|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 2:04:04 GMT
Cop discard seems scummy since there isnt alot of other strong roles in the game Also If they got 3 town cards it would be best to put the first strongest as your role,and then the 2nd strongest as your alignment to avoid looking scummy i mean cop is a pretty garbage role so |
|
|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 2:07:55 GMT
ok, claire got 4* votes cirrection. Still a lot more votes than I expected this early, I was sure this was usually when people try to start other wagons or stagger this one. Cop discard seems scummy since there isnt alot of other strong roles in the game Also If they got 3 town cards it would be best to put the first strongest as your role,and then the 2nd strongest as your alignment to avoid looking scummy So where are your reads at right now? It's about time you stop speaking from the neutral objective standpoint and share some hot takes with us all. |
|
|
|
Post by smallworldz on Feb 8, 2020 2:09:50 GMT
Its better than vanilla and all the choclate townie roles (And prob tracker and maybe conspiracy theorist)
Im just saying they should have put cop as their alignment instead of the discard, since its rareish to see 2 roles that are stronger than cop in your hand
Now that I thought it over we shouldnt be appealing to statistics though
|
|
|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 2:32:41 GMT
Its better than vanilla and all the choclate townie roles (And prob tracker and maybe conspiracy theorist) Im just saying they should have put cop as their alignment instead of the discard, since its rareish to see 2 roles that are stronger than cop in your hand Now that I thought it over we shouldnt be appealing to statistics though I don't think you know how GI/GestI power levels work, because tracker is one of the best roles and cop is one of the weaker ones. But yeah, I agree, we should drop the whole stats thing. So, can you respond to the request i made of you? |
|
|
|
Post by smallworldz on Feb 8, 2020 2:50:18 GMT
Claire feels like tryhard town rather than mafia
It seems weird how she said me n flushie were hesitating but thats because she wanted rvs
The nl thing was definetly a scumbait-If she wanted to she could've voted nl herself
XnadrojX-you give off a neutral read right now
Arc is a scumread for me-look at her posts so far-this seems like something scum would do for town brownie points
And thats about it so far
vote Arctina
|
|
|
|
Post by ZestOfLife on Feb 8, 2020 3:14:16 GMT
Sloppy Votecounter 1.3
Abdel (1) - Arctina
Claire (4) - micromorphic, Xnadrojx, gimm1ck, AlmostZero
ForgotToFlush (2) - Fenrir, Edjeanearations
AlmostZero (1) - Alexander489
Arctina (2) - Claire, smallworldz
Not Voting (3) - abdel, epicsnorlax, ForgotToFlush
With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to hammer. |
|
|
|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 4:33:00 GMT
Claire feels like tryhard town rather than mafia It seems weird how she said me n flushie were hesitating but thats because she wanted rvs The nl thing was definetly a scumbait-If she wanted to she could've voted nl herself XnadrojX-you give off a neutral read right now Arc is a scumread for me-look at her posts so far-this seems like something scum would do for town brownie points And thats about it so far vote Arctina Care to elaborate? Your thoughts so far seems pretty one-dimensional, I would like to see more detail behind the Arctina read in particular. |
|
|
|
Post by ZestOfLife on Feb 8, 2020 5:14:53 GMT
I forgot to count gimm1ck's vote, that has been reflected on the previous VC
|
|
|
|
Post by Claire on Feb 8, 2020 8:22:01 GMT
Yes the discard comment was a joke. The second comment about people not checking the discards was a nudge to make people see that we had the same discard and that was why I commented on it.
|
|
|
|
Post by abdel on Feb 8, 2020 10:32:47 GMT
hihi y'know claire is still scummy for the RVS comment but like, jesus that bandwagon gained traction a hella lot faster than I expected. Is no one going to jump to her defense or play the devils advocate or anything? It's kind of uncomfortable how easily claire got like 5 votes in a 7maj game, especially knowing how reluctant you guys are at getting anywhere near maj. ZestOfLife votecount pls I heavily dislike this post. It can be perceived as either justification in advance for shifting to someone on the Claire wagon or it can be used as reason to lynch someone tomorrow that was on the Claire wagon today, either way it negates your entire push on Claire as you clearly have doubts about the lynch which contradicts how confident you were about Claire being scum earlier. In general I dislike how focused you were on the Claire push today, even after a number of people have participated in the thread, but all you keep doing is talk about Claire's posts in general. Vote: Xnad |
|
|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 10:57:38 GMT
hihi y'know claire is still scummy for the RVS comment but like, jesus that bandwagon gained traction a hella lot faster than I expected. Is no one going to jump to her defense or play the devils advocate or anything? It's kind of uncomfortable how easily claire got like 5 votes in a 7maj game, especially knowing how reluctant you guys are at getting anywhere near maj. ZestOfLife votecount pls I heavily dislike this post. It can be perceived as either justification in advance for shifting to someone on the Claire wagon or it can be used as reason to lynch someone tomorrow that was on the Claire wagon today, either way it negates your entire push on Claire as you clearly have doubts about the lynch which contradicts how confident you were about Claire being scum earlier. In general I dislike how focused you were on the Claire push today, even after a number of people have participated in the thread, but all you keep doing is talk about Claire's posts in general. Vote: XnadI mean if you realized a major part of your argument was invalidated by your own stupidity I'm pretty sure you'd lose confidence too |
|
|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 11:07:35 GMT
hihi y'know claire is still scummy for the RVS comment but like, jesus that bandwagon gained traction a hella lot faster than I expected. Is no one going to jump to her defense or play the devils advocate or anything? It's kind of uncomfortable how easily claire got like 5 votes in a 7maj game, especially knowing how reluctant you guys are at getting anywhere near maj. ZestOfLife votecount pls I heavily dislike this post. It can be perceived as either justification in advance for shifting to someone on the Claire wagon or it can be used as reason to lynch someone tomorrow that was on the Claire wagon today, either way it negates your entire push on Claire as you clearly have doubts about the lynch which contradicts how confident you were about Claire being scum earlier. In general I dislike how focused you were on the Claire push today, even after a number of people have participated in the thread, but all you keep doing is talk about Claire's posts in general. Vote: XnadI mean, if there are other things to talk about then please point me to them because I don't see anyone other than Claire, me and maybe that other guy who I asked to chat worth talking about. If you want to go down that vein of reason, I could very well say "100% of your posts are about me" and not be wrong. The first part of your comment is interesting to me actually, about justificatiom or whatever. Mainly, why do you think thats what I'm trying to do and if I am trying to do so, what do you find wrong with it? Even though I don't really think your logic is at the right place I appreciate you actually putting in the effort to generate content rather than being sideliney like smallworldz is being rn so please, walk me through your line of logic here. |
|
|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 11:11:04 GMT
Yes the discard comment was a joke. The second comment about people not checking the discards was a nudge to make people see that we had the same discard and that was why I commented on it. This is a good time ti actually start playing now that RVS is over. You especially should have a lot of things to say rn. |
|
|
|
Post by ZestOfLife on Feb 8, 2020 11:32:04 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by smallworldz on Feb 8, 2020 13:05:15 GMT
thank you zol, very cool  now can we get some more posts on this thread going reading is hard when there's only 2 people you can really read This is my reason for why arctina is scum She asked people to start talking rather than putting pressure on those or even call them out on it This could be because she doesnt want to call out her scum partners for being inactive and just fencesitting She didnt even state her opinions on those 2 people either Also I dont think theres enough posts to state that rvs is over yet; 4 people didnt use their votes and most people have 1-2 posts so far, most of their content being fodder and the rvs vote |
|
|
|
Post by ZestOfLife on Feb 8, 2020 16:37:13 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by Bomb Moss on Feb 8, 2020 16:45:35 GMT
thank you zol, very cool now can we get some more posts on this thread going reading is hard when there's only 2 people you can really read This is my reason for why arctina is scum She asked people to start talking rather than putting pressure on those or even call them out on it This could be because she doesnt want to call out her scum partners for being inactive and just fencesitting She didnt even state her opinions on those 2 people either Also I dont think theres enough posts to state that rvs is over yet; 4 people didnt use their votes and most people have 1-2 posts so far, most of their content being fodder and the rvs vote RVS isn't about number of posts, RVS ends when the thread has discussable content, regardless of how many people it involves, which I daresay already exists. Hm, I see your point with Arc not stating any opinions. @arctina who were the people you said could be read and what's your read them? NGL the whole "they didnt call out because they dont want to shade their scumpartners" thing is a pretty far stretch, I kade offhand comments about people not posting as well, and there can only be so many scum, the inactive pool definitely doesn't solely consits of scumpartners. I know I said "especially Arc" but I would appreciate elaboration on anything else you can really. The more content we throw up early the better. |
|
|
|
Post by micromorphic on Feb 8, 2020 17:06:33 GMT
Hi
|
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Feb 8, 2020 20:42:45 GMT
Gosh I didn't realize people did rvs in forum games. I feel like it doesn't accomplish as much as it does in PS! but Vote: ForgotToFlushLets get some early game pressure going > Why would it be any different? Its not like theres anything else to do on daystart unless you're one of the psychos who like RQS. What do you think RVS doesn't acconplish here vs Chat environment, and do you have any other suggestions? Idk man I just don't remember doing rvs in the past games I played on forum. Probably just due to a bad memory. I have no problem with it at all |
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Feb 8, 2020 20:47:14 GMT
Claire feels like tryhard town rather than mafia It seems weird how she said me n flushie were hesitating but thats because she wanted rvs The nl thing was definetly a scumbait-If she wanted to she could've voted nl herself XnadrojX-you give off a neutral read right now Arc is a scumread for me-look at her posts so far-this seems like something scum would do for town brownie points And thats about it so far vote Arctina I don't see tryhard town at all. I'm sorry but Claire's first message was bad. Like so bad. Like really bad. Either way I'm gonna stay on (insert person I'm currently on because I forgot) until I see some reasoning from Claire, then I'll decide whether it's Lynch worthy or not |
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Feb 8, 2020 20:48:56 GMT
Also ZestOfLife you forgot to count my FTF Lynch from page 2 |
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Feb 8, 2020 20:52:03 GMT
hihi y'know claire is still scummy for the RVS comment but like, jesus that bandwagon gained traction a hella lot faster than I expected. Is no one going to jump to her defense or play the devils advocate or anything? It's kind of uncomfortable how easily claire got like 5 votes in a 7maj game, especially knowing how reluctant you guys are at getting anywhere near maj. ZestOfLife votecount pls I heavily dislike this post. It can be perceived as either justification in advance for shifting to someone on the Claire wagon or it can be used as reason to lynch someone tomorrow that was on the Claire wagon today, either way it negates your entire push on Claire as you clearly have doubts about the lynch which contradicts how confident you were about Claire being scum earlier. In general I dislike how focused you were on the Claire push today, even after a number of people have participated in the thread, but all you keep doing is talk about Claire's posts in general. Vote: XnadIdk man I don't really think focussing on the Claire Lynch is necessarily a bad thing. It's been what, like a day and a half since we started? It's still day 1 so I think pushing Claire still is a good way to go. No reason to give up pressure randomly within the same day, yknow? |
|
|
|
Post by Edjeanerations on Feb 8, 2020 20:55:20 GMT
More precisely, why is NL an option if your goal is to force the nonvoters to place a vote? NL is a bad option, but anyone who did it can then be questioned as a method of moving the game forward. I'm "insistent on forcing others" to vote as early game RVSes and wagons can provide a lot of information - better to start things off with something even if it's nothing substantial. I mean ok Claire r u town? </3 yeah <3 also anyone scumreading me for my "es discard is scummy" comment isn't paying enough attention to the discards Didn't see this before but this still isn't enough for me to even consider changing my read on Claire. Can you please just like, talk more? Ty Also sorry for the flooding I'm going through all the posts since I haven't been on since game start I'm psure |
|
|
|
Post by Alexander489 on Feb 9, 2020 0:03:16 GMT
alright ignore everything I said about discards it never happened imsorryclaireplsdonthurtme Alex there are a lot of things to read come back, more talk is always good. i mean obviously, and sorry been at work. what are your thoughts on claire after all of this 6.7.0 |
|
|
|
Post by Alexander489 on Feb 9, 2020 0:04:39 GMT
i seriously do not get why claire has 4 votes. a joke comment about discard?
|
|
/cloudfront-us-east-2.images.arcpublishing.com/reuters/F7HODRUU7ZKBNGT42ZA7JRDMZU.jpg)
