Greater Idea Rankdown

[gimm1ck]

Welcome! In this thread I am going to be hosting a Greater Idea Rankdown.

For those who do not know what a Rankdown is;

• There is a list of stuff (Songs, colors, Pokemion, anything really). This time it will be the roles and alignments present in one of the most popular and renowned theme on PS Mafia, Greater Idea.
• A group of people will submit a ranked list (1 is the best, last is the worst). You can rank them in any way; what you would rather play as, what you think is best to win as, etcetera; it is up to you.
• After a while, I will compile submissions and average the scores of each individual rank for each individual role. I will then present them last-to-first.

Rankdowns are a fun community exercise. We can discuss Greater Idea, individual rankings, and play styles in Greater Idea, as well as having some fun with predicting the top few spots. Join if you want!

GI mafia wiki page; wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Greater_Idea_Mafia

GI rolelist:
Vanilla Townie
Watcher
Tracker
Cop
Cop Lover
Seer
FBI Agent
Doctor
Roleblocker
Jailkeeper
Bodyguard
Vigilante
One-shot Vigilante
One-shot Dayvig
Compulsive Childkiller
Bulletproof Townie
Supersaint
One-shot Paranoid Gun Owner
Mason
Mason Doctor
Mason Lover
Lover
Jack-of-all-trades 
Vengeful Townie
Retired Werewolf Hunter 
Retired Marine
Miller
Hirsute Townie 
Evangelistic Townie 
Tentacled Townie 
Watchlisted Townie 
Wrong Place at the Wrong Time Townie 
Black Goo 
Ascetic Townie
Private Investigator 
Gravedigger 
Nymphomaniac 
One-shot Governor
One-shot Unlynchable Townie
Town Godfather
Innocent Child
Hider
Enabler
Treestump
Conspiracy Theorist 
One-shot Kingmaker
Weak Jailkeeper
Bloodhound
Vanilla Cop 
Hero
Tourist 
Nurse 
One-shot Commuter
Cop-of-all-Trades 
One-shot Gladiator 
Lynchbait 
Psychiatrist 
Reloader
Fruit Vendor 
Parrot Role
Judas
Saulus
One-shot Townie 
Underdog 
Mafia Goon
Mafia Godfather
Mafia Tracker
Mafia Doctor
Mafia Roleblocker
Mafia Lover
Mafia Seer
Mafia One-shot Dayvig
Mafia One-shot Governor
Mafia Strongman
Mafia Reflexive Doctor (protects anyone who targets them)
Hirsute Goon
Mafia Cupid
Alpha Goon 
Mafia Compulsive Hider
Mafia Fruit Vendor
Werewolf
Alpha Werewolf
Werewolf Roleblocker
Werewolf One-shot Bulletproof
Werewolf Cop
Werewolf Mason
Werewolf Watcher
Werewolf FBI Agent
Ninja Werewolf
Werewolf One-shot PGO
Werewolf Miller 
Werewolf Supersaint
Werewolf Godfather 
Werewolf Gravedigger
Wereparrot
Alien One-shot Unlynchable
Alien Prober 
Alien Vanillaiser
Alien Silencer
Bulletproof Alien Lover
Alien Psychotrooper 
Alien Mass Redirector 
Alien Bloodsucker 
Alien Sympathiser 
Survivor
Compulsive Bodyguard Survivor
Survivor Mason
Lyncher 
Serial Killer (Two-shot Bulletproof)
Serial Killer (Immune to Mafia/Alien/Werewolf kills)
One-shot Cult Recruiter
Cult One-shot Goomaker 
Wild Card

Copied out all double roles and merged SK Immune to Mafia/Werewolf/Alien kills because they're basically the same.

I also want this to double as thread of discussion of each individual role after it is released, it's role to play in earning its winfaction, how to successfully play it, and any dangers from discarding it. 

Have fun! I am probably going to keep signups open around 2-3 weeks. Post in chat if you are interested, or just want to talk about anything related to Greater Idea!


Please post anything along the lines of 'in' anywhere on the thread. Whenever you feel iike ranking them, PM me here or on the discord server we have. Have fun!

[C7]

In

[qtball]

In

[qtball]

Also Mafia / Werewolf Kill Immune SK > Alien Kill Immune SK

[gimm1ck]

Jun 15, 2019 2:39:38 GMT qtball said:

Also Mafia / Werewolf Kill Immune SK > Alien Kill Immune SK

Difference is minor enough tbh

[Claire]

In, just to see how different my opinions are to everyone else. I expect I will over/underrate a LOT of roles compared to everyone else.

[jodram22]

in

[gimm1ck]

Jun 15, 2019 10:45:01 GMT Claire said:

In, just to see how different my opinions are to everyone else. I expect I will over/underrate a LOT of roles compared to everyone else.

I think ASC will singlehandedly bringing up Nymphomaniac at least ten places and I’ll be disappointed if he doesn’t.

[❗]

in

[happylappy]

sure, in

[Schiavetto ♫ ♪ ♫ ♪]

in

[Arsenal]

in

[gimm1ck]

Helpful link;

czeckd.github.io/preference-revealer/dist/

Preference revealer; you just shove in the list I posted above, and sit through a session of it asking you which role you prefer over another and it will automatically rank it for you, Took me ~30-45 mins.

[gimm1ck]

We already have a submission whew
Haven't decided a formal deadline for submissions, but expect it to be more than a week from now and less than three weeks.
I will give a week in advance deadline and a shameless massping for y'all

[happylappy]

I wonder if people are going to rate werewolf cop higher than regular cop

[Sir Mister]

in

[Alexander489]

in

[meower9lives]

In
Also someone needs to add mafia strongman to the PS GI Module

[złerdzib]

still open? in if so

[ZestOfLife]

in

[gimm1ck]

This isn't dead!

If you havent sent already, please do so. The deadline is in one week, or Saturday, July 13. Will ping anyone who have joined but haven't submitted in a bit. Get ranking!

[Claire]

Is this dead as your other rankdown?

[Sir Mister]

Smh Asc, it's just been 3 months. Don't you have any patience?

[Snaq ◢ ◤]

Lets hope this doesn't happen to the actual mafia game

[Snaq ◢ ◤]

Hyped!