Newbie Game

[ZestOfLife]

I swear I see gim online but he never comes over here smh

[ZestOfLife]

May 24, 2019 3:09:54 GMT gimm1ck said:

C7 is relatively null as they haven't spoken much, although I do question their hesitance to post pretty much at all about the game once the deadline was near.

May 24, 2019 3:11:02 GMT gimm1ck said:

If I had to say scum was out of Sir Mister/FTF. I have a gut reading for FTF I'm going to tackle while sober tomorrow morning waiting for the forums circuit to begin #hype

I would love to see them elaborate on this.

I think gim/ftf is probably not a team.

[ForgotToFlush]

May 27, 2019 18:56:27 GMT ZestOfLife said:

May 24, 2019 3:09:54 GMT gimm1ck said:

C7 is relatively null as they haven't spoken much, although I do question their hesitance to post pretty much at all about the game once the deadline was near.

May 24, 2019 3:11:02 GMT gimm1ck said:

If I had to say scum was out of Sir Mister/FTF. I have a gut reading for FTF I'm going to tackle while sober tomorrow morning waiting for the forums circuit to begin #hype

I would love to see them elaborate on this.

I think gim/ftf is probably not a team.

(idk what he's talking about we've never played together)

[ForgotToFlush]

(well maybe we have on PS! but def not forums)

[ForgotToFlush]

May 27, 2019 18:51:59 GMT ZestOfLife said:

If scum wants to suicide they can CC me.

Honestly I feel like scum!FtF would have CCed me here. But again I don't really have a good grasp on how FtF plays scum.

gimm1ck C7 pls come here.

i feel like scum would cc depending on their situation
and the only one in a hypothetical world comfortable enough to cc is probs sfl and he hasn't
but that isn't clearing anyways

[gimm1ck]

Apologies I haven’t got any real down time to type an extremely well thought post for a few days now.
Given that Zol is clear (if mafia cc lol @ them), that leaves three scum teams from my POV:

-C7+FTF
-FTF+Sfl
-sfl+c7

The main scumteam as of now that I see is FTF+sfl, logs/reasonings coming shortly (when I get home to my computer).

@zol will say abt sir mister thing, have not forgotten

[C7]

ZOL, who have you investigated?

I'm thinking of a weird idea that might just work as long as both are alive

[C7]

Why am I saying its weird its actually decent looking at it

[ForgotToFlush]

May 28, 2019 1:55:46 GMT C7 said:

Why am I saying its weird its actually decent looking at it

so what im hearing is you don't have reads

[cyan]

let's hear that idea, shall we

[ForgotToFlush]

May 28, 2019 2:23:07 GMT cyan said:

let's hear that idea, shall we

you have stuff to respond to as well
hop to it

[cyan]

If you were looking for questions as to why I only submitted the reads when I did, I've been having problems in real life, namely not having the ease of access to my computer that I did when the game started. Not a very good reason to be inactive for long periods of time, I'll admit. It's much harder to read on mobile than it is to see things on a larger screen and be able to type out better stuff.

If you're also wondering why my reads aren't definite, it's because, well... I'm me. I find analyzing information a little harder to do than most people, and I can't find anything that conclusively suggests to me that any particular person is definitely town or scum. Basically, I'm still a newbie to the concept of finding reads, and normally I can't pick up on something very well. My reads just have a tendency to be half-assed in general, so I can't vouch for me being a useful player in this game.

If anything, though, I can gather more information once the two AFK people here start to speak. We've wasted about 24 hours doing almost nothing with them, and I'd like to see what we can find out from gimm1ck and C7 here.

[ZestOfLife]

May 23, 2019 7:49:32 GMT cyan said:

May 23, 2019 7:24:26 GMT ZestOfLife said:

?

We lost a journalist in one night and gained no useful information from it. The only thing we can work off of is if Mafia Journalist gets lynched, and even then we can only put faith in their first reveal. Aside from the first night, it's basically a guarantee that either the Mafia Framer will frame their partner for every night in which they both survive, or the Mafia Journalist will choose to reveal the Mafia Framer on one night and will be revealing framed townies for the rest.

If I'm correct with my memory here, Framers can only make town look like scum. If we kill the Mafia Journalist today or later, any townflip is a guaranteed clear.

May 27, 2019 19:01:11 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

May 27, 2019 18:51:59 GMT ZestOfLife said:

If scum wants to suicide they can CC me.

Honestly I feel like scum!FtF would have CCed me here. But again I don't really have a good grasp on how FtF plays scum.

gimm1ck C7 pls come here.

i feel like scum would cc depending on their situation
and the only one in a hypothetical world comfortable enough to cc is probs sfl and he hasn't
but that isn't clearing anyways

I think cuz of this post sfl can never CC journalist.

[ZestOfLife]

May 28, 2019 1:36:17 GMT C7 said:

ZOL, who have you investigated?

I'm thinking of a weird idea that might just work as long as both are alive

Even if both inspects are alive, claiming inspects are bad since scum knows if i'm safe to kill or no.

Also this is a really bad time to mech talk, not liking c7 here at all.

[ZestOfLife]

May 27, 2019 22:35:21 GMT gimm1ck said:

Apologies I haven’t got any real down time to type an extremely well thought post for a few days now.
Given that Zol is clear (if mafia cc lol @ them), that leaves three scum teams from my POV:

-C7+FTF
-FTF+Sfl
-sfl+c7

The main scumteam as of now that I see is FTF+sfl, logs/reasonings coming shortly (when I get home to my computer).

@zol will say abt sir mister thing, have not forgotten

I'm just going to wait for this, mind you I'm placing my vote tomorrow irl time.

[C7]

You not dying could imply a lot of things, though

And it gives us a good chance at a 50/50 lynch today

[ZestOfLife]

May 28, 2019 12:16:34 GMT C7 said:

You not dying could imply a lot of things, though

And it gives us a good chance at a 50/50 lynch today

Okay do you even have any reads??? Who do you think is scum?

[ForgotToFlush]

24 hours left
getting food

[ForgotToFlush]

as it stands
gimmick and c7 have both made empty promises to provide content
it's just which promises are emptier

or the more likely case
they're both woofing and have read the writing on the wall

[ForgotToFlush]

May 28, 2019 3:47:01 GMT ZestOfLife said:

May 27, 2019 19:01:11 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

i feel like scum would cc depending on their situation
and the only one in a hypothetical world comfortable enough to cc is probs sfl and he hasn't
but that isn't clearing anyways

I think cuz of this post sfl can never CC journalist.

mindgames itt

[ForgotToFlush]

May 28, 2019 12:16:34 GMT C7 said:

You not dying could imply a lot of things, though

And it gives us a good chance at a 50/50 lynch today

and what pray tell, does it imply?

[ForgotToFlush]

May 28, 2019 1:36:17 GMT C7 said:

ZOL, who have you investigated?

I'm thinking of a weird idea that might just work as long as both are alive

May 28, 2019 1:55:46 GMT C7 said:

Why am I saying its weird its actually decent looking at it

on reread this is worse than i remembered
the logical inference to be made here is that you're trying to out the inspects to know if you can kill zol safely or not
and why do you need to be alive? feels like day-buying

[cyan]

May 29, 2019 6:37:24 GMT ForgotToFlush said:

as it stands
gimmick and c7 have both made empty promises to provide content
it's just which promises are emptier

or the more likely case
they're both woofing and have read the writing on the wall

Oddly enough, out of the two, C7 has contributed more today than Gimm1ck. Of course, the reverse is true for all days from before today.

I'd like to suggest our lynch be amongst Gimm1ck and C7. But we're on a tight deadline here, and I'd like to see that a lynch does, in fact, happen today.

Lynch C7

Should the need for a counterwagon arise, my faith shall be on ZOL and FtF.

[C7]

Alright, I'll explain what my idea was.

Journalist has two inspects, if both are alive they should tell them and we lynch between whoever was not inspected. It still has chances to fail, but its better because journalist would die with more information being revealed.
on a different note a town is always a town but a mafia is not always a mafia but if the n1 inspect flips mafia they are more likely to be mafia than the n2

[cyan]

May 29, 2019 13:20:40 GMT C7 said:

Alright, I'll explain what my idea was.

Journalist has two inspects, if both are alive they should tell them and we lynch between whoever was not inspected. It still has chances to fail, but its better because journalist would die with more information being revealed.
on a different note a town is always a town but a mafia is not always a mafia but if the n1 inspect flips mafia they are more likely to be mafia than the n2

This would require the Journalist having inspected at most 1 mafia from the 6 available suspects, including both Schia and Sir Mister.

You are also assuming Mafia kills the Journalist later tonight. That is almost guaranteed not to happen.