Separated Scum (Game Over!)

[Deleted]

Dec 29, 2017 0:31:01 GMT @howdoitagyou said:

Dec 28, 2017 12:11:32 GMT @howdoitagyou said:

Actually, since we have roughly a day and a half of time left in this day, I would like to ul nl and lynch VigilanteVigoroth

Yeah, great meme vote on vigvig here, I see. smh Citrus.

I was mostly referring to Champ's vote, and the fact that your vote isn't optimal while Scorch is walking around a free man. Your emotions are valid and apologize for negating your thought process; but filler isn't that big of a deal.

[Deleted]

Dec 29, 2017 0:30:46 GMT ScorrchingTheaph said:

>I painted the duo Vig/Scorrch knowing that whoever was the real CV in that pair would shoot the fake-claimer without realizing was happening. Now they're going to die anyway, but CV likely dies from the 1-shot traitor vig. So that's nice /s
I suspected that you suspected one of me/vigvig to be vig which is why you had that odd pairing. Both of you claimed; why not let you sort out things between yourselves?

>or a gambit as risky as a townie fake-claiming, Scorch does not appeared to have expected anything more than mere reads as reward
You think I gambited a hidden fake-claim of vig as scum? That's asking for a death sentence. It is orders of magnitude better than hiding a message that says you are scum. Claiming CV is legitimate; but "sorting" via a hidden message that literally anybody can access is identical to a hard claim.

>it is convenient, don't you think, that the person he found the new scum read on is also his CV cc
Initially I thought VigVig was town attempting to hypo vig, but his response was no bueno. If he is CV I quit mafia.

>unclaiming is complete crap.
VigVig unclaimed too. After I subliminally pressured him into backing off.

[ScorrchingTheaph]

Citrus, if you truly believe one of me/vigvig is compvig then wouldn't the best play be to nl?

[Deleted]

Yes—which is exactly what I was trying to do before you unclaimed. Now that you're not cc'd, there is no guarantee that one of you is mafia, which makes the "have CV shoot the fake claimer" thing break down. Your reaction is strong evidence that you are scum, but unfortunately you did unclaim, so it's not proof, per se, if that's what you're getting at.

[Deleted]

Dec 29, 2017 0:31:02 GMT ajhockeystar said:

aso, tfw citrus thought I was being serious with my RVS meme post (as seen here:)

Dec 27, 2017 16:48:38 GMT Citrus Freak said:

This is separated scum—was this potential dumbtelling, or just a slip of memory? Town is more likely to forget that mafia lacks nightkill than mafia is. But this was like, post number one, so might be an early game dumbbell.

Ahh
well

I mean




>.>

[Deleted]

Dec 29, 2017 0:31:02 GMT ajhockeystar said:

Wow a lot has happened. I’ve been on vacation- last time I read over right before I got on the plane so I didn’t have a chance to post, rip. But now I can! Regarding everything that’s happened… “What the h*ck” (let’s make that a meme please)

alright so I think I personally need to compile my thoughts, so I’m just gonna make a read list. (it’s in order of the ISO list, if you’re wondering)

cseel- She started doing things after I placed that lynch on her, so that’s good I guess. None of her posts really scream town to me, but they’re not scummy either. For some reason I get a gut scummy feeling from reading her posts earlier in the day… but like gut vs head, I’m gonna overall go with Neutral here. Was doing other reads and came back to this. I remember why I had the gut scum read- the lynch on VigVig just seemed… too easy to me. If your "had" refers to your initial lynch, then what about the meme vote made you think it was serious, lol? "also, tfw citrus aj thought I was being serious with my RVS meme vote post Along with most of cseel’s posts. She only really started making contributions when I said to. To me, the rest of her posts after haven’t been anything major, you know? Like, scum not wanting to make a big play to stick out this early on. Not to mention- she hopped on the Pash turbo bandwagon early in the day what the h*ck!! it was just a meme vote!!, and even this most recent lynch was when Pash already had another lynch on him "had another lynch on him" It was Champ lynching him because he was being sexist lol. Not sure if you could actually count it as a real vote.. Gonna fix my read to (Slight?) Lean Scum

Durza- Has done next to nothing. Probably should get a sub @fenriraesir Fenrir. fixed the tag for you (He has been online but hasn’t been posting) The impulsive part of me is tempted to lynch him if we can’t agree on something else, but like, a) it’s probably better to wait for a sub, and b) lynching someone else will probably give us better info at this stage in the game. I definitely agree with these 2 points, as we get much more info from lynching someone else that isn't a lurker. (or NLing). No Read

Champ- most of Champ’s posts have given me a towny vibe, including the one towards the beginning of D2 when they questioned me. And you're not pointing out the lynch on VigVig, when you criticised me for it? Lean Town

Tballz- I almost forgot Tballz was in this game until his most recent post. lol didn't you tag him in the post you lynched me as a ping to post? That one post gives me a towny feel - I don’t think they’d openly be hypocritical like that Why not? Also the fact that he had no reasoning backing his reads made you feel it was towny feels weird to me. (I mean he did admit it, but still- it feels like he’s being genuine). Slight Lean Town

VigVig- y’all are being weird about Pash. That beginning of day post didn’t seem like a claim… at least to me. And yes playermeta, but imo when Pash is scum he tries more. (speaking from psanon experience.) You say this and you also point out that he hasn't been trying much, but yet you still neutral him, and even after you say you're not feeling the scumminess from him. Why? From an outside perspective, his posts are just neutral tbh, or maybe slightly scummy since he hasn’t been trying much, If you can see from how we could find pash scummy then why do you still think we're "being weird"? but I’m just gonna go with Neutral because I’m not feeling the scumminess from him.

Scorrch- Here we go. So like, that early day post about NLing- I agree with Citrus, I cannot see a scum saying that (unless they really value finding their partner I guess). And the CV claim… I can’t see scum being that obvious and taking that risk. Like, I know what happened with FTF, but there’s no way scum does something this obvious… Like, he said "what the h*ck why have i not received a sekret message back…”. Like if he just left it at the secret message for later game, then sure, but I find it very hard to believe that this is the long con. The only sketch thing really is his lynch on Pash since it’s the 3rd one… I’m still gonna say (Lean?) Town for now. That is the one post that makes me question my otherwise strong read, so lean? town works for me. I agree with most, if not all of this read. But from reading your reads, I can observe that you find whatever lynch that is not the first one scummy? Any reason why?

Citrus- If you thought Scorrch’s claim was the only one, revealing it would be bad. But the fact that you thought Vig’s was an actual claim makes that alright imo… although thinking that is a claim is farfetched. In most cases at least- you’re Citrus, and you look into those things more than most people. So in this specific case, I’d say that could be genuine. Honestly, looking through I’m finding it hard to get a solid read on you. I don’t really even have a gut read like I do with most people. Every time I think about it it flip flops in my head. So Neutral for the time being. I agree with this read, but I would put him as lean town, as he's been analysing things really well and consistently scumhunting.

Xnad- smh Champ didn’t include you on the list of ISOs (which don’t even work for the whole thread, rip). Slight Lean Scum from last day since you’ve done nothing this day to change my read. iirc you never stated your read for xnad day 1? Any reason you "slight lean scum"'d him even though you never posted your read on him (iirc) I’d like to hear your thoughts on all this to help me make a more concrete read. Why not neutral him if you're just waiting for him to post to gain a more concrete read?

[qtball]

Dec 29, 2017 0:39:43 GMT ScorrchingTheaph said:

Citrus, if you truly believe one of me/vigvig is compvig then wouldn't the best play be to nl?

Why would NL ever be the play...

[VigilanteVigoroth]

I never claimed Vig wtf

[Deleted]

Dec 27, 2017 0:21:19 GMT VigilanteVigoroth said:

I want the Vig's Babies

Everyone say "I want Vig's babies"
since he shot scum c:

OR SHE but guys are generally better at things than girls

[VigilanteVigoroth]

Vig as in, the Vigilante. The role

[Deleted]

Ya'll just got our CV lynched. I hope you're proud.

[VigilanteVigoroth]

I’m not Vig though oml

[Fenrir]

Votecount 2.3
******************************
VigilanteVigoroth(3)- Champ1604 , @howdoitagyou , ScorrchingTheaph
cseel(1)- ajhockeystar
Agent Orange(1)- qtball
ScorrchingTheaph(1)- Citrus Freak
No Lynch(0)-
Bringer of Chaos, Zeke(0)-
Champ∞1604(0)-
Thunder~BALLZ(0)-
ajhockeystar(0)-
Space Birds(0)-
Not Voting(3)- Durza , Bomb Moss , VigilanteVigoroth
******************************
There are 9 alive so it takes 5 to hammer. Plurality applies.
Deadline is Friday the 29th at 7pm EST.

VigilanteVigoroth was lynched. He was a:

SPOILER: Click to show

Traitor Cop

Night 2 commence! Deadline is Sunday the 31st at 7pm EST.

[Fenrir]

RADicate has been subbed in for Agent Orange.

[Fenrir]

The death of last night was of...

SPOILER: Click to show

ajhockeystar the Traitor 1-shot Vigilante Cop

This means ScorrchingTheaph the Compulsive Vigilante as well as all of the Vanilla Townies win!

...uh...yeah, I guess. Let me make those 2 nights worth of action logs real quick.

[ScorrchingTheaph]

GG~

[Fenrir]

Here goes:

SPOILER: Click to show

Night 1

FtF: Block Xnad, Inspect Scorrching
Vigvig: Inspect AJ
AJ: Inspect Citrus
Scorrching: Shoot FtF

Night 2

AJ: Inspect cseel
Scorrching: Shoot AJ

Meanwhile Xnad was the Miller, so...gg, I guess?

[ForgotToFlush]

:"""""((((((

[ForgotToFlush]

Dec 24, 2017 4:20:09 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

actually no fuCk that
unlynch Toni, lynch AJ
terrible response to VigVig questioning his lynch so we're rolling with this

Dec 24, 2017 4:22:08 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

also second lynch isn't as OP of an idea as y'all seem to think
Me thinks that it's p much just a waste of time implementing what is essentially filler format

Dec 24, 2017 4:22:20 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

Either way we should be signalling to the compvig 100%

Dec 24, 2017 4:23:32 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

Fenrir another lynch-count PLS

but instead i get vigged

[ForgotToFlush]

gg wp near clean sweep

[ForgotToFlush]

mvp scorch for sure tho shot 2 lynched a third

[RADicate]

I technically won! Go me

[RADicate]

also tf, my dude scorch is on a tear. That is to say tearing up the scum

[Deleted]

well then gg ig

[Bomb Moss]

10/10 would play again :^)