectively make reads and analyze It seems it's gonna take a long time for you to figure out that I'm town but I can guarantee you'll shit your pants once I prove it to you but you're gonna have to wait like a month
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 27, 2023 12:17:08 GMT
Some people tried to jump to conclusions while others sorta just made up their mind, and I think that says a lot about who was trying to low-effort push and who's actually trying to play the game i see so you're heavily implying i'm scum from this, but haven't taken a stance on me yet. why? Bro?
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 27, 2023 12:03:50 GMT
But this is something Spiderz always does, regardless of how much he's actually played.
I do agree that we need to see more activity from him and quite a few others but I don't see a huge reason to look into it too much Omega untrue btw Uhh no its definitely true, you definitely always like to ping a bunch of people to ask them stuff Blurb learned it from you too
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 19:17:47 GMT
Like i had previously stated i didnt like the vibe i got from how you responded to spiderz and winsy no voting you Buddy if I was sucking up to them then I would be doing so to get them to no vote on my trial. I thanked them for no voting me especially because they didn't need any convincing that I was town. There's a big difference I saw your little post about that earlier but ignored it because it was useless. Much like my thanks to the people who nved me but I needed to do that because they're cool individuals
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 19:15:58 GMT
What were these prior concerns Like i had previously stated i didnt like the vibe i got from how you responded to spiderz and winsy no voting you Buddy if I was sucking up to them then I would be doing so to get them to no vote on my trial. I thanked them for no voting me especially because they didn't need any convincing that I was town. There's a big difference
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 16:40:08 GMT
updated readlist i suppose wob: townlean, lines seem genuine so far schia: null to very slight townlean, gutread clouds: townlean, though i fear a pocket prodigu: null, i cant remember what theyve said, but i know theyre around. sorry bout that... abdel: townlean, questioning of me seems townie spiderz: null, needs to play the game sand: troll town, bad town, troll scum, troll. winsy: null, is being winsy.. edje: scumlean, dirty trial #1.... them saying they wanted to be trial #1 despite not mentioning it prior feels like a slip clems/iavh: townlean, opening feels town, more gutread than anything myan: null, needs to play the game Hi I exist I think this is a relatively good post in good faith Id like to see how your stance / read changes on Edj if at all now that i actually see where his post of requesting to be first trial actually came from which has been a large part of ppls read on him. Atm im still leaning not town due to prior concerns, however id like to see and look at further interactions to be able to form a more informed and concise read on the slot past being Trial 1. I dont like the ihbst / sand slot particularly this comes in main part that the slot proceeded to no vote without any context. The most they said was “I liked what they said”. Later as Clouds had pointed out, they did a complete 180 from No Vote to Vote, and were prompted to give an explanation which they still proceeded to not from what ive read up to so far. Later today id like to take a look at the interactions between you and Clouds, and see if anything comes from it / helps me form any reads, being on mobile and at work sucks for wanting to look at more than one post at a time. What were these prior concerns
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 16:39:01 GMT
this post feels like false townleader I could definitely see this as a “hey im here but lemme try to get others to be active instead trying to do more myself” But this is something Spiderz always does, regardless of how much he's actually played. I do agree that we need to see more activity from him and quite a few others but I don't see a huge reason to look into it too much
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 15:14:40 GMT
peng myan clem abby spiderz prodigu winsy ihbst wob schia edj ------------------------ surfed around for a bit and i'm here initially, highest towniest lowest scummiest What makes you put clem up there? And why is wob scummy to you? The other reads are kinda fine I guess but at the same time I can't figure out what I've done to seem like the scummiest person here
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 15:11:44 GMT
am not getting why people tr clem Clem is definitely a null shot. He just acts so passive all the time which makes it hard to determine if he's just low-effort town or low-effort scum
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 15:10:24 GMT
Because at least wob gave it some thought instead of just saying I was scummy for it. Wob specifically said that I said it again after I got called out for it, and that it didn't seem like a slip for that reason. So why would I think wob is scum when he at least asked for me to explain what happened instead of just resorting right to sring me Some people tried to jump to conclusions while others sorta just made up their mind, and I think that says a lot about who was trying to low-effort push and who's actually trying to play the game Whoops that's the same thing. *Some people tried to jump to conclusions while others considered different angles instead of making up their minds
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 15:09:28 GMT
but like for example why couldn't wob have not seen it too? do you think wob is scum for mentioning it? Because at least wob gave it some thought instead of just saying I was scummy for it. Wob specifically said that I said it again after I got called out for it, and that it didn't seem like a slip for that reason. So why would I think wob is scum when he at least asked for me to explain what happened instead of just resorting right to sring me Some people tried to jump to conclusions while others sorta just made up their mind, and I think that says a lot about who was trying to low-effort push and who's actually trying to play the game
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 15:07:59 GMT
why couldn't everyone have not seen it? tbf i saw it, i just didn't remember it but like for example why couldn't wob have not seen it too? do you think wob is scum for mentioning it? Because at least wob gave it some thought instead of just saying I was scummy for it. Wob specifically said that I said it again after I got called out for it, and that it didn't seem like a slip for that reason. So why would I think wob is scum when he at least asked for me to explain what happened instead of just resorting right to sring me
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 15:03:56 GMT
Also why are so many people acting like they didn't see a post in a thread that all of us were in? It feels like one person actually didn't see my post (PenguinD), and now others were just trying to piggyback off that post and use it as a genuine reason to conclude that I'm scum despite the post being very much real why couldn't everyone have not seen it? tbf i saw it, i just didn't remember it Well I mean why wouldn't they? It was right there and obviously I wasn't just pulling something out of my ass for no reason
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 15:01:57 GMT
Oh hi I'm technically not here and not gonna read any posts since the last time I posted. I just wanted to say (now that I'm in the clear since my trial has already been revealed ) that scum always puts one member within the second or third trial slot. Anyways gn Edjeanerations this is what i was referencing with the first trial stuff, felt like you were trying to deflect the attention to a scum being in the second or third trial due to the trial #s alone being somewhere mafia would traditionally put scum and you also say you're clear here due to your trial being first No no I didn't say I'm clear, I said I'm in the clear. As in: now that I've confirmed that my trial is not second or third I can gladly say that scum tends to do that. Tbh ask Myan or Clem to confirm that because I did it yesterday in fish and it worked. Because I am never wrong Also what's wrong with saying that scum could be in second or third slot? It's not like there was going to be a last-minute shift to voting me at that time, so I had already moved past my own trial and was just thinking about what, or who, comes next
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 14:58:43 GMT
Well don't spoil it but yes I do like to get ideas in my head Although it technically wasn't in this thread I was talking to my friends and was basically telling them how I'd react if I actually got put up first and then I thought of my favorite reaction video Which I've FINALLY gotten a chance to use!! irl friends? Oh yeah I was kinda just in story mode but yes irl friends I like to keep them updated on when I join forum/disc games because they love to hear about me arguing with people on the internet
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 14:44:00 GMT
But how would there be a last minute bus if my vote literally never had plur? I don't think it was close at any point besides the beginning of the day when PD had the first vote on me my working theory is he got spooked by people worrying about the early no votes so he switched last minute to avoid being lumped in with them but it's sand so he might not have even read these postsLol yeah the lack of reasoning kinda gave me this vibe
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 13:46:14 GMT
this post feels like false townleader Can you elaborate more on this? How come asking for information from people on my posts (not abdel's) seems fake to you? I mean I'm not seeing this as a townleader post either, but I don't get false townleader from it
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 13:32:07 GMT
Also why are so many people acting like they didn't see a post in a thread that all of us were in? It feels like one person actually didn't see my post (PenguinD), and now others were just trying to piggyback off that post and use it as a genuine reason to conclude that I'm scum despite the post being very much real
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Sept 26, 2023 13:27:49 GMT
updated readlist i suppose wob: townlean, lines seem genuine so far schia: null to very slight townlean, gutread clouds: townlean, though i fear a pocket prodigu: null, i cant remember what theyve said, but i know theyre around. sorry bout that... abdel: townlean, questioning of me seems townie spiderz: null, needs to play the game sand: troll town, bad town, troll scum, troll. winsy: null, is being winsy.. edje: scumlean, dirty trial #1.... them saying they wanted to be trial #1 despite not mentioning it prior feels like a slip clems/iavh: townlean, opening feels town, more gutread than anything myan: null, needs to play the game It's hard to look at this and see PD as anything but town, especially based on his reads throughout the duration of the game so far. I haven't fully developed reads like this since I was focused on not dying but at the same time these are fairly good. Though one thing I don't understand: Why is sand coming off as trolly?
|
|