|
|
Post by cyan on Sept 21, 2019 12:44:17 GMT
Out of context. Read my next post. I tried to upload an image and failed. OK. I'm back. I'll follow up with more posts after this. Meanwhile: 1. Schiavetto's FOS on everyone who speculated about flavor is flawed, especially with multiple players suspected. There are both possible town and scum motivations—solving flavor and pretending to contribute—but there's no context in which we can settle on either of the motives. Therefore, it's non-alignment-indicative. Better to say "FOS on everyone." 2. Same goes with abdel "defending" me. 3. Schiavetto, can you explain your read on Cyan Talon (I assume that that isn't RVS)? 4. Gimm1ck, please change the thread title to "Day One." Don't need to filler like that. This goes for everyone, too. Toni XY, posting in walls is probably the best strategy. Question for your wall: why did you waste one of the three posts? Also, is it "night" and not "day? , Overall had a pretty good approach to this day 1(I would say the best "towny" approach). Most of his post seems very considerate in a good way. Although Jocus seems to build himself up as a town, in my opinion, I sense that he may be overthinking in the way he wants to perceive himself After Further investigations. Before I go into details I would rather wait for further indications. There is One key detail I will keep to myself for the time being that prevents from gathering a precise read on this player. What is everyone else thoughts?Could you tell me a bit more on how you feel his posts are considerate? |
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Sept 21, 2019 12:47:26 GMT
Before I go I just want to ask you this - why do you feel this way? This post has no aspiration whats so ever. The post That Lati Made made have been a "trolly"/meme post which is what i am suspecting, however It may not be which is rather disappointing. I dont want to Say much about the post itself Since There no sense of intentions from that slot. I simply Responded in a way that can possible allow me to gather more information. After all im geting underachieving gameplay Vibes from This Slot. So you feel that Lati is being meme-posty; how does that translate into him not being town? And after everything that's been said so far, what information have you gathered? |
|
|
|
Post by cyan on Sept 21, 2019 12:50:20 GMT
Also guys I won't be there for EoD, so if anyone wants to chat in this thread hmu asap If you want a conversation starter, here are my 3 reads: Slight Townlean - Schiavetto Scumlean - Bluegummybear7 Someone who I'm fine with D1 80% policy 20% scum lynch - Edward Rest - Neutral You never did get around to explaining why Edward should be lynched today. Could you do that for us? |
|
|
|
Post by AlmostZero on Sept 21, 2019 13:34:37 GMT
My issue is that, if two out of three of your introductory posts are you speculating into the setup with minimal player interaction, it's going to catch my attention. If you deny it, that's going to catch my attention more. If you deny that you're giving undue focus to faction-solving and in the same breath continue to stress the point, it comes across as defensive. So I'll dig in my heels a bit here: You dropped a lynch on Lat a while back. What do you think of their play so far? Formatting on a phone is hard, but let's get into the big stuff. Your initial post that suggested the possibility of Replicants seemed a bit too... emotional, for lack of a better term, at least to me. But once again, I'm taking it as something not worth talking about. On the topic of what was bolded, I'm not saying that my effort up to that point wasn't focused mainly on the setup, because it was. I was saying that I wasn't going to pay too much attention to it once the game develops and there are bigger things I can look through. I can't exactly talk about what doesn't exist - or rather, I couldn't have tried to solve the game using interactions and lines that hadn't existed at that point. If we're talking about Lati, I feel like I feel too little of him. It would be great of him to speak more so I can be more certain of what I think, but let's give him the solid "absolute null" sticker. One hell of a post made by cyan. I don't mean to intimidate you mate, but I've just got too much to say about this. Firstly, red. Mate, I'm taking this quote from the same post you replied to: Unless you're being sarcastic here and saying "since we're being bad and faction solving instead of game solving then replicants might as well be there lol" Ding ding ding. This doesn't look good on you - it feels as if you only read the part of wallpost that concerns you, and not everything which a normal gamesolver would do. This is a pretty subjective and shallow reason to call someone, but trust me it raises a lot of fingers. And this ain't it. Purple - Two words; Okay, and? Look, you're apologetic. We get it. But that doesn't help it. If you really are apologetic, then give us reads. That's the best way to apologise. If you can't do that much, then don't say that you're trying to improve. If I didn't know you better by PMeta then I'd easily give you a big scumslot because at this point you're just trying to make yourself look good, "oh im good i admit my mistakes, sorry dont lynch me x-x" is the type of vibe you're giving, which does NOT help us. Give reads, not apologies. I want a player list from you, ordered from most town to least town. That might help us. Pink - Same as purple; No one asked you if you feel neutral towards lati. Everyone is by default neutral. Hell, I feel neutral towards the host. Let me give you a hint, it doesn't help us at all. You had no reason to mention this, yet you do. It feels like you're trying to post reads just to look active and that you're contributing and helping town, but in reality you're not helping scumhunting at all. Want to guess what faction you're looking like rn? I hope I don't have to spell it out for you. Want to fix your mistakes? Read the game again. Get reads. Scumhunt. I'm sorry if I sounded angry. |
|
|
|
Post by AlmostZero on Sept 21, 2019 13:44:04 GMT
Also guys I won't be there for EoD, so if anyone wants to chat in this thread hmu asap If you want a conversation starter, here are my 3 reads: Slight Townlean - Schiavetto Scumlean - Bluegummybear7 Someone who I'm fine with D1 80% policy 20% scum lynch - Edward Rest - Neutral You never did get around to explaining why Edward should be lynched today. Could you do that for us? Sure As said in my 5 worded description, it's mostly a policy because it's only day 1 and I don't want to take someone who's not going to be active further into the game. Not only that, but their only post is: Overrun makes more sense as to in terms of: (1)to defeat decisively and occupy the positions of. (2) : to invade and occupy or ravage. b : to spread or swarm over : infest. 2a : to run or go beyond or past the plane overran the runway. b : exceed overrun a budget. (Courtesy of marriam webster) If taking in account the last definitation i dont really see how it would make sense in those sentences. A part of me honestly believes that this slot could be scum solely because of this post being their only post. It's like, they were trying to seem like they're being helpful to town by contributing here, but other than that they haven't said anything substantial. |
|
|
|
Post by bluegummybear on Sept 21, 2019 13:44:06 GMT
I don't understand what BGB is trying to imply by the "overthinking" part. Meanwhile, I have lingering suspicions about the "one key detail." I'm no BGB but I can still say that the "overthinking" part refers to this line: 1. Schiavetto's FOS on everyone who speculated about flavor is flawed, especially with multiple players suspected. There are both possible town and scum motivations—solving flavor and pretending to contribute—but there's no context in which we can settle on either of the motives. Therefore, it's non-alignment-indicative. Better to say "FOS on everyone." I can only assume that the "one key detail" is something related to his role, and it was a pretty dumb move to announce that in public. Either you don't say anything, or you say what you have. You're basically saying "my role is something that says a lot about Jocus!!! But I ain't gonna tell you!!!", and that's really not helpful bluegummybear And as for Jocus.. I asked your opinions on that post, not your confusion.. do you think his post has any scummy nature to it? Why do you think he's giving that read? Is his read justified? I find the way you perceived the post rather interesting, Because you Could be completely right or completely wrong |
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Sept 21, 2019 14:01:50 GMT
I'm no BGB but I can still say that the "overthinking" part refers to this line:I can only assume that the "one key detail" is something related to his role, and it was a pretty dumb move to announce that in public. Either you don't say anything, or you say what you have. You're basically saying "my role is something that says a lot about Jocus!!! But I ain't gonna tell you!!!", and that's really not helpful bluegummybear And as for Jocus.. I asked your opinions on that post, not your confusion.. do you think his post has any scummy nature to it? Why do you think he's giving that read? Is his read justified? I find the way you perceived the post rather interesting, Because you Could be completely right or completely wrong Jocus+bgb unlikely, interactions seems ok(?) and the special emphasis on "Jocus" implies u know something about him. Not necessarily alignment indicative but possible scum v town/anti town(maybe solo scum?) but sure its not scum v scum. |
|
|
|
Post by bluegummybear on Sept 21, 2019 14:04:10 GMT
Jocus, Overall had a pretty good approach to this day 1(I would say the best "towny" approach). Most of his post seems very considerate in a good way. Although Jocus seems to build himself up as a town, in my opinion, I sense that he may be overthinking in the way he wants to perceive himself After Further investigations. Before I go into details I would rather wait for further indications. There is One key detail I will keep to myself for the time being that prevents from gathering a precise read on this player. What is everyone else thoughts? Could you tell me a bit more on how you feel his posts are considerate? This post has no aspiration whats so ever. The post That Lati Made made have been a "trolly"/meme post which is what i am suspecting, however It may not be which is rather disappointing. I dont want to Say much about the post itself Since There no sense of intentions from that slot. I simply Responded in a way that can possible allow me to gather more information. After all im geting underachieving gameplay Vibes from This Slot. So you feel that Lati is being meme-posty; how does that translate into him not being town? And after everything that's been said so far, what information have you gathered? Ill Address This At Another Time, I will likely just Make a reads list, So you can have more of an understanding. I love the attention I am getting, however, I want to hear from Others Lacking performance at the moment. |
|
|
|
Post by bluegummybear on Sept 21, 2019 14:05:20 GMT
What makes you think that my role is something related to jocus, when I said "one key detail"? I find the way you perceived the post rather interesting, Because you Could be completely right or completely wrong Jocus+bgb unlikely, interactions seems ok(?) and the special emphasis on "Jocus" implies u know something about him. Not necessarily alignment indicative but possible scum v town/anti town(maybe solo scum?) but sure its not scum v scum.  ayy whats up |
|
|
|
Post by bluegummybear on Sept 21, 2019 14:06:42 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Sept 21, 2019 14:11:09 GMT
Nobody has quetioned meh seems kinda sus huh? LYNCH Jocus Gut reads are OP af There is no point discussing these posts as they seems useless. Any further discussion on this waste of time imo. |
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Sept 21, 2019 14:12:47 GMT
Jocus+bgb unlikely, interactions seems ok(?) and the special emphasis on "Jocus" implies u know something about him. Not necessarily alignment indicative but possible scum v town/anti town(maybe solo scum?) but sure its not scum v scum. ayy whats up Hi lad. Just using some time to post. Just to confirm this jocus is at l3 or l2, and how many others are at l2 or l3(if any). |
|
|
|
Post by AlmostZero on Sept 21, 2019 14:16:20 GMT
I'm no BGB but I can still say that the "overthinking" part refers to this line:I can only assume that the "one key detail" is something related to his role, and it was a pretty dumb move to announce that in public. Either you don't say anything, or you say what you have. You're basically saying "my role is something that says a lot about Jocus!!! But I ain't gonna tell you!!!", and that's really not helpful bluegummybear And as for Jocus.. I asked your opinions on that post, not your confusion.. do you think his post has any scummy nature to it? Why do you think he's giving that read? Is his read justified? I find the way you perceived the post rather interesting, Because you Could be completely right or completely wrong I don't see why a town would be hiding something not role related. You could reveal a scum if you had the correct details. But you aren't. It's painfully obvious, honestly jeez. And you have something with your role forcing you to use green font? Your usage of green font is rather inconsistent. |
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Sept 21, 2019 14:19:12 GMT
I think you're wrong, but agree to disagree. Do you think Zest's behavior is AI? Wdym by zol behaviour being ai? |
|
|
|
Post by AlmostZero on Sept 21, 2019 14:19:39 GMT
What makes you think that my role is something related to jocus, when I said "one key detail"? I find the way you perceived the post rather interesting, Because you Could be completely right or completely wrong Jocus+bgb unlikely, interactions seems ok(?) and the special emphasis on "Jocus" implies u know something about him. Not necessarily alignment indicative but possible scum v town/anti town(maybe solo scum?) but sure its not scum v scum. Mm I am not exactly disagreeing to the possibility of that pair, but you might also want to talk about the other stuff that's happening? I want to hear your opinions, also it hasn't evolved into a bgb v jocus yet, they haven't showed thaaaat much interactions just yet |
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Sept 21, 2019 14:23:15 GMT
Jocus+bgb unlikely, interactions seems ok(?) and the special emphasis on "Jocus" implies u know something about him. Not necessarily alignment indicative but possible scum v town/anti town(maybe solo scum?) but sure its not scum v scum. Mm I am not exactly disagreeing to the possibility of that pair, but you might also want to talk about the other stuff that's happening? I want to hear your opinions, also it hasn't evolved into a bgb v jocus yet, they haven't showed thaaaat much interactions just yet Sure. On basis of reading i want to talk about afk ppl, cause for some reason i have a tendency of doing this every game. Till now other than crabbu is there someone else who has not talked till yet. |
|
|
|
Post by AlmostZero on Sept 21, 2019 14:23:29 GMT
oh you're online, suits me perfectly
what do you think of schia's long post? and your biggest tr/sr if possible, i think most ppl have contributed enough to be pretty alignment indicative
|
|
|
|
Post by AlmostZero on Sept 21, 2019 14:24:22 GMT
I think you're wrong, but agree to disagree. Do you think Zest's behavior is AI? Wdym by zol behaviour being ai? are zest's posts alignment-indicative? do they tell you anything? |
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Sept 21, 2019 14:29:49 GMT
oh you're online, suits me perfectly what do you think of schia's long post? and your biggest tr/sr if possible, i think most ppl have contributed enough to be pretty alignment indicative Alignment distinctive posts of latios and zol r amazing. No sl or sr d1 yet. Just want to see the lynches atm to determine the general view of majority of players. Gonna read schia long post again. |
|
|
|
Post by bluegummybear on Sept 21, 2019 14:30:19 GMT
What makes you think that my role is something related to jocus, when I said "one key detail"? I find the way you perceived the post rather interesting, Because you Could be completely right or completely wrong I don't see why a town would be hiding something not role related. You could reveal a scum if you had the correct details. But you aren't. It's painfully obvious, honestly jeez. And you have something with your role forcing you to use green font? Your usage of green font is rather inconsistent. Nah just taking a new approach to my playstyle, Green text is suppose to be questions and orange text is names. Also why are you so agitated about my "hidden detail" It not like I tend to keep it a secret forever |
|
|
|
Post by micromorphic on Sept 21, 2019 14:34:12 GMT
itzlatios220044 what are you current thoughts of what has happened so far? While you're waiting for a response on that, I'd actually super appreciate it if you talked to me about where you stand w/ Abby. He still lynchfodder, or do you see yourself moving elsewhere? Who is Abby? |
|
|
|
Post by micromorphic on Sept 21, 2019 14:36:45 GMT
oh nvm, ill probably unlynch since i dont have a really good reason to be on
Unlynch
|
|
|
|
Post by edwardzealchemist on Sept 21, 2019 14:39:06 GMT
oh nvm, ill probably unlynch since i dont have a really good reason to be on UnlynchWho were u lynching? |
|
|
|
Post by bluegummybear on Sept 21, 2019 14:40:29 GMT
What makes you think that my role is something related to jocus, when I said "one key detail"? I find the way you perceived the post rather interesting, Because you Could be completely right or completely wrong Jocus+bgb unlikely, interactions seems ok(?) and the special emphasis on "Jocus" implies u know something about him. Not necessarily alignment indicative but possible scum v town/anti town(maybe solo scum?) but sure its not scum v scum. |
|
|
|
Post by bluegummybear on Sept 21, 2019 14:41:45 GMT
Lynch: Tony XY
|
|
/cloudfront-us-east-2.images.arcpublishing.com/reuters/F7HODRUU7ZKBNGT42ZA7JRDMZU.jpg)
